Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Cycle de vie et opérations / Module 39

39Mergers and demergers

What happens when companies pay with shares, and when they split apart

Ce qui se passe quand on paie en actions, et quand une entreprise se scinde.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
11
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
9
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Compute an exchange ratio and the resulting ownership split.

  • Show who gains and who loses from a share deal, with and without synergies.

  • Explain why EPS accretion comes from a P/E gap and why it does not prove value creation.

  • Build a simple purchase price allocation and see what it does to reported EPS.

  • Distinguish merger from contribution of shares, and spin-off from split-off.

  • Judge whether a demerger removes a real discount or only costs money.

1A merger is a swap of ownership, priced by an exchange ratio

What changes hands, and how the ratio is fixed.

A share deal swaps ownership instead of moving cash

Sellers become co-owners, so risk and reward are shared

In a cash purchase, Harmony would pay Luma Drive's owners and keep all future gains and losses. In a share deal Luma Drive's owners hand over their Luma Drive shares and receive new Harmony shares. They now own a slice of everything, including Luma Drive. If the deal turns out well, they gain. If it disappoints, they lose with Harmony's old shareholders.

Two real attractions follow. No financing is needed, so a heavily indebted company can still buy. And in many tax systems the sellers pay no tax until they sell the new shares.

The exchange ratio is the price of the deal, expressed in shares

The exchange ratio says how many acquirer shares one target share receives. If Luma Drive's owners are offered 22.50 per Luma Drive share and Harmony's shares trade at 14.40, the ratio is 22.50 / 14.40 = 1.5625 Harmony shares per Luma Drive share. Luma Drive has 2.0 million shares, so Harmony issues 3.125 million new shares.

Exchange ratio = offer value per target share / acquirer share price

The offer of 22.50 is a 25% premium on Luma Drive's 18.00. The total price is 45.0 million, against 36.0 million of stand-alone value.

Relative weights come from comparing the two firms on several yardsticks

The ratio is first a negotiation about relative size

The relative weight of a company is its share of the combined whole. If Luma Drive's owners end up with 20% of the new Harmony, then 20% is Luma Drive's weight in the combined firm. New shares = weight / (1 − weight) × existing acquirer shares. With 20%, that is 0.20 / 0.80 × 12.5 = 3.125 million.

Each side argues for the yardstick that flatters it. Harmony points to market values and discounted cash flows. Luma Drive points to earnings and book equity. The table shows how far apart the answers are.

Yardstick Harmony Luma Drive Luma Drive's weight
Net income (€m) 9.0 3.0 25.0%
Book equity (€m) 100.0 30.0 23.1%
Market value (€m) 180.0 36.0 16.7%
Stand-alone DCF value (€m) 190.0 40.0 17.4%

Luma Drive's weight under four yardsticks. Book equity and DCF figures are illustrative.

The negotiated 20% sits inside the range. Earnings favour Luma Drive because its low P/E makes its profits cheap. Market value favours Harmony. No yardstick is correct: the deal is the point where both boards stop arguing.

1.1 A richer offer

Luma Drive's owners ask for 27.00 per Luma Drive share instead of 22.50. Compute the exchange ratio, the number of new Harmony shares, and Luma Drive's owners' share of the combined company. Then say what premium on 18.00 this represents.

Ratio = 27.00 / 14.40 = 1.875. New shares = 2.0 × 1.875 = 3.75 million. Combined shares = 16.25 million, so Luma Drive's owners hold 3.75 / 16.25 = 23.1%. The premium on 18.00 is 50%.

Marta runs a flower shop. Her cousin's firm has just 'merged' with a larger one and she is told he 'sold nothing and bought nothing'. Explain to Marta, in plain words, what her cousin and the other shareholders actually did, and why the number of new shares matters more than the headline price.

      Her cousin gave his shares in his old firm and received shares in the bigger one. He is still an owner, now of a larger company. What matters is the slice: the more new shares issued to the sellers, the less is left for the buyer's old owners. The headline price is just that slice valued at the day's share price.

      a slider for the offer price per Luma Drive share, from 18.00 to 36.00. It redraws the exchange ratio, the number of new shares, Luma Drive's ownership percentage and the four yardstick weights as horizontal markers. The learner discovers which offer prices fall between the 'market value' and 'earnings' weights and sees how quickly ownership rises with the premium.

      1

      1. Harmony trades at 14.40 and offers 22.50 per Luma Drive share. What is the exchange ratio?

      2. Why does the earnings yardstick give Luma Drive a larger weight than market value?

      3. What makes paying in shares attractive to an indebted buyer?

      2Who gains depends on the premium, and EPS is a poor guide

      Harmony's deal creates value only if the combination is worth more than the sum of the parts. The split of that value, and the EPS arithmetic, are then separate matters.

      In a pure share swap, one side's gain is the other side's loss

      Without synergies the combined value is the sum of the parts

      Assume investors value the merged company at 216.0 million, the sum of 180.0 and 36.0. With 15.625 million shares each is worth 216.0 / 15.625 = 13.82, 4.0% below Harmony's 14.40. Harmony's old shareholders hold 12.5 million shares worth 172.8 million, a loss of 7.2. Luma Drive's owners hold 3.125 million worth 43.2 million, a gain of 7.2 on their 36.0.

      The two figures are equal and opposite. The premium is a transfer of value, and the buyer's shareholders pay for it by sharing the combined company.

      Synergies are the only thing that can make both sides richer

      A synergy is value that exists only because the two firms are combined. Suppose Harmony and Luma Drive save 1.0 million a year after tax by buying battery cells together. At a 9% discount rate that is worth 1.0 / 0.09 = 11.1 million. Integration costs 1.1 million once. The net synergy is 10.0 million. Valuers often haircut such figures, because savings arrive late.

      The negotiating range is bounded by the two stand-alone positions

      At the lowest sensible deal Luma Drive's owners receive only the stand-alone value of 36.0, which at 14.40 is 2.5 million shares, a ratio of 1.25. At the highest, they receive 46.0, which is 3.194 million shares and a ratio of 1.597. Any ratio between 1.25 and 1.60 splits the 10.0 between the two groups.

      EPS accretion is arithmetic, not value

      The deal raises earnings per share whenever the buyer's P/E is higher than the price it pays

      Combined net income is 9.0 + 3.0 = 12.0 million, shared over 15.625 million shares. EPS becomes 0.768, up from 0.72: a gain of 6.7%. Harmony's shareholders have lost 7.2 million of value, yet EPS rose.

      The reason is the P/E gap. Harmony pays 45.0 million for 3.0 million of earnings, a P/E of 15. It pays with shares that the market values at 20 times earnings. Harmony gives up shares that carry one euro of earnings for every 20 euros of value, and receives one euro of earnings for every 15 euros it pays, so EPS must rise. This is accretion. If the bidder pays a P/E above its own, EPS falls: dilution.

      Accretion if P/E paid < acquirer's P/E (all-share deal, no synergies, no accounting adjustments)

      The 'magic chain' works only if the market stops looking

      Combined EPS of 0.768 at Harmony's old P/E of 20 would give a price of 15.36, up 6.7%. Some bidders count on this chain: buy cheap earnings, raise EPS, keep the P/E. But the blended P/E of the group is 216.0 / 12.0 = 18.0, not 20. If investors price the group on what it holds, the price is 13.82. A serial acquirer needs endless lower-P/E targets and investors who never adjust.

      2.1 A dearer target

      Luma Drive's owners instead demand 66.0 million, paid in Harmony shares at 14.40. Compute the new shares issued, the combined EPS and the accretion or dilution against 0.72. At what total price does the deal become EPS-neutral?

      New shares = 66.0 / 14.40 = 4.583 million. Total shares 17.083 million. EPS = 12.0 / 17.083 = 0.702, against 0.72: a dilution of 2.4%. The paid P/E is 22, above Harmony's 20. EPS is neutral at a P/E of 20, so a price of 20 × 3.0 = 60.0 million.

      A fixed ratio hands price risk to the sellers, a floating ratio to the buyer

      The ratio is agreed months before closing. With a fixed ratio, Luma Drive's owners always receive 3.125 million shares, so their value follows Harmony's price. If Harmony falls 10% to 12.96, the package is worth 3.125 × 12.96 = 40.5 million, not 45.0. With a floating ratio, Harmony promises 45.0 million of value and issues more shares if its price falls, which hurts its own owners. A collar fixes the ratio inside a price band and floats it outside.

      Jonas is a carpenter. A newspaper says: 'The merger will boost earnings per share by 7%'. His pension fund owns Harmony shares. Explain to him why the headline can be true while his fund is poorer, and what single question he should ask instead.

          EPS divides profit by the number of shares. The deal adds profit but also adds shares, and the buyer may have paid too much for the profit it bought. The pension fund is richer only if its shares are worth more afterwards. The question to ask is how much was paid compared with the value of what was bought, including synergies.

          a deal simulator with three sliders: offer premium, net synergy and the acquirer's P/E. Two gauges show EPS accretion and the change in value per old Harmony share. The learner discovers that EPS can be positive when value is negative, and finds the premium at which each gauge crosses zero.

          1. 2.2 A bidder with a P/E of 12 buys a target at a P/E of 18 in an all-share deal. Is EPS accreted or diluted, and why?

          2. 2.3 In the no-synergy case, why is Luma Drive's gain of 7.2 equal to Harmony's loss of 7.2?

          3. 2.4 Under a fixed exchange ratio, who bears the risk that the acquirer's price falls before closing?

          2

          1. With no synergies, Harmony's owners lose 7.2 million. Who gains it?

          2. When is an all-share deal accretive to EPS, with no synergies or accounting adjustments?

          3. Under a fixed exchange ratio, who bears the risk that the acquirer's price falls before closing?

          3Accounting and law shape how the deal looks and who survives

          Booking and legal structure change reported earnings, contracts and approvals.

          Accounting turns the premium into goodwill, and goodwill into an EPS cost

          The buyer records what it bought at fair value

          Under IFRS 3 every business combination is an acquisition: the buyer records the target at fair value. Simply adding the two sets of books is no longer allowed. The price is the fair value of the new shares on the acquisition date. If Harmony still trades at 14.40 that day, it is 3.125 million × 14.40 = 45.0 million. The buyer then values every identifiable asset and liability of the target, a step called purchase price allocation.

          Whatever price exceeds the fair value of the net identifiable assets is goodwill. It is not amortised under IFRS. It is tested for impairment at least once a year, and written down if the acquired business disappoints.

          This is why managers quote EPS 'before amortisation of acquired intangibles'. The cost is non-cash, but it records that part of the price bought assets that wear out.

          3.1 A heavier allocation

          Suppose the uplift to patents is 12.0 over 6 years and there is no land uplift. Keep the price at 45.0 and tax at 25%. Compute the goodwill, the after-tax amortisation, and the EPS against 0.72.

          Net identifiable assets = 30.0 + 12.0 − 3.0 = 39.0, so goodwill = 45.0 − 39.0 = 6.0. Amortisation is 12.0 / 6 = 2.0 a year, or 1.5 after tax. EPS = (12.0 − 1.5) / 15.625 = 0.672, a dilution of 6.7%.

          3

          1. Under IFRS 3, what is goodwill?

          2. Why might Harmony choose a contribution of shares rather than a merger by absorption?

          3. In a French fusion, what does the commissaire à la fusion do?

          4Demergers undo combinations that no longer pay

          A group is worth more than its parts only while it adds something. When it does not, splitting it up can release value.

          Splitting a group frees its parts from the group's discount

          Three forms of demerger differ in what shareholders hold afterwards

          • Spin-off: the parent distributes the shares of a subsidiary to its own shareholders in proportion to their holdings. They now hold both companies.

          • Split-off: shareholders may exchange parent shares for subsidiary shares. Some end up with only one of the two.

          • Split-up: the parent is divided into two or more new companies and disappears.

          The case for a demerger rests on a conglomerate discount

          A conglomerate discount is the gap between what a group is worth and the sum of what its units would be worth alone. Causes include capital sent to weak units, investors who cannot judge a mixed business, and head-office costs. A demerger gives each part its own management, peers and shareholders.

          4.1 Is separation worth it?

          A unit is worth 30.0 million on peer multiples, and the market prices it inside the group at a 10% discount. Separation costs 4.0 million. Compute the net gain or loss, and say how large the discount must be for the demerger to break even.

          Value inside the group is 30.0 × 0.90 = 27.0, so the gain is 3.0. After costs of 4.0 the net result is −1.0 million. Break-even needs a gain of 4.0, which is 4.0 / 30.0 = 13.3%.

          A demerger has limits and a long preparation

          A small spun-off company may be too small for index funds and analysts, so its shares can trade at a discount. Holders who do not want it may sell at once. Lenders will want to know who keeps the debt, since a demerger can move assets away from creditors. Loan documents often allow lenders to demand early repayment unless they agree. Preparation takes six months or more.

          Tax-neutral regimes make reorganisations possible

          Neutrality postpones tax and does not remove it. Tax falls due when assets or new shares are sold, so anti-abuse rules watch demergers followed by quick sales.

          Zoé is a primary school teacher who owns shares in a group of 'cycling and charging'. The group announces it will spin off its charging business. Explain what she receives, why the group says shareholders will be better off, and what has to be true for that claim to hold.

              She keeps her shares in the cycling group and also receives shares in the new charging company, in proportion to what she holds. The group says each part will be run and valued on its own. That holds only if the market was undervaluing the combined group and the cost of separation is smaller than the gain.

              a sum-of-the-parts calculator. The learner sets the size of the conglomerate discount and the separation cost, and watches the net gain turn from negative to positive. The learner discovers the break-even discount for each unit size and why small units need a large discount to justify the costs.

              1. 4.2 What is the difference between a spin-off and a split-off?

              2. 4.3 Name two reasons a spun-off small company may trade below its fair value.

              3. 4.4 What should a lender check before agreeing to a demerger of its borrower?

              4

              1. What is the difference between a spin-off and a split-off?

              2. A unit worth 24.0 alone is valued at 20.0 inside the group, and separation costs 1.5. What is the net gain if the discount closes?

              3. Why should a lender examine a planned demerger of its borrower?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              Les formules du module

              Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

              Parité d’échange

              = /

              Actions nouvelles à partir d’un poids

              = / (1 − w) ×

              Condition de relution du BPA

              <

              Opération tout en actions, sans synergie ni retraitement : le BPA passe de 0,72 à 0,768.

              Écart d’acquisition

              = −

              Idea What to remember
              Exchange ratio Offer per target share divided by the acquirer's share price.
              Relative weight Target's share of the combined firm. New shares = weight / (1 − weight) × acquirer shares.
              No synergies Gains of one side equal losses of the other. The premium is a transfer.
              Synergy Value that exists only through the combination. The premium decides who keeps it.
              Negotiation range From the target's stand-alone value to stand-alone value plus all net synergy.
              EPS accretion Occurs when P/E paid is below the acquirer's P/E. It is arithmetic, not value.
              Magic chain Works only if the market keeps paying the old P/E for a blended business.
              Fixed vs floating ratio Fixed leaves price risk with sellers. Floating leaves it with the buyer. A collar splits it.
              Purchase price allocation Price minus fair value of net identifiable assets is goodwill, tested not amortised.
              Merger vs contribution Merger absorbs the target. Contribution of shares keeps it alive as a subsidiary.
              Demerger Spin-off, split-off, split-up. Pays only if the discount removed exceeds the cost.

              The one-sentence version

              In a share deal, what matters is the slice of the combined company that the sellers receive, and EPS is only a by-product of the P/E gap.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              Exchange ratio Number of acquirer shares given for one target share.
              Accretion / dilution Rise or fall in the acquirer's EPS after a deal.
              Synergy Extra value that exists only when two firms are combined.
              Purchase price allocation Spreading the price over the target's assets at fair value.
              Goodwill Price paid above the fair value of the target's net identifiable assets.
              Collar Band around the acquirer's price within which the ratio is fixed.
              Spin-off Shares of a subsidiary distributed to the parent's shareholders.
              Conglomerate discount Gap between a group's value and the sum of its units' stand-alone values.
              Commissaire à la fusion French court-appointed auditor of a merger's exchange ratio.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on mergers and demergers.

              • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on mergers, acquisitions and corporate control.

              • IASB — IFRS 3 Business Combinations.

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.