Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Au-delà du manuel / Module 47

47International corporate finance

How borders, currencies and tax change what a project and a subsidiary are worth

Comment frontières, devises et fiscalité changent la valeur d’un projet et d’une filiale.

Lecture
20 min
Sections
14
Exercices
4
Questions de rappel
9
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
3

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • Read an exchange rate and use inflation and interest differences to build expected and forward rates.

  • Value a foreign project by two routes and show that they give the same answer.

  • Place country risk in the discount rate or in the cash flows, and explain why not both.

  • Tell transaction, translation and economic exposure apart and match each to a response.

  • Explain how financing, trapped cash, transfer pricing and the global minimum tax change what a subsidiary is worth to its parent.

1Exchange rates follow two parities

Before valuing anything abroad, you need to know what an exchange rate is and which two relations tie it to inflation and interest. The rest of the module rests on them.

An exchange rate is a price, and two parities explain most of its logic

The quote tells you how many zloty one euro buys

EUR/PLN 4.30 means that one euro buys 4.30 zloty. The euro is the base currency. A higher number means a stronger euro and a weaker zloty. Turn it upside down and one zloty is worth 1 / 4.30 = 0.2326 euro. The spot rate is today's price. A forward rate is a price agreed today for an exchange on a later date.

Differences in inflation pull rates apart over the years

A bike should cost roughly the same wherever you buy it once prices are converted. If prices in Poland rise 4% a year and prices in the euro area rise 2%, the zloty has to lose about 2% a year, or Polish goods would become ever cheaper. This is purchasing power parity.

Expected spot in year t = Spot today × [(1 + inflation PLN) / (1 + inflation EUR)]ᵗ

With spot 4.30, the expected rate is 4.30 × 1.04 / 1.02 = 4.384 after one year and 4.738 after five. The idea works over years. Over a single year the rate can move by 10% for reasons that have nothing to do with prices.

Differences in interest rates fix the forward price, and the forward is not a forecast

Suppose a bank sells you zloty for delivery in a year. It can borrow euros today, swap them into zloty, deposit them at the zloty rate and hand you the zloty at maturity. If the forward price did not reflect the interest difference, this chain would give a free profit. So the forward must offset it. This is covered interest parity.

Forward = Spot × (1 + interest rate PLN) / (1 + interest rate EUR)

With risk-free rates of 5% in zloty and 3% in euro, the one-year forward is 4.30 × 1.05 / 1.03 = 4.3835. The zloty trades at a discount because it pays more interest. Nothing in this calculation says what the spot rate will be in a year.

Notice that the interest gap (5% against 3%) matches the inflation gap (4% against 2%). Lenders in each country ask for a real return, and money gets a higher nominal rate where prices rise faster. In this module the figures are built so that the two parities agree. In practice they only roughly do.

1.1 The dealer's invoice

A Polish dealer owes Harmony PLN 12.9 million in one year. At spot 4.30 this is worth 3.0 million euros. Harmony sells the amount forward today, using the rates above. How many euros does it lock in, and why is that less than 3.0 million?

The forward rate is 4.3835, so Harmony locks in 12.9 / 4.3835 = 2.94 million euros.

It is 0.06 million less than 3.0 because the zloty pays a higher interest rate. The forward discount is that interest advantage turned into a price.

Sofia runs a bakery in Lyon. She read that Polish banks pay 5% on savings against 3% at home, and she wants to move her savings there. Explain to her, without using the word parity, why the extra 2 points are not free money.

      Tell Sofia that the bank in Poland pays her in zloty. To spend the money at home she must convert it back, and the exchange rate for a year ahead is already worse by about the same 2 points. Unless the zloty happens to fall less than that, she ends up with no more than 3%, and with some risk.

      1. 1.3 EUR/PLN moves from 4.30 to 4.60. Which currency strengthened?

      2. 1.4 Which of the two, the forward rate or the inflation-based expected rate, is set by arbitrage and not by a forecast?

      3. 1.5 Euro-area inflation rises to 3% while Polish inflation stays at 4%. Does the expected yearly fall of the zloty get larger or smaller?

      1

      1. EUR/PLN is 4.30. Polish inflation is 4%, euro-area inflation 2%. What is the expected rate after one year?

      2. With rates of 5% in zloty and 3% in euro, the one-year forward is 4.3835. What does it tell you about the spot rate in a year?

      3. Sofia wants to move her savings to Poland to earn 5% instead of 3%. What should you tell her?

      2A foreign project is valued in one currency from end to end

      Harmony's plant is valued twice, by two methods that have to agree. Then comes the harder question of country risk.

      Route one: convert each year's cash flow into euros, then discount in euros

      The plant is an ordinary project written in another currency

      Route two: discount in zloty at the zloty rate, then convert once

      The zloty discount rate carries the extra inflation

      A zloty received in year 3 will buy less than a euro received then. A discount rate in zloty must therefore be higher than the euro rate by the expected inflation gap. The exact link is a product, not a sum.

      1 + k(PLN) = (1 + k(EUR)) × (1 + inflation PLN) / (1 + inflation EUR)

      Here k(PLN) = 1.10 × 1.04 / 1.02 − 1 = 12.16%. Discount the zloty flows at that rate and the NPV is PLN 6.76 million. Convert it once at today's spot: 6.76 / 4.30 = 1.57 million euros. The same answer, as it must be. The two routes describe one project and only the language differs.

      a calculator with the Harmony table. The learner picks the currency of the cash flows (PLN or EUR), the currency of the discount rate and the conversion rate (spot or expected). Only the two consistent combinations show 1.57; the mixed ones show 2.92 and a warning. The learner discovers that consistency, not the choice of route, is the rule.

      Country risk goes in the discount rate or in the cash flows, never in both

      Country risk is the extra danger of operating in a particular state

      It covers expropriation, capital controls, abrupt legal change and the weakness of the state itself. A common way to price it starts from the sovereign spread, the extra yield investors demand on a country's government bonds over a safe benchmark, and adds only part of it to the project rate, since a plant in Poland is exposed to far less than a government bond is. Harmony's one point is a judgement of this kind.

      The NPV is 2.19 million euros at 9% and 0.98 at 11%. Each point of premium costs about 0.6 million. A premium is therefore a decision worth debating, not a rounding.

      The alternative is to leave the rate alone and put the danger into the cash flows, for example a scenario in which the plant is shut for a year. Both routes are legitimate. Using both counts the same danger twice and rejects good projects.

      2.1 A tougher committee

      The investment committee finds Harmony's country-risk point too light and uses a euro rate of 12%, keeping the expected rates unchanged. Compute the NPV in euros. Does the plant still pass? What is the highest euro rate at which it passes, roughly?

      At 12% the NPV is +0.41 million euros. The plant still passes, narrowly.

      The NPV reaches zero at about 12.75%, the IRR in euros. The plant passes at any euro rate below that.

      Marc is a mechanic at the Lyon plant. He says: the Polish plant is the same project, so use the same 10% as in euros and the zloty figures as they are. Explain to him, with one number, why the zloty figures cannot be discounted at a euro rate.

          Tell Marc that in year 5 a zloty is worth 4.738 to the euro instead of 4.30, about 9% less. A 10% rate in zloty gives no credit for that loss, so it values the plant at 2.92 million euros instead of 1.57. The zloty rate has to be 12.16%.

          1. 2.3 Why is the zloty discount rate higher than the euro rate for the same project?

          2. 2.4 Polish inflation is forecast at 6% instead of 4% and the zloty cash flows are left unchanged. Does the euro NPV rise or fall?

          3. 2.5 Name the two places where country risk can be put, and the rule that connects them.

          2

          1. Harmony's plant: route one gives +1.57 million euros. What does route two give?

          2. Why is the zloty discount rate 12.16% rather than 10%?

          3. Each point of country premium costs Harmony about 0.6 million. Where should country risk go?

          3Currency exposure comes in three kinds

          The zloty can hurt Harmony in three different ways. Each one needs its own answer, and only two of them involve cash.

          Transaction exposure is a promise made in the wrong currency

          A receivable in zloty is worth a different number of euros every day

          Forwards, options and swaps are the tools. CF43 explains how to choose between them.

          Translation exposure changes reported equity and leaves cash alone

          Consolidating a foreign subsidiary means converting its balance sheet at the current rate

          The plant's net assets are PLN 86.0 million. At 4.30 they appear as 20.0 million euros in the group accounts. If the zloty falls to 4.60 they appear as 18.70 million. The 1.30 million difference goes to a reserve in equity and not to profit. No euro has left the company. CF7 explains the rules of translation.

          Economic exposure moves value, and a natural hedge is the cheapest answer

          Costs in one currency and sales in another set the real risk

          Suppose the plant sells frames to Lyon for 30 million euros a year and pays 90 million zloty of local costs. At 4.30 those costs are 20.93 million euros. If the zloty falls to 4.60 they are 19.57 million and the margin rises by 1.37 million. If it rises to 4.00 they are 22.50 million and the margin falls by 1.57 million. This is economic exposure: the effect of currency on future cash flows.

          The cure is to match. Selling part of the output to Polish dealers in zloty, buying components in zloty and borrowing in zloty all make costs and revenues move together. This is a natural hedge. It costs nothing and does not expire.

          3.1 The strong zloty

          Using the figures above, the zloty strengthens to 4.10 and Harmony has not hedged. By how much does the plant's yearly margin fall in euros? Which of the three exposures is this?

          Costs rise from 20.93 to 21.95 million euros, so the margin falls by 1.02 million. This is economic exposure.

          a slider for EUR/PLN from 3.80 to 5.00 that updates three panels together: the value of the PLN 8.6 million receivable, the euro value of the net assets, and the plant's yearly margin. A toggle switches the forward hedge and the zloty costs on and off. The learner sees that the receivable and the margin move cash while the net assets move only a reserve, and that a natural hedge flattens the margin.

          1. 3.2 Harmony pays Polish wages in zloty and sells every frame in euros. Which exposure does it face, and which way does a stronger zloty push it?

          2. 3.3 A forward costs nothing to enter. Why is it still not free?

          3. 3.4 The translation loss on the plant is 1.30 million euros. Has Harmony's cash fallen?

          3

          1. Harmony's PLN 86.0 million of net assets fall from 20.0 to 18.70 million euros when the zloty goes to 4.60. What kind of exposure is this?

          2. The plant sells 30 million euros to Lyon and pays PLN 90 million of costs. The zloty strengthens to 4.10. What happens?

          3. What is the cheapest answer to economic exposure?

          4Across borders, cash and tax decide what the plant is worth to its parent

          A subsidiary that earns money does not automatically enrich the group. Financing, borders and tax determine how much of it arrives.

          Borrow in the currency of the cash flows, and the cheap loan is not cheap

          A lower interest rate abroad is often just lower expected inflation

          Harmony can fund the plant with a zloty loan at 6.5% or a euro loan at 4.5%. The euro loan looks two points cheaper. If the zloty weakens at the expected 1.96% a year, repaying a zloty loan costs 1.065 × 1.02 / 1.04 − 1 = 4.45% in euros, almost exactly the same. The saving is an illusion, and the euro loan adds a risk: the plant earns zloty and would repay in euros.

          The default is therefore to borrow in the currency in which the project earns. CF33 covers the other design choices for debt.

          Trapped cash is profit that cannot be brought home at full value

          Between the plant's bank account and the parent's lies a tax border

          In a good year the plant earns PLN 21.5 million after tax, which is 5.0 million euros at 4.30. The shareholders only benefit from what reaches the parent. Dividends, intra-group loans, royalties and service fees are each taxed differently. Some countries limit how much cash may leave. Where a dividend tax of 10% applies, 0.5 million euros of the 5.0 stays behind. Within the EU, the Parent-Subsidiary Directive usually removes withholding tax on dividends between a qualifying parent and subsidiary, so for Harmony's Polish plant this leakage should be small. Outside the EU it can be real. Meanwhile the parent may be paying 5% on debt while cash sits idle in a subsidiary account.

          Transfer prices decide in which country a profit appears

          The price between two group companies moves profit across the border

          The plant sells frames to the Lyon factory. Its cost is 10.0 million euros. A markup of 8% gives a price of 10.8 and a profit in Poland of 0.8. A markup of 15% gives a price of 11.5 and a profit of 1.5. The extra 0.7 of profit is taxed in Poland at 19% instead of in France at 25%, so the group saves 0.7 × 6% = 0.04 million euros.

          Tax authorities check this with the arm's-length principle: the price must be the one two unrelated companies would agree. The right markup is what an independent assembler would earn, supported by comparable firms and a file of documents. A price outside that range invites an adjustment and double taxation of the same profit.

          4.1 The markup temptation

          Harmony raises the plant's markup from 8% to 15% on a cost of 10.0 million euros. Compute the extra Polish tax, the French tax saved and the net saving for the group. Then say why a saving this small may not justify the risk of an audit.

          Extra Polish tax is 0.7 × 19% = 0.133. French tax saved is 0.7 × 25% = 0.175. The net saving is 0.04 million euros.

          A saving of 40,000 euros is small against the cost of an adjustment, penalties and double taxation of the same 0.7 million if an authority rejects the price.

          The global minimum tax puts a floor under the game

          Pillar Two sets a 15% effective rate in every country for large groups

          The OECD's Pillar Two rules ask very large groups to pay at least 15% tax on the profit made in each country. If a subsidiary is taxed below that, a top-up tax brings it to 15%. A subsidiary with 10.0 million of profit taxed at 9% would trigger a top-up of 10.0 × 6% = 0.6 million. The rules also contain relief for real payroll and assets, ignored here.

          The rules apply to groups with consolidated revenue of 750 million euros or more. Velora, with sales of about 1.2 billion, is in scope. Harmony at 120 million is not. Poland's 19% headline rate is above the floor, so unless local incentives pulled the plant's effective rate below 15%, it would raise no top-up question even for a larger group.

          Nadia is a freelance designer. She says: a company can simply put its profits in the country with the lowest tax and pay almost nothing. Explain to her, using the markup example, the two limits that stand in the way.

              Tell Nadia that the price between the two group companies must be one that unrelated parties would agree, so profit cannot be moved at will. And for large groups a 15% minimum applies in every country, which wipes out most of the gain from a very low rate. A third limit is that profit has to reach shareholders as cash, with taxes along the way.

              a slider for the plant's markup from 0% to 30% that shows the tax paid in Poland, in France and in total. A shaded band marks the arm's-length range, and a switch adds a subsidiary in a 9% country for a group above the revenue threshold. The learner sees that the saving per point of markup is small, that it vanishes outside the band, and that the top-up cancels most of a low-tax location's advantage.

              4

              1. A zloty loan costs 6.5% and a euro loan 4.5%. If the zloty weakens at the expected 1.96% a year, what does the zloty loan cost in euros?

              2. Harmony raises the plant's markup from 8% to 15% on a cost of 10.0. Poland taxes at 19%, France at 25%. What does the group save?

              3. A subsidiary of a large group earns 10.0 million taxed at 9%. What does Pillar Two add?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              Les formules du module

              Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

              Cours attendu (parité des pouvoirs d’achat)

              = × [(1 + ) / (1 + )]ᵗ

              Cours à terme (parité couverte des taux)

              = × (1 + ) / (1 + )

              Un prix fixé par arbitrage, pas une prévision.

              Taux d’actualisation en zlotys

              = (1 + ) × (1 + π PLN) / (1 + π EUR)

              Les deux voies donnent la même VAN : +1,57 M€.

              Complément d’impôt minimum (Pilier 2)

              = × (15 % − )

              Pour les groupes d’au moins 750 M€ de chiffre d’affaires ; Harmony, à 120, n’est pas concernée.

              Idea What to remember
              Quote EUR/PLN 4.30 means one euro buys 4.30 zloty. Higher means a weaker zloty.
              Expected spot Spot × (1 + inflation PLN) / (1 + inflation EUR) per year. 4.30 becomes 4.384 after one year.
              Forward rate Spot × (1 + i PLN) / (1 + i EUR). Fixed by arbitrage. It is a price, not a forecast.
              Two valuation routes Convert at expected rates and discount in euros, or discount in zloty and convert once. Both give +1.57.
              Zloty discount rate (1 + k EUR) × (1 + inflation PLN) / (1 + inflation EUR) − 1 = 12.16%.
              Mixed currencies Zloty flows at a euro rate gives 2.92. It is wrong.
              Country risk In the rate or in the cash flows, never both. Each point costs Harmony about 0.6.
              Three exposures Transaction and economic exposure move cash. Translation moves reported equity only.
              Natural hedge Match the currency of costs, revenues and debt. It is free.
              Loan currency A cheap foreign-currency loan is cheap only if the currency does not weaken as expected.
              Trapped cash Value what reaches the parent after withholding tax and restrictions.
              Transfer pricing Arm's length. Profit shifting gains little and risks double taxation.

              The one-sentence version

              Value a foreign project in one currency from end to end, hedge only the exposures that matter, and count only the cash that reaches the parent after tax.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              Spot rate The exchange rate for an exchange today.
              Forward rate An exchange rate agreed today for an exchange on a later date.
              Purchasing power parity The idea that exchange rates move to offset differences in inflation.
              Covered interest parity The link between spot, forward and the two interest rates that leaves no free profit.
              Sovereign spread The extra yield on a country's government debt over a safe benchmark.
              Natural hedge Matching currencies of costs, revenues and debt so that risks cancel.
              Withholding tax Tax taken at source on a dividend, interest or royalty paid abroad.
              Transfer price The price charged between two companies of the same group.
              Arm's-length principle The rule that a transfer price must match what unrelated parties would agree.
              Pillar Two The OECD rules setting a 15% minimum effective tax rate for large groups.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on the cost of capital, the organisation of a group and risk management in the firm.

              • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on international financial management.

              • Eun and Resnick — International Financial Management (McGraw-Hill).

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.