What you will be able to do
Show why retained earnings have a cost and test a retention decision against the cost of equity.
Explain why a dividend, taken alone, moves value from the company to the shareholder without creating any.
Compute the earnings per share effect of a buyback and say when it is an illusion.
Choose between ordinary dividend, special dividend, scrip dividend and buyback for a given goal.
Apply the main French limits on distributions and buybacks, and the tax treatment of a French shareholder.
1The decision: keep the cash or return it
Before choosing a tool, decide whether the cash should leave. The answer depends on one comparison: what the company can earn on the money against what the shareholders can earn.
Retained earnings cost as much as new equity
Keeping profit looks free, but it is shareholders' money
Managers often say retained earnings are a cheap source of funds because nobody is paid for them. This is wrong. The profit belongs to shareholders. If the company keeps it, shareholders are in effect reinvesting it. They give up the return they could have earned by receiving it and investing it themselves.
So the cost of retained earnings is the cost of equity. Keeping a euro is the same as paying it all out and then asking shareholders to put it back in a share issue. The only difference is that no fees are paid and no one has to vote.
Retention creates value only when the marginal return beats the cost of equity
The test applies to the marginal return, the return on the next euro invested, not to the company's average return. A firm with a proud average ROE can still have only poor projects left.
Retention also sets the speed of growth
Without new shares or extra leverage, equity grows only by what is kept:
g = ROE × (1 − payout ratio)
The payout ratio is dividends divided by net income. Harmony's ROE is 13.9%. With no payout it could grow equity by 13.9% a year, and with a 40% payout by 13.9% × 0.60 = 8.34%.
A dividend alone creates no value
The share price falls by the dividend on the day it is paid
A dividend is cash leaving the company. The company has less in it, so each share is worth less. On the ex-dividend date the price drops by about the amount paid. The shareholder holds more cash and a lower-priced share, and is no richer.
Shareholders can make their own dividend policy
Suppose an investor with 1,000 shares wants no income. She receives 300 and buys more Harmony shares at 11.70: 300 / 11.70 = 25.64 shares. She now holds 1,025.64 shares worth 12,000, exactly what she held before. Another investor who wants income can sell a few shares instead. Each can reach the pattern he or she prefers whatever the company does.
This is the irrelevance result (Modigliani and Miller). In a world with no taxes, no transaction costs and the same information for everyone, the way a company splits its cash between payout and retention changes nothing, as long as its investments stay the same. The next section lists the frictions that make payout matter in practice.
a slider for the dividend per share from 0 to 1.00 that redraws the price before and after the ex-dividend date and the investor's cash plus shares. Add a toggle 'reinvest / spend'. The learner discovers that total wealth stays the same on the slider's whole range, until the tax toggle is switched on.
Payout still matters because markets have frictions
Four frictions explain why companies care about payout
Tax. Dividends and capital gains are often taxed differently, and gains are taxed only when the shares are sold. The better route depends on the shareholder's status (see part 3).
Agency. Managers who hold idle cash may spend it on projects that enlarge the firm and not the shareholders' wealth. Paying out removes the temptation and forces the company to raise new money, with scrutiny, when it needs more.
Signalling. Managers know more than outsiders. A dividend increase that is expensive to reverse tells the market they expect lasting profit. A cut tells the opposite, which is why firms rarely cut.
Clienteles. Retirees and some institutions like regular income. Others prefer growth and low tax. Companies attract the holders that suit their policy.
Companies smooth dividends and change them reluctantly
Since Lintner in the 1950s, surveys show firms moving slowly toward a target payout: dividends rise less than earnings in good years and fall less in bad ones. The widespread suspensions of 2020 were a rare exception, and most were restored.
1.1 A project earns 12% and the cost of equity is 10.4%. Should the company retain the cash to fund it?
Yes. 12% beats the 10.4% required, so each euro retained for it creates value.
1.2 Why does the share price fall on the ex-dividend date, and who is better off?
The company has paid cash out, so what remains is worth less. Nobody is richer from the payment itself. Only tax or a taste for cash changes that.
1.3 Name two reasons a listed company might still prefer a steady dividend even though payout is irrelevant in a perfect market.
Signalling: a dividend managers dislike cutting tells the market they expect lasting profit. Clienteles: some investors need regular income. Agency: a regular payout limits idle cash.
1
Harmony keeps 2.0 million for a project earning 6% a year after tax, for ever. Its cost of equity is 10.4%. The decision…
Right. The project is worth 0.12 / 0.104 = 1.15.
The project is funded with shareholders' money.
Retained cash costs the cost of equity.
That is the income, not the value created.
With an ROE of 13.9% and a payout of 40%, equity can grow internally by…
Growth is ROE times retention.
Right. 13.9% × 0.60.
That assumes no payout.
That uses the payout instead of the retention.
On the ex-dividend date, a 0.30 dividend…
Risk belongs to the operations, not to the label.
Cash has left the firm.
Right. 12.00 becomes about 11.70.
The company is worth less after paying out cash.
2The tools: dividends, buybacks and capital reductions
Once the cash is to leave, the form matters. Each tool differs in flexibility, signal, tax and effect on ownership.
Dividends come in four forms, each with a different message
Ordinary, interim, special and scrip dividends serve different goals
Ordinary dividend: regular, voted once a year after the accounts. It is a commitment the market expects to see repeated.
Interim dividend: an instalment paid during the year, before accounts are final. It spreads cash across the year.
Special dividend: a one-off, announced as such. It returns surplus cash without promising a repeat.
Scrip dividend: shareholders may take new shares in place of cash. The company keeps the cash, and the number of shares rises.
The right tool depends on the goal
Dividends commit, buybacks flex
| Criterion | Ordinary dividend | Buyback |
|---|---|---|
| Flexibility | Low, cuts send a bad signal | High, can be paused |
| Signal | Lasting profit | Shares look cheap, or surplus cash |
| Effect on ownership | None, all shareholders paid | Holders who stay own a bigger share |
| Tax for the shareholder | Taxed on receipt | Gain taxed only on those who sell |
| Share-based pay | No offset | Can offset dilution from new shares |
Rules of thumb, not laws. Tax depends on the country and the shareholder.
A company with stable, predictable cash flows can support a regular dividend. A company with volatile cash flows does better to keep the regular dividend small and use buybacks or special dividends for the surplus.
Your cousin Karim owns shares in a listed company that just announced a large buyback. He says: they are using my money, so I lose. Explain to him in everyday words who gains and who loses from a buyback, and what he should check before cheering or complaining.
A good answer says: the company buys shares from those who want to sell. If you stay, you own a bigger slice of a company with less cash. You gain if the price was below what the shares are worth and lose if above. Check the price against value.
2.2 A scrip dividend gives shareholders new shares at a discount. Who pays for the discount?
Shareholders who take cash. The new shares issued at a discount dilute their stake. If everyone takes shares, the discount washes out.
2.3 A company buys back shares at twice their true value. Who gains and who loses?
Sellers gain, since they receive twice what the shares are worth. Remaining shareholders lose. EPS may still rise, which is why value per share is the test.
2.4 Why can a company with volatile profits prefer buybacks to a high ordinary dividend?
A dividend is hard to cut without a bad signal, so a high one forces borrowing or share issues in a bad year. A buyback can be paused.
2
Harmony spends 3.75 million buying back shares at 12.00, their fair value. Value per share afterwards is…
Right. 146.25 / 12.1875. The EPS gain is an illusion.
EPS is not value.
Shares were cancelled, so the price does not drop.
That is the value if the shares were bought at 9.60.
A buyback lifts EPS when…
Right. 6.0% against 2.25% or 3.75% for Harmony.
The source is captured by its after-tax cost.
Debt is irrelevant to the test.
That is not the EPS test.
In a scrip dividend at a 10% discount, who pays for the discount?
Right. New shares at a discount dilute them.
Lenders are unaffected.
Tax is not involved in the transfer.
It is a transfer between shareholders.
3In France: legal limits, buyback rules and shareholder tax
French company law restricts what can be paid out and in what way, to protect creditors and minority shareholders. The tax treatment of the shareholder then shapes how much of the payout reaches them.
French law only lets a company pay out what it has really earned
Dividends come from distributable profit, never from capital
In France the general meeting of shareholders (assemblée générale ordinaire, AGO) votes the dividend on the board's proposal, once the annual accounts are approved. The vote is based on the company's own statutory accounts, not the group accounts. The aim of the rules is to protect creditors: they lent against the capital, which must stay in the company.
Distributable profit = profit of the year − prior losses − allocations to reserves required by law or the articles + retained earnings brought forward + distributable reserves
The réserve légale (legal reserve) must receive 5% of each year's profit until it reaches 10% of share capital. It cannot be distributed. A company also cannot pay out so much that equity falls below share capital plus reserves that the law or the articles forbid it to distribute.
French buybacks are capped, time-limited and reported
The general meeting authorises, the board executes, and 10% is the ceiling
A French listed company needs shareholder approval to buy back its own shares. The meeting votes a programme that states a maximum price, a purpose and a limit of 10% of share capital, for at most 18 months. The board then acts within it. Treasury shares carry neither vote nor dividend, and the company must report its purchases.
Cancelling shares needs an extraordinary meeting and creditors' protection
To cancel shares, an extraordinary general meeting (AGE) must authorise the capital reduction. In general terms, a company may cancel up to 10% of capital in any 24-month period. Where a company wants to buy a larger block, it can launch an offre publique de rachat d'actions (OPRA): a public offer to all shareholders at a fixed price, followed by cancellation. Creditors can oppose a capital reduction.
3
Harmony's legal reserve holds 1.0 against a ceiling of 1.25. With profit of 9.0 and 6.0 of retained earnings, distributable profit is…
The legal reserve allocation is missing.
That deducts the full 5% × 9.0 = 0.45.
Retained earnings brought forward count too.
Right. The allocation is only the 0.25 needed to reach the ceiling.
A French listed company may buy back shares up to…
The ceiling is 10% of capital.
The meeting must authorise it.
The cap protects creditors and minorities.
Right. Harmony: 1.25 million shares.
An individual under the 2026 French flat tax receives 300 of dividends. He keeps…
Dividends are taxed on receipt.
Right. 31.4% = 12.8% income tax + 18.6% social contributions.
That is a holding under the parent-subsidiary regime.
That uses the old 30% rate.
4Harmony's payout policy
Claire Dubois now combines the ideas. The policy has to be affordable in bad years, sensible for projects and clear for shareholders.
A small dividend, a leverage ceiling and a flexible buyback fit Harmony
Start from what the company can afford
Assume free cash flow to equity, after interest, capex and working capital, is 6.0 million. EBITDA is 21.0 million and net debt, once the second plant is paid for, is 15.0 million, so net debt over EBITDA is 15.0 / 21.0 = 0.71×. The board's ceiling is 1.5×, which allows net debt of 31.5 million and leaves headroom of 16.5 million.
4.1 Using all the headroom
Suppose Harmony used the full 16.5 million of headroom for a buyback. Next year EBITDA falls by 25%. Compute net debt over EBITDA, assuming net debt otherwise stays at 31.5 million. Say what this tells the board about the size of an ordinary dividend compared with a buyback.
EBITDA falls to 21.0 × 0.75 = 15.75 million. Net debt over EBITDA is 31.5 / 15.75 = 2.0×, well over the 1.5× ceiling. The buyback would also be too big for one programme: 16.5 million at 12.00 is 1.375 million shares, above the 10% cap of 1.25 million.
A buyback can be stopped in a bad year. A dividend sized to the headroom cannot. Keep the dividend small and let buybacks absorb the surplus.
4
Why does Harmony keep its ordinary dividend at 0.30 rather than paying out the full 16.5 million of headroom?
Distributable profit would allow more.
Right. With EBITDA down 25%, leverage would hit 2.0×.
It depends on who holds the shares.
Tax is not the main reason here.
The 3.75 million dividend is what share of Harmony's 6.0 million free cash flow to equity?
Right. A level Harmony can hold in a poor year.
2.25 is left for buybacks or projects.
That is the share of net income.
Check the division.
When should Harmony use the surplus for buybacks?
Buybacks are the flexible tool in all years.
EPS rises at almost any price.
Right. Projects first, buybacks below value.
Buying dear transfers value to sellers.
Summary and cheat sheet
Les formules du module
Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.
Croissance autofinancée
= × (1 − )
Quand un rachat relève-t-il le BPA ?
>
Relever le BPA ne crée pas de valeur : seul un prix inférieur à la valeur le fait.
Valeur par action après un rachat
= ( − ) / ()
Bénéfice distribuable (droit français)
= − +
| Idea | What to remember |
|---|---|
| Cost of retention | Retained earnings cost the cost of equity. Keep cash only for projects that beat it. |
| Marginal return | Judge the next euro invested, not the average ROE. |
| Internal growth | g = ROE × (1 − payout). Payout slows growth unless leverage or new shares fill the gap. |
| Dividend irrelevance | In a perfect market, the price drops by the dividend. Shareholders can create their own policy. |
| Frictions | Tax, agency, signalling and clienteles make payout matter. |
| Smoothing | Firms raise dividends slowly and cut them reluctantly. |
| Scrip dividend | Shares in place of cash at a discount. Keeps cash in, adds shares. |
| Buyback and EPS | EPS rises when earnings yield beats the after-tax cost of the cash used. |
| Buyback and value | Value per share rises only if shares are bought below true value. |
| French distributions | Distributable profit after the legal reserve, voted by the AGO. |
| French buybacks | AGO programme, 10% of capital, 18 months. Cancellation by AGE. OPRA for large blocks. |
| French tax | PFU 31.4% headline for individuals since 2026 (30% before). Parent-subsidiary regime about 1.25% for companies. |
The one-sentence version
Return cash when the company has no project that beats shareholders' required return, choose the form that keeps flexibility and suits the shareholders' tax position, and judge a buyback by the price paid against value, not by its effect on earnings per share.
Key terms
| Term | Plain-language meaning |
|---|---|
| Payout ratio | Dividends divided by net income. |
| Ex-dividend date | The first day a new buyer no longer receives the coming dividend, so the price falls by about its amount. |
| Scrip dividend | A choice between cash and new shares, usually at a discount. |
| Buyback | The company buys its own shares, then cancels them or keeps them as treasury shares. |
| Treasury shares | Own shares held by the company. They carry no vote or dividend. |
| Capital reduction | A legal cut in share capital, for example by cancelling bought-back shares. |
| OPRA | French public offer to buy back shares from all shareholders at a fixed price. |
| PFU | French flat tax on investment income, 31.4% headline since 2026. |
| Régime mère-fille | French rule that makes dividends received by a company with at least 5% of the payer almost tax-free. |
Going further
Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on payout policy and on the implementation of payout.
Miller and Modigliani (1961) — Dividend policy, growth, and the valuation of shares, Journal of Business.
Lintner (1956) — Distribution of incomes of corporations among dividends, retained earnings, and taxes, American Economic Review.
Jensen (1986) — Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers, American Economic Review.
Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.