Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Marchés et risque / Module 16

16Required return and the yield curve

What investors should demand for waiting and for risk, and how the price of waiting changes with the date

Ce que les investisseurs doivent exiger pour attendre et pour le risque, et comment ce prix varie avec l’échéance.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
17
Exercices
3
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
2

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Compute a required return with the CAPM and read it on the security market line.

  • Explain why a share's total volatility does not set its required return, while its beta does.

  • Choose a risk-free rate, a market premium and a beta for a 2026 valuation, and show how much the answer moves with each choice.

  • Name the main limits of the CAPM and what size, value, momentum and liquidity premia add.

  • Read a yield curve, bootstrap zero-coupon rates from coupon bonds and compute a forward rate.

  • Discount each cash flow at the rate of its own maturity and explain why this matters.

1The CAPM: only market risk earns a premium

Investors are not paid for every risk they take. They are paid for the part they cannot get rid of. The CAPM turns that sentence into a formula.

A diversified investor ignores risks that cancel out

Two owners of the same company demand different returns

Léa Moreau owns a large share of Harmony and most of her wealth depends on it. If the bike market collapses, or a battery recall hits, or a dealer goes bankrupt, she suffers. An investor holding a thousand shares across Europe barely notices a recall at Harmony, because the other nine hundred and ninety-nine companies carry on. What even she cannot escape is Harmony's tendency to fall when the whole market falls.

That tendency is called beta, and it is the only risk measure the model prices

Beta measures how much a share moves, on average, when the market moves by 1%. A beta of 1 means the share moves in step with the market. A beta of 1.34, Harmony's, means it tends to move 1.34% for each 1% in the market, in both directions. A beta of 0.6 means a calmer share, such as a food retailer or a water utility.

The formula adds a risk premium to the risk-free rate in proportion to beta

Start from the safe rate, then pay for the market risk taken

Take a safe asset: a government bond in your own currency, held to maturity. It pays the risk-free rate, written rF here. Now take the whole stock market. Holding it is risky, so investors expect more than rF. The extra expected return is the equity risk premium, the expected market return minus rF.

A share with a beta of 1 should earn the market's return: rF plus the full premium. A share with a beta of 0 should earn rF. In between, the premium is scaled by beta. That is the CAPM (Capital Asset Pricing Model, MEDAF in French).

Required return k = rF + β × (E[market return] − rF) = rF + β × equity risk premium

Plotted against beta, required returns form a straight line: the security market line

Put beta on the horizontal axis and required return on the vertical axis. The CAPM says every fairly priced asset sits on one straight line. It starts at rF when beta is 0 and rises by the premium for each unit of beta. This is the security market line.

A change in rates shifts the line, a change in the premium tilts it

If the risk-free rate rises by one point and the premium stays put, the whole line moves up in parallel: Harmony's required return becomes 4.0% + 1.34 × 5.5% = 11.37%. If instead investors become more nervous and the premium rises from 5.5% to 6.5%, the line pivots around rF and steeper: 3.0% + 1.34 × 6.5% = 11.71%. High-beta shares are hit hardest by a pivot, low-beta shares barely at all.

a security market line with two sliders, one for the risk-free rate and one for the equity risk premium, and six shares plotted as dots at their analysts' expected return. The learner sees the line shift or tilt, watches dots cross from cheap to dear, and discovers that a rate move and a premium move have different effects on high-beta and low-beta shares.

Placing a share against the line is the core skill

1.1 Cheap or dear?

With rF = 3.0% and a premium of 5.5%, a share has beta 1.1 and an analyst expects 8.5% a year. Another has beta 0.4 and an expected 5.0%. Compute each required return and say which one is above the line and which below. Then say what happens to both verdicts if the premium rises to 6.5%.

Beta 1.1: required 3.0% + 1.1 × 5.5% = 9.05%. Expected 8.5% is below it, so the share is below the line (dear). Beta 0.4: required 5.2%, expected 5.0%, also just below.

At a premium of 6.5%, requirements become 10.15% and 5.6%. Both look dearer, and the high-beta share worsens faster.

Samir Haddad, Harmony's CTO, is an engineer and not a financier. He asks: our shares jump around less than the shares of a small software company, so why does the market ask Harmony for the higher return? Explain it to him without using the word beta. Use the idea of a crowd of investors who each hold a bit of everything.

      Imagine the investors as a crowd with a little money in many companies. One firm's bad year for its own reasons is a drop among many gains elsewhere. What the crowd cannot escape is a year when everything goes badly together, such as a recession. So it asks extra return only from companies that suffer in those years.

      Harmony is tied to consumer spending, so it suffers when the economy slows. The small software company's swings may come from its own products, which the crowd can cancel out.

      1. 1.2 An asset has a beta of 0. What return does the CAPM require, and why does it not matter that the asset may be very volatile on its own?

      2. 1.3 The risk-free rate falls by one point and the premium does not change. Does a share with a beta of 2 lose more required return than one with a beta of 0.5?

      3. 1.4 Why is a project's required return not the same as that of the company's shares?

      1

      1. With rF = 3.0% and an equity risk premium of 5.5%, what does the CAPM require from Harmony's shares (beta 1.34)?

      2. A small biotech swings 40% a year, but its beta is 0.5. Why does it require less than Harmony?

      3. The equity risk premium rises from 5.5% to 6.5% while rF stays at 3.0%. What happens to the security market line?

      2Feeding the model in 2026

      The CAPM is only as good as its three inputs, and none of them can be observed directly. Each one needs a choice, and each choice moves the result.

      The risk-free rate must match the currency and the horizon of the cash flows

      Use a government bond, in the same currency, with a maturity close to the cash flows

      The closest thing to a risk-free rate is the yield on the debt of a government that issues its own currency or, in the euro area, of the highest-rated states. For euro cash flows, practitioners use German government bonds or a euro-area curve built from them. For dollar flows, US Treasuries. For sterling, UK gilts. The rule is consistency: euro flows get a euro rate, because a dollar rate carries different inflation expectations.

      LIBOR has disappeared. The short-term references are now SOFR for the dollar, SONIA for sterling and, for the euro, €STR alongside the reformed EURIBOR, which most euro loans still use. They sit at the short end of the curve (Part 4).

      The equity risk premium cannot be observed and must be estimated

      History gives a number that depends on the period, and the future may not repeat it

      The simplest method is to average, over many decades, the gap between stock returns and government bond returns. The result depends heavily on the period chosen and on how lucky investors happened to be. Even a long history is a noisy guide.

      The implied premium asks what price today says about expected returns

      A second method works backwards from current prices. If you know today's index level and forecast the cash it will pay out, you can solve for the return that makes the two match. Subtract the risk-free rate and you have the premium that investors are accepting today.

      Beta is a noisy estimate, so improve it before you trust it

      A regression beta depends on the window, the frequency and the index

      The usual estimate is a regression: plot the share's returns against the market's returns over past periods and take the slope. Different choices give different slopes for the same company. Five years of monthly returns may give 1.20 for Harmony, two years of weekly returns 1.48. Those two estimates imply required returns of 3.0% + 1.20 × 5.5% = 9.6% and 3.0% + 1.48 × 5.5% = 11.14%. The gap is 1.5 points, from a choice nobody would call fundamental.

      Two repairs make betas more reliable: pull them towards 1, and use the peers

      Extreme betas tend to drift back towards 1 over time. A common adjustment, named after the economist Marshall Blume, takes two thirds of the measured beta and one third of 1. A measured beta of 1.60 becomes 0.67 × 1.60 + 0.33 × 1 = 1.40. A better route still is the average beta of comparable firms (the bottom-up beta, CF25), which has much less noise than one regression.

      A defensible rate shows where each input comes from

      2.1 Two betas, one decision

      A broker reports a regression beta of 1.80 for a young competitor of Harmony. Compute the Blume-adjusted beta. With rF = 3.0% and a premium of 5.5%, give the required return from the raw and from the adjusted beta. By how many points do they differ?

      Adjusted beta: 0.67 × 1.80 + 0.33 = 1.536. Required return: raw 3.0% + 1.80 × 5.5% = 12.9%, adjusted 3.0% + 1.536 × 5.5% = 11.45%. The gap is about 1.45 points. An extreme measured beta probably includes chance, so pulling it towards 1 is sensible.

      2

      1. Which risk-free rate suits a long-term valuation of euro cash flows?

      2. A broker reports a regression beta of 1.80. What is the Blume-adjusted beta?

      3. Claire Dubois tests reasonable extremes and finds Harmony's cost of equity between about 7.5% and 13%. What should she report?

      3Where the CAPM falls short and what richer models add

      The CAPM is a clean idea and a rough instrument. Knowing where it breaks decides when to add a premium, and when to leave the model alone.

      The CAPM rests on assumptions that reality only half respects

      Three weaknesses are worth remembering

      • The market portfolio is not observable. The theory needs every risky asset in the world, so a stock index stands in for it, and the choice changes betas. Richard Roll argued in 1977 that the model can therefore never be cleanly tested.

      • Beta is unstable. It moves as the business, the debt and the size of a company change.

      • The line is flatter than predicted. In many studies low-beta shares earned more than the line gives, and high-beta shares less.

      None of this makes the model useless. It separates time from risk and forces you to say which risk you are paying for. The danger is false precision: quoting a cost of equity to two decimals as if the model could deliver it.

      Multifactor models price several sources of risk, not just one

      If there is more than one way to be hurt in bad times, there is more than one premium

      The arbitrage pricing theory of Stephen Ross allows several broad risks, each with its own premium. The best-known practical version is the Fama and French model. It adds a size factor (small companies have historically earned more than large ones) and a value factor (cheap companies relative to book value have earned more than expensive ones). Practitioners also use momentum, quality and low volatility. Some add a size, liquidity or country premium by hand. Each such addition needs a reason, and the evidence for a size premium has weakened in several markets.

      k = rF + β market × premium market + β size × premium size + β value × premium value

      The limits call for a cross-checked range, not a better point

      3

      1. Which of these is a known weakness of the CAPM?

      2. With illustrative exposures (market 1.25, size 0.5, value −0.2) and premiums (5.5%, 2.0%, 1.5%), the three-factor model gives Harmony…

      3. An analyst adds a 3-point size premium to Harmony's cost of equity “to be safe”. What is the best response?

      4The yield curve: the price of time depends on the date

      So far the risk-free rate was a single number. In reality, lending for one year and for ten years earn different rates. The set of those rates is the yield curve, and it matters for every discounting exercise.

      A yield curve plots the rate for each maturity

      Zero-coupon rates are the clean version, because one payment has one rate

      A zero-coupon bond pays a single amount at maturity and nothing before. The annual return that bond earns is the zero rate for that maturity. Because there is only one payment, the rate is unambiguous. A bond that pays coupons mixes several dates, so its yield to maturity is a sort of average of the zero rates for those dates.

      The curve of zero rates by maturity is the term structure of interest rates. Three shapes appear. It is normal when longer rates are higher than shorter ones. It is flat when they are equal. It is inverted when short rates are above long rates. The euro and dollar curves inverted in 2022 and 2023 as central banks raised short rates quickly while longer rates rose less.

      Coupon bonds hide the zero rates, which can be dug out one maturity at a time

      Most traded bonds pay coupons, so zero rates are not quoted directly. They are derived by bootstrapping: start with the shortest maturity, whose zero rate is simply its yield, then use it to strip out the part of the next bond's price that comes from the first coupon. What remains gives the next zero rate, and so on.

      Each cash flow should be discounted at the rate of its own maturity

      If a payment arrives in two years, the right discount rate is the two-year zero rate, not the three-year rate and not an average. Discounting each flow at its own zero rate is the consistent way to value a stream of known payments.

      a curve builder where the learner drags the zero rates for one to five years. The page redraws the curve, shows the implied forward rates and the present value of a payment stream such as Harmony's contract. The learner sees how a steeper or inverted curve changes values, and where flat-rate shortcuts go wrong.

      A forward rate is the rate for a future year that today's curve already implies

      Two ways to invest for two years must give the same result, which pins down the future rate

      Suppose you can lend for two years at z₂, or lend for one year at z₁ and then lend again for a year at a rate fixed today. If both routes earn the same, the rate for the second year is determined by the curve. It is the forward rate.

      (1 + z₂)² = (1 + z₁) × (1 + f₁,₂) so f₁,₂ = (1 + z₂)² / (1 + z₁) − 1

      From the curve above: f₁,₂ = 1.0301² / 1.025 − 1 = 3.52%, and f₂,₃ = 1.0342³ / 1.0301² − 1 = 4.25%. A rising curve implies rising forward rates. A forward rate is a rate you can lock in today, for example with a forward contract, which is why it is a price and not a prediction.

      What the shape of the curve tells a CFO

      The curve says what fixed and floating funding cost, and which risk-free rate to use

      • Choosing the risk-free rate. Match the maturity of the cash flows.

      • Fixed against floating debt. Floating debt follows the short end of the curve (CF33, CF43).

      • Pricing corporate debt. Borrowing cost is the risk-free curve plus a credit spread (CF17). The banker's view is in the DCM module on this site.

      Zero and forward rates can be built from any two bonds

      4.1 A two-year curve from one bond

      The one-year zero rate is 2.0%. A two-year bond with a 3.0% coupon sells for 100. Find the two-year zero rate, then the forward rate for the second year.

      100 = 3 / 1.02 + 103 / (1 + z₂)². The first term is 2.941, so 103 / (1 + z₂)² = 97.059, and z₂ = 3.02%. The forward rate is 1.0302² / 1.02 − 1 = 4.04%.

      The second year costs about 2 points more than the first, which is what a rising curve implies.

      Hugo, a taxi driver with no finance training, hears on the radio that the yield curve has inverted. Explain to him what that means, using the idea of a bank that pays more for a one-year deposit than for a ten-year deposit, and say in one sentence why it is not a guarantee of anything.

          Normally a bank pays more if you lock money away for ten years than for one. When the curve inverts, it pays more for one year than for ten. That happens when short-term rates are high, often because the central bank is fighting inflation, and people expect them to fall.

          It is a signal, not a guarantee. Inverted curves have often come before slowdowns, but the link is a habit, not a law, and the timing varies.

          1. 4.2 Why is the yield to maturity of a coupon bond a mixture of several zero rates?

          2. 4.3 Harmony has one payment of 10 due in five years. Which rate discounts it, and why not an average of the one-to-five-year rates?

          3. 4.4 A curve is normal, with a ten-year rate of 3.0% and a one-year rate of 2.0%. Does that prove the market expects the one-year rate to reach 3.0%? Explain.

          4

          1. The one-year zero rate is 2.5% and the two-year zero rate 3.01%. What is the forward rate for the second year?

          2. Harmony has one payment of 10 due in five years. Which rate discounts it?

          3. The curve is normal: 2.0% at one year, 3.0% at ten. Does the market expect the one-year rate to reach 3.0%?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Modèle d’équilibre des actifs financiers (MEDAF)

          = + ×

          3,0 % + 1,34 × 5,5 % = 10,37 %, arrondi à 10,4 % dans le reste du cours.

          Bêta ajusté (Blume)

          = 0,67 × + 0,33 × 1

          Taux à terme

          = (1 + )² / (1 + ) − 1

          Un prix qu’on peut bloquer aujourd’hui, pas une prévision : il contient une prime de terme.

          Valeur d’un flux certain sur la courbe

          = Σ / (1 + )ᵗ

          Idea What to remember
          Why only market risk is paid for Diversified investors set prices, so company-specific risk cancels out for them. Only co-movement with the market earns a premium.
          Beta Sensitivity of a share to the market. 1 means in step with it, above 1 amplifies it, below 1 dampens it.
          CAPM k = rF + β × equity risk premium. Harmony: 3.0% + 1.34 × 5.5% = 10.37%.
          Security market line Required return plotted against beta. A change in rates shifts it up or down. A change in the premium tilts it.
          Risk-free rate Government yield, same currency, similar maturity as the cash flows. Never mix a short rate with a long-run premium.
          Equity risk premium Estimated, never observed. Historical or implied by prices. Quote a range, about 4% to 6.5% for mature markets.
          Multifactor models Add premia for size, value, momentum, quality and others. Useful for very small or unusual firms. Adjustments need a reason.
          Yield curve Zero rate by maturity. Normal, flat or inverted. Each cash flow is discounted at the rate for its own date.
          Forward rate f = (1 + z₂)² / (1 + z₁) − 1. A rate you can lock in today. It contains a term premium, so it is not a forecast.

          The one-sentence version

          A required return is the price of time at the right maturity plus the price of the market risk the asset carries, and honest inputs give a range, not a point.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Beta How much a share moves, on average, when the market moves by 1%.
          Equity risk premium The extra return investors expect from the stock market over a risk-free government bond.
          Security market line The straight line of required return against beta.
          Risk-free rate The yield on a government bond in your own currency, with no default worry and a chosen maturity.
          Multifactor model A model that explains required returns with several risk sources, each with its own premium.
          Zero rate The annual return on a bond that pays one amount at one date and nothing before.
          Yield curve The rates for every maturity, plotted against maturity.
          Bootstrapping Extracting zero rates from coupon bonds, one maturity at a time.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on required return and market equilibrium, and on the term structure of interest rates.

          • Sharpe (1964) — Capital asset prices: a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk, Journal of Finance.

          • Fama and French (1993) — Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds, Journal of Financial Economics.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on risk and return and on the term structure of interest rates.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.