Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Reading the accounts / Module 4

4The income statement

How earnings are built, layer by layer, and what each layer can and cannot tell you

How earnings are built, layer by layer, and what each layer can and cannot tell you.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
13
Exercises
3
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
9
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why profit and cash differ in a given year, and say which one a given event moves.

  • Build Harmony's income statement by nature and by function, and show that both reach the same operating profit.

  • Say what EBITDA, EBIT and net income each measure, and what each hides.

  • Separate recurring from one-off items and challenge an adjusted figure by reconciling it.

  • Read the IFRS 18 categories and the French intermediate balances.

1Earnings record wealth created, not cash moved

Before any layout, the logic. An earnings figure counts what the activity produced and what it used up, at the moment each happens. Four rules decide when.

Cash and wealth move separately

Three events show that cash can move while wealth stands still

Harmony pays 3.0 million in cash for a plot of land. Its bank balance falls by 3.0, yet the company is no poorer: it owns land worth the same amount. Harmony then borrows 5.0 million. Cash rises by 5.0, yet the company is no richer: it owes 5.0.

Now a fire destroys 0.8 million of uninsured stock in a warehouse. No payment is made, so cash does not move. But Harmony has lost something it owned, and it is poorer by 0.8. The income statement exists to capture this third kind of event and ignore the first two.

Earnings compare what was created with what was consumed

Earnings = revenues (value created) − expenses (resources consumed)

A revenue is recorded when the company earns it. An expense is recorded when the resource is used up, matched to the revenue it helped to produce. This is called accrual accounting: events are booked when they happen, not when the money moves.

Revenue is recorded when Harmony has done what it promised

The standard on revenue asks when each promise to the customer is delivered

IFRS 15 is the international standard on revenue from contracts with customers. Its logic fits in five questions: what is the contract, which distinct promises does it contain, what is the price, how is the price shared between the promises, and when is each promise delivered? Revenue appears as each promise is kept.

A purchase becomes an expense only when its benefit is used up

Spending that lasts for years is stored as an asset, then released slowly

Harmony pays 1.2 million for a moulding tool that will serve four years. Charging the whole amount to year 1 would make year 1 look terrible and years 2 to 4 look flattering. Instead the tool is recorded as an asset and its cost is spread: depreciation of 1.2 ÷ 4 = 0.3 million a year. Cash leaves once. Earnings bear the cost four times.

Depreciation is a calculated charge: no payment is made in the year it is booked. A related charge, impairment, is a one-time write-down when an asset turns out to be worth less than its book value. Neither is cash, and both are real costs.

The line between expense and asset is a judgement, and it moves profit

Nadia runs a flower shop. This year her accountant says she made a profit of 4,000, yet her bank balance fell. She bought a delivery van for 15,000 in cash and the accountant spreads it over five years. Explain to Nadia, in everyday words, how both statements can be true, and what her bank balance did over the year.

      A good answer says that the van is used up over five years, so each year bears 15,000 ÷ 5 = 3,000 of cost, but the full 15,000 was paid on day one. Before the van, the shop generated 4,000 + 3,000 = 7,000 of cash. After paying 15,000, the bank balance fell by 8,000. Profit is not spare money: the van pays its cost back over the years.

      Unsold production is stock, and stock moves the margin

      Only what was sold is charged against the sales

      A manufacturer pays for everything it makes, but only the part it sells belongs to this year's earnings. The rest sits in the warehouse as stock, an asset at cost.

      In a statement presented by nature, this correction appears as a line called change in stocks of finished goods. Harmony adds 2.0 million of it in year N, because it made 2.0 million more than it sold. The statement then shows the value of what was produced, not only what was invoiced.

      1.1 Battery packs in the warehouse

      Harmony makes 5,000 battery packs in a year at a cost of 300 each and sells 3,500 at 450 each. Compute revenue, the cost of packs sold, earnings and the value of unsold stock. Then compute what a naive 'received minus spent' figure would say. Finally, the 1,500 unsold packs prove to be worth only 200 each: what are earnings after the write-down?

      Revenue is 3,500 × 450 = 1.575 million. The cost of packs sold is 3,500 × 300 = 1.05 million. Earnings are 0.525 million. The 1,500 unsold packs are stock worth 1,500 × 300 = 0.45 million.

      The naive figure is revenue minus all spending: 1.575 − 1.5 = 0.075 million. It is wrong as a measure of earnings, because it charges the cost of the unsold packs too early. It is, however, the cash movement.

      The write-down is 1,500 × (300 − 200) = 0.15 million. Earnings fall to 0.525 − 0.15 = 0.375 million.

      a simulator with two sliders, bikes produced and bikes sold, using the worked example's prices. Two bars update live, one for earnings and one for cash movement. The learner discovers that producing more than is sold leaves earnings unchanged but lowers cash, and that the gap equals the stock built.

      1. 1.2 On 1 July Harmony pays 0.9 million for twelve months of insurance. How much is an expense in the accounts closed on 31 December?

      2. 1.3 A dealer pays a deposit of 50,000 in December for bikes that Harmony will deliver in March. Is that revenue this year? Is it cash?

      3. 1.4 Harmony's stock of finished bikes rises by 2.0 million during the year. Does that raise or lower earnings compared with a year in which stock stayed flat, if sales are the same?

      1

      1. Harmony borrows 5.0 million. What happens to its earnings?

      2. On 1 July Harmony pays 0.9 million for twelve months of insurance. The expense in the year to 31 December is…

      3. Harmony builds 10,000 bikes at 1,000 and sells 8,000 at 1,500. Earnings and cash movement are…

      2Building the statement: from sales to net income

      Now the layers. The same earnings can be shown in two layouts, and each layer of the staircase answers a different question.

      Presented by nature, the statement shows what Harmony pays for

      Each cost is listed under what it is, whichever job it serves

      In the by-nature layout, costs are grouped by their kind: materials, personnel, outside services, taxes, depreciation. A euro of wages stays a wage, whether the person works on the line or in the office. This layout is easy to audit, because each line matches a type of payment.

      EBITDA is the result of the operating cycle, EBIT is after the cost of the equipment

      EBITDA means earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation. It is what the day-to-day cycle of buying, making, selling and collecting leaves, before charging the wear of equipment. EBIT, or operating profit, deducts depreciation. It is the profit of the business before anyone who financed it is paid.

      Presented by function, the same earnings are cut differently

      The by-function layout groups costs by the job they serve

      Here costs are sorted by purpose: producing the goods, researching, selling, administering. Depreciation of the factory sits in the cost of production, depreciation of the head office in administration. The statement produces a gross profit, sales minus the cost of what was sold, which managers like because it is close to how they run the business.

      Harmony, year N, by function € million % of sales
      Sales 120.0 100.0%
      Cost of sales −78.0 65.0%
      Gross profit 42.0 35.0%
      Research and development −6.0 5.0%
      Selling and distribution −16.0 13.3%
      General and administrative −8.0 6.7%
      Operating profit (EBIT) 12.0 10.0%

      Depreciation of 6.0 is inside these lines: 4.5 in cost of sales, 0.5 in each of the other three.

      Operating profit is the same 12.0 as before. Only the cutting differs. EBITDA does not appear in this layout, but it can be rebuilt: operating profit 12.0 plus the depreciation of 6.0 disclosed in the notes gives 18.0. A company that presents by function therefore has to disclose its depreciation, or the reader cannot find EBITDA.

      • By nature is simple, hard to manipulate and shows the weight of wages and materials. It does not show the margin on what was sold, and it needs the stock-change line.

      • By function gives a gross margin and matches management reporting. It requires allocating shared costs to functions, which is a judgement.

      2.1 A division in both layouts

      A Harmony division, Harmony Pro, has these figures in € million, by nature: sales 40.0, materials consumed 19.0, personnel 10.0, other external costs 4.0, taxes other than income tax 0.5, depreciation 2.5, no change in stocks. Compute EBITDA, EBIT and their margins.

      The same division by function shows cost of sales 27.0, research 3.0, selling 3.5 and administration 2.5. Compute gross profit and its margin, then check that EBIT matches the first layout. Depreciation inside the function lines is 2.0, 0.3, 0.1 and 0.1: rebuild EBITDA from this layout.

      By nature: EBITDA = 40.0 − 19.0 − 10.0 − 4.0 − 0.5 = 6.5, a margin of 16.25%. EBIT = 6.5 − 2.5 = 4.0, a margin of 10.0%.

      By function: gross profit = 40.0 − 27.0 = 13.0, a margin of 32.5%. EBIT = 13.0 − 3.0 − 3.5 − 2.5 = 4.0, the same. Depreciation in the lines totals 2.0 + 0.3 + 0.1 + 0.1 = 2.5, so EBITDA = 4.0 + 2.5 = 6.5, the same again.

      Below EBIT the statement shows who is paid after the operations

      Interest, tax and shareholders each take their turn

      Net interest of 2.0 is the cost of Harmony's borrowing. Compared with EBIT, it gives an interest cover of 12.0 ÷ 2.0 = 6.0 times. Compared with EBITDA, it gives the 9 times used in the course ratios. Profit before tax is 10.0. The state takes 25%, so 2.5, and net income of 7.5 is what belongs to the shareholders.

      Where Harmony's EBITDA of 18.0 goes € million
      Wear of equipment (depreciation) 6.0
      Lenders (net interest) 2.0
      The state (income tax) 2.5
      Shareholders (net income) 7.5
      Total 18.0

      Suppliers and employees were already paid higher up the statement.

      Yannick is a joiner with a small workshop. He hears that Harmony has an EBITDA of 18 million and says: so they have 18 million to spend. Explain to him, using the staircase, why that is wrong, and name the three or four calls on that 18 million before anything is left to spend.

          The 18 million is what is left after materials, wages and outside costs, but before three things. Depreciation of 6.0 reflects the wear of the equipment that must be renewed. Interest of 2.0 goes to lenders and tax of 2.5 to the state. That leaves 7.5 of net income.

          Even that is not spare cash, because Harmony also invested 9.0 in new equipment and 3.0 in extra stock and customer credit. Cash available after all of this was about 1.5 million.

          Harmony's statement with a switch between by-nature and by-function. Clicking a subtotal (EBITDA, EBIT, gross profit) highlights the lines it includes and shows the question it answers. The learner discovers that EBIT is identical in both layouts, while EBITDA and gross profit depend on layout and disclosure.

          1. 2.2 An investor wants to compare two companies in the same industry, one heavily indebted and one debt-free. Which subtotal should come first, and why?

          2. 2.3 Compute Harmony's interest cover on EBIT. Is it higher or lower than the 9 times on EBITDA, and why?

          3. 2.4 Two companies have the same EBIT. Name two reasons why their net incomes can differ.

          2

          1. Which subtotal is the same whether Harmony presents its costs by nature or by function?

          2. Harmony's EBITDA of 18.0 goes to depreciation 6.0, lenders 2.0, the state 2.5 and shareholders…

          3. An investor compares an indebted company with a debt-free one in the same industry. Which subtotal first?

          3Reading the layers: what is lasting, what is adjusted

          A statement is only useful if you can tell which parts will come back next year.

          One-offs matter, but the label is a judgement

          Operating profit should show what the business earns year after year

          Some items are rare and large: the sale of a building, the closing of a factory, a court settlement. If they sit inside operating profit, the figure no longer predicts next year. Analysts therefore separate recurring from non-recurring items. The split is the single most subjective step in reading accounts.

          A one-off that returns every year is a recurring cost

          A restructuring charge once is an event. The same charge year after year is a way of doing business. Ask whether an informed outsider would expect the item to come back, and apply the test to gains as well as losses.

          International standards do not define an exceptional category, and the label extraordinary is banned. Each company therefore decides which items to show separately, and must justify it. That freedom is why two firms with the same events can report different operating profits.

          An adjusted measure helps only if you can reconcile it

          Companies publish their own versions of profit, and the gap is the story

          Many companies report adjusted EBITDA or underlying profit. These are alternative performance measures, figures not defined by accounting standards. Regulators in Europe expect each one to be defined, reconciled to the nearest audited figure, shown no more prominently than the audited one and used consistently across years.

          EBITDA is a useful half-measure, not cash

          EBITDA ignores the cost of the equipment that produced it. After Harmony's capital expenditure of 9.0, only 9.0 of the 18.0 remains, which is half.

          Leases inflate EBITDA without changing the economics

          Under IFRS 16, a lease is no longer a rent expense. It becomes a depreciation charge plus an interest charge. Harmony's case figures keep the 1.5 million yearly rent of its warehouse inside EBITDA, as under the old rules. Booked under IFRS 16, year 1 would carry depreciation of 1.27 and interest of 0.38 instead (CF8 derives them).

          EBITDA would be 1.5 higher (19.5 against 18.0) and operating profit 0.23 higher (12.23 against 12.0). Profit before tax would be 0.15 lower (9.85), because interest is highest early in a lease; over its life the charges add up to the rent. The business did not change, only the layout.

          IFRS 18 puts every line in a category and audits management's own measures

          A new standard replaces the old layout from 2027

          IFRS 18 replaces IAS 1 for reporting periods starting on or after 1 January 2027, with comparative figures restated. It does not change how profit is measured. It changes how the statement is laid out and what must be disclosed. Three changes matter.

          • Five categories. Each income and expense falls into operating, investing, financing, income taxes or discontinued operations. Operating is what is left after the others are assigned.

          • Two defined subtotals. Operating profit and profit before financing and income taxes become required lines, so EBIT-like figures become comparable.

          • Management-defined performance measures. A subtotal of income and expenses that the standards do not define and that management uses in public communication, such as adjusted EBITDA, must be explained in one note and reconciled to a defined subtotal.

          A company that presents costs by function must also disclose, in a note, certain costs by nature: depreciation, amortisation, employee benefits and some impairments. This answers the earlier problem: EBITDA can always be rebuilt.

          3.1 Which IFRS 18 category?

          Place each item for Harmony in operating, investing, financing, income taxes or discontinued operations: (a) interest on the bank loan; (b) wages of assembly staff; (c) interest received on a cash deposit; (d) Harmony's share of the profit of a 30%-owned battery start-up; (e) corporate income tax; (f) the cost of closing the repair workshop.

          (a) Financing. (b) Operating. (c) Investing, because it is the return on cash held as an investment. (d) Investing, as income from an associate. (e) Income taxes. (f) Operating, because closing a workshop is part of running the business, even if it is rare. Under IFRS 18 there is no place outside operating profit for an unusual operating cost, which is why management measures are disclosed in a note.

          Rivelo's reconciliation as a toggle table. Each add-back (restructuring, share-based pay, pro forma synergies) has a switch, and a bar shows EBITDA moving between 6.0 and 9.0. The learner decides which to accept, then sees a short commentary on each. They discover that most of the gap rests on items the company chose, not on items the accounts required.

          3

          1. Rivelo's adjusted EBITDA is 9.0 against an audited EBITDA of 6.0. The most questionable add-back is…

          2. A restructuring charge appears for the third year running. An analyst should…

          3. What does IFRS 18 change from 2027?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Earnings

          = −

          From sales to EBIT, by nature

          = −

          By function EBIT is the same: 42.0 − 6.0 − 16.0 − 8.0 = 12.0.

          Where EBITDA goes

          = + + +

          Idea What to remember
          Earnings versus cash Earnings count value created and used when events happen. Cash counts payments. They differ whenever timing, stock or long-lived assets are involved.
          Revenue Recorded when the promise to the customer is delivered, not when paid. Money received early is a debt to the customer.
          By nature or by function Same operating profit. By nature shows what is paid for, by function shows gross margin and needs disclosure of depreciation.
          EBITDA Result of the operating cycle before equipment cost. Useful, but not cash. Harmony: 18.0, of which 9.0 survives after capex.
          EBIT Operating profit before any financing. The fair comparison between firms with different debt. Harmony: 12.0.
          Net income What belongs to shareholders after lenders and the state. Distributable, not distributed, and not spare cash. Harmony: 7.5.
          Recurring versus one-off Apply one test to gains and losses. A one-off that returns every year is a recurring cost.
          Adjusted measures Trust them only with a reconciliation to an audited figure. Look at what is added back.
          IFRS 18 From 2027: five categories, defined operating profit and profit before financing and tax, management measures reconciled.
          France The SIG staircase: value added, EBE, résultat d'exploitation, résultat courant, résultat exceptionnel, résultat net.

          The one-sentence version

          Read the income statement as a staircase from sales to net income, remember that it measures wealth and not cash, and trust each adjusted subtotal only if you can reconcile it to the audited one.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Accrual accounting Recording an event when it happens, not when money moves.
          Depreciation Spreading the cost of a lasting asset over the years it is used.
          EBITDA Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation.
          EBIT Operating profit: earnings before interest and tax.
          Non-recurring item A gain or cost judged unlikely to repeat.
          Alternative performance measure A profit figure defined by the company, not by the standards.
          Value added Production less purchases from outside: what the firm itself adds.
          EBE The French gross operating surplus, close to EBITDA.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on earnings and the income statement.

          • IFRS Foundation — IFRS 18 Presentation and Disclosure in Financial Statements (2024), the standard replacing IAS 1.

          • IFRS Foundation — IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers.

          • ESMA — Guidelines on Alternative Performance Measures (2015).

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.