Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Foundations / Module 1

1What corporate finance is for

The three jobs of a finance director, the test of value, and the limits of finance

The three jobs of a finance director, the test of value, and the limits of finance.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
14
Exercises
4
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Name the three jobs of a finance director and say which question each one answers.

  • Explain why value creation is the yardstick, and state the test for it in one sentence.

  • Show with numbers why higher earnings per share and cheaper-looking debt can both mislead.

  • Explain in plain words what arbitrage, signalling and agency mean, and what each one limits.

  • Say where sustainability enters corporate finance, and find any topic on the course map.

1The finance director does three jobs

Before any formula, the shape of the work. Money enters a company, becomes assets, comes back as cash and is shared out again. The finance director stands at each point on that loop.

Every company's money makes one loop

Money goes out into assets, comes back as cash, and is split among those who supplied it

Picture Harmony's year. Investors and lenders put money in. Harmony turns it into a plant, components and stock. It sells bikes, and cash flows back. Part of that cash repays lenders and pays interest. Part goes to shareholders. The rest is kept and put to work again.

Three jobs sit on this loop. Investing is choosing which assets and projects to spend on. Raising is choosing who provides the money and on what terms. Returning is deciding how much to pay out to lenders and shareholders and how much to keep.

Job The question it asks Harmony in year N Modules
Invest Which projects deserve our cash? Capex 9.0 million, plus 3.0 tied up in working capital CF24 to CF28
Raise Who funds it, and on what terms? Net debt 30.0 against equity 54.0 CF17 to CF22, CF29 to CF33
Return What do we pay out, and what do we keep? No dividend before the IPO; cash kept to cut debt CF31

Raising money means selling promises

A loan or a share is a promise to pay, and its price moves with the market rate

A security is a contract that gives its holder a claim on future cash. When Harmony borrows from investors it sells them a promise of repayment.

What it is worth depends on the going rate of return. The higher the rate investors demand, the less they will pay for the same promise. That is why interest rates and bond prices move in opposite directions, as holders of long bonds learned painfully when rates rose in 2022.

Debt looks cheaper only because it is less risky

Harmony's debt costs 5% before tax, or 3.75% after the tax saving. Its equity costs 10.4%. It is tempting to conclude that the more debt the better. The error is to compare two prices for two different risks. Debt is cheap because lenders are paid first. The more debt there is, the riskier the shareholders' position becomes, and the more they demand.

1.1 When the market rate moves

Harmony's one-year note repays 105 for every 100 raised at 5%. (a) If investors now demand 7%, how much does the same note raise? (b) How much must Harmony promise in a year to raise 100 at 7%?

(a) 105 / 1.07 = 98.13. The note raises 1.87 less than at 5%.

(b) 100 × 1.07 = 107. To raise the same amount at a higher rate, Harmony must promise more.

Between the investors and the assets stand a controller and a strategist

The finance director also checks returns, watches risks and shapes the portfolio

Around the three jobs sit further roles. The controller compares the return a business earns with the return investors require, and so shows where value is being created or lost. The strategist helps decide which businesses the group should be in at all.

  • Controller of value: is each division earning more than its capital costs?

  • Controller of risk: rates, currencies, commodities, customers who do not pay (CF43).

  • Strategist: what to buy, sell or close, and how fast to grow.

Your aunt Nadia is a pharmacist. She says a finance director is an accountant who finds cheap money. In everyday words, tell her three things the job involves that an accountant does not do.

      A good answer names three jobs in plain terms: choosing projects, deciding who provides the money and on what terms, and deciding how much to pay out. It may add watching risks and comparing returns with what investors require.

      1. 1.2 A note repays 110 in one year. Does its price rise or fall when market rates fall? Why?

      2. 1.3 Harmony's CFO says: "Our loan costs 3.75%, so any project returning 4% is worth doing." Which two things has she confused?

      3. 1.4 Which of the three jobs is being done when Harmony decides to keep cash rather than pay a dividend?

      1

      1. Harmony's one-year note repays 105. Investors' required rate rises from 5% to 6%. The note now raises…

      2. Harmony's debt costs 3.75% after tax and its equity 10.4%. Why is debt cheaper?

      3. Harmony keeps its cash to reduce debt instead of paying a dividend. Which job is the finance director doing?

      2Value creation is the yardstick

      Finance needs a way to say that one decision is better than another. It uses a single test: does the return exceed what investors could earn elsewhere at the same risk? This part builds the test and then shows where it must be handled with care.

      A project creates value when its return beats the required return

      There are only three cases: above, equal or below

      The required return is what investors could earn elsewhere on an investment of the same risk. The expected return is what the project is forecast to earn. If the expected return is above the required one, the project creates value. If it is equal, nothing happens. If it is below, value is destroyed, even if the project shows a profit.

      The gain appears at once, in today's money

      A steady cash flow that lasts for ever is worth the yearly amount divided by the required return. This is the perpetuity formula, and it gives the quickest picture of the idea.

      Value = yearly cash flow / required return NPV = Value − outlay

      a slider for the project's yearly cash from 0.5 to 1.5 million, and a second slider for the required return from 5% to 15%. The learner finds that the NPV changes sign exactly where the return equals the required rate.

      For a whole company the test is the spread between its return and its cost of capital

      Economic profit puts a price on the capital the business uses

      Economic profit = (ROCE − WACC) × capital employed

      Capital employed is the money tied up in the operating assets. ROCE is operating profit after tax divided by capital employed. WACC, the weighted average cost of capital, is what investors as a group require on that capital. When ROCE exceeds WACC, the firm earns a spread, and the spread times the capital is the surplus created each year.

      A spread is a rent, and rivals work to erode it

      A spread above zero is an economic rent: a return that exceeds what the risk requires. It lasts only while something protects it, such as a brand, a patent or a cost advantage. When rivals such as Velora enter, prices fall and the spread shrinks towards zero.

      2.1 The bigger rival

      Altus Bikes, a larger rival, has capital employed of 900 million, operating profit after tax of 72 million and a WACC of 8.5%. Compute its ROCE and its economic profit. Does ten times Harmony's size mean more value?

      ROCE is 72 / 900 = 8.0%. Investors require 900 × 8.5% = 76.5. Economic profit is 72 − 76.5 = −4.5 million.

      Altus Bikes is ten times larger and destroys value, while Harmony, with a spread of 1.7 points, creates it.

      The objective is value, but value is what is left for shareholders after everyone else

      Shareholders are paid last, so a strategy that cheats the others usually cheats them too

      Employees, suppliers, lenders and the tax authority are paid before shareholders, who hold the residual. A firm that underpays staff or squeezes dealers may raise this year's profit and lower the value of the business.

      Real conflicts remain. A plant closure can raise value and cost jobs. No single number settles that. Value is a test of whether resources are used better than in their alternative use, applied inside the law and ethics.

      Earnings per share can rise while value falls

      Earnings per share (EPS) is net income divided by the number of shares. It ignores the risk taken and the capital used.

      Your uncle Marc is a retired teacher. He believes a company must choose between serving its shareholders and serving society. Using the idea that shareholders are paid last, explain to him why the choice is less sharp than he thinks, and name one case where it is real.

          A good answer says that shareholders are paid last, so a firm that mistreats staff, customers or lenders usually ends up worth less. It names a real conflict, such as a plant closure that raises value but costs jobs, and says that value is a test applied within law and ethics, not a licence.

          1. 2.2 A project costs 50 and returns 4.0 a year after tax for ever. Investors require 9%. What is its NPV?

          2. 2.3 A company earns a ROCE of 15% against a WACC of 9%. Does it follow that its shares are a good buy?

          3. 2.4 Name one reason why a CFO who aims at value will still care about her employees.

          2

          1. A project costs 50 and returns 4.0 a year after tax for ever. Investors require 9%. Its NPV is…

          2. Harmony earns a ROCE of 10.7% on capital employed of 84.0 with a WACC of 9.0%. Its economic profit is…

          3. Harmony borrows 12 at 5% for a project returning 10% before tax; EPS rises from 0.75 to 0.795. What happened to value?

          3Finance shares value but cannot conjure it

          Value comes from businesses that earn a spread. Finance decides how that value is split and how reliably it is delivered. This part gives four ideas that mark the limits: markets without free lunches, additivity, signals and conflicts of interest.

          In a competitive market, prices cannot allow a free lunch, so values add up

          Two assets with the same payoff must have the same price

          Arbitrage means earning a sure profit with no money at risk. If it were possible, everyone would do it until prices moved and the profit vanished. So in a well-working market, prices rule it out.

          A group is worth the sum of its parts

          From the same principle, the value of two businesses together equals the sum of their values: V(A + B) = V(A) + V(B), unless the combination changes the cash flows. Shareholders can hold both businesses themselves, so merging them to "smooth earnings" gives them nothing new.

          3.1 A note that is too cheap

          A safe note pays 206 in one year. The risk-free rate is 3% and the note trades at 195. What should it be worth? Describe the arbitrage and compute the profit per note.

          It should be worth 206 / 1.03 = 200. An investor borrows 195, owes 195 × 1.03 = 200.85 in a year, collects 206, and keeps 5.15 without risk. Such buying pushes the price up to 200.

          Insiders know more than outsiders, so actions speak louder than words

          A signal is a costly act that a weaker firm could not afford to copy

          Managers know more about the firm's prospects than investors do. Saying that the future is bright costs nothing, so investors look at what managers do. A signal is a costly act that a weaker firm would not dare repeat.

          When Harmony's founders agree to keep their 40% stake through a future listing, they bear risk and give up liquidity. A founder who expected the shares to fall would not accept that. By contrast, the announcement of a new share issue is often read as bad news, because managers who think the shares are expensive are the ones most likely to sell them. CF29 and CF32 return to this.

          People who share a firm have conflicting interests, and conflicts cost money

          Agency theory studies what happens when one person acts for another

          An agent acts on behalf of a principal. Managers act for shareholders, and neither can see everything the other does. Three conflicts matter most: between managers and shareholders, between shareholders and lenders, and between a controlling shareholder and minority ones. The remedies are pay linked to value, boards that monitor, debt that forces discipline, and contract clauses called covenants. They are covered in CF31, CF33 and CF35.

          Shareholders can gain at lenders' expense by raising risk

          Lenders are promised a fixed amount. Above it, the gain is the shareholders'. Below it, the loss falls on lenders. Shareholders in a heavily indebted firm can therefore favour a gamble that is worse on average.

          a toggle between the safe plan and the risky plan for Pedalia, with sliders for the size of the debt and the good and bad outcomes. The learner discovers that the more debt there is, the more shareholders prefer risk.

          1. 3.2 Classify as a positive, negative or neutral signal: (a) the founders buy shares with their own money, (b) the firm issues new shares at a low price, (c) the firm announces a "new strategic vision".

          2. 3.3 Why does buying an unrelated business to steady profits not create value for Harmony's shareholders?

          3. 3.4 In Pedalia's case, what could lenders do before the gamble is chosen?

          3

          1. A safe note pays 103 in a year, the risk-free rate is 3%, and the note trades at 98. What follows?

          2. Why is a press release saying "shareholders are our priority" not a signal?

          3. Pedalia owes 50. The safe plan is worth 60; the risky plan 90 or 20, equally likely. Who wants the gamble?

          4Sustainability and the map of the course

          One more theme runs through the course, and then a guide to what comes next.

          Sustainability reaches finance through cash flows, the cost of capital and access to money

          ESG matters to a CFO because it changes numbers she already uses

          ESG stands for environmental, social and governance factors. They enter in three places, explored in CF45.

          • Cash flows: a carbon price, new regulation, customer demand, supply-chain breaks.

          • Discount rate and access: investors and banks screen borrowers, and some price loans according to sustainability targets.

          • Reporting: in the EU, the CSRD requires large companies to publish detailed sustainability reports, although the EU narrowed its scope in its recent simplification measures. The ISSB standards give a global baseline for investors.

          A label without substance is a valuation risk

          Greenwashing means presenting a business or a security as greener than it is. Investors who discover it reprice the firm. A sustainability target is a signal only if it is costly to miss and independently checked.

          The course has 47 modules, and each answers the same question from another angle

          Ten families cover the loop of invest, raise and return

          Family Modules The question it answers
          A Foundations CF1 to CF2 What is finance for, and why does time have a price?
          B Reading the accounts CF3 to CF8 What do the statements really say about cash and capital?
          C Financial analysis CF9 to CF13 Is the firm profitable, solvent and value-creating?
          D Markets and risk CF14 to CF16 How do markets price risk, and what return is required?
          E Financial securities CF17 to CF22 What are the instruments, and how are they sold?
          F Value and investment CF23 to CF28 Which projects and companies are worth their price?
          G Financial policy CF29 to CF33 How much debt, how much payout, how much new equity?
          H Life cycle and deals CF34 to CF41 How do firms start, list, buy, sell and fail?
          I Running finance CF42 to CF44 How are cash, risks and property managed day to day?
          J Beyond the textbook CF45 to CF47 Sustainability, forecasting models and international finance.

          The banker's view lives in the site's ECM, DCM, Structured Products, Derivatives and Corporate Banking Financing modules. This course gives the company's.

          the table above as a clickable map. The learner picks a question such as "Should we buy Volta Parts?" or "Can we afford this debt?" and the map highlights the modules to read first.

          4.1 Find the module

          Place each question in a family of the map and name the first module you would read. (a) Should Harmony buy Volta Parts? (b) How much cash should Harmony keep as a safety buffer? (c) How does Harmony's return on capital compare with Velora's? (d) What does a beta of 1.34 imply for the cost of equity?

          (a) Buying Volta Parts is a deal question: family H, starting with CF38 Buying and selling companies.

          (b) A cash buffer is day-to-day treasury: family I, starting with CF42 Working capital and treasury management.

          (c) Comparing returns on capital is financial analysis: family C, starting with CF13 Returns, the leverage effect and the final verdict.

          (d) Turning a beta into a cost of equity is about markets and risk: family D, starting with CF16 Required return and the yield curve.

          4

          1. How does a new carbon rule reach Harmony's investment decisions?

          2. A loan margin is cut by 0.10 point on 20 million if Harmony meets emissions targets. The yearly saving after tax is…

          3. Which family of the course answers "How much cash should Harmony keep as a safety buffer?"

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Value and NPV of a perpetual cash flow

          NPV = / −

          1.2 / 0.09 − 10 = +3.33m; at 0.7 a year, −2.22.

          Economic profit

          = ( − ) ×

          Earnings per share

          = /

          Debt-funded, the 12 million project lifts EPS to 0.795 but has an NPV of −2.0.

          Idea What to remember
          Three jobs Invest (which projects), raise (who funds and how), return (pay out or keep).
          Raising money Selling securities, which are promises to pay. Their price falls when market rates rise.
          Cost versus value Debt looks cheaper because it is safer. Compare returns with the required return for the project's risk, not with the financing cost.
          Value creation test Expected return above required return. For a project, NPV above zero. For a firm, ROCE above WACC.
          Economic profit (ROCE − WACC) × capital employed. Harmony: 1.44 million a year.
          EPS Can rise while value falls, because it ignores the risk and capital used.
          No free lunch Equal payoffs mean equal prices. Value of a group is the sum of its parts, except for industrial synergies.
          Signals Costly actions carry information. Free statements do not.
          Agency Managers, shareholders and lenders have conflicting interests. Debt can push shareholders towards risk.

          The one-sentence version

          A finance director invests, raises and returns money so that every project and the company as a whole earn more than investors could get elsewhere at the same risk, and finance can share that value and protect it but cannot invent it.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Security A contract that gives its holder a claim on future cash, such as a share or a bond.
          Required return What investors could earn elsewhere on an investment of equal risk.
          ROCE Operating profit after tax divided by capital employed.
          WACC The average return required by all providers of capital, weighted by their share.
          Economic rent A return above what the risk requires, which lasts only while something protects it.
          Arbitrage A sure profit with no money at risk, which markets quickly remove.
          Signal A costly action that reveals what the insiders believe.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on the financial objective and on value and corporate finance.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, opening chapters on the goal of the firm and agency problems.

          • Jensen and Meckling (1976) — Theory of the firm: managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure, Journal of Financial Economics.

          • Ross (1977) — The determination of financial structure: the incentive-signalling approach, Bell Journal of Economics.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.