Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Foundations / Module 2

2Time value of money and rates of return

Why a euro today is not a euro next year, and how to say by how much

Why a euro today is not a euro next year, and how to say by how much.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
16
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Compound and discount a single amount, and find the rate or the number of years that connects two amounts.

  • Value an annuity, a perpetuity and a growing perpetuity, and say when each shortcut applies.

  • Convert between nominal, periodic, effective and continuous rates, and spot a rate that is quoted in a flattering way.

  • Keep real and nominal rates matched to real and nominal cash flows.

  • Build the repayment schedule of a loan and compare repayment shapes.

1Why time has a price

Start with one amount and one date. Everything later is repetition of two moves: carrying money forward and bringing it back.

A euro today is worth more than a euro later, for three separate reasons

Waiting costs you the use of the money, the buying power of the money, and the certainty of the money

Offer someone 100 today or 100 in a year, and almost everyone takes today. There are three reasons, and they are different in kind. First, money in hand can be put to work: lent, deposited, or invested in a machine. Waiting means giving up what it would have earned. Second, prices usually rise, so 100 next year buys less. Third, a promise can be broken, while cash in hand cannot.

A rate of return rolls these three reasons into one number. The risk-free rate pays only for waiting and for inflation. Add a premium for the chance that the promise fails, and you have the rate required on a risky asset. Module CF16 builds that premium. In this module the rate is simply given.

Compounding carries an amount forward and lets interest earn interest

After each year the base grows, so each year's gain is larger than the last

Put 100 in an account paying 10% a year. After one year you hold 110. In the second year the 10% applies to 110, not to 100, so you earn 11 and hold 121. The extra 1 is interest on interest. That is compounding: gains are added to the base, and the next gains are earned on the larger base.

FV = PV × (1 + r)ⁿ

PV is the amount today (the present value), r the rate per period, n the number of periods and FV the amount at the end (the future value). The only difficult part is remembering that n is a power. Growth that doubles the base every few years looks gentle at first and enormous later.

Doubling time gives a quick feel for any rate

How long does money take to double? The exact answer needs logarithms. The shortcut is the rule of 72: divide 72 by the rate in percent. At 9%, Harmony's standard discount rate, that gives 8 years. The exact figure is 8.04. At 3% the rule gives 24 years against an exact 23.4.

Discounting is compounding run backwards

To value a future amount today, ask what smaller sum would grow into it

If 100 today becomes 109 in a year at 9%, then 109 in a year is worth 100 today. Go the other way: divide by (1 + r) for each period. This is discounting, and the rate used is the discount rate.

PV = FV / (1 + r)ⁿ

The factor 1 / (1 + r)ⁿ is the discount factor. It is always below one when the rate is positive, and it shrinks as n grows. It is the price today of one euro delivered at date n.

The farther away an amount is, the more a change of rate hurts it

At 9%, 100 due in ten years is worth 42.24 today. Due in thirty years it is worth 7.54. Distant cash flows are fragile: a small change in the rate moves their value a lot. This is why assumptions about long-lived projects and about the final value of a business deserve the most suspicion (see CF27).

1.1 Parking Harmony's cash

Harmony leaves 10.0 million on deposit at 3%. (a) How much does it hold after five years? (b) How many years until it holds 20.0 million? Compare the exact answer with the rule of 72.

(a) 10.0 × 1.03⁵ = 11.59 million.

(b) The exact time to double is ln 2 / ln 1.03 = 23.4 years. The rule of 72 gives 72 / 3 = 24 years. The shortcut is close, which is all it claims to be.

Marta runs a flower shop and has been told that her savings plan turned 2,000 into 3,000 in five years. She says: that is 1,000 over five years, so 200 a year, so 10% a year. Explain to her, in everyday language and without the words compound or exponent, why her yearly rate is lower than 10% and what she should compare it with.

      A good answer says: 200 a year is right only if interest never earns interest. In reality each year's gain joins the pile and earns in turn, so a smaller yearly rate reaches the same 1,000. Her plan grew by about 8.4% a year, and that is the figure to compare with what a bank pays on a deposit.

      sliders for amount, rate and years, with the amount growing forward, a toggle to discount it back, and a simple-interest line for comparison. The learner discovers how the gap widens with rate and horizon.

      1. 1.3 Suppose inflation is zero and the borrower never defaults. Why is 100 today still worth more than 100 in a year?

      2. 1.4 A deposit grows by 40% in four years. Is the yearly rate 10%? Compute it.

      3. 1.5 Harmony is owed 5.0 million due in two years and another 5.0 million due in twenty years. The discount rate rises from 9% to 10%. Which amount loses more value, and by how much in percentage?

      1

      1. Harmony places 10.0 million at 3% for five years. It ends with…

      2. A deposit grows by 40% in four years. Its yearly rate is…

      3. Harmony is owed 5.0 in two years and 5.0 in twenty years. The rate rises from 9% to 10%. Which loses more value?

      2Streams of payments and their shortcuts

      Real contracts pay many times. Adding each discounted payment works, but patterns such as equal payments allow a one-line price.

      An annuity is a run of equal payments, and its value has a closed form

      Add the discounted payments once, then reuse the answer

      A rent, a loan repayment, a lease or a pension often pays the same amount each period for a fixed number of periods. That pattern is an annuity. The convention is that the first payment arrives one period after the date of valuation, and the last at the end of period n.

      PV of annuity = C × [1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ] / r

      C is the payment. The bracket divided by r is the annuity factor, the value today of one euro paid at the end of each period. At 9% over eight years it is 5.5348.

      A perpetuity is the limit of an annuity, and it has a finite price

      Payments that never stop can still be worth a fixed amount

      Let the number of periods grow without end. The term (1 + r)⁻ⁿ shrinks towards zero and the formula collapses to a simple fraction. A stream of C every year, forever, is a perpetuity.

      PV of perpetuity = C / r

      Suppose a dealer pays Harmony a fixed fee of 0.6 million a year for exclusive use of a regional brand, with no end date. At 9% the fee is worth 0.6 / 0.09 = 6.67 million. At 8% it is worth 7.50, and at 10% it is worth 6.00.

      Growth turns the perpetuity into a rule with one condition

      If payments grow at g, the price is the first payment divided by the gap between r and g

      Many streams grow: rents indexed to inflation, dividends that rise with profit, a fee linked to sales. If the first payment arrives next year and then grows at a constant rate g forever, its value is given by the growing perpetuity formula.

      PV of growing perpetuity = C₁ / (r − g), valid only if g < r

      The logic is the same fraction as before, with r replaced by the gap r − g. Growth cancels part of the discounting. If the dealer fee above starts at 0.6 next year and grows by 2% a year, its value is 0.6 / (0.09 − 0.02) = 8.57 million, up from 6.67.

      Most of a long stream sits far in the future

      Take the same fee growing at 2% but paid for only ten years. Its value is 4.16 million, 48.5% of the perpetual 8.57. The other 4.41 million sits beyond year 10, which is why valuation models need a final value (CF27).

      2.1 A contract that grows

      A fleet customer will pay Harmony 0.9 million next year for maintenance, and the amount will grow by 3% a year indefinitely. (a) Value the contract at 9%. (b) What is the value if the discount rate falls to 8%, and by what percentage does the value change?

      (a) 0.9 / (0.09 − 0.03) = 15.0 million.

      (b) At 8%: 0.9 / (0.08 − 0.03) = 18.0 million, a rise of 20%. A one-point fall in the rate lifts the value by a fifth because the gap r − g is small. This is the sensitivity warned about in the section.

      2

      1. A saving of 1.5 million a year for eight years is worth 8.30 at 9%. Why is it less than 8 × 1.5 = 12?

      2. A fleet contract pays 0.9 next year and grows by 3% a year for ever. At 9% it is worth…

      3. When does the growing perpetuity formula C₁ / (r − g) break down?

      3One rate, many names

      The same cost can be quoted per month, per year, with interest on interest or without. To compare offers you must convert them to a common basis.

      A quoted rate is only a label until you know how often it compounds

      Three rates describe one loan: the periodic rate, the nominal rate and the effective rate

      A bank advertises 6% a year, paid monthly. What that means is a periodic rate of 0.5% each month. The nominal rate (also called the stated or quoted rate) is the periodic rate multiplied by the number of periods: 12 × 0.5% = 6%. It is a label, not a growth rate, because it ignores interest on interest.

      The effective annual rate (EAR) is what the money really grows by in a year. Compounding 0.5% twelve times gives 1.005¹² − 1 = 6.17%.

      EAR = (1 + nominal rate / m)ᵐ − 1, where m is the number of periods in a year

      Compounding Periods a year (m) Effective rate for a 6% nominal rate
      Annual 1 6.000%
      Half-yearly 2 6.090%
      Quarterly 4 6.136%
      Monthly 12 6.168%
      Daily 365 6.183%
      Continuous unlimited 6.184%

      The more often interest is added, the higher the effective rate, but the gain flattens out quickly.

      Continuous compounding is the limit, and it makes the algebra tidy

      Let the number of periods a year grow without bound and the limit is the exponential: an amount grows by e^(r × t), where e is about 2.718. At a 6% continuous rate the effective annual rate is e^0.06 − 1 = 6.18%. Options theory uses it (CF20); business contracts almost never do.

      Always convert to effective rates before comparing offers. A loan quoted at 6.1% a year with annual interest costs less than one quoted at 6% a year compounded monthly, because 6.10% is below 6.17%.

      Hidden rates hide in payment terms, and they can be very large

      A discount for paying early is a rate of interest in disguise

      Suppliers often write terms such as 2/10 net 30: take 2% off if you pay within ten days, otherwise pay the full amount by day thirty. Paying late means borrowing from the supplier for twenty extra days. The cost of that borrowing is the 2% discount you give up.

      Day counts

      Interest is paid for a number of days, and conventions differ. ACT/360 counts actual days over a 360-day year, 30/360 treats every month as 30 days. On 10.0 million at 4%, 91 days under ACT/360 cost 10.0 × 4% × 91 / 360 = 0.1011 million, against 0.1000 for a plain quarter. LIBOR has gone: dollar and sterling loans now float on overnight rates (SOFR, SONIA), and €STR replaced EONIA. Most euro loans still float on EURIBOR, which was reformed rather than abolished.

      Real and nominal rates must match the cash flows they discount

      A nominal rate includes expected inflation; a real rate removes it

      A nominal rate is quoted in euros of the day. A real rate is quoted in euros of constant buying power. The two are linked exactly by the Fisher relation.

      1 + nominal = (1 + real) × (1 + inflation)

      At a nominal 5% and 2.2% inflation, the real rate is 1.05 / 1.022 − 1 = 2.74%. Subtracting gives 2.8%, close enough at low inflation but increasingly wrong when inflation is high.

      Keep the unit of the cash flows and the unit of the rate identical. Discounting nominal flows at a real rate overstates value; the reverse understates it.

      A yield to maturity is the single rate that explains a price

      Turn the question around: given the price and the payments, what is the rate?

      Often the price and the promised payments are known and the rate is the unknown. It is the rate at which the discounted payments equal the price. For a security it is the yield to maturity; for a project it is the internal rate of return (CF24). It is the same calculation. Bonds are covered in CF17.

      3.1 Comparing quotes

      A bank quotes Harmony a deposit at 4.8% a year, interest added quarterly. A card issuer charges a business customer 1.5% a month. Convert both to effective annual rates.

      Deposit: 1.012⁴ − 1 = 4.89% (quarterly rate is 4.8% / 4 = 1.2%). Card: 1.015¹² − 1 = 19.56%, well above the 18% that a simple multiplication suggests.

      Julien is a plumber. His card statement says 1.5% interest per month, and he thinks that is 18% a year. Explain to him, in everyday language, why the true yearly cost is higher and roughly what it is.

          A good answer says: the 1.5% is charged every month on a balance that already includes the earlier interest. Twelve months of that multiplies the balance by 1.015 twelve times, about 19.6%, not 18%. The yearly figure is the one to compare with other loans.

          a decision game with five offers quoted in different ways, including a 2/10 net 30 term. The learner ranks them by cost, then checks the effective rates and discovers that the offer that sounds cheapest rarely is.

          1. 3.3 Harmony can borrow at 6.0% compounded monthly or at 6.1% compounded once a year. Which is cheaper?

          2. 3.4 A contract pays a real 1.0 million in five years. Does the value depend on whether you discount in real or in nominal terms, if you do it consistently?

          3. 3.5 A bond bought at 98 pays a 4.5% coupon and is repaid at 100. Is its yield above or below 4.5%? Why?

          3

          1. A card charges 1.5% a month. Its effective annual rate is…

          2. A supplier offers 2/10 net 30. Harmony borrows at about 5%. What should it do?

          3. A bond bought at 98 pays a 4.5% coupon and repays 100 in five years. Its yield to maturity is…

          4Loans and spreadsheets put the formulas to work

          A loan is the cleanest application of the annuity formula, and a spreadsheet is where every practitioner meets these tools.

          A loan is worth its repayments, and the schedule shows where each euro goes

          The amount borrowed equals the present value of the repayments at the loan's rate

          Banque du Rhône lends Harmony 12.0 million for five years at 5%, in five equal payments. Because the loan is worth exactly what it will be repaid, the payment solves 12.0 = payment × annuity factor. The annuity factor at 5% over five years is 4.3295, so the payment is 12.0 / 4.3295 = 2.772 million a year.

          Each payment has two parts. Interest is the rate times the balance still owed. The rest repays principal and reduces the balance. Because the balance falls, interest falls too, and the principal share rises.

          Year Opening balance Interest at 5% Principal repaid Payment Closing balance
          1 12.000 0.600 2.172 2.772 9.828
          2 9.828 0.491 2.280 2.772 7.548
          3 7.548 0.377 2.394 2.772 5.154
          4 5.154 0.258 2.514 2.772 2.640
          5 2.640 0.132 2.640 2.772 0.000

          Amortisation schedule, € million. Total interest over five years: 1.858.

          The closing balance is also the present value of the payments still to come: after year two, three payments of 2.772 at 5% are worth 7.548.

          Repayment shapes differ in interest paid but not in value

          A loan that is repaid earlier pays less interest, and that is all there is to it

          There are three common shapes. A bullet loan (in fine) pays interest each year and the whole principal at the end. A constant-principal loan repays 1 / n of the principal each year plus interest on the balance. An annuity loan keeps the total payment constant, as above.

          Shape Payments, years 1 to 5 Total interest
          Bullet 0.6 · 0.6 · 0.6 · 0.6 · 12.6 3.000
          Constant principal 3.00 · 2.88 · 2.76 · 2.64 · 2.52 1.800
          Annuity 2.772 each year 1.858

          A 12.0 million loan at 5% over five years, € million.

          The totals differ because the lender's money stays outstanding for different lengths of time. At 5%, however, the payments of all three are worth exactly 12.0 million today, so no shape is cheaper in value. The shape matters for cash flow and refinancing risk: a bullet is the cheapest to service and the riskiest to repay.

          A floating rate rewrites the remaining schedule at every reset

          Most corporate loans float: a reference rate plus a margin. If the rate on the loan above rises from 5% to 6% after year two, the balance of 7.548 is repaid over three years at 6% and the payment becomes 7.548 / 2.6730 = 2.824 million (CF43 covers hedging this).

          4.1 Build a short schedule

          Harmony borrows 6.0 million for three years at 6% in equal year-end payments. Compute the payment, then the interest and the closing balance after year one and after year two.

          The annuity factor at 6% over three years is 2.6730. The payment is 6.0 / 2.6730 = 2.245 million.

          Year 1: interest 0.360, principal 1.885, closing balance 4.115. Year 2: interest 0.247, principal 1.998, closing balance 2.118. Year 3 repays the last 2.118 with interest of 0.127.

          a loan simulator with a toggle between bullet, constant principal and annuity. The learner sees total interest move with the shape while the present value of the payments stays the same.

          Spreadsheet functions are the formulas above, and each has a timing trap

          Know which unknown each function solves, and when it assumes the first payment arrives

          Function What it solves Watch for
          PMT The payment of an annuity loan Rate must match the period (monthly rate for monthly payments)
          RATE, NPER The rate, or number of periods, that fits a price May need a starting guess
          NPV Present value of a list of flows Discounts the first flow by one full period
          IRR The rate that makes NPV zero Assumes evenly spaced flows
          XNPV, XIRR Same, with actual dates Uses a 365-day year

          4

          1. Banque du Rhône lends 12.0 at 5% for five years in equal payments. The payment is…

          2. A bullet loan of 12.0 at 5% pays 3.000 of interest; an annuity loan pays 1.858. At 5%, the payments of the bullet are worth…

          3. The spreadsheet NPV function is fed −12.0, 2.25, 3.2, 3.975, 3.975, 5.35 at 9%. It returns about 1.95 instead of 2.12 because…

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Compounding and discounting

          = × (1 + )

          The other way: PV = FV / (1 + r)ⁿ; 8.0 due in three years is worth 6.18 at 9%.

          Annuity

          = × [1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ] / r

          The bracket over r is the annuity factor: 5.5348 at 9% over eight years.

          Growing perpetuity

          = / ( − )

          Effective annual rate

          = (1 + / )ᵐ − 1

          Idea What to remember
          Compounding FV = PV × (1 + r)ⁿ. Interest earns interest, so the yearly rate is a root, not a quotient.
          Discounting PV = FV / (1 + r)ⁿ. Distant amounts are fragile: a rate change hurts them most.
          Annuity PV = C × [1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ] / r. First payment one period after the valuation date.
          Growing perpetuity PV = C₁ / (r − g), valid only if g < r. Extremely sensitive when g is close to r.
          Effective rate EAR = (1 + nominal / m)ᵐ − 1. Convert before comparing any two quotes.
          Hidden rates Early-payment discounts and fees are rates in disguise. 2/10 net 30 is about 45% a year.
          Real and nominal 1 + nominal = (1 + real)(1 + inflation). Match the rate to the cash flows.
          Yield to maturity The rate that makes discounted payments equal the price. Same calculation as the IRR.
          Loan schedule Interest is rate × balance; the rest repays principal. The balance is the PV of remaining payments.
          Spreadsheet NPV Discounts the first value by one period. Add the time-zero flow outside.

          The one-sentence version

          A rate is the price of moving money between dates, so compounding carries an amount forward, discounting brings it back, and every loan, bond and project is a pattern of payments that you convert into one date to compare.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Compounding Adding interest to the base so that later interest is earned on it too.
          Discount rate The yearly rate used to turn a future amount into today's value.
          Annuity A fixed payment made at regular intervals for a set number of periods.
          Perpetuity A fixed payment made at regular intervals with no end date.
          Nominal rate The quoted rate: the periodic rate times the number of periods in a year.
          Effective annual rate The true yearly growth after compounding. Use it to compare offers.
          Real rate A rate stated in constant buying power, after removing inflation.
          Yield to maturity The rate at which a security's discounted payments equal its price.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on value and interest rates and on yield to maturity.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on the time value of money and on valuing bonds.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.