Aller au contenu
Corporate & Investment Banking Mon parcours English

Accueil / Corporate Finance / Politique financière / Module 33

33Designing debt

How a company chooses the shape of its borrowing, not just the amount

Choisir la forme de sa dette, et pas seulement son montant.

Lecture
30 min
Sections
12
Exercices
3
Questions de rappel
6
Questions de QCM
12
Simulateurs
4

Le texte de ce module est encore en anglais : la version française arrive. Les outils interactifs, eux, sont déjà en français.

What you will be able to do

  • List the parameters of a loan and say which ones create risk and which ones create cost.

  • Build a maturity ladder, spot a liquidity wall and fix it.

  • Compare holding cash with a committed credit line, in euros per year.

  • Decide how much of a debt to fix, and explain why borrowing in the wrong currency is a bet and not a saving.

  • Read a covenant, compute its headroom and explain what happens at a breach.

  • Judge whether a refinancing or a sustainability-linked margin is worth its price.

1Debt is a bundle of choices

A loan is not only an amount and a rate. It has a lender, a life, a repayment profile, a ranking and a set of promises. Each choice moves risk between the company and its lenders.

Every loan is eight dials, and the rate is only one of them

Each dial decides who bears which risk

Lenders accept a low rate only when they are protected, or when they can walk away early. The company accepts a higher rate when it wants freedom. Designing debt means choosing where to sit on each dial.

  • Lender: bank, bond investors, or a private investor group. This decides who you negotiate with when things go wrong.

  • Maturity: the date the last euro is due. Longer is safer for the borrower.

  • Repayment profile: bullet (everything at the end) or amortising (paid in instalments).

  • Rate: fixed for the whole life, or floating, reset every few months on a market reference such as Euribor or SOFR, plus a fixed margin.

  • Currency: the currency in which you owe.

  • Ranking: whether you are paid before or after other creditors if the company fails.

  • Security: whether specific assets are pledged to the lender.

  • Covenants: promises the borrower makes during the life of the loan.

Harmony's present debt scores badly on three. The maturities are short, three-quarters of the debt floats, and the repayments bunch in two years. The rate, at 5.0% all in, looks fine. That is why rate alone is a poor guide.

Banks, bonds and private placements sell different things besides money

Size, speed and flexibility trade against each other

Bank loan Bond Private placement
Typical size Small to large Large, to be tradable Medium
Speed Weeks Weeks to months, plus rating and prospectus Months
Flexibility High: lender can be called and a waiver asked Low: many holders, hard to renegotiate Medium: few holders, a direct conversation
Maturity Short to medium Medium to very long Medium to long
Extras Relationship, cash management, advice Publicity, investor base Diversifies away from banks

A rule of thumb. Individual deals vary a great deal.

A bank lends while hoping to sell Harmony other services, so it may price the loan thinly. A bond gives long money without a bank in the middle but costs a rating, documents and fees, and a bond with thousands of holders cannot be easily amended. A private placement (in Germany a Schuldschein) sits between the two. The banker's view of these markets is in the DCM module and the Corporate Banking Financing modules.

At 40 million in total, Harmony is far too small for a public bond. Its realistic menu is bank loans plus a private placement, and it already uses both.

  1. 1.1 Name the eight dials of a loan and say which two matter most for avoiding a refinancing crisis.

  2. 1.2 Why can a bank loan with a covenant be riskier for the borrower than a bond with a slightly higher rate?

  3. 1.3 Why is a public bond not an option for Harmony today?

1

  1. Harmony's debt costs 5.0% all in. Why is that figure a poor guide to how risky the debt is?

  2. Which two dials matter most for avoiding a refinancing crisis?

  3. Why is a public bond not a realistic option for Harmony today?

2Time and liquidity: never be forced to refinance on a bad day

Most companies that fail on debt did not borrow too much. They borrowed too short, or held too little liquidity when the market closed. Maturity and liquidity are two halves of one policy.

Short debt looks cheap until the day it has to be refinanced

A liquidity wall is a year in which too much falls due at once

Plot the repayments year by year and you get a maturity ladder. A liquidity wall is a rung much higher than the company's cash generation. On that day Harmony must refinance, however the market looks, because it cannot repay from its own resources.

Match the life of the funding to the life of what it pays for

Plant and equipment last a decade or more. Funding them with debt that falls due in two years gives the lender a veto over the plant. The standard rule is maturity matching: long assets with long funding, seasonal working capital with short lines. A company should also stagger maturities so that no single year is large.

a drag-and-drop ladder. The learner moves bars of debt between years, sets annual cash generation as a line across the chart and sees any bar that rises above the line turn red. A cost meter adds the extra margin for longer maturities. The learner discovers that the cheapest ladder is almost always the one with a wall in it.

Liquidity is bought, and a committed credit line is the cheapest way to buy it

A revolving line is insurance paid in small premiums

A revolving credit facility (RCF) is a committed line the company can draw, repay and draw again during its life. Until drawn it costs only a commitment fee on the unused amount. The word committed matters: the bank must lend on demand if the conditions are met. An uncommitted line can be cancelled when you need it most.

Your uncle runs a restaurant and keeps the equivalent of three months of costs in a savings account while paying 6% on a bank loan. Explain to him, in everyday words, what an agreed overdraft limit could do for him, what it would cost, and one thing he must check in the small print before relying on it.

      Uncle with savings: an agreed overdraft is a promise from the bank to lend up to a limit. It costs a small fee on the unused part and lets him use the savings for something productive. He must check that the line is committed for a stated period, not cancellable at any moment.

      Neighbour with a mortgage: she chooses between certainty and a lower starting rate that could rise. She should ask what her budget can bear if payments rise, not which rate the bank expects.

      2.1 Another company's ladder

      A company owes 30 million, repaid as 12 in year 1, 10 in year 2 and 8 in year 3. Its yearly cash generation after interest is 2 million. Compute the average life. Then propose a three-piece structure with a longer average life and no repayment above 6 in the first five years, and give its average life.

      Average life = (12 × 1 + 10 × 2 + 8 × 3) / 30 = 56 / 30 = 1.9 years.

      One structure: a loan of 12 amortising 2.4 a year over five years (average life 3.0), 10 repaid in year 6, and 8 repaid in year 7. No year in the first five exceeds 2.4. Average life = (12 × 3 + 10 × 6 + 8 × 7) / 30 = 152 / 30 = 5.1 years. Other solutions are possible. The test is that the largest repayment is small beside cash generation and the average life is longer.

      2

      1. Harmony's ladder reads 4.0, 4.0, 14.0, 14.0 and 4.0. What is its average life?

      2. Holding a reserve of 10.0 as borrowed cash costs 0.2 a year. What does the same reserve cost as the undrawn part of a committed line with a 0.5% fee?

      3. Claire extends the line to N+6 and replaces the notes by a new placement due in N+7. What does this insurance cost?

      3Rate, currency, ranking and covenants: what lenders ask for and what you give

      Once the timetable is set, three further choices decide how the debt behaves when the world moves: how its rate resets, what currency it is in, and what rules the lender imposes.

      Fixing the rate buys certainty, not savings

      Floating debt moves the profit and loss account, fixed debt moves the value of the debt

      With floating debt, a rise in the reference rate raises next quarter's interest bill. With fixed debt the bill is stable, but if market rates fall the company keeps paying the old, higher rate. Neither choice is better on average. The question is which risk the company can bear.

      In practice a company seldom needs to change its loans. It adds an interest-rate swap, a contract in which it pays a fixed rate and receives the floating one, which turns floating debt into fixed. CF43 explains swaps. Here we use them as a switch.

      A simple policy fixes enough to keep cover comfortable in a bad case, not enough to lose all benefit if rates fall. Half to three-quarters is a common range for a company with stable margins. A business whose prices follow inflation can tolerate more floating debt, because its revenues rise when rates do.

      a slider for the share of debt that is fixed (0% to 100%) and a slider for the change in the reference rate (−2 to +3 points). The page shows interest cost, interest cover and net income. The learner discovers that a fixed share between the two extremes limits the worst case without giving up all the gain.

      Borrow in the currency in which you earn

      A loan in a currency with lower interest rates looks cheaper. The saving is the premium for a risk: the currency may rise. Harmony sells almost entirely in euros. Borrowing 10.0 million-equivalent in dollars at 4.0% instead of euros at 5.0% saves 10.0 × 1.0% = 0.1 million a year.

      If the dollar then rises 10% against the euro, the debt is worth 1.0 million more in euros. That wipes out ten years of savings in a single move. Unless the company earns the foreign currency, foreign borrowing is a bet on the exchange rate.

      Ranking, security and covenants decide who is in control when things go wrong

      Lenders ask for priority, collateral or promises, and each one shifts risk

      Senior debt is paid first. Subordinated debt is paid after it and is therefore dearer. Debt that ranks equally with other debt is pari passu. Secured debt has specific assets, such as property or receivables, set aside for its holder. The more security one lender takes, the less is left for the others, so a negative pledge forbids pledging assets to new lenders without consent.

      Debt can also be subordinated by structure. A lender to a parent company is paid only after the lenders to its subsidiaries have been paid out of the subsidiaries' assets. This is structural subordination, covered in CF36.

      Covenants are the promises. Financial covenants set a limit on a ratio, for example net debt over EBITDA, tested every half-year. Others restrict dividends, asset sales or new debt, and a change of control clause lets the lender demand repayment if the owners change. A cross-default clause says that a default on any other debt triggers a default here, so one problem becomes all problems.

      At a breach the lender may demand repayment, raise the margin or ask for a fee. Usually it grants a waiver and charges for it. Companies negotiate a margin grid, in which the margin rises as leverage rises, so that a weaker year costs money before it triggers a default. They also negotiate to keep covenants few, tested on simple measures and set with wide headroom against their own forecast.

      a covenant gauge. The learner chooses a covenant level (2.5× to 4.0×) and an EBITDA shock, and sees leverage move toward the red zone with the headroom in percent. A second toggle adds the 15.0 acquisition loan. The learner discovers that headroom is set at signing but consumed by later decisions.

      3.1 A partial hedge

      Suppose Claire swaps only 5.0, so 25.0 of Harmony's 40.0 floats. Ignore the swap's cost. The base rate rises by two points. Compute the extra interest, the new total interest (starting from 2.0) and EBITDA over interest.

      Floating debt of 25.0 pays 25.0 × 2% = 0.5 more. New interest is 2.0 + 0.5 = 2.5, and EBITDA over interest is 18.0 / 2.5 = 7.2×. Compare with 7.8× when a one-point rise hits the unhedged 30.0: twice the rise costs only a little more cover.

      Your neighbour is about to sign a mortgage and the bank offers a fixed rate at 4.2% or a floating one at 3.6%. Explain to her, without the word swap, what she is really choosing between, and what she should ask herself about her own budget.

          Uncle with savings: an agreed overdraft is a promise from the bank to lend up to a limit. It costs a small fee on the unused part and lets him use the savings for something productive. He must check that the line is committed for a stated period, not cancellable at any moment.

          Neighbour with a mortgage: she chooses between certainty and a lower starting rate that could rise. She should ask what her budget can bear if payments rise, not which rate the bank expects.

          1. 3.2 Why is borrowing in a low-rate currency not a saving for a company with euro revenues?

          2. 3.3 A covenant allows leverage of 3.0× and the company stands at 2.8×. Is the covenant a risk even if the company is profitable?

          3. 3.4 What does a cross-default clause do, and why does it concern the treasurer even when a loan is perfectly healthy?

          3

          1. Harmony swaps 20.0 of its 30.0 floating debt into fixed. The base rate then rises by one point. What happens to interest?

          2. Net debt 30.0, EBITDA 18.0, leverage covenant 3.0×. Harmony then borrows 15.0 for an acquisition that adds no EBITDA at first. What happens to headroom?

          3. What does a cross-default clause do?

          4Relationships, renegotiation and documents

          A debt structure is a living contract. It depends on the lenders behind it, it can be reopened, and its documents decide who can do what on the worst day.

          Few banks give a relationship, many banks give safety, so aim for a handful

          Diversify lenders, but do not scatter them

          A single bank can withdraw the whole funding on its own decision, because of its own capital rules or a change of strategy. A dozen banks mean no one knows the company well. Most mid-sized groups settle for a core of three to six banks, with a private placement or a bond as a different source on top.

          Documentation is where the risk is written down

          A loan agreement is long because it lists what happens in every bad case. In Europe, many syndicated loans follow standard forms from the Loan Market Association (LMA), which speeds negotiation. Four clauses repay the reading: events of default, covenants, the definition of EBITDA used in ratios, and the right to transfer the loan to other lenders. A wide definition of EBITDA, for example, can add real headroom.

          Reopening a debt is worth it only when the saving beats the exit price

          Prepayment, tender and exchange are three ways out of an old debt

          A bank loan can usually be prepaid, often for a fee. A bond has fixed holders, so an issuer may tender (offer to buy back at a price), exchange old bonds for new ones, or ask holders to vote on an amendment, which is a consent solicitation. Some bonds carry a make-whole clause: the issuer may repay early at the present value of the remaining payments, discounted at a low benchmark rate, so the holder loses nothing by being repaid early.

          4.1 Is a 2% fee too high?

          Take the same loan and the same saving, but a prepayment fee of 2.0% and a discount rate of 5.0%. Compute the net gain and say whether to refinance. Then say what else the treasurer should check that is not in the arithmetic.

          The saving is worth 0.05 × 3.546 = 0.177. The fee is 10.0 × 2.0% = 0.20. Net gain = 0.177 − 0.20 = −0.023 million: do not refinance.

          Beyond the arithmetic, check whether the new loan has a shorter maturity, tighter covenants or a fee for early exit of its own, and whether the rate saving rests on a margin grid that could rise.

          Sustainability-linked terms attach a small price tag to a promise

          The margin moves with a target, but the price is small, so the credibility of the target matters more

          A sustainability-linked loan adjusts its margin depending on whether the borrower meets agreed targets, for example cutting carbon emitted per bike assembled. It differs from a green loan, whose proceeds must fund specific green projects. Market guidelines ask for targets that are ambitious, measured, and checked by an outside party. CF45 covers the wider topic.

          Suppose the margin on Harmony's 30.0 of drawn bank debt moves by 0.05 percentage points up or down. That is 30.0 × 0.05% = 0.015 million a year. The gain lies elsewhere: the promise has to be kept in public, and a missed target has a reputational cost.

          a decision game. The learner is Claire and chooses, for each of the eight dials, an option from a menu, with a running dashboard showing cost, average life, liquidity, interest cover and covenant headroom. Four market scenarios (calm, rates up, sales down 15%, credit market closed) are then applied. The learner discovers that no structure wins in all four, and that the best one loses little in any.

          4

          1. Refinancing 10.0 of notes saves 0.5 point a year for four years. At 5%, the saving is worth 0.177 today. Should Harmony pay a 2.0% prepayment fee?

          2. Why do most mid-sized groups keep a core of three to six banks?

          3. A sustainability-linked margin moves by 0.05 point on Harmony's 30.0 of bank debt. What is it mainly about?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          Les formules du module

          Touchez un terme pour voir ce qu’il veut dire et sa valeur chez Harmony.

          Vie moyenne de la dette

          = Σ ( × t) /

          Plan de Claire : (20 × 3 + 10 × 6 + 10 × 7) / 40 = 4,75 ans.

          Marge de manœuvre sur un covenant de levier

          = 1 − ( / ) /

          Avec le prêt d’acquisition de 15,0 : 1 − 15,0 / 18,0 = 17 %.

          Coût d’une réserve de liquidité

          = ×

          Gain d’un refinancement

          = × −

          Frais d’équilibre : 0,177 / 10,0 = 1,8 %.

          Idea What to remember
          Eight dials Lender, maturity, repayment profile, rate, currency, ranking, security, covenants. Rate is the least informative.
          Worst-year test Judge a debt structure by its cost in a bad year, not an average one.
          Average life Weighted average of repayment dates. Harmony: 3.25 years before, 4.75 after.
          Liquidity wall A year in which repayments far exceed cash generation. Flatten it before the market closes.
          Committed line An RCF costs only a commitment fee until drawn: 0.05 against 0.2 for the same reserve held in cash.
          Fixing the rate Buys certainty, not savings. Set a range, never follow a forecast.
          Currency Borrow where you earn. A lower foreign rate is a premium for exchange-rate risk.
          Ranking and security Senior is paid first, secured has assets set aside. A negative pledge protects other lenders.
          Covenant headroom The fall in EBITDA before a test is breached: 44% for Harmony, 17% after a 15.0 acquisition loan.
          Bank relationships A core of three to six banks, plus a different source on top.
          Refinancing Go only if the present value of the saving exceeds the fee. Harmony's break-even fee is about 1.8%.
          Sustainability-linked The margin step is small, so the target's credibility is the point.

          The one-sentence version

          Design debt so that it can be repaid from the company's own cash, priced in a way that suits its earnings and currency, with a committed line behind it and covenants that leave room for the plan.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Maturity The date when a loan must be fully repaid.
          Amortising loan A loan repaid in instalments over its life, not all at the end.
          Revolving credit facility A committed line the company can draw, repay and draw again, paying a fee on the unused part.
          Covenant A promise in a loan agreement, such as keeping leverage below a limit.
          Headroom How far a ratio can move before a covenant is breached.
          Negative pledge A promise not to give security over assets to other lenders.
          Make-whole An early-repayment price equal to the present value of a bond's remaining payments, discounted at a low benchmark rate.
          Cross-default A clause under which a default on other debt is a default on this one.
          Masse In France, the legal group formed by holders of one bond issue.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on implementing debt policy.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on how corporations issue securities and on short-term financial planning.

          • Loan Market Association — recommended forms of facility agreement, and the Sustainability Linked Loan Principles (LMA, APLMA, LSTA).

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.