Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Titres financiers / Module 21

21Hybrid securities

Convertibles, warrants, preference shares and other instruments between debt and equity

Obligations convertibles, bons de souscription, actions de préférence et autres titres entre dette et fonds propres.

Lecture
30 min
Sections
16
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
15
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Split a convertible bond into a bond floor and an option, and price each.

  • Estimate the real cost of a convertible, a warrant and a mandatory convertible.

  • Compute diluted earnings per share and warrant dilution.

  • Explain what a perpetual hybrid does for a rating and what it costs.

  • Convert a venture note with a cap or a discount.

  • Name the main French instruments and say what each is for.

1Why hybrids exist and why they are never free

A hybrid mixes the rights of a lender with those of an owner. Before any detail, one rule: an option has a value, and someone always pays for it.

Hybrids sit on a spectrum between debt and equity

Three dials separate a loan from a share

A loan pays fixed amounts, ranks ahead of shareholders in a failure and must be repaid on a date. A share pays what the board decides, ranks last and never matures. Three dials separate them: how the payment is set, where the holder ranks, and whether there is a maturity.

Turn the dials part way and you get a hybrid. A bond the holder may swap for shares has a fixed coupon and a maturity, plus a share in the upside. A perpetual bond whose coupon the issuer can skip ranks near the bottom and never matures, yet it is still legally a bond and its coupons are often tax-deductible.

Two families do two different jobs

  • Option-type hybrids (warrants, convertibles, mandatory convertibles) give the investor a stake in the share price. They cut cash cost today or sell shares later at a better price.

  • Capital-type hybrids (preference shares, perpetual bonds, participating loans) absorb losses before senior lenders. They strengthen the balance sheet without ordinary shares.

A low coupon is paid for with an option

The cheap coupon is the visible half of a two-part price

Investors do not give things away. If a company pays 1.5% when straight debt costs 5.0%, the investor receives something worth the difference. In a convertible bond it is the right to turn the bond into shares.

Hybrids still make sense where the no-free-lunch rule meets a friction

In a perfect market the choice would not matter. Four frictions give hybrids a role.

  • Disagreement about risk. A young, volatile firm may think its shares are worth more than the market does, and borrows cheaply now, accepting dilution only if proved right.

  • Lender and owner conflicts. Owners of a risky firm gain by taking risk, lenders lose. A lender holding an option gains from risk too.

  • Signalling. A plain share issue makes the market fear overpricing. A convertible sold at a premium sends a milder signal (CF32).

  • Rating room. Some instruments count partly as equity for agencies (Part 4).

1.1 Nadia, a primary school teacher, is offered a chance to lend 30,000 to a friend's café at 1% instead of 4%, with the right to buy 10% of the café in five years at today's price. She finds 1% mean. Explain why the offer may not be mean and what she should ask, without the words option or discount.

      The 1% is only part of the payment. Nadia also gets the right to buy 10% of the café at a fixed price, which is worth a lot if it thrives. She should ask how much that right is worth against the 3 points of interest she gives up, 900 a year on 30,000. For a risky café that could double, the right may be worth more and the offer is generous. For a steady one it may be worth less.

      1.2 The zero-coupon proposal

      1.2 A zero-coupon convertible: 30.0 million, five years, otherwise like Harmony's below. At a 5.0% straight rate, find the bond part and, by difference, what the conversion right must be worth for investors to accept. Is that credible?

      Bond part: 30.0 ÷ 1.05⁵ = 23.51 million. The conversion right must be worth 30.0 − 23.51 = 6.49 million, or 3.25 per share on 2.0 million shares.

      With 25% volatility each option is worth about 2.31, so 3.25 would need volatility in the mid-30s per cent. Not credible at 15.00. Investors would ask for a lower conversion price or a coupon.

      1

      1. Harmony is offered a convertible at 1.5% when straight debt costs 5.0%. What explains the gap?

      2. Which three dials separate a loan from a share?

      3. Which of these is a capital-type hybrid rather than an option-type one?

      2Convertible bonds: a bond with a share option stapled on

      The convertible is the best known hybrid. Taking it apart into a bond and an option makes its value, its cost and its dilution straightforward to compute.

      A convertible is a straight bond plus a call option

      The terms fix what the investor can swap and at what price

      The holder of a convertible can hand it back for a fixed number of shares instead of cash. The number is the conversion ratio, and the price paid per share is the conversion price, often 20% to 40% above the current share price. That gap is the conversion premium.

      Term Harmony's convertible What it means
      Amount and price 30.0m at par, 30,000 bonds of 1,000 Cash received on day one
      Coupon 1.5% a year, 0.45m Straight debt would cost 5.0%
      Maturity 5 years Repaid at par if not converted
      Conversion price 15.00 Price per share paid by converting
      Conversion premium 25% over the 12.00 share price 15.00 ÷ 12.00 − 1
      Conversion ratio 66.67 shares per bond 1,000 ÷ 15.00
      Shares if all convert 2.0m 30.0m ÷ 15.00

      Conversion ratio = face value ÷ conversion price

      Convertible value ≈ bond floor + value of the conversion option

      The bond floor is what the bond would be worth without the option

      Discount the coupons and the repayment at the rate Harmony would pay on straight debt, 5.0%. The result is the bond floor: 0.45 a year for five years plus 30.0 at the end gives 25.45 million. Investors paid 30.0, so they paid 4.55 million for the option.

      The convertible follows whichever of two values is higher

      Low share price: a bond. High share price: shares

      If the share falls far below 15.00, conversion is pointless and the convertible is worth about its floor. If it rises far above, the bond is worth the shares it can become. In between the option has time value and the convertible is worth more than either.

      Share price Conversion value Bond floor Regime
      6.00 12.0m 25.45m Bond-like
      12.00 24.0m 25.45m Mixed
      15.00 30.0m 25.45m Mixed, option at the money
      20.00 40.0m 25.45m Equity-like
      30.00 60.0m 25.45m Equity-like

      Floor and conversion value for Harmony's 30.0m convertible, before the time value of the option

      If Harmony's credit deteriorates, the floor itself falls and the convertible trades like distressed debt. Issuers can also redeem early once the share has stayed well above the conversion price, which forces conversion and ends the coupon.

      The real cost lies between the cost of debt and the cost of equity

      Nobody knows the cost until the share price is known

      If Harmony's shares fall, investors take cash, Harmony repays 30.0 million and has borrowed at 1.5%. If the shares reach 20.00, investors convert and Harmony hands over shares worth 40.0 million for the 30.0 million received. The extra 10.0 million falls on old shareholders.

      Share price at maturity Investor chooses Harmony delivers Value delivered Plus coupons paid
      8.00 Cash 30.0m repayment 30.0m 2.25m
      20.00 Conversion 2.0m new shares 40.0m 2.25m

      Two ends of the cost of Harmony's convertible

      A fairly priced convertible is neither cheap nor dear: like straight debt sold at a fair price, it transfers no value between old shareholders and new investors. Its required return lies between the cost of debt and the cost of equity, because part of it is an option on the shares. It costs more where it converts and less where it does not.

      Reported interest is higher than the coupon

      Under IFRS the proceeds are usually split. The bond floor, 25.45 million, is debt and the remaining 4.55 million is equity. The debt accrues interest at the straight rate: 25.45 × 5.0% = 1.27 million in year one, against a cash coupon of 0.45 million. Profit bears the larger figure.

      2.1 Diluted EPS with higher earnings

      2.1 Suppose instead that next year's net income is 10.5 million. Compute basic and diluted EPS, using the same convertible, and the percentage by which diluted EPS is below basic.

      Basic EPS: 10.5 ÷ 12.5 = 0.84. Interest added back: 25.45 × 5.0% × 0.75 = 0.95 million. Diluted EPS: (10.5 + 0.95) ÷ 14.5 = 0.79, which is 6.0% below basic.

      2.2 Marc, a baker, is offered a 2% loan where 6% is normal, but the bank may take 15% of the bakery if its value doubles. He thinks it is a favour. Explain what the bank gives up, what it gets, and the one question he should ask.

          The bank charges 2% where 6% is normal, so it gives up 4 points a year. In return it takes the right to 15% of the bakery if the value doubles. That is the price of the low rate, paid in a different currency. Marc should ask what he would hand over if things go well. If the bakery doubles, 15% may be worth far more than the 4 points saved a year.

          a slider for Harmony's share price at maturity (4 to 40) plotting the convertible's value against shares and straight debt, with the conversion price and coupon adjustable. The learner discovers that a lower coupon is always bought with a lower conversion price or higher volatility.

          1. 2.3 At maturity the share is at 13.00. Do investors convert? Show the sum.

          2. 2.4 Why does an IFRS income statement show more interest than the cash coupon?

          3. 2.5 In year two the share reaches 25.00. What is the conversion value of the issue, and how can Harmony end the coupon?

          2

          1. Harmony's 30.0 million convertible has a bond floor of 25.45 million. What does the floor measure?

          2. At maturity the share trades at 20.00. What does the convertible cost Harmony's old shareholders?

          3. Why does Harmony's income statement show 1.27 million of interest on the convertible when the coupon is 0.45 million?

          3Warrants and mandatory convertibles: options and obligations to take shares

          A warrant is an option sold by the company itself. A mandatory convertible removes the investor's choice and turns the bundle into equity with a coupon.

          A warrant is a call option that creates new shares

          Warrants look like calls but the issuer stands behind them

          A warrant gives the right to buy new shares from the company at a fixed price until a fixed date. An exchange-traded call is a bet between investors. A warrant is issued by the company, so exercise creates shares and brings in cash. The dilution makes it worth a little less than the matching call, and long lives give it a large time value.

          Companies attach warrants to loans as a sweetener, give them to lenders in restructurings and to private equity investors as a kicker, and grant them to managers. Each replaces cash the company cannot or does not want to pay now.

          Dilution from warrants is counted by the treasury method

          Assume the exercise money is used to buy back shares at the market price. Only the shares it cannot buy back are new.

          Net new shares = warrants × (1 − strike ÷ share price), if the share price exceeds the strike

          3.1 Counting dilution from warrants

          3.1 A holder has 2.0 million warrants with a strike of 13.00 on Harmony shares. How many net new shares does the treasury method add at a share price of 18.00? At 12.00? What percentage of 12.5 million is the first figure?

          At 18.00: 2.0 × (1 − 13 ÷ 18) = 0.56 million net new shares, 4.4% of 12.5 million. At 12.00 the warrants are out of the money and dilution is zero.

          A mandatory convertible is equity that pays a coupon on the way

          The investor loses the choice, so the bond floor disappears

          A mandatory convertible must become shares at maturity. With no bond floor, it is a way of selling shares later, with a coupon meanwhile. The coupon exceeds a bond's because the investor bears share-price risk.

          Most designs cap the investor's upside. Below a reference price the investor gets one share per unit invested. Between the reference price and a cap, fewer shares, so the value stays flat. Above the cap, a fixed smaller number of shares. The investor has sold the middle band of upside, and the high coupon pays for it.

          Share price at maturity Shares received per 12.00 invested Value received
          9.00 1.00 9.00
          12.00 1.00 12.00
          15.00 0.80 12.00
          18.00 0.80 14.40

          Payoff of a mandatory convertible with a reference price of 12.00 and a cap at 15.00

          a payoff diagram of the mandatory convertible with draggable reference price and cap, against plain shares. The learner discovers that every point of upside given up is paid for with coupon, and that below the reference price the two lines coincide.

          3

          1. How does a warrant differ from an exchange-traded call on the same shares?

          2. Harmony grants 1.0 million warrants with a strike of 14.00. The share is at 12.00. What dilution does the treasury method count?

          3. What does the investor in a mandatory convertible give up in exchange for a high coupon?

          4Capital-type hybrids and venture instruments

          Some hybrids exist to build a cushion under senior lenders. Others exist to avoid putting a price on a company that has no profits yet. Both carry a price.

          Preference shares pay before ordinary shares but cost more after tax

          A preference share ranks between debt and ordinary equity

          A preference share has a priority claim on dividends, often at a fixed rate, and on proceeds in a winding up. In return it usually has no vote. If dividends are cumulative, missed ones must be paid before ordinary shareholders receive anything.

          Listed companies use them little, because they cost more after tax. Interest is deductible and dividends are not. A 6% preference dividend costs the same as pre-tax interest of 6 ÷ (1 − 25%) = 8.0%. They are common in private equity and venture deals, where rights can be tailored: a liquidation preference, a conversion right, a vote on key decisions.

          A perpetual hybrid buys balance-sheet room for a higher coupon

          Rating agencies count part of it as equity

          A perpetual hybrid bond has no maturity. The issuer may redeem it at a first call date, typically five years or more away, may defer coupons without default, and ranks behind all other lenders. IFRS can classify it as equity if payment is at the issuer's discretion. Rating agencies usually count part of it, often half, as equity in leverage ratios.

          Venture instruments postpone the valuation until someone can price it

          A convertible note is a loan that becomes shares at the next round

          A start-up with no profits cannot be valued with confidence. A convertible note is a small interest-bearing loan that converts into shares at the next priced round. Early investors get a better price than the new investor through a discount on the conversion price, a valuation cap on the company value at which the note converts, or both. The investor takes whichever is better.

          A SAFE (simple agreement for future equity) does the same with no interest and no maturity. The danger is that several SAFEs, each with its own cap, convert at once and founders see their dilution only at the priced round.

          4.2 Cap or discount?

          4.2 A different start-up issues a 1.0 million note: 8% interest, a 25% discount, a cap of 15.0 million, converting after one year at a Series A pre-money value of 18.0 million. Which device applies? What are the shares worth at the Series A price, and what percentage of a 24.0 million post-money value is that?

          Discount: 18.0 × 75% = 13.5 million. Cap: 15.0 million. The lower, 13.5, applies, so the discount wins. The note with interest is 1.08 million and converts at 75% of the Series A price, so the shares are worth 1.08 × 18.0 ÷ 13.5 = 1.44 million, which is 1.44 ÷ 24.0 = 6.0% of post-money.

          a cap-table simulator for a note. The learner sets amount, interest, discount, cap and Series A value, and sees which device applies and who holds what. The aim is to discover that a cap bites only when the round is priced above it.

          1. 4.3 A company pays 6% on preference shares and 6% on a bond. With 25% tax, which costs more after tax, and by how much?

          2. 4.4 Why does an issuer of a perpetual hybrid almost always redeem it at the first call date?

          3. 4.5 What are the two main differences between a convertible note and a SAFE?

          4

          1. A company pays a 6% preference dividend. With 25% tax, what pre-tax interest rate costs the same?

          2. Harmony replaces 20.0 of senior debt with a perpetual hybrid that agencies count half as equity. Adjusted net debt becomes…

          3. A start-up's note has a 20% discount and a 12.0 cap. The Series A pre-money is 18.0. Which applies?

          5The French toolbox: the legal frame and the acronym zoo

          France has a rich vocabulary of hybrids, built on corporate law that makes shareholders decide first and the board act second.

          The shareholders vote the instrument and the board chooses the moment

          Securities giving access to capital need an extraordinary meeting

          Bonds convertible into shares, warrants and similar securities are valeurs mobilières donnant accès au capital. The extraordinary general meeting (assemblée générale extraordinaire) must authorise them. In practice it delegates the power to the board for up to 26 months, with a ceiling on the amount, and the board issues when the market is right.

          Existing shareholders hold a preferential subscription right (droit préférentiel de souscription, DPS) on such securities, which the meeting can waive under conditions (CF22, CF32). Capital increases only when the securities are exercised or converted.

          Employees and start-ups have their own instruments

          BSPCE give employees a stake without cost to them

          Bons de souscription de parts de créateur d'entreprise (BSPCE) are granted free to employees and some executives of young companies, within conditions on age, ownership and, for listed companies, size. The holder pays only the exercise price, and the gain gets a special flat tax rate when conditions are met. Rates and conditions have changed in recent finance laws, so check the current text.

          BSA AIR (bons de souscription d'actions, accord d'investissement rapide) are the French answer to the SAFE (CF34).

          French law has flexible shares and loans with a hybrid feel

          ADP and prêts participatifs adapt to the deal

          Actions de préférence (ADP) let the company tailor a class of shares: priority dividend, extra votes, no votes, a conversion right. French law sets limits, including on non-voting shares in listed companies. They suit private equity deals and family groups.

          A prêt participatif is a deeply subordinated loan whose interest can combine a fixed part and a profit-linked part. French lenders and analysts treat it as quasi-equity (quasi-fonds propres), so the borrower's financial standing improves while the lender shares in success. Bpifrance and banks use it for small and medium companies. The ORA is mandatory by design: French accounting often presents it as quasi-equity, while IFRS follows the contract terms. Tax treatment depends on the terms and on the interest deduction limit in CF29.

          5

          1. Under French law, who must authorise an issue of bonds convertible into new shares?

          2. What is an ORNANE?

          3. Why do French analysts often treat a prêt participatif as quasi-equity?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Le convertible en deux morceaux

          ≈ +

          Les 4,55 de coupons économisés paient l’option.

          Ratio de conversion

          = /

          BPA dilué

          = ( + ) / ()

          Méthode du rachat d’actions (bons de souscription)

          = × (1 − / )

          Coût d’une action de préférence, en équivalent avant impôt

          = / (1 − )

          Idea What to remember
          No free lunch A low coupon is paid for with an option or a lower rank.
          Conversion ratio Face value ÷ conversion price: 1,000 ÷ 15.00 = 66.67 shares.
          Bond floor The convertible's value without the option: 25.45m for 30.0m.
          True cost A blend of debt and equity cost, known only after the share price is.
          Reported interest IFRS splits a convertible, so interest exceeds the coupon.
          Diluted EPS Assume conversion: add back after-tax interest, add the new shares.
          Treasury method Net new shares = warrants × (1 − strike ÷ price).
          Mandatory convertible No floor. The investor sells upside for a higher coupon.
          Preference shares Dividends not deductible: 6% costs 8.0% pre-tax.
          Perpetual hybrid Often 50% equity credit, for a higher coupon.

          The one-sentence version

          A hybrid bundles a bond or a share with an option and special rights, and the cheap coupon or the cushion it offers is always paid for by the option or the lower rank it gives the investor.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Conversion premium How far the conversion price sits above the share price.
          Bond floor What a convertible is worth if the option is worth nothing.
          Warrant A company-issued right to buy new shares at a fixed price.
          Dilution The fall in an old shareholder's stake when new shares appear.
          Equity credit The share of a hybrid an agency counts as equity.
          Valuation cap The highest company value at which a note converts.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on hybrid securities.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on warrants and convertibles.

          • Brennan and Schwartz (1977) — Convertible bonds: valuation and optimal strategies for call and conversion, Journal of Finance.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.