Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Marchés et risque / Module 14

14Financial markets and efficiency

What markets do, how well they price things, and what that means for the person running the company

Ce que font les marchés, comment ils fixent les prix, et ce que cela change pour qui dirige l’entreprise.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
13
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
9
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain what a financial system does using its six functions, and tell direct finance from intermediated finance.

  • Distinguish the primary market from the secondary market and say who receives the cash in each.

  • State the three forms of market efficiency and say what evidence supports and what evidence challenges each.

  • Name the main behavioural biases and the limits to arbitrage that allow mispricing to last.

  • Explain why most investors do better in a low-cost index fund than in an average active fund.

1What a financial system does

Some people have money they do not need today. Others have uses for money they do not have. A financial system exists to bring them together safely and cheaply.

A financial system does six jobs

Payments, pooling, transfer, risk, information and incentives cover everything the system is for

  • Payments and clearing. Moving money so that a sale in Lyon can be settled by a buyer in Hamburg.

  • Pooling and dividing. Gathering small savings into a large project, and splitting a large asset into small shares anyone can buy.

  • Transferring resources across time, place and industry: from savers now to a factory that pays later.

  • Managing risk. Insurance, diversification and derivatives let those who cannot bear a risk pass it to those who can.

  • Producing price information. Prices tell everyone where capital is wanted without a central planner.

  • Aligning incentives. Contracts, covenants and share options try to make the person using the money act in the interest of the person who supplied it.

Fintech firms, neobanks and payment apps compete mainly on the first two jobs. Crypto-assets and so-called decentralised finance claim to do all six without intermediaries. Their record on the last three, risk and incentives especially, is thin and has included large failures.

The primary market raises money, the secondary market only changes the owner

A share is sold to the company once and to other investors many times

The primary market is where a security is created and sold for the first time, and the issuer receives the cash. The secondary market is where investors then trade it among themselves. The issuer receives nothing from these trades.

The secondary market still matters to the company, for two reasons. It gives investors liquidity, the ability to sell quickly without moving the price, and investors pay more for a security they can sell. It also produces a continuous price. When the secondary price falls, the next primary issue costs more.

Three kinds of participant keep the system working

  • The hedger reduces a risk it already has. Harmony buys battery cells priced in dollars and fixes the euro cost in advance.

  • The speculator takes a risk deliberately, hoping to profit from being right. Speculators supply liquidity and take the other side of hedgers.

  • The arbitrageur seeks a riskless profit from the same thing trading at two prices, buying the cheap one and selling the dear one. This pushes the two prices together.

1.1 The bank's margin

A regional bank lends 200 million to companies at 5.0%. It funds 180 million of this with deposits at 2.0% and the remaining 20 million with its shareholders' money, which carries no interest cost. Compute the interest margin in millions and say why the bank can pay savers less than the 5.0% that borrowers pay.

Interest income is 200 × 5.0% = 10.0 million. Interest paid is 180 × 2.0% = 3.6 million. The margin is 6.4 million.

Savers accept less than the borrower pays because the bank takes over the work and the risk: it checks borrowers, spreads the risk across many loans, absorbs the losses and lets savers withdraw when they like. The margin is the payment for those services, and for the shareholders' capital that stands behind them.

1.2 Who gets the cash?

Northlight sells 1.0 million Harmony shares at 12.00 to a pension fund. How much cash does Harmony receive? What percentage of Harmony's 12.5 million shares does Northlight still hold if it started from 3.5 million?

Harmony receives nothing: a trade between two investors is a secondary transaction. Northlight receives 12.0 million.

Northlight started with 3.5 million shares and now has 2.5 million, which is 2.5 ÷ 12.5 = 20% of the 12.5 million shares.

a drag-and-drop board with eight transactions (a deposit, an IPO, a bond sale, a share bought on the exchange, a forward, a loan, an insurance policy, a card payment). The learner sorts each into primary, secondary, intermediated lending, derivative or payment, and discovers that most market volume never reaches the company.

Your aunt Amina keeps her savings in a deposit account and is nervous about "the stock market". Explain to her in everyday words how the bank turns her deposit into a loan to a company, what she gives up and gets in return, and how this differs from buying the company's shares herself.

      Amina. Deposits from many savers are pooled. The bank lends to companies, checks them and bears the losses. Amina gives up some return and gets safety and easy access. With shares she would hold one company's risk directly.

      Tomas. Efficiency says the price is a fair estimate that is hard to predict or beat, not that it is exactly right. A 5% fall means new information or a shift in mood changed the estimate.

      Sophie. Before fees, managers as a group earn the market return, so after fees the average trails it, and past winners rarely repeat. If she still wants an active fund, she should look for a low fee and a long, consistent record.

      1. 1.3 Name two functions of a financial system that a deposit account performs for Amina.

      2. 1.4 A listed company's share price doubles on the exchange. Does the company receive any cash? Why might it care anyway?

      3. 1.5 A trader sells euros forward because her employer will receive dollars in six months. Is she a hedger, a speculator or an arbitrageur?

      1

      1. A year after the IPO, Northlight sells 1.0 million Harmony shares to a pension fund at 12.00. Who receives the 12.0 million?

      2. A trader sells euros forward because her employer will receive dollars in six months. She is…

      3. Why does a listed company care about its secondary market price if it receives none of that cash?

      2Efficient markets: why prices are hard to beat

      If thousands of informed, competing investors push the price of Harmony towards what the shares are worth, then the price already contains what is known. That claim is called market efficiency, and it is more modest than its critics assume.

      In an efficient market the price already holds the available information

      Prices move when news arrives, and news is by definition unpredictable

      Think of a price as the market's best estimate of value today. Tomorrow's price differs from today's only if something unexpected happens. Unexpected events cannot be forecast, so price changes cannot be forecast either. The path of an efficient price therefore looks like a random walk: each step is independent of the last.

      This does not say prices move without reason. It says that the reasons are already inside the price when they are known, and only surprises move it afterwards.

      There are three versions, depending on what counts as information

      Form Information in the price What it rules out Evidence
      Weak Past prices and volumes Profits from chart patterns Mostly supported, after costs
      Semi-strong All public information Profits from reading accounts and news quickly Largely supported, with exceptions
      Strong Public and private information Profits from inside knowledge Rejected: insiders can profit, and trading on such information is illegal

      Each form contains the one above it. The three forms were popularised by the economist Eugene Fama in a 1970 review of the evidence.

      An event study shows semi-strong efficiency at work

      Active managers on average do not beat the market after fees

      Beating the market is a zero-sum game before costs and a losing one after costs

      All investors together hold the whole market. Before costs, their average return equals the market return, so if some beat it, others trail it by the same amount. After fees and trading costs, the average active investor must trail. Studies in many countries find that most active funds fall short of their benchmark over long periods, and the few winners rarely repeat.

      2.1 A surprise that is half a surprise

      Harmony announces a new dealer contract with a net present value of 3.0 million. Analysts had already priced in half of it. By how much should the share price move, in euros per share, and to what level from 12.00? Assume 12.5 million shares.

      Only the unexpected half counts: 3.0 × 0.5 = 1.5 million. Per share: 1.5 ÷ 12.5 = 0.12. The price should rise to about 12.12, a rise of 1.0%.

      If the whole 3.0 million had been a surprise, the rise would be 0.24. The market had already paid for half.

      a price simulator. The learner sees ten charts, five random walks and five real anonymised shares, and tries to tell them apart, then draws trend lines on a random chart. The learner discovers that the eye finds trends in pure noise.

      Your friend Tomas, a retired teacher, hears that "the market is efficient" and replies: so the share price must always be exactly right, and a fall of 5% in a day means investors are stupid. Explain to him what efficiency does and does not claim, in two or three sentences without technical words.

          1. 2.3 Which form of efficiency does a profitable strategy based on the moving average of past prices contradict?

          2. 2.4 Why is it impossible for all investors together to beat the market?

          3. 2.5 A listed company announces a profit rise that the market had fully expected. The share price does not move. Is that evidence against efficiency?

          2

          1. Harmony announces a dealer contract with an NPV of 3.0 million, half of which analysts had already expected. With 12.5 million shares, the price should move from 12.00 to about…

          2. A strategy based on the moving average of past prices earns reliable profits after costs. Which form of efficiency does it contradict?

          3. Why must the average active investor trail the market after costs?

          3Where prices go wrong: behaviour, limits and bubbles

          The evidence for efficiency is strong but not complete. Some patterns do not fit, and some episodes fit very badly. Understanding them also teaches a CFO when to be wary of the screen.

          People make predictable errors, and some of them are shared

          Losses hurt about twice as much as equal gains please

          Behavioural finance studies how real people decide, as opposed to how a perfectly rational person would. Its best-known result is loss aversion, from the work of Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky: people feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size, and so refuse bets that are favourable on average.

          Other documented biases include overconfidence, which leads to excessive trading, and anchoring, where an investor clings to the price paid. They matter for markets only if the errors point in the same direction at the same time.

          Herding turns individual mistakes into collective ones

          Investors copy others for three reasons. Some follow rules, because their mandate says to hold what the benchmark holds. Some follow information, assuming that a crowd buying must know something. Some follow the price itself, buying because it is rising and expecting someone else to pay more. The third kind has no link to value and is the engine of bubbles.

          Arbitrage is limited, so mispricing can last

          A mispricing is only corrected if someone can profit from correcting it at low risk

          Efficiency does not need every investor to be rational, because smart investors should correct errors. But correction is costly and risky. Selling an overvalued share short means borrowing it, the price may rise further first, and the arbitrageur's own investors may withdraw their money before the price falls. The market can stay wrong longer than you can stay solvent.

          A bubble is a price that needs ever-faster growth to be justified

          Bubbles can be recognised by what the price would require, not by the price itself

          A bubble is a rise in price far beyond what the cash flows can justify, sustained by the expectation of selling to someone else at a higher price. Famous cases include the technology shares of the late 1990s, which peaked in March 2000, and the US housing market before 2008. Bubbles seem obvious afterwards and are hard to call as they happen. A useful test is to ask what the price implies.

          3.2 How long to justify the price?

          Harmony's price rises from 12.00 to 36.00. At a constant price-to-earnings ratio, how many years of 15% annual earnings growth does it take to triple earnings? Compare with 20%. Which growth rate is more plausible for a maker of e-bikes, and why does it matter?

          Tripling at 15% a year takes about 7.9 years (1.15 to the power 7.86 is 3.0). At 20% it takes about 6.0 years.

          Most e-bike makers cannot sustain 20% for six years, and 15% for eight is ambitious. If the price implies a pace above what the business can plausibly deliver, it is leaning on the next buyer. That is the sign of a possible bubble.

          a bubble game. Each month the learner holds, sells or shorts a fictional share, with a panel showing the earnings growth the price implies. The crash comes at a random date. The learner discovers that the panel flags danger early, but acting too soon loses money.

          1. 3.3 Why does loss aversion lead investors to sell winners and hold losers?

          2. 3.4 Give two reasons why an arbitrageur cannot always correct a mispricing.

          3. 3.5 A friend says that because a price bubble burst, markets are clearly inefficient. What is the weakest point in that reasoning?

          3

          1. Why does loss aversion lead investors to hold losing shares too long?

          2. Which is NOT a reason why arbitrage may fail to correct a mispricing?

          3. Harmony's price rises from 12.00 to 36.00 with no change in its prospects. What is the useful bubble test?

          4Passive investing and what efficiency means for a CFO

          If prices are hard to beat, the sensible response for most savers is to stop trying. For the CFO the sensible response is different: to treat the price as information and as a cost, and to stop trying to outsmart it.

          Passive investing buys the whole market and pays almost nothing for it

          An index fund holds every share in proportion to its size

          A passive fund copies an index, such as a list of the largest companies, instead of choosing shares. In a market-capitalisation weighted index, each company's weight is its market value divided by the total. Because there is no research and little trading, fees are very low.

          For a CFO, efficiency has five practical consequences

          Treat the share price as a fair but imperfect estimate of what investors expect

          • Do not time the market with financing. If prices are hard to predict, waiting for a better moment to issue shares gains little on average. CF32 discusses when acting on a view is worth it.

          • Cosmetic accounting does not fool the market for long. Changing how profit is reported, without changing cash flow, should not raise the price (see CF9).

          • Financing is mostly fair-priced. A bond or share sold at the market price is neither a bargain nor a rip-off. Value comes from the investments the money pays for (CF24, CF29).

          • Disclose clearly and promptly. Investors cannot price what they cannot see, and uncertainty raises the cost of capital.

          • Use the price as information, not as an order. If it differs strongly from your own value estimate, ask what the market knows that you do not. Buying back shares you believe are cheap is covered in CF31.

          Your neighbour Sophie, a gardener, has inherited 20,000. A friend says she should pick a clever fund manager, and her bank adviser says she should buy a cheap index fund. Explain in everyday words why the average clever manager will not beat the index after fees, and what she might look for if she still wants an active fund.

              4

              1. Harmony is worth 150 million in an index whose members total 30,000 million. A tracking fund holds…

              2. For a CFO, what does market efficiency mean about financing?

              3. The share price is well below the CFO's own estimate of value. What should be the first response?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              Les formules du module

              Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

              Réaction du cours à une annonce

              = /

              Seules les surprises bougent un prix efficient.

              Poids dans un indice pondéré par la capitalisation

              = /

              Années de croissance qu’exige un cours

              = ln() / ln(1 + )

              Idea What to remember
              Direct vs intermediated finance Direct: the saver holds the company's security. Intermediated: the saver holds a claim on a bank or fund, which holds the company's.
              Primary market Security sold for the first time. The issuer gets the cash. Harmony's IPO raised 30.0 million.
              Secondary market Investors trade among themselves. The issuer gets nothing but liquidity and a price.
              Hedger, speculator, arbitrageur Reduces a risk, takes a risk for profit, locks in a gain from two prices for one asset.
              Market efficiency Prices already reflect available information, so only surprises move them. Weak, semi-strong, strong.
              Active vs passive Before costs, investors as a group earn the market return. After fees, the average active investor trails it.
              Behavioural finance Loss aversion, overconfidence, herding. Errors matter when they are shared.
              Bubble test Ask what growth the price needs. If the answer is implausible, the price is leaning on the next buyer.
              What efficiency means for a CFO Do not time issues, do not rely on cosmetic accounting, disclose well, create value in the business.
              Harmony's market 12.5 million shares at 12.00: 150 million. A +2.12 million NPV surprise moves the price by about 0.17.

              The one-sentence version

              Markets link savers and companies through intermediaries and exchanges, their prices absorb most public information quickly and are hard to beat after costs, they can still be wrong for long stretches, and a CFO should read them as information while creating value in the business itself.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              Intermediation A bank or fund standing between savers and borrowers, holding the claims on both.
              Primary market Where a security is first sold and the issuer receives the money.
              Secondary market Where existing securities are traded between investors.
              Liquidity How quickly an asset can be sold without moving its price.
              Arbitrage Profit from a price difference for the same thing, with little or no risk.
              Random walk A path whose next step cannot be predicted from earlier steps.
              Loss aversion The tendency to feel losses more than equal gains.
              Bubble A price far above what the cash flows justify, sustained by hope of a higher resale.
              Index fund A fund that copies an index instead of picking shares.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on financial markets.

              • Fama (1970) — Efficient capital markets: a review of theory and empirical work, Journal of Finance.

              • Kahneman and Tversky (1979) — Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk, Econometrica.

              • Merton and Bodie (1995) — A conceptual framework for analyzing the financial environment, in The Global Financial System: A Functional Perspective, Harvard Business School Press.

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.