Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Analyse financière / Module 13

13Returns, the leverage effect and the final verdict

How to judge what a company earns on its capital, what borrowing does to that return, and whether the firm is safe and creating value

Juger ce qu’une entreprise gagne sur ses capitaux, ce que l’endettement y change, et conclure le diagnostic.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
11
Exercices
3
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Split a return on capital into margin and turnover and say which of the two drives a company's result.

  • Compute ROCE and ROE from a set of accounts and reconcile the two with the leverage formula.

  • Explain both faces of the leverage effect and find the return at which borrowing stops helping.

  • Compare an accounting return with the required return, and name four reasons the comparison is rough.

  • Reach a written verdict on solvency and value creation, using net assets, cash-flow evidence and a simple distress score.

1Return on capital is margin multiplied by turnover

A profit figure alone says nothing about efficiency. Divide it by the money that was needed to earn it, and companies of any size can be compared.

A return puts profit next to the money that earned it

A bigger profit does not mean a better business

Cyclora earns 1.8 million of operating profit, Harmony 12.0 million and Velora about ten times as much as Harmony. These amounts mostly reflect size. Only a ratio, which removes size, can say which business is better.

The ratio that measures how well a firm uses the money invested in its operations is the return on capital employed, or ROCE. Capital employed is fixed assets plus working capital, financed by equity and net debt together. That is why the ratio ignores how the firm is financed.

ROCE = operating profit × (1 − tax rate) / capital employed

The numerator is operating profit after the tax it would pay if there were no debt. Analysts call it NOPAT, net operating profit after tax. Using a standard rate of 25% instead of the tax actually paid keeps the ratio comparable across years and across countries.

Margin and turnover are two different routes to the same return

Every business earns its return in one of two ways

A jeweller sells few items and keeps a large margin on each. A supermarket keeps a thin margin and sells its stock many times a year. Both can earn the same return on capital.

ROCE = NOPAT / sales × sales / capital employed = after-tax operating margin × capital turnover

The margin says how many cents of NOPAT remain from each euro of sales. The turnover says how many euros of sales each euro of capital produces in a year. A firm lifts its return by earning more on each sale or by making its assets work harder.

Harmony Velora Cyclora
Sales (€m) 120.0 1,200.0 60.0
Capital employed (€m) 84.0 750.0 60.0
NOPAT (€m) 9.0 90.0 1.35
After-tax margin 7.5% 7.5% 2.25%
Capital turnover 1.43× 1.60× 1.00×
ROCE 10.7% 12.0% 2.25%

Velora and Cyclora are fictional.

Velora earns the same after-tax margin as Harmony and does better through turnover, because it outsources more. Cyclora loses on both counts: a thin margin and capital that turns only once a year. Reading margin and turnover separately tells the analyst where to look next: pricing and costs when the margin is weak (CF10), inventories, receivables and capex when turnover is weak (CF11).

1.1 Two ways to reach 12%

Harmony wants a ROCE of 12% instead of 10.7%. Route A: keep turnover at 1.43 and raise the margin. Route B: keep the 7.5% margin and raise turnover. For each route, compute what has to change in euros: the operating profit needed, or the capital that must be released. Then say which route the CFO should check first and why.

Route A: the after-tax margin needed is 12.0% / 1.43 = 8.4%, an operating margin of 8.4% / 0.75 = 11.2%, or operating profit of 13.44 million instead of 12.0.

Route B: turnover needed is 12.0% / 7.5% = 1.6 times, so capital employed must fall to 120.0 / 1.6 = 75.0 million. That releases 9.0 million.

Check B first: it needs no price rise or cost cut, only tighter inventories and receivables (CF11). Inventories of 30.0 are the obvious place to look.

Your uncle Karim runs a bakery and a small shop next door. He is proud that the bakery makes 25 cents of profit on every euro of bread, while the shop makes only 4 cents on every euro of groceries. Explain to him, in everyday words, why the shop may still be the better use of his money.

      Uncle Karim: the shop needs less capital per euro of sales. A bakery may need ovens and premises, so 25 cents on a euro of bread could be a lower return on his money than 4 cents on stock that turns over many times. The measure is profit relative to the money tied up, and turnover counts as much as margin.

      Hélène: she is right when the flat earns more than the mortgage costs after tax, and borrowing multiplies the gain. She is wrong if the rent falls, the flat stays empty or the rate on her mortgage rises, because the mortgage must be paid regardless and the loss is multiplied in the same way.

      a grid with after-tax margin on one axis and capital turnover on the other, with curved lines of equal ROCE. The learner drags Harmony, Velora, Cyclora and the dealer around the grid and discovers that the same return can sit at very different points, and that moving along a line of equal return changes the business but not the result.

      1

      1. Why does ROCE use operating profit taxed at a standard 25% rather than the tax Harmony actually paid?

      2. Harmony and Velora both keep a 7.5% after-tax margin. Velora's ROCE is 12.0%, Harmony's 10.7%. Why?

      3. Harmony wants a 12% ROCE while keeping its 7.5% margin. How much capital must it release?

      2Borrowing multiplies the return in both directions

      Shareholders do not earn ROCE. They earn what is left after lenders are paid, on the equity they put in. The distance between the two is the leverage effect.

      ROE is ROCE plus what the firm makes on borrowed money

      Equity holders earn the profit left after interest

      The return on equity, or ROE, is net income divided by equity. For Harmony: 7.5 / 54.0 = 13.9%. That is higher than the ROCE of 10.7%. The gap comes from lenders: Harmony uses 30.0 million of other people's money, and it earns more on it than it pays for it.

      The formula follows from one line of algebra

      Start from net income = (operating profit − interest) × (1 − t) = NOPAT − interest × (1 − t). Write capital employed as equity plus net debt, so NOPAT = ROCE × (E + D). Divide by E.

      ROE = ROCE + (ROCE − i) × D / E, where i = interest × (1 − t) / D

      D is net debt, E is equity, and i is the after-tax cost of that debt. The term in brackets is the spread: what each euro of borrowed capital earns, minus what it costs. The ratio D / E is the leverage: the number of euros borrowed for each euro of equity.

      The leverage effect has two faces

      The formula is symmetrical. If ROCE is above the cost of debt, the spread is positive and borrowing lifts ROE. If ROCE is below the cost of debt, the spread is negative and borrowing drags ROE down. The more the firm borrows, the stronger the effect in either direction.

      ROCE after tax No debt (D/E = 0) Harmony today (D/E = 0.56) Higher leverage (D/E = 1.0)
      4.0% 4.0% 3.4% 3.0%
      8.0% 8.0% 9.7% 11.0%
      10.7% 10.7% 13.9% 16.4%
      14.0% 14.0% 19.0% 23.0%

      ROE for different operating results. The after-tax cost of debt is held at 5.0%.

      Read the table by columns. With no debt, ROE equals ROCE. Harmony today turns a good year into a better one and a bad year into a worse one. Raising leverage to 1.0 strengthens both. At a ROCE of 5.0%, the cost of debt, the spread is zero and leverage changes nothing.

      two sliders, one for ROCE and one for D / E, with the cost of debt fixed at 5.0%. A live bar shows ROCE, ROE and the leverage contribution, which turns red when the spread goes negative. The learner finds the 5.0% crossing point and sees that more leverage widens the gap between good and bad years.

      Leverage raises ROE, but it does not create value by itself

      The return goes up and so does the risk

      A CFO who sees the table might borrow more: ROE would rise from 13.9% to 16.4% at today's ROCE. But it falls to 3.0% in a bad year, and the interest must be paid regardless. Shareholders carry more risk, so they require more. Higher ROE is not higher value.

      The comparison that matters is between ROE and the return shareholders require. At Harmony the cost of equity is 10.4%. An unlevered Harmony would earn 10.7% on equity, against roughly the 9% that its assets require. Borrowing lifts ROE, but it lifts the required return too. CF29 and CF30 explain why and what it means for the best mix of debt and equity.

      2.1 Moving to 42 million of debt

      Harmony's CFO considers raising net debt to 42.0 million and cutting equity to 42.0 million, with capital employed unchanged at 84.0 million and the after-tax cost of debt still 5.0%. Compute interest after tax, net income and ROE if NOPAT stays at 9.0 million. Then compute ROE if ROCE falls to 4.0%. Finally, say in one sentence why the bank would not lend at 5.0%.

      After-tax interest is 5.0% × 42.0 = 2.10 million. Net income = 9.0 − 2.1 = 6.9 million and ROE = 6.9 / 42.0 = 16.4%.

      If ROCE falls to 4.0%, NOPAT is 3.36 million, net income 3.36 − 2.10 = 1.26 million and ROE = 1.26 / 42.0 = 3.0%.

      The bank would charge more: equity of 42.0 is a thinner buffer and interest cover falls. The cost of debt rises with leverage and part of the gain disappears.

      Your neighbour Hélène has a mortgage and rents out a flat. She says: if the flat earns more than my mortgage costs me, borrowing makes me richer, so I should borrow for a second flat. Explain, using the leverage formula in words, when she is right and what could make her wrong.

          The spread is zero, so ROE = ROCE whatever D / E is. Leverage changes nothing. At 5.0% after tax on both, ROE is 5.0%.

          [object Object]

          2

          1. Harmony: ROCE 10.7%, after-tax cost of debt 5.0%, D / E 0.56. Its ROE is…

          2. At what ROCE does leverage stop changing Harmony's ROE?

          3. Harmony moves to 42.0 of net debt and 42.0 of equity. Why would the bank probably not lend at 5.0%?

          3An accounting return only means something against the return required

          Is 10.7% good? It depends on what investors could earn elsewhere for the same risk. That comparison turns a ratio into a judgement about value.

          Value is created only when the return beats the price of the capital

          Compare ROCE with the cost of capital, ROE with the cost of equity

          Capital is not free. Lenders require interest, and shareholders require a return for waiting and for bearing risk. Harmony's blended cost of capital, the WACC, is 9.0% and its cost of equity is 10.4%. Both are explained in CF16 and CF25. For now, take them as the bar to clear.

          Return earned Return required Spread
          Operations (ROCE vs WACC) 10.7% 9.0% +1.7 points
          Shareholders (ROE vs cost of equity) 13.9% 10.4% +3.5 points

          Both spreads are positive. A spread multiplied by the capital it applies to gives an amount of wealth. This amount is the economic profit: the profit left after paying everyone, shareholders included, the return they require.

          Economic profit = (ROCE − WACC) × capital employed = NOPAT − WACC × capital employed

          Accounting returns are rough because they look backwards at book values

          Four reasons the comparison needs a margin of error

          • Book values are historic. An old, depreciated factory sits in the accounts at a small figure and flatters ROCE. A new one sits at full cost and depresses it. The comparison shows age, not quality.

          • Risk is absent. A 10.7% return looks the same in a stable and in a volatile business.

          • Timing is absent. A plant still under construction is in capital employed but earns nothing yet.

          • Accounting choices move both numerator and denominator. Under IFRS 16 leases sit on the balance sheet, so capital employed is higher and ROCE usually lower than before 2019. Capitalised research and software raise profit and capital together. Treat leases and intangibles the same way across years and firms.

          [object Object]

          3

          1. Harmony's economic profit is…

          2. Why must ROCE be after tax when it is compared with the WACC?

          3. Which is NOT one of the reasons the module gives for treating accounting returns with caution?

          4The final verdict asks two questions: will it survive, and is it creating value

          A diagnosis ends with a conclusion. The two questions are different, and a company can pass one and fail the other.

          Solvency means the assets cover the debts, not just this month's bills

          Liquidity is about the next payments, solvency about the whole balance sheet

          A company is liquid when it can pay what falls due soon. It is solvent when its assets, sold at a fair price, would cover everything it owes. A firm can be solvent and illiquid, for example when a bank line is withdrawn for a month. It can also be liquid and insolvent, living on fresh borrowing while its equity has gone. CF12 covers liquidity.

          Equity is the buffer. If assets fall in value, equity absorbs the loss first, and creditors are untouched until equity is gone. The thinner the buffer, the smaller the fall that triggers trouble.

          Losses feed on themselves

          Losses reduce equity. A smaller equity means a higher debt-to-equity ratio, so lenders ask for more interest and tighter terms. The extra interest creates more losses, and interest on loss-making debt no longer produces a tax saving. This is the vicious circle of a weak company, and the leverage formula describes its early stage: the spread is negative and leverage is at its strongest.

          Net asset value tests the buffer more honestly than book equity

          Book equity is an accounting figure. A sounder test restates the balance sheet: remove goodwill that no buyer would pay for, add hidden gains on land or brands, value stock at what it would sell for. The result is net asset value. If it is negative, creditors are not covered, whatever the profit and loss account says.

          4.1 Cyclora's distress score

          Cyclora's Z' inputs: total assets 81.2, working capital 12.8 (after 6.0 of debt due within a year), retained earnings −8.0, operating profit 1.8, equity 33.6, total liabilities 47.6, sales 60.0. Compute the five ratios and the Z' score with the weights given in the next section, and say which zone it falls in. Then explain why a score alone does not settle the verdict.

          X1 = 12.8 / 81.2 = 0.158. X2 = −0.099. X3 = 1.8 / 81.2 = 0.022. X4 = 33.6 / 47.6 = 0.706. X5 = 0.739.

          Z' = 0.113 − 0.083 + 0.069 + 0.296 + 0.737 = 1.13, below 1.23: the distress zone.

          A score does not settle the verdict. Check the maturity of the 28.4 of gross debt, the cash and the covenants, and ask whether the business earns more than its 6.1% cost of debt. That separates a sound business with too much debt from one that does not earn its capital (CF41).

          A distress score is a warning light, not a verdict

          The Z-score turns five ratios into one number

          In 1968 Edward Altman combined five ratios, found by statistics to separate firms that later failed from firms that did not, into a single score. A version for private manufacturers, Z', uses the weights shown below. Below 1.23 is the distress zone, above 2.90 the safe zone, and between the two a grey zone.

          Z' = 0.717 × X1 + 0.847 × X2 + 3.107 × X3 + 0.420 × X4 + 0.998 × X5

          Altman ratio Meaning Harmony Weight Contribution
          X1 = working capital / assets Short-term cushion 30.0 / 120.0 = 0.250 0.717 0.179
          X2 = retained earnings / assets Profits kept over time 30.0 / 120.0 = 0.250 0.847 0.212
          X3 = operating profit / assets Earning power 12.0 / 120.0 = 0.100 3.107 0.311
          X4 = equity / liabilities Buffer for creditors 54.0 / 66.0 = 0.818 0.420 0.344
          X5 = sales / assets Asset turnover 120.0 / 120.0 = 1.000 0.998 0.998

          The Z' version for private manufacturers. The balance sheet detail is invented within the case figures: assets 120.0, current assets 60.0, current liabilities 30.0 (payables 26.0 and 4.0 of debt due within a year), retained earnings 30.0, liabilities 66.0.

          The sum is 2.04, in the grey zone: Harmony looks neither clearly safe nor clearly fragile. The weight on operating profit (X3) shows what matters most, which is earning power on the assets.

          The verdict joins the tests into two sentences

          A finished diagnosis answers two questions in plain words. First: is the firm solvent, and for how long on its present path? Second: does it create value? Each answer rests on evidence, not on one ratio.

          Evidence Harmony in year N Reading
          Operating return ROCE 10.7%, above the 9.0% required Value-creating, with a small margin
          Leverage D / E 0.56, spread +5.7 points Borrowing helps now; a ROCE below 5.0% would hurt
          Cash Net debt / EBITDA 1.67×, EBITDA / interest 9× Comfortable
          Balance sheet Equity 54.0 against liabilities of 66.0 Solid buffer
          Distress score Z' 2.04, grey zone Not alarming; no cause for complacency

          a decision game with three firms (Harmony, Velora, Cyclora) and a tray of evidence cards: ROCE, WACC, D / E, interest cover, Z', net assets. The learner drags cards into two columns, solvency and value creation, writes a one-line verdict for each firm, and sees how a reviewer would grade it. The point to discover is that no single card settles a verdict.

          4

          1. Cyclora earns a 2.25% ROCE and pays 4.5% after tax on its debt. What does the leverage formula say?

          2. Harmony's Z' score is 2.04. What should the analyst conclude?

          3. Under French law, what triggers the cessation des paiements?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Rentabilité des capitaux employés

          = ×

          Effet de levier

          = + (ROCE − ) ×

          10,7 points viennent de l’exploitation, 3,2 de l’emprunt.

          Profit économique

          = − ×

          Score Z’ (entreprises industrielles non cotées)

          Z' = 0,717 + 0,847 + 3,107 + 0,420 + 0,998

          Harmony : 2,04, zone grise (détresse sous 1,23, sécurité au-dessus de 2,90).

          Idea What to remember
          ROCE After-tax operating profit divided by capital employed. Judges the business, ignores financing.
          Margin × turnover ROCE equals after-tax margin times sales over capital. Margin points to pricing and costs, turnover to capital use.
          ROE Net income divided by equity. What the shareholders earn on their own money.
          Leverage formula ROE = ROCE + (ROCE − i) × D / E, with i the after-tax cost of net debt.
          Two faces Positive spread: debt lifts ROE. Negative spread: debt drags it down. Both effects grow with D / E.
          Leverage and risk Higher ROE from debt comes with higher risk and a higher required return.
          Economic profit (ROCE − WACC) × capital employed. A euro amount of value created or destroyed.
          Limits of accounting returns Historic book values, no risk, no timing, accounting choices such as leases and intangibles.
          Solvency vs liquidity Solvency: assets cover all debts. Liquidity: the next payments can be met.
          Z-score A distress warning from five ratios. Zones: below 1.23, grey, above 2.90 for Z'. Never a verdict alone.

          The one-sentence version

          Measure what the business earns on the capital it uses, see how borrowing changes what owners earn, compare both with the return investors require, and conclude with evidence on two questions: will the firm survive, and is it creating value.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          ROCE Return on capital employed: after-tax operating profit over the capital the business uses.
          NOPAT Operating profit after the tax it would pay with no debt.
          Capital turnover Sales divided by capital employed: how hard the assets work.
          ROE Return on equity: net income over shareholders' equity.
          Leverage Net debt divided by equity: euros borrowed per euro of owners' money.
          Economic profit Profit left after charging for all capital at its required return.
          Solvency Ability of the assets to cover all the debts over time.
          Net asset value Equity restated to what the assets would really fetch.
          Z-score A single distress score built from five accounting ratios.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on accounting profitability analysis and on the conclusion of the financial diagnosis.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on financial analysis and on the value created by returns above the cost of capital.

          • Altman, E. (1968) — Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy, Journal of Finance.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.