Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Reading the accounts / Module 3

3Cash flows first

Where a company's cash comes from, where it goes, and what is left for the people who funded it

Where a company’s cash comes from, where it goes, and what is left for the people who funded it.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
11
Exercises
5
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Sort any cash movement into the operating, investment, debt or equity cycle.

  • Build free cash flow from EBITDA, working capital, tax and capital expenditure.

  • Explain why profit, EBITDA and cash flow differ, using Harmony's year N.

  • Split free cash flow between lenders and shareholders, and follow the change in net debt.

  • Read a cash forecast and spot when a year-end cash figure has been flattered.

1Cash moves in four loops

Before any calculation, a map. Four loops carry all the money in and out of a company, and each has its own logic.

The operating cycle pays out first and collects later

A business spends cash to make something and waits to be paid for it

Harmony buys components, assembles bikes, keeps some in stock, and sells them to dealers who pay after a delay. Cash goes out on day one and comes back weeks later. The weeks in between must be funded by someone. This is the operating cycle, and it is the source of all the cash a company earns.

Growth needs cash before it brings cash

Stock and customer credit grow with sales. Working capital is the money tied up in stock and customer credit, net of what suppliers have not yet been paid. Harmony keeps it near 20% of sales. When sales rose from 105 to 120 million in year N, working capital rose from 21.0 to 24.0 million.

Investment and financing are two sides of one transaction

Capital expenditure is spending whose benefit outlasts the year

Some spending is consumed within the cycle: paint, wages, freight. Other spending buys something that will keep producing for years: a welding jig, a new assembly hall. The second kind is capital expenditure, or capex. It belongs to the investment cycle.

A tooling item costing 0.5 million that lasts five years is capex. The same 0.5 million of paint used up in a few months is an operating cost. In year N Harmony spent 9.0 million of capex, against 6.0 million of depreciation, which is the accounting charge that spreads past capex over the years.

Lenders are paid by contract, shareholders take what is left

The money for operations and investment comes from two sources. Lenders advance cash and are owed fixed interest and repayment on fixed dates. Shareholders put in cash and are owed nothing fixed: they receive dividends if there is something to distribute, and they bear the risk if there is not. These are the debt cycle and the equity cycle.

Cash held is debt not yet needed, so net debt counts it as negative debt

A company with 40 of debt and 10 of cash could repay a quarter of its debt tomorrow. Net debt is gross debt minus cash and cash-like investments. Harmony's is 40.0 − 10.0 = 30.0 million. It says what lenders would still be owed if all cash went to repay them.

Your neighbour Mireille, a retired teacher, reads that Harmony earned 7.5 million last year. She asks why the company still has a loan of 40 million and so little cash. In your own words, and without the terms EBITDA or working capital, tell her three places a profitable bike maker's cash can go besides the bank account.

      Mireille. Three places: stock of bikes waiting to be sold, invoices from dealers not yet paid, and new equipment. In Harmony's year, 6.0 of it was depreciation, which pays nothing, while 9.0 went on equipment and 3.0 on stock and credit.

      Karim. He is right that he gets paid sooner. He is wrong if the factor can come back to him when the customer does not pay: then he has received a loan secured on the invoices. Example: he sells 10,000 of invoices for 9,700 cash. If he must repay when a customer fails, the 9,700 is a loan. He also cannot repeat it next year using the same invoices.

      a drag-and-drop sorting game. Twelve cash movements of Harmony (a dealer pays an invoice, the bank is repaid, a paint robot is bought, a dividend is declared, parts are bought on credit, and so on) are dragged into four buckets. Each wrong drop explains the rule it broke. The learner discovers that the test is always the same: who is the counterparty and does the benefit last beyond the year.

      1

      1. Harmony pays suppliers on credit for components. In which cycle is that payment?

      2. A 0.5 million tooling item that lasts five years is…

      3. Harmony has gross debt of 40.0 and cash of 10.0. What does its net debt of 30.0 tell you?

      2From EBITDA to free cash flow: Harmony's year N

      One line of arithmetic connects the accounting figure everyone quotes to the cash that investors can actually take away.

      Free cash flow is what the business leaves after paying to stay in business

      Three deductions take Harmony from 18.0 of EBITDA to 3.0 of free cash flow

      EBITDA is operating profit before depreciation and amortisation. It is the nearest accounting figure to the cash the operating cycle produces, but it leaves out three real payments. Free cash flow deducts them.

      Free cash flow = EBITDA − increase in working capital − tax on operating profit − capital expenditure

      • Increase in working capital. Cash locked into stock and customer credit during the year.

      • Tax on operating profit. The tax the company would pay if it had no debt, so that free cash flow does not depend on how the company is financed.

      • Capital expenditure. Cash spent on assets that will last.

      The tax is 3.0, not the 2.5 in the income statement

      Harmony's income statement shows tax of 2.5 million, which is 25% of a profit of 10.0 million after 2.0 million of interest. Interest is deductible, so borrowing saves 25% × 2.0 = 0.5 million of tax. Free cash flow charges the full 3.0 so that it measures the business alone. The 0.5 saving is credited to the financing side in Part 3.

      Profit, EBITDA and cash flow tell three different stories

      A profit of 7.5 became a fall in net debt of only 1.5

      Start from net income and correct for what is not a cash movement. Depreciation was deducted to reach profit but nothing was paid, so it is added back. Working capital and capex were paid but never appear in profit, so they are deducted.

      € million, year N Amount
      Net income 7.5
      Add back depreciation (no cash paid) +6.0
      Increase in working capital −3.0
      Capital expenditure −9.0
      Cash available to reduce net debt 1.5

      No dividend was paid and no shares were issued, so all of it went to reducing net debt.

      The same 1.5 appears from the other direction: free cash flow of 3.0, less interest after tax of 2.0 × (1 − 25%) = 1.5. Net debt therefore fell from 31.5 to 30.0 million.

      Look at leverage, which is net debt divided by EBITDA. It fell from 31.5 / 14.7 = 2.14 times to 30.0 / 18.0 = 1.67 times. Most of that improvement came from EBITDA growing from 14.7 to 18.0, and only a small part from paying debt down.

      2.1 Harmony's next year

      Harmony forecasts year N+1 with sales up 15%, an EBITDA margin still at 15%, depreciation of 6.9 million, capex of 12.0 million, and working capital at 20% of sales. Tax is 25% of operating profit. Build the free cash flow. Compare it with year N and say what drove the change.

      Sales are 120 × 1.15 = 138.0, EBITDA 20.7, operating profit 20.7 − 6.9 = 13.8. Working capital is 20% × 138.0 = 27.6, so it rises by 27.6 − 24.0 = 3.6. Tax is 25% × 13.8 = 3.45. Free cash flow = 20.7 − 3.6 − 3.45 − 12.0 = 1.65 million.

      It is lower than year N (3.0) even though EBITDA rose by 2.7. The extra EBITDA is more than absorbed by capex up 3.0, working capital up 0.6 and tax up 0.45. With after-tax interest of 1.5, net debt would fall by only 0.15.

      a waterfall chart of Harmony's year N, from EBITDA down to free cash flow, with sliders for sales growth, EBITDA margin, working capital as a share of sales, and capex. The learner pushes growth up and watches free cash flow turn negative while EBITDA rises, discovering that growth consumes cash before it produces it.

      2

      1. Harmony's EBITDA is 18.0. Working capital rose by 3.0, tax on operating profit is 3.0 and capex 9.0. Free cash flow is…

      2. Why does free cash flow charge tax of 3.0 when the income statement shows 2.5?

      3. Net income 7.5 + depreciation 6.0 − working capital 3.0 − capex 9.0 gives…

      3Who receives the free cash flow

      Free cash flow is produced by the business and claimed by the people who funded it. Following the claims explains the change in net debt, and shows why leases need a rule.

      Lenders are paid first and shareholders receive the remainder

      Harmony's 3.5 of cash did not cover the 4.0 owed to its lenders

      Free cash flow to the firm is the figure built in Part 2, before any payment to funders. Add the 0.5 tax saving from interest and Harmony had 3.5 million to distribute. Lenders were owed interest of 2.0 million and a repayment of 2.0 million.

      Free cash flow to equity is what remains for the shareholders

      Free cash flow to equity = free cash flow to the firm − interest × (1 − tax rate) + new borrowing − repayments

      For Harmony: 3.0 − 1.5 + 0 − 2.0 = −0.5 million. The shareholders' side was in deficit, covered from the cash balance. One such year in a company that is investing is normal. Year after year, it would not be.

      Free cash flow to the firm values the whole business at the cost of capital (CF27). Free cash flow to equity values the shares alone at the cost of equity. Never mix the two.

      Net debt falls only when free cash flow exceeds what funders take out

      Fall in net debt = free cash flow to the firm − interest after tax − dividends + new equity raised

      For Harmony: 3.0 − 1.5 − 0 + 0 = 1.5. Notice what is missing. Repaying debt from cash does not appear, because it lowers gross debt and cash by the same amount. If Harmony used 2.0 of its 10.0 of cash to repay 2.0 of debt, gross debt would be 38.0, cash 8.0, and net debt still 30.0.

      1. 3.3 Harmony's free cash flow to equity is −0.5 million, yet the company is not in trouble. Give two reasons.

      2. 3.4 Why does free cash flow to the firm ignore interest, while net income deducts it?

      3. 3.5 In the lease table that follows, Banque du Rhône proposes in a renegotiation to cut the 3.0 times net debt / EBITDA covenant to 2.0 times. What is the headroom under each presentation?

      A lease moves cash between lines without creating any

      Under IFRS 16 a rent becomes depreciation and interest

      A lease is the right to use an asset in return for regular payments. Suppose Harmony rents a distribution warehouse for 1.5 million a year. Under IFRS 16, the lease standard for companies reporting under IFRS, the lessee records the right to use the building as an asset and the present value of the payments still due as a debt, the lease liability. The rent disappears from operating costs and is replaced by depreciation and interest.

      The case figures for Harmony keep the 1.5 million of rent inside EBITDA. The table shows the same year with the lease booked as IFRS 16 requires. It uses the year-1 figures CF8 derives for this lease: depreciation of the right-of-use asset of 1.27, interest of 0.38 and a lease liability of 7.61. It ignores tax effects.

      Pair every measure with its consistent partner

      If leases are treated as debt, then EBITDA before the rent goes with net debt including the lease liability. If rent is treated as an operating cost, EBITDA after the rent goes with net debt excluding leases. Mixing the two, for example an EBITDA before rent with a net debt without leases, flatters the ratio. CF8 gives the analyst's field guide to leases and other tricky items.

      3.1 A company in a hurry

      A company has EBITDA of 40, an increase in working capital of 5, tax on operating profit of 6 and capex of 18. It pays interest of 4 before tax (tax rate 25%), borrows 10, repays 4 and pays a dividend of 5. Compute free cash flow to the firm, free cash flow to equity, and the change in net debt. Then check the last answer against the change in cash and debt.

      Free cash flow to the firm = 40 − 5 − 6 − 18 = 11. Interest after tax is 4 × 0.75 = 3. Free cash flow to equity = 11 − 3 + 10 − 4 = 14. Change in net debt: it falls by 11 − 3 − 5 = 3.

      Check: cash rises by 14 − 5 = 9, because free cash flow to equity of 14 less the dividend of 5 stays in the bank. Gross debt rises by 6. Net debt changes by +6 − 9 = −3, so it falls by 3.

      3.2 Rivelo's three leverage ratios

      Rivelo, a smaller bike maker, reports under IFRS 16 an EBITDA of 6.0, of which 1.0 is rent that used to be an operating cost. Its net debt excluding leases is 14.0 and its lease liabilities are 3.0. Compute net debt / EBITDA three ways: with leases in both numerator and denominator, with rent treated as an operating cost and leases excluded, and with the inconsistent mix. Which one flatters Rivelo?

      With leases in both: (14 + 3) / 6 = 2.83. With rent as an operating cost: 14 / (6 − 1) = 2.80. The mix, net debt without leases over EBITDA with leases: 14 / 6 = 2.33.

      The mix flatters Rivelo. The two consistent versions agree closely: applied consistently, the lease treatment barely changes the verdict.

      1. 3.6 Harmony pays 2.0 of interest but the income statement shows tax of 2.5, not 3.0. Where does the missing 0.5 go in a free cash flow calculation?

      2. 3.7 A company repays 5 of debt using 5 of cash. What happens to gross debt, cash, net debt and free cash flow?

      3. 3.8 Name one reason to prefer free cash flow to the firm when comparing two companies with different amounts of debt.

      3

      1. Harmony's free cash flow to equity in year N is…

      2. A company repays 5 of debt using 5 of cash. Net debt…

      3. Rivelo: EBITDA 6.0 including 1.0 of former rent, net debt 14.0 without leases, leases 3.0. Which ratio flatters it?

      4Cash is managed in weeks, and some cash is borrowed in disguise

      A yearly cash flow can be comfortable while the company runs out of money in April. And a year-end cash balance can be improved by arrangements that are really borrowing.

      A yearly free cash flow hides the month when cash runs out

      The tightest month decides how much credit the company needs

      Harmony builds bikes in winter and spring, and dealers pay after the spring sales. Suppliers must be paid before. Cash therefore falls for several months and recovers later. The table shows the first four months of a year, with Harmony starting at 10.0 million of cash and a 20.0 million revolving facility, 10.0 already drawn. Net cash position is cash minus the extra amount drawn.

      € million Jan Feb Mar Apr
      Receipts from dealers and online 8.0 7.5 8.5 12.0
      Payments to suppliers −9.5 −10.5 −11.0 −9.0
      Payroll and overheads −3.0 −3.0 −3.0 −3.0
      Capex and tax −0.5 −0.5 −1.5 −0.5
      Net cash flow −5.0 −6.5 −7.0 −0.5
      Net cash position at month end 5.0 −1.5 −8.5 −9.0

      A negative net cash position means the facility is drawn by that amount beyond the 10.0 already drawn.

      At the end of April Harmony has drawn a further 9.0 million of the 10.0 million still available, leaving 1.0 million of headroom. The rest of the year, as bikes are sold, brings the cash back.

      Treasurers therefore keep a 13-week cash forecast, refreshed every week. It lists receipts by the date each invoice falls due and payments by the date each bill must be paid. It is the tool for liquidity. The annual budget is the tool for planning. For how banks structure such credit lines, see the Corporate Banking Financing modules on the site.

      4.1 A bad spring

      Suppose dealers pay badly in spring: April receipts come in 3.0 lower than in the table, and a supplier insists on being paid 1.0 earlier, in March instead of April. Recompute the lowest net cash position. Is the 10.0 of available credit enough? How much available credit would leave a buffer of 2.0?

      March net flow falls from −7.0 to −8.0 because the 1.0 payment arrives early. April loses 3.0 of receipts but no longer carries that 1.0 payment, so its flow goes from −0.5 to −2.5. The position is 5.0, −1.5, then −9.5 in March and −12.0 in April. The lowest point is −12.0 million: the 10.0 of available credit is 2.0 short. To leave a buffer of 2.0, the available credit should be 14.0.

      a cash-plan simulator with the Harmony monthly table and sliders for dealer payment delay, supplier payment terms and the size of the credit line. A coloured bar shows headroom month by month. The learner discovers that the credit line must cover the trough, not the year.

      Selling receivables improves year-end cash but is borrowing

      Factoring turns customer credit into cash today

      In factoring, a company sells its customer invoices to a specialist, the factor, for a little less than their face value. The company receives the cash immediately and the customer pays the factor later. Receivables fall, working capital falls, and operating cash flow jumps.

      The jump happens once. Next year the same invoices do not exist to be sold again. And when the company stays responsible if customers fail to pay, which is called recourse, the money received is in substance a loan secured on the invoices. Under IFRS such invoices stay on the balance sheet and the cash is shown as a borrowing. Other rulebooks and contracts can be more lenient, so analysts read the notes.

      Your brother-in-law Karim runs a plumbing firm. He says that selling his unpaid invoices to a factor is just collecting his money faster, so it cannot count as borrowing. Explain to him, with a small example in euros, when he is right and when he is wrong.

          4.2 Selle Nord and the factor

          Selle Nord, a components supplier, reports EBITDA of 4.0 and net debt of 8.0. Its notes reveal that 1.5 of receivables sold to a factor have left its balance sheet although Selle Nord still bears the loss if customers do not pay. Compute net debt / EBITDA as reported and as an analyst would adjust it.

          As reported: 8.0 / 4.0 = 2.00 times. Adjusted for recourse financing: (8.0 + 1.5) / 4.0 = 2.38 times. The difference is the debt that was moved out of sight on the last day of the year.

          1. 4.3 Name two signs in a company's accounts that its year-end cash may have been flattered.

          2. 4.4 Harmony's free cash flow is positive for the year, yet its cash falls for four months. Explain in one sentence.

          3. 4.5 Why does a 13-week forecast list receipts by due date, when the budget lists them by month of sale?

          4

          1. Harmony's net cash position reaches −9.0 in April with 10.0 of credit available. The lesson is…

          2. Harmony sells 4.0 of receivables with recourse on 31 December. An analyst…

          3. Which sign suggests that year-end cash has been flattered?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Free cash flow to the firm

          = − − −

          Free cash flow to equity

          = FCF − +

          Fall in net debt

          = FCF − − +

          Repaying debt out of cash does not change net debt.

          Idea What to remember
          Four cycles Operating, investment, debt and equity. Every cash movement belongs to one.
          Working capital Stock plus customer credit minus supplier credit. Grows with sales: Harmony 21.0 to 24.0.
          Capex Spending whose benefit outlasts the year. Harmony year N: 9.0 against depreciation of 6.0.
          Free cash flow to the firm EBITDA − increase in working capital − tax on operating profit − capex. Harmony: 3.0.
          Free cash flow to equity Free cash flow to the firm − interest after tax + net borrowing. Harmony: −0.5.
          Net debt Gross debt minus cash. Moves only with free cash flow, interest, dividends and equity raised. Harmony: 31.5 to 30.0.
          Leases (IFRS 16) Rent becomes depreciation plus interest and a liability. Cash is unchanged; EBITDA and net debt both rise.
          Cash forecast 13 weeks, by due date. The credit line must cover the trough, not the year.
          Flattered cash Factoring brings cash forward once. Treat the amount as debt.

          The one-sentence version

          A company's cash flows through four cycles, free cash flow is what the operating and investment cycles leave after tax and growth, and the debt and equity cycles show who is paid with it, so profit, EBITDA and cash must always be read together.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Free cash flow Cash left after the business has paid its running costs, tax, working capital growth and capex.
          Working capital Cash tied up in stock and customer credit, net of supplier credit.
          Capital expenditure (capex) Spending on assets that will keep producing for more than a year.
          Net debt Gross debt minus cash and cash-like investments.
          Lease liability The debt a company records for rent it has agreed to pay in future under IFRS 16.
          Factoring Selling customer invoices to a specialist for immediate cash.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on cash flows.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on financial analysis and on short-term financial planning.

          • IFRS Foundation — IAS 7 Statement of Cash Flows and IFRS 16 Leases.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.