Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Valeur et investissement / Module 27

27Valuation I: discounted cash flow

How to turn a forecast of free cash flow into the value of a company and of its shares

Transformer une prévision de flux de trésorerie disponible en valeur de l’entreprise et de ses actions.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
10
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
9
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Say how enterprise value differs from equity value, and which cash flows and rate belong to each.

  • Build a free cash flow forecast from sales, margin, depreciation, capex and working capital.

  • Compute a terminal value two ways and explain why growth without reinvestment is an error.

  • Bridge from enterprise value to equity value and to a value per share, including debt-like items.

  • Test a DCF for consistency and read a sensitivity table without being fooled by it.

  • Describe what the adjusted present value and equity-flow methods do differently.

1Value is the present value of free cash flow

Two questions come before any spreadsheet: whose cash are we valuing, and which cash is it.

Enterprise value is what the business is worth to everyone who financed it

Valuing the operations first keeps the financing out of the way

Harmony's operations earn cash. That cash is then shared between lenders, who are paid interest and repayment, and shareholders, who get what is left. If we value the operations first, we get one number for the whole business that does not depend on how the financing is split. That number is the enterprise value (EV), in French the valeur d'entreprise.

The equity value is the part that belongs to shareholders. It is the enterprise value minus what is owed to the other providers of money, mainly net debt. This is the "indirect" route: value the whole, subtract the lenders' claim. Part 4 does the subtraction.

Equity value = Enterprise value − net debt − other debt-like claims + non-operating assets

Free cash flow is the cash left after the business has paid for its own growth

Free cash flow (FCF) is the cash the operations release in a year, before any payment to lenders or shareholders. You met it in CF24. Start with operating profit, remove the tax the business would pay if it had no debt, add back depreciation because it costs no cash, then subtract what the business must spend to stay in place and to grow.

FCF = EBIT × (1 − t) + depreciation − capex − increase in working capital

EBIT × (1 − t) is called NOPAT, net operating profit after tax. Capex is spending on fixed assets. Working capital is the money tied up in stock and customer credit, less supplier credit. Interest is not deducted: lenders are paid out of this cash.

The discount rate must match the cash flow

Free cash flow belongs to lenders and shareholders together, so it is discounted at the rate they jointly require: the weighted average cost of capital, WACC. Harmony's is 9%, rebuilt in CF25. Cash flow and rate must describe the same investors.

1.1 Free cash flow of a supplier

A supplier to Harmony has EBIT of 8.0, depreciation of 3.0, capex of 5.0, and working capital that rose by 1.0. The tax rate is 25%. Compute its free cash flow. Then say what its FCF would be if it had borrowed heavily and paid 2.0 of interest.

NOPAT = 8.0 × 0.75 = 6.0. FCF = 6.0 + 3.0 − 5.0 − 1.0 = 3.0.

Borrowing and paying 2.0 of interest changes nothing. FCF is measured before financing. The interest affects what shareholders receive, not what the operations release.

A growing flow of cash has a simple present value

If a flow of 6 arrives next year and then grows by 2% every year for ever, discounted at 8%, its value is 6 ÷ (0.08 − 0.02) = 100. The gap between the rate and the growth is what keeps the sum finite. This growing perpetuity is the engine of the terminal value in Part 3.

Value today = next year's cash flow ÷ (discount rate − growth rate)

Your aunt Hélène owns a small flat that she rents out. She says: "A buyer should pay me a multiple of the rent I declare, and that is the end of it." Explain to her, in everyday words, why the buyer should look at the rent minus repairs, tax and the cost of replacing the boiler, and why the future matters more than last year.

      The buyer pays for future cash left over after repairs, tax and the boiler, plus the resale price at the end. Last year's rent is gone and costs are real.

      1

      1. In year N Harmony earned 7.5 of net income. How much free cash flow did it release?

      2. Free cash flow is discounted at…

      3. A flow of 6 next year growing 2% a year for ever, at 8%, is worth…

      2A forecast is a set of linked assumptions, not a list of numbers

      The forecast period is where the analyst can be specific. The task is to keep every line consistent with the others.

      Each line of free cash flow answers a different question

      Start from sales and let everything else follow from it

      Sales growth drives the rest. Margin turns sales into operating profit. Capex and depreciation say how fast the asset base must grow. Working capital says how much cash extra sales trap in stock and credit.

      For Harmony we assume sales growth fades from 10% in year 1 to 6% in year 5, as the dealer network matures. The EBIT margin rises from 10.0% to 11.0%, because the plant spreads fixed costs over more bikes. Depreciation is 5% of sales. Capex starts at 7% of sales and falls to 5.75% once the new capacity is installed. Working capital stays at 20% of sales, the ratio observed in year N.

      A good forecast is coherent before it is optimistic

      A forecast can be checked against itself. Capital employed, the money tied up in fixed assets and working capital, was 84.0 in year N. Adding each year's capex and working capital increase, and subtracting depreciation, gives 106.1 by year 5. Operating profit after tax in year 5 is 14.54, which is a return of 14.2% on the capital at the start of that year, up from 10.7% in year N.

      That rise is the real claim in the forecast. It says Harmony will earn much more on its capital than the 9% investors require, and keep doing so.

      Cash flows and the discount rate must both include inflation or both exclude it. Harmony's 9% includes it, so the forecast does too. The horizon should be long enough for the business to reach a steady state. Harmony uses five years, since its growth fades to a mature rate by year 5.

      Harmony's forecast table with a slider for each driver: sales growth, margin, capex percentage, working capital percentage. As the learner moves a slider, the free cash flow row, the five present values and the enterprise value redraw, with the capital employed and ROCE lines underneath. The learner discovers that margin and working capital move value far more than a point of growth, and that a margin gain needs a reason.

      2.1 The margin that never improves

      Suppose Harmony's margin never rises and stays at 10.0% in every year, including the terminal year of Part 3. Recompute the enterprise value (the flows change, the other assumptions do not). By how much does the value fall from 144.1, and what does the answer say about how fragile a margin story is?

      With a 10.0% margin throughout, the enterprise value is 131.4, which is 12.6 below 144.1, about 9%. The margin gain is worth nearly a tenth of the company, so it needs a competitive explanation.

      1. 2.2 Why is interest not subtracted when computing free cash flow for a DCF?

      2. 2.3 Harmony's sales double but the forecast leaves working capital unchanged. Which direction is the error, and why?

      3. 2.4 A forecast has margins rising and capex falling every year. Name two checks that would show whether this is credible.

      2

      1. If Harmony's margin stays at 10.0% for ever instead of rising to 11.0%, enterprise value is…

      2. Why must working capital rise when Harmony's sales rise?

      3. The forecast lifts ROCE from 10.7% to about 14%. What is that?

      3Most of the value sits beyond the forecast

      Harmony's first five years carry about a fifth of its value. How the remainder is computed decides the answer.

      The terminal value prices every year after the forecast

      Treat the years beyond year 5 as a growing flow at a steady rate

      After year 5 we stop forecasting year by year. We assume Harmony's cash flow grows at a constant rate g for ever and apply the growing perpetuity of Part 1 at the end of year 5. The result is the terminal value (TV), the worth at year 5 of all later flows.

      TV at year 5 = FCF in year 6 ÷ (WACC − g)

      No company can outgrow the economy for ever. For a euro-area business the ceiling is the long-run nominal growth of the economy: inflation of about 2% plus modest real growth. Harmony uses 2%, a cautious choice below that ceiling.

      The year 6 cash flow must include the reinvestment that growth needs

      A company that grows 2% a year must keep adding capital: more equipment, more stock. The cash it spends is a fraction of NOPAT. If new capital earns a return RONIC (return on new invested capital), the share of NOPAT that must be reinvested is g ÷ RONIC.

      FCF in year 6 = NOPAT in year 6 × (1 − g / RONIC)

      This is the value-driver form of the terminal value. It makes the assumption explicit: growth is not free. For Harmony we take RONIC of 12%, below the 14.2% of year 5.

      What growth is worth depends on the return on new capital

      Growth adds value only when RONIC exceeds the WACC

      The same 2% growth can add or destroy value. If RONIC equals the WACC, each euro invested earns exactly what investors require, and growth changes nothing. With Harmony's inputs, setting RONIC to 9% gives an enterprise value of 136.4. Setting it to 15% gives 148.7. The base case at 12% gives 144.1.

      A RONIC equal to the WACC is the cautious benchmark: the advantage fades. A higher RONIC means a lasting edge, and it should be argued, not assumed.

      A sensitivity table shows the range, not the answer

      Terminal value rests on two rates that nobody knows to a decimal. The table shows Harmony's EV (€ million) for a range of WACC and g, with RONIC held at 12%.

      WACC \ g 1% 2% 3%
      8% 161.1 170.4 183.1
      9% 138.7 144.1 151.0
      10% 121.3 124.4 128.1

      Enterprise value, € million

      The corners run from 121.3 to 183.1. A single figure of 144.1 hides that spread, so present a range with the assumptions beside it.

      An exit multiple imports the market's mood

      Applying a multiple such as 8 times EBITDA to year 5 is quick, but it makes the DCF circular, because a market price enters a test of market prices. Use it only as a cross-check. Harmony's 176.6 is 12.1 times year 5 NOPAT and 1.66 times the capital employed of 106.1, so excess returns are assumed to last.

      a heat-map of enterprise value over WACC (7% to 11%) and growth (0% to 4%), with a separate toggle for RONIC at 9%, 12% and 15% and a bar showing the share of value that sits in the terminal value. The learner discovers that the cells where g approaches the WACC explode, and that setting RONIC equal to the WACC flattens the growth axis.

      3.1 Should Tandemo grow?

      Tandemo, a smaller, indebted bike maker, has year 6 NOPAT of 10.0. WACC is 9% and g is 2%. Compute the terminal value (a) with RONIC of 6%, (b) with no growth at all, and (c) with RONIC of 9%. What do the three results say about whether Tandemo should grow?

      (a) 10.0 × (1 − 0.02 ÷ 0.06) ÷ 0.07 = 95.2. (b) With no growth: 10.0 ÷ 0.09 = 111.1. (c) With RONIC of 9%: 10.0 × (1 − 0.02 ÷ 0.09) ÷ 0.07 = 111.1.

      With RONIC below the WACC, growth lowers value, from 111.1 to 95.2. With RONIC equal to the WACC it changes nothing. Tandemo should grow only where new capital earns more than 9%.

      Your neighbour Karim is a carpenter with a workshop that makes a steady living. Someone tells him that four fifths of what his business is worth comes from years he cannot yet see. Explain to him why that is natural, and why it still calls for caution.

          A steady business keeps earning for decades, so most of its value lies in later years. The caution: those years are the least certain, and a small change in growth or return moves the figure a lot. So show the share and argue the assumptions.

          1. 3.3 Why must g be at or below the long-run growth of the economy?

          2. 3.4 What happens to the terminal value as g approaches the WACC, and what does that tell you about trusting a high g?

          3. 3.5 A valuation shows terminal value at 90% of enterprise value. What would you look at before accepting it?

          3

          1. An analyst sets year 6 free cash flow equal to NOPAT. The error…

          2. With RONIC equal to the WACC, more growth…

          3. Harmony's terminal value is 79.7% of its enterprise value. You should…

          4From enterprise value to what shareholders own

          The enterprise value belongs to everyone who financed the company. The bridge assigns each claim to its owner.

          The bridge removes every claim that ranks ahead of the shareholders

          Net debt comes first, and anything that behaves like debt joins it

          Start with net debt: gross debt less cash. Harmony's is 40.0 − 10.0 = 30.0. Then add other obligations that behave like debt, meaning a fixed amount that must be paid and cannot be avoided. Lease liabilities are one: under IFRS 16 they are on the balance sheet, and Harmony's case figures keep the 1.5 yearly rent of its warehouse inside EBITDA and leave the lease liability (7.61 at 5%) out of the 30.0 of net debt, which is consistent with free cash flows computed after the rent. Pension deficits are another, as is financing that does not show as debt, such as receivables sold to a factor and removed from the balance sheet.

          The rule is consistency with the forecast. If free cash flow was computed after paying lease rentals, leases are not deducted again. If rentals were removed from the flows, the lease liability must be subtracted in the bridge.

          Some items are added, some are removed, and tax applies to each

          A pension deficit will be paid out of future taxable profit, so it saves tax when paid. Harmony's unfunded pension deficit is 2.0 before tax, 2.0 × 0.75 = 1.5 after tax. Minority shareholders in a subsidiary own part of the cash flows already counted in the EV, so their share is subtracted at its own value. A stake in a company that Harmony does not consolidate produced no flows in the forecast, so it is added. Harmony owns 25% of a small charging-network start-up worth 4.8 in total, so the stake is worth 1.2.

          4.1 Bridge for Dynamo Components

          Dynamo Components, a components supplier, has an enterprise value of 20.0. Gross debt is 9.0 (including 1.5 of leases), cash is 3.0, and an unfunded pension deficit of 1.0 before tax. An outside investor owns 20% of a subsidiary worth 5.0. Dynamo also owns 8% of a start-up worth 5.0 in total. Compute Dynamo's equity value, taking tax at 25%.

          Net debt = 9.0 − 3.0 = 6.0 (leases are already in the 9.0). Pension deficit after tax: 1.0 × 0.75 = 0.75. Minority: 20% × 5.0 = 1.0. Start-up stake: 8% × 5.0 = 0.4.

          Equity value = 20.0 − 6.0 − 0.75 − 1.0 + 0.4 = 12.65.

          A DCF can be done other ways, and the answers should agree

          Adjusted present value separates the business from its tax shield

          The WACC method folds the tax saving on interest into the discount rate. The adjusted present value (APV) method keeps it apart. First value the business as if it had no debt, discounting at the unlevered cost of capital, the return investors would require with no debt. Then add the present value of the tax savings from the debt.

          With permanent debt, Harmony's unlevered rate is 9 ÷ (1 − 0.25 × 0.21) = 9.5%. At that rate the same free cash flows give an unlevered value of 133.6. The tax saving on 30.0 of permanent debt is worth 0.25 × 30.0 = 7.5. The APV is 141.1, about 2% below the WACC answer of 144.1. The gap is expected: WACC assumes debt stays at 21% of a growing value, this APV that it stays at 30.0. APV suits cases where debt changes a lot, as in a buyout.

          Valuing equity directly needs cash flows to shareholders

          The equity method discounts the cash that reaches shareholders, after interest and net borrowing, at the cost of equity of 10.4%. The dividend version suits banks and insurers, whose operating cash is hard to define.

          Timing. We discounted each year's flow as if it arrived on the last day of the year. Cash arrives all year, so on average at mid-year. Moving the five flows half a year closer multiplies their value by 1.09^0.5, adding about 1.3 to Harmony's EV.

          Five checks before the number leaves the room

          Rate and cash flow describe the same investors. Inflation is treated the same in both. Terminal growth is below the economy's. The terminal value carries reinvestment and implies a plausible return on capital. The result sits near what other methods give: Harmony's 144.1 is 8.0 times EBITDA. CF28 builds that comparison.

          a drag-and-drop bridge. The learner receives Harmony's or Dynamo's balance sheet items (gross debt, cash, leases, pension deficit, minority stake, associate, stock options) as cards, drops each on "subtract", "add" or "already in the cash flows" and sees a waterfall from EV to equity value redraw. The learner discovers that the same lease can be in the flows or in the bridge but never both.

          1. 4.2 Why is a pension deficit tax-effected but gross debt is not?

          2. 4.3 A DCF gives 100 for EV. The analyst then subtracts net debt of 30 and also applies a 20% minority discount. What is the second step doing wrong?

          3. 4.4 Why can a DCF at the WACC and an APV give slightly different answers for the same company?

          4

          1. Harmony's free cash flows are computed after paying the warehouse rent. In the bridge, the lease liability is…

          2. Why is the pension deficit deducted at 1.5 rather than 2.0?

          3. Harmony's equity value per share from the DCF is…

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Flux disponible

          = + − −

          Valeur terminale (forme des moteurs de valeur)

          = × (1 − / ) / ( − g)

          Sa valeur actuelle, 114,8, fait 79,7 % de la valeur d’entreprise.

          Le pont vers les fonds propres

          = − − − +

          Idea What to remember
          Enterprise value Value of the operations to all financiers: discounted free cash flow plus terminal value.
          Free cash flow NOPAT + depreciation − capex − increase in working capital. Before interest.
          Profit is not free cash Harmony's year N: net income 7.5, free cash flow 3.0.
          Terminal value Year 6 FCF ÷ (WACC − g), taken at the end of the forecast.
          Reinvestment Growth needs capital: reinvest g ÷ RONIC of NOPAT. Without it growth is free.
          Growth and value Growth adds value only when RONIC is above the WACC.
          Equity bridge EV − net debt − debt-like items − minorities + non-operating assets.
          Leases and pensions Treat consistently with the flows; tax-effect deductible deficits.
          APV Unlevered value plus present value of the tax shield; useful when debt changes.

          The one-sentence version

          Forecast the cash the operations will release after tax and after the reinvestment growth requires, discount it at the WACC, add a terminal value that carries its own reinvestment, then subtract what is owed to others to reach the shareholders' share, and present the result as a range.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Enterprise value Value of the operating business to all those who financed it.
          Free cash flow Cash the operations release before any payment to lenders or shareholders.
          NOPAT Operating profit after the tax the business would pay with no debt.
          WACC Average return that lenders and shareholders together require.
          Terminal value Worth, at the end of the forecast, of all the years that follow.
          RONIC Return earned on new capital invested to support growth.
          APV Valuation that adds the tax shield on debt to a value computed with no debt.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the practice of company valuation (DCF part).

          • Koller, Goedhart, Wessels — Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies (McKinsey & Company; Wiley), chapters on free cash flow, continuing value and the enterprise-to-equity bridge.

          • Damodaran — Investment Valuation (Wiley), chapters on discounted cash flow valuation and terminal value.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.