Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Lire les comptes / Module 6

6From earnings to cash

Why profit and cash differ, and how to build the cash flow statement that links them

Pourquoi résultat et trésorerie diffèrent, et comment bâtir le tableau de flux qui les relie.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
15
Exercices
3
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
2

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain in plain words why a profitable company can generate little cash.

  • Build a cash flow statement from two balance sheets and an income statement, and prove that it balances.

  • Move between cash earnings, operating cash flow, free cash flow and the change in net debt without losing a euro.

  • Compute and interpret cash conversion, and say what raises or lowers it.

  • Read a cash flow statement as a story about growth, investment and funding.

1Profit and cash run on different clocks

A company can be profitable and short of cash in the same year, with nobody lying. Two kinds of timing difference explain it: operating credit and long-lived assets. This part puts numbers on both.

A sale is not a payment

The income statement records the event, the bank records the money

Harmony delivers 50 bikes to a dealer in December. The income statement records the sale that month, because the bikes have left the plant. The dealer pays in February. For two months Harmony has profit and no cash. The difference is customer credit, and it sits in the balance sheet as a receivable.

The buying side works the same way. Components received in November and paid in January are a cost without cash: a payable. Bikes built but not yet sold are cash spent without a cost booked: inventory.

Three balances stand between profit and cash

  • Receivables: sales booked, cash not yet collected. When they rise, cash is lower than sales.

  • Inventories: goods paid for, cost not yet booked. When they rise, cash is lower than costs.

  • Payables: costs booked, cash not yet paid. When they rise, cash is higher than costs.

Together these form working capital, the cash locked into the operating cycle. Harmony's was 24.0 million at the end of year N. Its increase is the first bridge between earnings and cash.

Harmony's working capital explains half of the gap

Two balance sheets reveal what the income statement hides

The income statement shows sales of 120.0 million. It does not show how much Harmony collected. To find out, compare receivables at the start and the end of the year. They rose from 18.0 to 20.0, so 2.0 of the year's sales were still unpaid. Cash collected: 120.0 − 2.0 = 118.0.

The same logic applies to costs. Harmony's operating costs, everything except depreciation, were 120.0 − 18.0 = 102.0. Inventories rose by 3.0, so Harmony paid for 3.0 of goods it has not yet sold. Payables rose by 2.0, so it has not yet paid 2.0 of its costs. Cash paid out: 102.0 + 3.0 − 2.0 = 103.0.

Sales grew 14% in year N, from 105.0 to 120.0. Working capital is 20% of sales, so each extra euro of sales needs about twenty cents of new funding. Analysts use the gap between EBITDA and the operating cash surplus as a first diagnostic. The cause may be healthy growth, customers paying later, or stock piling up unsold. The numbers look alike. The stories do not.

1.2 — Your cousin Chloé runs a furniture workshop. She says: we made 40,000 euros of profit this year, yet the bank balance is lower than in January. She suspects her accountant. Explain to her, with one concrete example from a workshop, how both numbers can be right.

      Chloé sold a table in December for 2,000 and the customer pays in January: profit now, cash later. She also bought wood for next year's tables: cash gone, no cost yet.

      Profit counts the sale when it happens. The bank counts money when it moves. The accountant made no mistake: the gap is customer credit and stock.

      Depreciation is the same problem seen from the other side

      A machine is paid for once and charged over many years

      Harmony buys a paint robot for 1.5 million. The cash leaves on day one. The accounts spread the cost over five years, so the income statement carries a depreciation charge of 1.5 / 5 = 0.3 million a year. In year 1 the cash outflow is five times the charge. Over the whole life the totals are equal. In any single year they are not.

      In year N Harmony spent 9.0 million on capital expenditure (capex, the purchase of long-lived assets) and charged 6.0 million of depreciation. Cash left 3.0 million faster than cost was recognised. That is the second bridge.

      1.1 One order, two clocks

      Harmony ships 80 bikes in the last week of the year at 2,400 euros each, to a new dealer who pays in 60 days. Each bike cost 1,500 euros, paid during the year. Compute the profit and the cash movement on this order within the year. Then say what would change if the dealer paid on delivery.

      Sales: 80 × 2,400 = 0.192 million. Cost: 80 × 1,500 = 0.120 million. Profit: 0.072 million.

      Cash within the year: nothing collected and 0.120 paid, so −0.120 million. The dealer's 0.192 arrives next year.

      If the dealer paid on delivery, cash would be 0.192 − 0.120 = +0.072 million, equal to the profit. The gap between profit and cash was only the receivable.

      1

      1. Harmony reported net income of 7.5 and paid no dividend, yet net debt fell by only 1.5. Where did the other 6.0 go?

      2. Inventories rise by 3.0 during the year. What does that do to cash compared with costs?

      3. Harmony buys a 1.5 million robot depreciated over five years. Which statement is true?

      2Building the statement from two balance sheets

      This part is the method itself. Five steps, one company, and a proof at the end that no euro has been lost.

      Two balance sheets and one identity do most of the work

      Start with the economic balance sheet at both dates

      Step one: put the balance sheets at the start and end of the year in economic form, showing what the firm uses (fixed assets, working capital) and how it is funded (equity, net debt). Step two: subtract to get the change in every line.

      € million End N−1 End N Change
      Fixed assets 57.0 60.0 +3.0
      Working capital 21.0 24.0 +3.0
      Capital employed 78.0 84.0 +6.0
      Equity 46.5 54.0 +7.5
      Gross debt 42.0 40.0 −2.0
      Cash 10.5 10.0 −0.5
      Net debt 31.5 30.0 −1.5
      Total funding 78.0 84.0 +6.0

      Harmony, economic balance sheets. Net debt is gross debt less cash.

      Net debt is the right balancing item, not cash

      A company that borrows 5.0 and leaves it in the bank has 5.0 more cash, but it is no better off: its net debt has not moved. The analyst therefore ends the statement on the change in net debt, and treats cash as a detail inside it. The table gives one identity that every statement must satisfy.

      Change in net debt = change in capital employed − net income + dividends − new equity raised

      For Harmony: 6.0 − 7.5 + 0 − 0 = −1.5. The company grew by 6.0 but retained 7.5 of earnings, so it needed no new funding. The statement now explains this result flow by flow.

      Operating flows turn earnings into cash earnings, then into cash

      Step three adds back what was never paid

      Begin with net income and add back charges that took no cash out: depreciation, impairments and provisions. Subtract gains on asset sales, because the cash from a sale belongs in investing. The result is cash earnings, called CAF in French analysis.

      Cash earnings = net income + depreciation + provisions and impairments − gains on disposals

      Harmony: 7.5 + 6.0 = 13.5 million, with no provisions or disposals in year N.

      Step three continues by paying for working capital

      Operating cash flow = cash earnings − increase in working capital

      Harmony: 13.5 − 3.0 = 10.5 million. This figure is after interest and tax, because both were deducted on the way to net income.

      There are two routes to the same figure

      The route above is additive: it starts from net income. The subtractive route starts from EBITDA and takes away what was paid. Both must agree, so computing both is a free check.

      Investing and financing flows complete the statement

      Capex is the cash paid, not the depreciation charged

      The balance sheet shows net fixed assets, which fell by depreciation and rose by purchases. Reverse the movement to recover the purchases.

      Capex = change in net fixed assets + depreciation + book value of assets sold

      Harmony: 3.0 + 6.0 + 0 = 9.0 million, which matches the case. Operating cash flow of 10.5 less capex of 9.0 leaves 1.5 million of free cash flow after financial costs.

      Financing flows explain how the free cash flow was used

      What remains after capex goes to lenders, shareholders and the bank balance.

      New borrowings = change in gross debt + repayments

      Dividends paid = opening equity + net income − closing equity

      Harmony: dividends = 46.5 + 7.5 − 54.0 = 0, as the case states. Gross debt fell by 2.0, so Harmony repaid 2.0 and borrowed nothing new. It had 1.5 of free cash flow and repaid 2.0, so cash fell by 0.5, from 10.5 to 10.0.

      Strip out the movements that involved no cash

      Some balance sheet changes are not flows. A revaluation raises book value with no cash. A foreign subsidiary's accounts change value when the exchange rate moves. A debt of 3.0 converted into shares lowers net debt by 3.0 and raises equity by 3.0, with no cash flow. The test: did cash cross the company's boundary? If not, it is a transfer, so remove it.

      2.1 Tandemo's cash flow statement

      Tandemo, a smaller bike maker, had these figures (€ million): EBITDA 9.0, depreciation 3.0, interest 2.0, tax 1.0 (paid in cash), net income 3.0, dividends 1.0, capex 4.0, no disposals. Build the statement down to the change in net debt, say what is unusual, and check with the identity.

      Opening Closing
      Net fixed assets 40.0 41.0
      Working capital 18.0 24.0
      Equity 20.0 22.0
      Net debt 38.0 43.0

      Cash earnings: 3.0 + 3.0 = 6.0. Operating cash flow: 6.0 − 6.0 = 0.0, after interest and tax. Free cash flow after financial costs: 0.0 − 4.0 = −4.0. Dividends of 1.0 take it to −5.0, so net debt rises by 5.0, from 38.0 to 43.0.

      Check with the identity. Capital employed rises by (41.0 − 40.0) + (24.0 − 18.0) = 7.0. Change in net debt = 7.0 − 3.0 + 1.0 − 0 = +5.0.

      What is unusual: Tandemo reports a profit of 3.0 and pays a dividend, yet its operations generated no cash at all. Working capital swallowed 6.0, which is twice the net income. The dividend was financed with debt.

      2.2 — Marc is a chef who reads a balance sheet as a list of what the restaurant owns and owes. Explain to him why you subtract last year's balance sheet from this year's, and why every difference needs a flow to explain it.

          A balance sheet is a photograph at one date. A year's activity is the change between two photographs, so you subtract. If the stock of wine rose by 3,000, the restaurant bought more than it used. Every difference has a cause: a purchase, a payment, a repayment, a profit kept. You are finished when every bottle bought is either used, in stock or accounted for.

          1. 2.3 Fixed assets rise by 5.0, depreciation is 4.0 and nothing was sold. What was capex?

          2. 2.4 Why does the statement end on the change in net debt and not on the change in cash?

          3. 2.5 A firm's net income is 6.0 and it paid 2.0 in dividends, with no new equity. By how much did equity grow?

          Harmony's two balance sheets and its income statement shown as movable tiles. The learner drags each tile (net income, depreciation, working capital change, capex, debt repayment, change in cash) into the right section of an empty statement. A check turns green when the net debt change matches the balance sheet. The learner discovers that it balances only when every tile is placed once.

          2

          1. Which identity must every Harmony statement satisfy?

          2. Fixed assets rise from 57.0 to 60.0, depreciation is 6.0 and nothing was sold. Capex was…

          3. Why does the analyst end the statement on net debt rather than on cash?

          3Reading the result: conversion, methods and free cash flow

          A correct statement is the start of the analysis. Three tools turn it into judgement: cash conversion, the choice between direct and indirect presentation, and the right definition of free cash flow.

          Cash conversion shows how much of EBITDA reaches the till

          One ratio compares what the firm earned with what it kept

          Cash conversion is the share of EBITDA that survives the working capital build and, in a stricter version, the capex. There is no single standard, so always say which one you use.

          Operating cash conversion = (EBITDA − increase in working capital) / EBITDA

          Cash conversion after capex = (EBITDA − increase in working capital − capex) / EBITDA

          Harmony: (18.0 − 3.0) / 18.0 = 83.3%. After capex: (18.0 − 3.0 − 9.0) / 18.0 = 33.3%. Roughly a third of each euro of EBITDA was left after the firm had funded its growth. A mature firm shows a higher figure. A growing firm shows a lower one, and that is normal.

          There are two ways to present the operating flows

          The direct method lists payments, the indirect method corrects profit

          Part 2 used the indirect method: start from net income and correct for non-cash items and working capital. The direct method lists what was collected from customers and paid to suppliers and staff. It is easier to understand and harder to produce.

          Direct method (€ million) Year N
          Cash collected from customers 118.0
          Cash paid to suppliers and employees −103.0
          Operating cash surplus 15.0
          Interest paid −2.0
          Tax paid −2.5
          Operating cash flow 10.5

          Same answer as the indirect method, built from receipts and payments.

          Both give 10.5. IAS 7 encourages the direct method, but nearly all companies publish the indirect one. An analyst can rebuild the direct view from the balance sheets, as in Part 1.

          Free cash flow has three common definitions, so name the one you use

          Before financing, after financial costs, and for shareholders

          The label covers three figures, which differ in who has already been paid.

          Definition Computation Harmony (€ million)
          Before financing (to the firm) EBITDA − ΔWC − notional tax on EBIT − capex 3.0
          After financial costs Operating cash flow − capex 1.5
          To shareholders After financial costs + net borrowing −0.5

          Notional tax is 25% of EBIT, the tax Harmony would pay with no debt.

          Before financing: 18.0 − 3.0 − 25% × 12.0 − 9.0 = 3.0. Valuation uses this figure (CF27), because it does not depend on funding. It exceeds the figure after financial costs by the after-tax interest: 2.0 × (1 − 25%) = 1.5.

          To shareholders: 1.5 + (0 new borrowing − 2.0 repaid) = −0.5. Harmony generated 1.5 but repaid 2.0, so cash fell by 0.5.

          3

          1. Harmony's EBITDA is 18.0, its working capital build 3.0 and capex 9.0. Cash conversion after capex is…

          2. Which free cash flow does a DCF valuation use?

          3. The direct and indirect methods applied to Harmony's year N give…

          4Growth consumes cash before it produces it

          The statement is a story about how a company grows and who pays for it. This part uses Harmony's growth to show why profitable firms need funding.

          Growth pays out cash before it brings any in

          Each euro of extra sales needs about twenty cents of working capital

          Harmony's working capital is 20% of sales. If sales rise, working capital must rise too, immediately. The extra profit arrives later and is smaller. Hold the margin at 15% of sales and the ratio at 20%. The table compares four growth rates for year N+1.

          € million 0% 7.5% 15% 25%
          Sales 120.0 129.0 138.0 150.0
          EBITDA at 15% 18.0 19.35 20.7 22.5
          Working capital at 20% 24.0 25.8 27.6 30.0
          Increase in working capital 0.0 1.8 3.6 6.0
          EBITDA less ΔWC 18.0 17.55 17.1 16.5

          Harmony, year N+1, margin and working capital ratio held constant.

          The faster Harmony grows, the more EBITDA it earns and the less cash it keeps. At 25% growth, EBITDA is 4.5 higher than today, but cash after working capital is 1.5 lower. At 15% growth, extra EBITDA is 2.7 against a working capital build of 3.6.

          a slider for the sales growth rate from −10% to +40%, with Harmony's margin and working capital ratio as inputs. Two bars show EBITDA and cash after working capital. The learner discovers that the two bars diverge as growth rises.

          A profitable firm can still run out of funding

          Growth in capital employed must be financed by profit, equity or debt

          Use the identity from Part 2. If growth needs more capital employed than profit retains, the difference is borrowed. Harmony's capital employed is 70% of sales (84.0 / 120.0). If that holds at 25% growth, it must rise by 25% × 84.0 = 21.0.

          The warning sign is not profit but the combination of rapid growth, low conversion and rising net debt. Firms growing faster than their funding allows are overtrading. Tandemo in exercise 2.1 earned 3.0 and saw net debt rise by 5.0.

          Five questions turn the statement into a diagnosis

          Read the statement from top to bottom as one story

          • Is operating cash flow positive after working capital? Harmony: yes, 10.5.

          • Is working capital growing faster than sales? Harmony: no, both grew 14.3%.

          • Is capex above depreciation? Harmony: 9.0 / 6.0 = 1.5 times, so the asset base is expanding.

          • Who funded the gap? Harmony: nobody. It repaid 2.0 of debt from its own cash.

          • Is leverage moving the right way? Harmony: net debt over EBITDA fell from 31.5 / 14.7 = 2.14× to 30.0 / 18.0 = 1.67×.

          The verdict on year N: a company that grows quickly, keeps its credit terms steady, invests more than it depreciates and still deleverages. Healthy, though thin: free cash flow after financial costs is only 1.5.

          4.1 Harmony's N+1 statement

          Harmony grows 15% in year N+1 as in the running case. Depreciation is 6.9, capex is 12.0 (the forecast used in CF3), interest is 2.0, tax is 25% and there is no dividend. Compute net income, operating cash flow after interest and tax, free cash flow after financial costs, and the change in net debt. Then check the last one with the identity from Part 2.

          EBITDA 20.7. Depreciation 6.9, so EBIT is 13.8. Interest 2.0, so profit before tax is 11.8 and tax at 25% is 2.95. Net income: 8.85.

          Cash earnings: 8.85 + 6.9 = 15.75. Working capital rises by 3.6, so operating cash flow is 12.15. Less capex of 12.0: free cash flow after financial costs of 0.15. With no dividend, net debt falls by only 0.15, as CF3 found by another route.

          Identity check: capital employed rises by (12.0 − 6.9) + 3.6 = 8.7. Change in net debt = 8.7 − 8.85 = −0.15. Both agree.

          1. 4.2 Harmony's growth accelerates and its profit rises, but its operating cash falls. Give the mechanism in one sentence.

          2. 4.3 A competitor reports rising sales, rising profit and rising receivables days. What do you suspect, and what do you check?

          3. 4.4 Why is the sentence 'we are profitable, so we are safe' wrong?

          4

          1. Margin 15%, working capital 20% of sales. As growth accelerates, cash after working capital…

          2. Tandemo earned 3.0, paid a 1.0 dividend and saw net debt rise by 5.0. The best description is…

          3. Why is “we are profitable, so we are safe” wrong?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          L’identité maîtresse

          = − + −

          Harmony a grandi de 6,0 mais garde 7,5 de bénéfice : sa dette nette baisse de 1,5.

          Du résultat au flux d’exploitation

          = + −

          Les deux premiers termes forment la CAF : 13,5.

          Capex retrouvé à partir des bilans

          = + +

          Conversion de trésorerie

          = ( − ) / EBITDA

          Dites toujours quelle version vous utilisez.

          Idea What to remember
          Why profit differs from cash Timing (receivables, inventories, payables, capex versus depreciation) and non-cash entries (depreciation, provisions).
          Working capital Inventories + receivables − payables. When it rises, cash is lower than EBITDA by the same amount.
          Cash earnings Net income + depreciation + provisions − gains on disposals. French analysis calls it CAF.
          Operating cash flow Cash earnings − increase in working capital. After interest and tax.
          Capex Change in net fixed assets + depreciation + book value of assets sold.
          Dividends paid Opening equity + net income − closing equity, if no other equity movements.
          Master identity Change in net debt = change in capital employed − net income + dividends − new equity.
          Direct and indirect Both give the same operating cash flow. Direct lists receipts and payments; indirect corrects net income.
          Cash conversion (EBITDA − ΔWC) / EBITDA, or after capex. State the definition used.
          Free cash flow Before financing, after financial costs, to shareholders. Name the one you use.
          Non-cash movements Revaluations, translation and debt conversions are not flows. Remove them.

          The one-sentence version

          Difference two balance sheets, explain every change with a flow, and the statement will show how much of the profit became cash, where it went, and who paid for growth.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Receivable Money customers owe for sales already booked.
          Payable Money owed to suppliers for costs already booked.
          Working capital Cash locked in stock and customer credit, net of supplier credit.
          Capex Cash spent on long-lived assets such as machines and buildings.
          Cash conversion Share of EBITDA that remains after working capital, and sometimes capex.
          Net debt Borrowings less cash and equivalents.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the move from earnings to the change in net debt, and the chapters on cash flows and on analysing accounts.

          • IFRS Foundation — IAS 7 Statement of Cash Flows and its 2023 amendments on supplier finance arrangements.

          • Schilit and Perler — Financial Shenanigans (McGraw-Hill), on how reported profit and operating cash flow can be made to diverge.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.