Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Valeur et investissement / Module 25

25Cost of capital

What the assets must earn, and how to rebuild Harmony's 9%

Ce que les actifs doivent rapporter, et comment retrouver les 9 % d’Harmony.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
14
Exercices
2
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
9
Simulateurs
2

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why the cost of capital depends on the risk of the asset and not on the way it is financed.

  • Estimate a cost of capital by the direct route, the weighted average (WACC) route and the implicit route, and reconcile them.

  • Unlever and relever a beta, and spot the spreadsheet error of changing weights without changing costs.

  • Choose market-value weights, today's cost of debt and a risk-appropriate rate for a project in a new business or currency.

  • Say what a manager can and cannot do to lower the cost of capital.

1The cost of capital belongs to the asset, not to the funding

Start with the idea everything else rests on: the price of money depends on what it is used for.

Investors price the risk of the business, however it is financed

The hurdle rate is the return below which investors would rather be elsewhere

Picture Harmony owned by one wealthy investor with no debt at all. She can put her money into any asset in the world. For Harmony she asks for a return that matches the risk of making and selling electric bikes. Call it k. This is the cost of capital of the assets: the minimum return the operating assets must earn to be worth owning.

Now Harmony borrows 30 and the investor funds the rest. The lenders are paid first and carry only a slice of the risk, so they accept a lower return. The shareholder is left with a more fragile slice and asks for more. The business has not changed, so the blended return the two groups require is still k.

Borrowing makes equity riskier and offsets the cheapness of debt

Debt looks cheaper than equity, and it is. But every euro of debt added makes the remaining equity dearer. A cheap slice plus a dearer slice averages to the same cost as before. Setting taxes aside, the average cost of capital does not move when the company changes its mix. This is the Modigliani and Miller result. CF29 develops it and adds taxes and distress costs.

What the business does decides how risky the asset is

Four features of a business push its risk up or down

Only risk that moves with the whole economy is paid for, because investors can diversify the rest away (CF15). Four features matter most.

  • Cyclicality. Electric bikes bought out of income sell worse in a recession. Bread sells much the same.

  • Fixed costs. A plant with high fixed costs turns a small fall in sales into a large fall in profit (CF10).

  • Visibility. Signed multi-year contracts make cash flows predictable. Sales to dealers season by season are less so.

  • Duration of growth. If most of the value lies far in the future, small changes in the discount rate move it a lot.

None of these says anything about the balance sheet. That is the point. Two firms in the same business with very different debt have the same asset risk and different equity risk.

The direct route applies the CAPM to the asset's own beta

The asset beta is the weighted average of the betas of everyone who funds it

The assets of a company are the sum of the claims on them. So the beta of the assets is the average of the betas of equity and debt, each weighted by its share of value. Debt has a small but positive beta. Part of the spread a lender earns over the risk-free rate pays for expected default losses and illiquidity. Only the rest rewards market risk.

β(asset) = E/(E+D) × β(equity) + D/(E+D) × β(debt)

k = risk-free rate + β(asset) × market risk premium

Hélène is a primary school teacher. She is buying a flat to let, with a mortgage at 3.5%. She says: “The flat only has to earn 3.5%, because that is what the money costs me.” Explain to her, without the words beta or WACC, why the mortgage rate is the wrong yardstick and what she should compare the flat's return with.

      The mortgage tells her what the bank charges. It says nothing about how risky the flat is. Rents can fall, the flat can stand empty, prices can drop, and Hélène bears all of that, because the bank is paid first.

      She should compare the flat with what she could earn on another investment of similar risk, such as a property fund or a diversified portfolio. If the flat earns less than that, she is better off elsewhere, whatever the mortgage rate.

      1. Harmony's bank offers a cheaper loan for a new warehouse. Should the warehouse's hurdle rate fall? Why?

      2. Two bike makers have identical operations. One is heavily indebted. Which has the higher equity beta, and which the higher asset beta?

      3. Which has the higher asset beta, a supermarket chain or a luxury yacht builder? Give the reason in one sentence.

      1

      1. Harmony's loan costs 5%, or 3.75% after tax. What hurdle should a project funded by that loan use?

      2. Why does the average cost of capital barely move when a company swaps equity for debt (ignoring taxes)?

      3. Using equity 114, net debt 30, equity beta 1.34 and debt beta 0.10, what is Harmony's asset beta?

      2The indirect route averages what each funder requires

      The weighted average cost of capital is the version used in most companies. It is simple to compute and easy to get wrong.

      WACC pays each funder its required return, weighted by its share of value

      The weighted average cost of capital is the direct route seen from the funders' side

      The second route asks each group of funders what it requires, then averages. Shareholders require the CAPM return on their equity beta. Lenders require today's market yield on the debt. Each is weighted by the share of total value it represents.

      WACC = E/(E+D) × kE + D/(E+D) × kD × (1 − t)

      Interest is deductible from taxable profit, so a lender paid 5% costs the company only 5% × (1 − 25%) = 3.75%. The saving is counted once, here, inside the rate. That is why the project cash flows in CF24 are taken before interest and tax computed as if there were no debt.

      Weights must be market values, because funders are owed today's value

      Book equity records history, market equity records what shareholders have at stake

      The weights show how much each group has riding on the assets now. Harmony's book equity is 54, a record of past contributions and retained profits. The market values the equity at 114. Using book values gives weights of 64.3% equity and 35.7% debt, and a WACC of 0.643 × 10.4% + 0.357 × 3.75% = 8.03%. That is about one point too low, because the book weights underplay the dearer source.

      A rate one point too low accepts marginal projects that destroy value.

      Net debt, leases and pensions belong in the debt weight if you treat them as debt

      Harmony's 30 is net debt: gross debt of 40 minus cash of 10, since cash can repay debt and reduces the risk borne by funders. Lease liabilities under IFRS 16, pension deficits and hybrid securities are debt-like claims. Count the same items consistently in weights, cost and cash flows (CF5, CF8). Market weights create a loop, since value depends on the WACC and the weights on value: fix a target structure or iterate.

      The cost of debt is what lenders would charge today

      The coupon on an old loan is history; the current yield is the cost

      Suppose Harmony borrowed in 2021 at 2.5%, when rates were near zero. Lenders would charge 5.0% now for the same risk. The cost of debt is the 5.0%, which you read from traded bonds of similar risk or from a fresh bank quote. After tax it is 2.5% × 0.75 = 1.875% on the old loan, against 3.75% on today's terms.

      Using the old coupon would give a WACC of 0.792 × 10.4% + 0.208 × 1.875% = 8.62%. Investors care what capital costs to replace.

      A yield is a promise, not an expectation. For a shaky borrower such as Pedalia it overstates what lenders expect to earn once defaults are counted.

      Changing the weights without re-levering the costs is the commonest spreadsheet error

      More debt raises the cost of equity and the cost of debt at the same time

      Claire Dubois wants to see what a 40% debt weight does to the WACC. The quick way is to change the weights and leave the costs alone: 0.6 × 10.4% + 0.4 × 3.75% = 7.74%. It looks as if borrowing saves 1.3 points of cost. The saving is imaginary, because at 40% debt the shareholders hold a riskier slice and the lenders see more risk too.

      The correct method is to go back to the asset. The asset beta stays at 1.082. Only its split between equity and debt changes. Relevering means rebuilding the equity beta for a new capital structure. Take the equation from Part 1 and solve for the equity beta.

      β(equity) = [ β(asset) − D/(E+D) × β(debt) ] / [ E/(E+D) ]

      A slider moves Harmony's debt weight from 0% to 60%. Three live bars show the cost of equity, the after-tax cost of debt and the WACC. A toggle switches between “naive” (costs frozen) and “relevered” (costs recalculated from the asset beta of 1.082). The learner should discover that the naive WACC slides down in a straight line, while the relevered WACC stays almost flat while the cost of equity climbs.

      Weights and after-tax cost of debt

      A company has equity worth 200 and net debt worth 50. The cost of equity is 11%, lenders require 6% before tax and the tax rate is 25%. Compute the WACC.

      Weights: 200 / 250 = 80% equity and 50 / 250 = 20% debt. After-tax cost of debt = 6% × 0.75 = 4.5%.

      WACC = 0.8 × 11% + 0.2 × 4.5% = 8.8% + 0.9% = 9.7%.

      Marc is a retired electrician. He says: “Debt is cheap, equity is dear. So if a company borrows more and uses less equity, the average cost must fall.” Explain to him, without the words beta or WACC, what happens to the price of the remaining equity and why the average barely moves.

          Debt is cheaper because lenders are paid first and run little risk. Each time the company swaps equity for debt, the shareholders who remain stand behind a larger pile of debt, so their results swing more. They ask for a higher return for that.

          The cheap slice gets bigger and the dear slice gets dearer. Together they cost about what they did before. Borrowing moves the risk between the two groups. It does not remove any.

          2

          1. Which weights belong in Harmony's WACC?

          2. Harmony borrowed in 2021 at 2.5%; lenders would now charge 5.0%. Which cost of debt is right?

          3. Claire Dubois moves the debt weight to 40% and keeps kE at 10.4% and kD at 3.75%. What is wrong?

          3Using the rate: each project carries its own, and a few traps remain

          A formula gives a number. Judgement decides which number goes with which decision.

          Each project should be discounted at the rate of its own risk

          A company's rate is an average of its projects, so applying it to all of them subsidises the risky and penalises the safe

          Harmony's 9% suits a project that looks like the company, such as a bike assembly line. It does not suit a warehouse extension, nor a product in a market where Harmony has no record. A single rate accepts the risky project too easily and rejects the safe one.

          A new activity borrows its beta from listed firms that already do it

          When Harmony has no history in an activity, it looks at listed companies that do only that activity, the pure plays. Their equity betas include their own leverage, so each must be unlevered first. A common simplification assumes the debt beta is zero and the debt is stable.

          β(asset) = β(equity) / [ 1 + (1 − t) × D/E ]

          This Hamada-style formula is rough: it ignores the debt beta. It is fair for moderate leverage. Average several peers.

          Each of the two projects has a slider for its asset beta from 0.5 to 1.6, with the hurdle rate and the NPV updating live and the accept or reject verdict flipping at a marker. A second slider changes the risk-free rate. The learner should find each project's break-even beta, the beta at which its NPV is zero, and see that a safe project tolerates a lower return and a risky one needs a higher return.

          Borrowing a beta

          Harmony studies a bike-rental and servicing business. The listed pure play Roulex has an equity beta of 1.10 and net debt equal to 25% of its equity value. The tax rate is 25%. Find the asset beta and the project rate, and say whether Harmony's 9% would be too high or too low.

          Asset beta = 1.10 / (1 + 0.75 × 0.25) = 1.10 / 1.1875 = 0.93.

          Rate = 3.0% + 0.926 × 5.5% = 8.09%. Harmony's 9% would be too high for this business. Applied to it, the 9% would reject projects worth doing.

          The cost of equity is a required return, not a profit ratio or a past return

          Required return looks forward; every accounting ratio looks back

          The market price already contains a required return, and the implicit route reads it

          The third route turns the valuation around. If you know a firm's value and its expected cash flows, the discount rate that links them is the market's implied cost of capital. For a steady growth pattern, enterprise value equals next year's free cash flow divided by (k − g), so k = free cash flow ÷ value + g.

          EV = FCF₁ / (k − g) so k = FCF₁ / EV + g

          Suppose analysts think Harmony will, once growth capex fades, generate a normalised free cash flow of 10.08 next year, growing at 2% for ever. With an enterprise value of 144, k = 10.08 / 144 + 2% = 9.0%. All three routes now agree. The implicit route is a sanity check, not independent proof: it depends on the forecast. If the market price implies 14%, either investors see more risk or the forecast is too rosy.

          Currency, distress and green funding change the cash flows or the label, not the arithmetic of risk

          Rates and cash flows must be in the same currency

          A rate in euros cannot discount cash flows in a currency with higher inflation. The two rates differ by the inflation gap: (1 + k local) = (1 + k euro) × (1 + local inflation) / (1 + euro inflation). With a euro rate of 9%, local inflation of 6% and euro inflation of 2%, the local rate is 1.09 × 1.06 / 1.02 − 1 = 13.3%. Political risk is separate: add a country premium or model it in the cash flows (CF47).

          Distress raises equity beta, not the cost of the assets

          Pedalia, heavily indebted, has a very high equity beta, since shareholders hold a thin slice above large debts. Its bikes are no riskier to sell. Default risk is a financing problem (CF41), not a reason to raise every project's discount rate.

          Managers lower the cost of capital only by lowering the risk of the assets

          Most of the usual moves rearrange risk without removing it

          • More debt. Raises the cost of equity by about what it saves, apart from a tax shield that distress costs eventually offset (CF29, CF30).

          • Diversifying into unrelated businesses. Investors can diversify for themselves (CF36).

          • Better disclosure and timing of issues. Real but small.

          The lever that works is the business itself: fewer fixed costs, longer contracts, less dependence on one customer. These lower the asset beta.

          Nadia is a chef who runs a restaurant and a catering arm. The restaurant's cash flows are steady, catering is lumpy. Her accountant uses one hurdle rate for both. Explain to her, without finance jargon, why one rate favours the catering arm and starves the restaurant, and what she should do instead.

              One rate is the same as saying both arms are equally risky. They are not. Catering looks better than it is, since its higher risk is not charged for. The restaurant looks worse than it is, since it is held to a return its steady cash flows do not need to promise.

              She should set a higher hurdle for catering and a lower one for the restaurant, and judge each by its own risk.

              1. Harmony builds a plant in a country whose currency has 6% inflation against 2% in the euro area. Why can it not use 9% on local-currency cash flows?

              2. A friend says Harmony's cost of equity is its ROE of 13.9%. What is wrong with that, in one sentence?

              3. Pedalia's equity beta is very high. Should it discount a new bike line at a rate built from that beta? Explain.

              3

              1. Harmony prices a battery-swap network from Swapline (equity beta 1.70, net debt 50% of equity). What rate applies?

              2. What does the implicit route do?

              3. Which move actually lowers Harmony's cost of capital?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              Les formules du module

              Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

              Bêta d’actif

              = × + ×

              Route directe : k = 3,0 % + 1,082 × 5,5 % = 8,95 %.

              Coût moyen pondéré du capital

              = E/(E+D) × + D/(E+D) × × (1 − )

              Réendettement du bêta

              = ( − D/(E+D) × βD) / E/(E+D)

              Coût des fonds propres 12,55 %, CMPC réendetté 9,18 %, contre 7,74 % en naïf.

              Dé-levage d’un comparable (simplifié)

              = / [1 + (1 − t) × ]

              Taux du réseau d’échange : 3,0 % + 1,24 × 5,5 % = 9,8 %.

              Route implicite

              = / +

              Idea What to remember
              Cost of capital The return the assets must earn given their market risk. A property of the business, not of the funding.
              Direct route k = risk-free rate + asset beta × market premium. Harmony: 3.0% + 1.082 × 5.5% = 8.95%.
              Asset beta Weighted average of equity beta and debt beta at market values. Unaffected by capital structure.
              WACC E/(E+D) × kE + D/(E+D) × kD × (1 − t). Harmony: 9.01%, used as 9%.
              Weights Market values, with net debt. Book weights understate equity: Harmony would get 8.03%.
              Cost of debt Today's yield on similar debt, not the coupon of an old loan. After tax multiply by (1 − t).
              Relevering When the debt weight changes, rebuild equity beta and cost of debt. Changing weights alone is the commonest error.
              Project rate Unlever pure-play peers, average, and apply the CAPM. Swap network 9.8%, warehouse 7.4%, company 9%.
              Implicit route k = FCF₁ / EV + g. A sanity check on the other two routes.
              Required return What investors can earn elsewhere at the same risk. Not ROE, not earnings yield, not dividend yield.
              Lowering the rate Only lower asset risk helps. More debt, diversification and disclosure mostly do not.

              The one-sentence version

              The cost of capital is the return the assets must earn for their risk: estimate it from the asset beta or by averaging funders' required returns at market weights, apply the rate of the project's own risk, and do not mistake a financing cost or an accounting ratio for it.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              Cost of capital The return a company's assets must earn to be worth owning, given their risk.
              WACC The average of what equity and debt funders require, weighted by their share of value, with debt after tax.
              Asset beta The market risk of the business itself, before any effect of debt.
              Unlevering Removing the effect of debt from an equity beta to leave the asset beta.
              Relevering Adding the effect of a chosen amount of debt back to an asset beta.
              Pure play A listed company that does only the activity you want to price.
              Hurdle rate The minimum return a project must offer to be accepted.
              Implied cost of capital The discount rate that makes forecast cash flows equal the market value.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the cost of capital.

              • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on the opportunity cost of capital and on risk, return and capital budgeting.

              • Damodaran — Investment Valuation (Wiley), chapters on the risk-free rate, risk premiums and estimating betas and the cost of capital.

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.