Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Piloter la fonction finance / Module 42

42Working capital and treasury management

How a company runs its stock, customer credit, supplier credit and cash day to day

Gérer au quotidien stocks, crédit clients, crédit fournisseurs et trésorerie.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
13
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Convert days of working capital into euros and into a yearly financing cost.

  • Compute the annual interest rate hidden in a discount offer, in either direction.

  • Set a credit limit and explain what credit insurance and factoring do and do not change.

  • Build a rolling cash forecast and find the month when funding is needed.

  • Show how a cash pool cuts interest costs and name its legal limits.

  • Rank cash investments by liquidity, safety and yield, and describe the controls that stop payment fraud.

1Tied-up cash has a price, and every lever must beat it

Before any technique, the arithmetic of what tied-up cash costs and what a cash release is really worth.

A day of working capital is a fixed number of euros

Every day customers delay is money Harmony must fund

Harmony sells €120.0 million a year, so one day of sales is 120.0 / 365 = €0.329 million. Every day that customers pay earlier releases that amount once.

Releasing cash does not create value equal to the cash

A consultant who says that cutting €10 million of working capital creates €10 million of value is wrong. The cash released swaps against lower net debt, and the two are worth the same. Value comes from the interest saved, minus whatever was given up to get the cash: price cuts, lost sales, empty shelves.

Four levers, in descending order of quality

  • Remove waste: wrong invoices, unresolved disputes, dormant stock. It costs nothing and should come first.

  • Change the structure: shorter lead times, made-to-order, fewer product variants.

  • Trade margin for cash: discounts and tighter terms. Worth it only at the right price (next section).

  • Finance it off the balance sheet: factoring or reverse factoring. This moves the funding. It does not reduce the working capital.

A discount offer is a loan whose rate you can compute

Paying late means borrowing from the supplier at a stated rate

Suppose a supplier offers 2% off if Harmony pays on day 10 instead of day 40. Not taking the discount means borrowing €98 for 30 days and repaying €100. The cost over 30 days is 100 / 98 − 1 = 2.04%. A year holds 365 / 30 periods of that length, so the annual rate is 1.0204 raised to the power 365/30, minus 1.

Longer credit terms are a purchase of sales

Dealers generate 70% of Harmony's sales, €84.0 million. Dealers ask for 90 days instead of 60. Harmony would fund 84.0 × 30 / 365 = €6.90 million more receivables, costing 6.90 × 5.0% = €0.345 million a year.

sliders for days gained on receivables, inventory and payables, with a field for Harmony's cost of debt. The page shows euros released once and the yearly saving. A toggle then switches to "bought with a discount" and displays the implied annual rate. The learner discovers that a discount can wipe out the saving.

1.1 Is 1% worth taking?

A supplier offers Harmony 1% off if it pays on day 10 instead of day 40. Compute the implied annual rate and say whether Harmony, borrowing at 5.0%, should accept.

The cost of waiting 30 days is 1 / 0.99 − 1 = 1.01%. The annual rate is 1.0101 raised to 365/30, minus 1: 13.0%.

That is well above the 5.0% credit line, so Harmony should accept, provided it has the liquidity or a committed line to fund the early payment.

Nadia runs a plumbing firm and asks whether to give clients 2% off for paying in ten days instead of thirty. Explain to her, without the word annualised, how to tell whether this is cheap or expensive money, and what she should compare it with.

      If clients pay on day ten instead of day thirty, she gets her money 20 days sooner and gives up 2% for it. Twenty days fit into a year about eighteen times, so the 2% repeats that often: roughly 45% a year, far dearer than a bank loan.

      She should compare it with her overdraft rate.

      1

      1. Harmony's sales are 120.0. How much cash does one day of receivables represent?

      2. A supplier offers 2% off for paying on day 10 instead of day 40. Harmony borrows at 5.0%. What should it do?

      3. A consultant says cutting working capital by 10 million creates 10 million of value. What is wrong?

      2Each of the three components has its own lever

      Receivables, stock and payables are managed differently, by different people, with different tools.

      Receivables are controlled before the sale, not after the delay

      Most lateness comes from inside the company

      Customers pay late because they cannot pay, because a dispute is open, or because the invoice cannot be processed. The last two are Harmony's own doing: wrong prices, missing order numbers and unresolved complaints delay payment more often than insolvency does. Fix invoice quality first.

      A dunning process, meaning a fixed sequence of reminders, makes the rest routine: a check before the due date, a phone call just after, escalation to the sales director after a month, and a formal notice or collection agency after two.

      A risky customer can be worth serving, up to a limit

      Credit insurance is the usual protection. The insurer reimburses most of an unpaid invoice, in exchange for a premium and a deductible. It also monitors customers and helps with collection. Its weakness is that insurers cut or withdraw cover on a weak customer just when it matters. A company reporting under IFRS 9 provisions expected losses on receivables from day one.

      Inventory is controlled by forecasts and order sizes, not by cuts

      Stock exists because of lead times, batches and forecast errors

      Battery cells take about ten weeks to arrive, so Harmony holds stock against uncertainty. Cutting stock without touching the cause only creates empty shelves.

      One lever is order size. Ordering costs money (administration, delivery) and so does holding stock (financing, insurance, obsolescence). The economic order quantity balances the two.

      EOQ = √(2 × D × S / H) where D = yearly demand, S = cost per order, H = holding cost per unit per year

      The formula is a guide. Larger savings come from better forecasts, selling dormant stock such as old models early, and fewer product variants.

      Payables are a free loan only until the due date

      Pay on the agreed date, neither earlier nor later

      Paying early gives the supplier a free loan. Paying late harms small suppliers and, in France, breaks the law. Pay when goods are received and the invoice matches.

      Factoring and reverse factoring move the funding without changing the cycle

      In factoring, Harmony sells its invoices to a financial company that pays cash now. In reverse factoring, a bank pays Harmony's suppliers early on invoices Harmony has approved, and Harmony pays the bank at the normal due date. Suppliers get cheap cash because the bank prices Harmony's credit. The risk is a company stretching its terms so that bank funding hides outside reported debt. IFRS now requires disclosure of such schemes.

      a decision game in which the learner receives dealer orders with different margins and default risks. Sliders set the credit limit and switch credit insurance on or off. The learner discovers that break-even default risk equals the margin, and that limits matter because of the worst case.

      2.1 The new dealer

      Harmony takes a €200,000 order from a new dealer and grants a 10% discount. Variable costs are 55% of the list price. Find the break-even probability of default. How many fully paid orders does one default cancel?

      Price after discount: 180,000. Variable costs: 55% of 200,000 = 110,000. Contribution if paid: 70,000. Loss if unpaid: 110,000. Setting (1 − p) × 70 = p × 110 gives p = 70 / 180 = 38.9%, the contribution margin on the discounted price.

      One default cancels 110 / 70 = 1.57 paid orders. The discount has cut the break-even default rate from 45% to 38.9%.

      1. 2.2 A dealer pays 20 days late on 60-day terms. Name two possible causes that Harmony controls.

      2. 2.3 Why can credit insurance disappear on a weak customer just when it is needed?

      3. 2.4 Why does selling receivables to a factor not shorten the time customers take to pay?

      2

      1. A dealer order brings €45,000 if paid and loses €55,000 if not. What is the break-even probability of default?

      2. What does factoring change?

      3. Under the French LME, what is the maximum agreed payment term?

      3Treasury makes sure the cash is there on the day

      A company can be profitable and still run out of cash. The treasurer's tools are knowing the real balance and forecasting the low point.

      Three balances exist at once, and only one can be spent

      The bank's date, not the accountant's, decides when money is usable

      The accounting balance records items when they happen. The bank balance counts them from the value date, the day the bank treats the money as available. The treasurer's balance is what Harmony can actually spend, after allowing for value dates and for payments already committed.

      A dealer's cheque of €0.5 million deposited on Monday is in the accounts on Monday. If the bank gives it value on Wednesday, the money cannot be spent before then. In the past, treasurers earned or lost money on such delays. SEPA transfers, which arrive by the next business day, and instant payments, which settle in seconds at any hour, have almost removed the gap. The risk has moved: cash can now leave the account at once, so the balance must be watched in real time.

      A rolling forecast shows the low point before it arrives

      Forecast in short buckets and update every week

      Treasurers use several horizons: an annual budget, a rolling twelve-month forecast by month, a thirteen-week forecast by week and a daily forecast by value date. Forecasts are compared with outcomes, and the biggest errors are traced to their causes.

      A committed line is a contract: the bank must lend when asked, and charges a fee on the unused part. An uncommitted line is a courtesy that can be withdrawn. For cash that must be there, liquidity comes before price.

      a simulator with sliders for how many days dealers delay payment and how large the winter stock build is. A chart draws the cash line against the €4.0 million minimum, and the page shows the line draw needed. The learner discovers how sensitive the low point is to dealer delay.

      3.1 A worse March

      Use Harmony's table, but let the March net cash flow be −5.0 instead of −4.0. Recompute closing cash for February to June. What is the lowest month, and what draw keeps cash at or above €4.0 million?

      Closing cash: January 8.0, February 4.5, March −0.5, April 0.5, May 4.0, June 8.5. The lowest point is March at −0.5.

      To keep €4.0 million, Harmony needs a draw of 4.0 − (−0.5) = €4.5 million in March, which it can repay from May. Without it, the account would be overdrawn.

      Paul teaches history. He reads that Harmony made €7.5 million of profit and cannot see why its finance director spends hours on a cash forecast. Explain to him, in everyday words, why profit and the bank balance can move in opposite directions in the same quarter.

          Profit is counted when a bike is sold. Cash moves when someone pays. In winter Harmony pays for parts and wages long before dealers pay in spring, so cash goes down while the profit for the year is still on its way.

          3

          1. Which balance can Harmony actually spend?

          2. Harmony's cash falls to 0.5 in March against a 4.0 minimum. What does it arrange?

          3. Why is a committed line worth its fee?

          4Pooled group cash is cheaper, and surplus cash needs a safe home

          Once a company has several entities and spare cash, two questions arise: how to net the balances, and where to put the surplus.

          A cash pool lets the bank charge interest on the net balance

          Pooling stops one subsidiary lending at 2% while another borrows at 6%

          Each Harmony subsidiary has its own bank account. Some end the day in credit, others in overdraft. The bank pays a low rate on the credit balances and charges a high one on the overdrafts. Pooling nets them.

          In zero-balancing, every night the balances are swept to a master account, leaving each subsidiary at zero, and the transfers are recorded as intra-group loans. In notional pooling, no money moves and the bank calculates interest as if the balances were added together.

          Pools run into law, tax and incentives

          • Law: a subsidiary lending to a sister company must have a corporate interest in doing so. Minority shareholders and local rules can block it, and some countries restrict cross-border sweeps.

          • Tax: intra-group interest must be at arm's length, meaning the rate independent parties would agree.

          • Incentives: a healthy unit funds a weak one.

          Surplus cash must pass three tests, in order

          Liquidity first, safety second, yield last

          Harmony's surplus cash exists to pay bills, so the first test is whether it can be recovered when needed. The second is whether the full amount comes back. Only then comes the yield. Since 2022 deposits pay a positive return again, and the era when holding cash cost money is over.

          Instrument Access Main risk Typical use
          Term deposit Fixed date Bank failure Known needs
          Money-market fund Daily Small price moves Core buffer
          Treasury bill Daily market Price before maturity Safe reserve
          NEU CP of a sound issuer At maturity Issuer default Higher yield, short term

          Payments are where cash leaves, so controls matter most there

          Fraud works on people and procedures, not on bank systems

          In a transfer the payer starts the payment. In a direct debit the payee does. Cheques are fading. The commonest fraud is a convincing email: a fake chief executive asks for an urgent payment, or a supplier appears to announce new bank details. The defence is procedure.

          • Two people approve every payment above a set limit.

          • Any change of bank details is confirmed by a call to a number already on file.

          • The person who enters suppliers cannot also release payments.

          • Banks check that the payee name matches the account number for euro transfers.

          4.1 Pooling three accounts

          Harmony Deutschland holds +€2.4 million, Harmony Italia −€1.5 million and Harmony France +€0.3 million. The bank pays 2.0% and charges 6.0%. Compute the yearly saving from pooling, and name one legal precaution.

          Without a pool: (2.4 + 0.3) × 2.0% − 1.5 × 6.0% = 0.054 − 0.090 = −€0.036 million. With a pool, the net balance is +1.2, earning 0.024. The saving is €0.06 million.

          Precaution: each lending entity must have a documented corporate interest, with intra-group interest set at arm's length.

          1. 4.2 Why must interest inside a cash pool be set at arm's length?

          2. 4.3 A money fund offers 0.3 points more than another. Which two tests should Harmony apply before looking at yield?

          3. 4.4 Why is a call-back rule a better anti-fraud tool than a software upgrade alone?

          4

          1. In notional pooling, what happens?

          2. In what order should surplus cash be judged?

          3. Which control best defeats a fake change of supplier bank details?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Trésorerie par jour de ventes

          = / 365

          Cinq jours de créances : 1,64 libérés, 0,082 économisés par an à 5 %.

          Taux implicite d’une remise

          = (1 / (1 − ))^(365 / ) − 1

          Défaut d’équilibre

          = /

          Quantité économique de commande

          EOQ = √(2 × × / )

          400 packs par commande, 24 000 € de coût total par an.

          Idea What to remember
          Cash per day of sales Sales / 365. One day of change frees or absorbs that amount once.
          Value of a release Yearly financing saving, not the cash. Cash released and debt repaid are an even swap.
          Discount offer Implied annual rate = (1 / (1 − discount)) ^ (365 / days gained) − 1. Compare with the cost of debt.
          Credit terms Extra receivables × cost of debt = yearly cost. Divide by contribution margin for break-even extra sales.
          Break-even default rate Equals the contribution margin share of the price. Limits and insurance cover the worst case.
          Economic order quantity √(2DS / H). A guide: forecasts, dormant stock and range simplification matter more.
          Factoring Moves the funding, costs more than a credit line, does not shorten payment times.
          Value date The day the bank counts money as available. The spendable balance differs from the ledger.
          Rolling forecast Short buckets, updated weekly. Find the low point early and secure committed funding.
          Cash pooling Nets balances to save the deposit-overdraft spread. Limited by law, tax and incentives.
          Investing surplus Liquidity, then safety, then yield. Extra yield pays for extra risk.

          The one-sentence version

          Treat every euro in stock, customer credit and idle accounts as an investment that must beat the cost of debt, release it only where the price is right, and forecast and protect cash so that the right amount is in the right account on the day.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Working capital Cash tied up in stock and customer credit, net of supplier credit.
          Dunning A fixed sequence of reminders and escalations for unpaid invoices.
          Credit limit The most a company will be exposed to one customer.
          Contribution margin Price minus variable costs: what a sale adds towards fixed costs and profit.
          Economic order quantity The order size that minimises ordering plus holding costs.
          Reverse factoring A bank pays a company's suppliers early on invoices the company approved.
          Value date The day a bank treats money as usable.
          Committed line A credit line the bank must honour when drawn.
          Cash pooling Netting the balances of group accounts so that interest is charged on the net.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on working capital management and treasury management.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on working capital management and short-term financial planning.

          • AFTE (Association Française des Trésoriers d'Entreprise) — professional guides on treasury practice.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.