Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial analysis / Module 12

12Financing, liquidity and solvency

How to tell whether a company can carry its debt, and whether it can pay on the day

How to tell whether a company can carry its debt, and whether it can pay on the day.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
13
Exercises
3
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Read a cash flow statement as the story of how growth was financed.

  • Compute and interpret leverage, interest cover, FFO and FCF to debt, and DSCR, and say what each hides.

  • Separate solvency from liquidity and build a maturity table that shows a refinancing wall.

  • Measure how floating rates and covenants expose a company to a change in rates or earnings.

  • Run a simple stress test and name the real weak point.

1How the company has been financing itself

Before judging whether debt is safe, find out where the cash came from and where it went. The cash flow statement, read as a story, shows whether growth is paying for itself.

The cash flow statement tells the story in five lines

Start from what operations produce, then subtract what the business must reinvest

A company's year follows a sequence. Operations generate cash. Part of it is reinvested in working capital and equipment. What is left is free cash flow, available to pay lenders first and shareholders second.

If free cash flow is large, interest and dividends are covered. If it is small or negative, the gap is filled by borrowing, issuing shares or selling assets. Which one was used tells you more than any ratio.

Growth uses cash before it produces cash

A faster-growing company needs more working capital and more equipment, immediately

Every extra euro of sales ties up stock and customer credit before cash comes in, and every extra bike needs capacity. So growth consumes cash first. A profitable firm that grows too fast can run out of money while its income statement looks excellent. This is called overtrading.

Give Harmony simple rules for next year. EBITDA is 15% of sales. Working capital is 20% of the increase in sales. Capex is 6.0 plus 20% of the increase in sales. Depreciation stays at 6.0, interest at 2.0, tax at 25% of profit before tax. The rules reproduce year N exactly.

Two spirals: one lifts the company, one sinks it

In a virtuous spiral, operating cash flow covers investment and interest, net debt falls, lenders grow generous and borrowing gets cheaper. Harmony at 0% or 12.5% growth is on this path.

In a vicious spiral, interest eats the operating cash flow, the company borrows to pay interest, and debt rises faster than earnings. Take a heavily indebted bike maker: EBITDA 6.0, working capital up 1.0, maintenance capex 3.0, net debt 50.0 at 6% so interest 3.0, no tax because of losses. Free cash flow after interest is 6.0 − 1.0 − 3.0 − 3.0 = −1.0. Net debt rises to 51.0, or 8.5× EBITDA, and next year's interest is higher.

When free cash flow falls short, there are three ways to fill the gap

Borrow, which is fast and cheap while credit lasts but adds fixed payments (CF18, CF33). Issue shares, which is slower and costlier but adds a cushion with no due date (CF32). Or cut the payout or sell assets, which is cheapest in risk terms but only works if there is a dividend or a business to sell (CF31).

1.1 A middle speed for Harmony

Using the same rules, compute Harmony's year N+1 if sales grow 10%. Give EBITDA, tax, working-capital increase, capex, free cash flow after interest, year-end net debt and net debt / EBITDA.

Sales: 132.0. EBITDA: 15% × 132.0 = 19.80. Tax: 25% × (19.80 − 6.0 − 2.0) = 2.95. Working capital: 20% × 12.0 = 2.40. Capex: 6.0 + 20% × 12.0 = 8.40.

Free cash flow after interest: 19.80 − 2.95 − 2.40 − 8.40 − 2.0 = 4.05. Net debt: 30.0 − 4.05 = 25.95. Net debt / EBITDA: 25.95 / 19.80 = 1.31×, between the 0% and 12.5% cases, as it should be.

Your uncle Karim runs a restaurant. His profit rose 20% this year, yet his bank balance fell. Explain to him, in everyday language, three places the profit could have gone without reaching his account.

      Karim: profit is not cash. It can sit in more stock and supplies, in customers on credit, or in equipment bought for cash, which is an outflow but not a one-year cost. Loan repayments are another: they are not an expense either.

      Maryse: solvent means what she owns exceeds what she owes. Liquid means money is in the bank when wages and invoices are due. The van does not pay payroll, and a customer paying 60 days late can leave a solvent firm short for a week.

      Harmony's year N+1 as a simulator with sliders for sales growth (0% to 30%) and working-capital days. Bars show operating cash flow, capex, interest and cash left. The learner finds where free cash flow after interest turns negative (just above 20%) and sees leverage keep falling beyond it.

      1

      1. In year N Harmony's free cash flow before financing was 3.5 and net interest 2.0, with no dividend. Net debt…

      2. At 25% growth Harmony burns 1.13 of cash in N+1, yet net debt / EBITDA falls from 1.67× to 1.38×. Why?

      3. A heavily indebted maker has EBITDA of 6.0, working capital up 1.0, maintenance capex 3.0 and interest of 3.0 on 50.0. What happens?

      2Solvency: can the cash flows carry the debt?

      Solvency is a long-term question. The tools are ratios that compare the debt with the earnings or cash flows available to repay it, and with the interest it costs.

      Six ratios, each answering a slightly different question

      Net debt is compared with earnings, with cash flow and with equity

      Net debt is gross debt minus cash (CF5). Divide it by a measure of earning power and you get a rough count of years. Divide the cost of the debt into earnings and you see the cushion. Each ratio catches a different weakness.

      Ratio Formula Harmony How to read it
      Leverage Net debt / EBITDA 30.0 / 18.0 = 1.67× Years of EBITDA the debt represents. The most quoted ratio, and the one covenants use.
      Interest cover EBITDA / net interest 18.0 / 2.0 = 9.0× How many times interest is earned. The stricter version uses EBIT (12.0 / 2.0 = 6.0×).
      Gearing Net debt / equity 30.0 / 54.0 = 56% Debt against book equity. A cushion measure, not a cash measure.
      Cash flow to debt FFO / net debt 13.5 / 30.0 = 45% FFO (funds from operations) is EBITDA minus tax paid minus interest.
      FCF to debt Free cash flow / net debt 3.5 / 30.0 = 11.7% Share of the debt free cash flow could repay in a year, after growth capex.

      Harmony's solvency ratios, year N. Tax paid is 2.5.

      Practitioners treat net debt / EBITDA below roughly 2× as comfortable for an industrial company, and 3× to 4× as where lenders tighten terms. Buyouts go well above that (CF40). These bands are habits, not laws. They move with rates, with the stability of cash flows and with what the assets would fetch if sold.

      The definitions decide the answer

      Two companies with the same ratio can be in different positions

      Both sides of a ratio are open to choice. Does net debt include leases, pension deficits, factoring or hybrids (CF8)? Is EBITDA reported or adjusted for add-backs? A loan agreement fixes one definition and a rating agency uses another. Compare only on the same basis.

      The debt service cover ratio asks the lender's question directly

      Leverage looks at a stock of debt. Lenders also care about the flow: what must be paid this year, interest and scheduled repayment together. The debt service cover ratio (DSCR) divides cash available for debt service by that sum.

      DSCR = (EBITDA − tax paid − working capital increase − maintenance capex) / (interest + scheduled repayment)

      Growth capex is left out because management can pause it. Harmony's cash available is 18.0 − 2.5 − 3.0 − 6.0 = 6.5. Debt service next year is 2.0 of interest plus 4.0 of scheduled repayment, so 6.0. The DSCR is 6.5 / 6.0 = 1.08×. Around 1 means almost nothing left over. Lenders often want a margin above 1.2× to 1.3×.

      2.1 Borrowing to buy earnings

      Harmony borrows 6.0 million at 5% to buy a small business with EBITDA of 1.0 million and no debt. Compute the new net debt / EBITDA and the new EBITDA / net interest. Does the deal make Harmony look more or less safe?

      Net debt becomes 36.0 and EBITDA 19.0, so leverage is 1.89×. Interest rises by 0.3 to 2.3, so cover is 19.0 / 2.3 = 8.26×. Both are slightly worse and still comfortable. Six times EBITDA is a cheap price, which limits the damage.

      1. 2.2 Why is interest cover on EBIT lower than on EBITDA, and which would a lender of long-lived equipment prefer?

      2. 2.3 A company shows net debt / EBITDA of 1.0× and a DSCR of 0.7×. Say in one sentence what is happening.

      3. 2.4 Two companies both show 2.5×. One leases its trucks, the other owns them. What must you check before calling them equally indebted?

      2

      1. Why is net debt / EBITDA of 1.67× not the number of years Harmony needs to repay its debt?

      2. Harmony's DSCR is 6.5 / 6.0 = 1.08×. What is left out of the cash available, and why?

      3. Restated under IFRS 16, Harmony's leverage rises from 1.67× to 1.93×. What changed in its cash?

      3Liquidity: can it pay on the day?

      Solvency can be fine while liquidity fails. The questions are about timing: when do payments fall due, how will they be met, and what happens if the money to refinance is not there.

      A company can be solvent and still run out of cash

      Solvency compares value with debt, liquidity compares cash with dates

      A company is solvent if what it owns, valued for its earning power, exceeds what it owes. It is liquid if it can pay each bill when due. A firm whose factory is worth far more than its loan is solvent, but if the loan falls due next month and no bank renews it, the firm is illiquid.

      Balance sheet liquidity ratios look at the next twelve months only

      Three classic ratios compare what can be turned into cash with what is due within a year. At Harmony, current assets are inventories 30.0, receivables 20.0 and cash 10.0, or 60.0. Current liabilities are payables 26.0 and 4.0 of debt due within a year, or 30.0.

      • Current ratio = current assets / current liabilities = 60.0 / 30.0 = 2.0×.

      • Quick ratio = (current assets minus inventories) / current liabilities = 30.0 / 30.0 = 1.0×. Inventories are slower to turn into cash, so they are left out.

      • Cash ratio = cash / current liabilities = 10.0 / 30.0 = 0.33×. The strictest test.

      All three are blind to what happens after the first year. A current ratio of 2.0 can sit beside a huge repayment in year two or three. For that you need a maturity table.

      The maturity table shows where the wall is

      List every repayment by year, then compare it with what the business will generate

      A maturity table sets out how much debt falls due each year. A refinancing wall is a year in which a very large amount falls due at once. The company must repay from cash or borrow again, and borrowing depends on lenders being willing at that moment.

      Undrawn lines count as liquidity, but only partly. Harmony's undrawn 10.0 is real money today, but the line expires in N+3, and drawing it needs the bank to accept that the covenants are met. A line that vanishes when you need it is not a safety net. Financing a twenty-year plant with a three-year facility is transformation risk: spread maturities and refinance early (CF33).

      3.1 Closing the gap

      Banque du Rhône agrees to extend the 10.0 drawn on the RCF for three more years. What is year-end cash at N+4 and N+5? Is the problem solved?

      Extending the 10.0 removes it from N+4. Year-end cash at N+4 is −8.0 + 10.0 = 2.0 and at N+5 it is −7.5 + 10.0 = 2.5. Cash stays positive but thin, and the extension itself falls due three years later. The wall has been moved, not removed.

      Rates and currencies change the cost and the size of the debt

      Floating-rate debt makes interest cover depend on the rate cycle

      A floating-rate loan pays a reference rate such as Euribor plus a margin, so interest moves with the market. In 2020 and 2021 euro rates were near zero or negative and floating debt looked free. Since 2022 rates are positive again, and the bill matters.

      Of Harmony's debt, 30.0 is floating (term loan and RCF) and 10.0 fixed (the notes). A rise of two points adds 30.0 × 2% = 0.6 of interest. Net interest goes from 2.0 to 2.6 and EBITDA cover falls from 9.0× to 6.9×, EBIT cover from 6.0× to 4.6×. Nothing in the business changed, yet it is more fragile. Hedging is covered in CF43. Interest on cash would offset part of the rise, so this stress is slightly harsh.

      Foreign-currency debt adds a risk the business does not offset

      A dollar loan can look cheaper, but Harmony sells in euros. USD 10 million borrowed at 1.10 dollars per euro is €9.09 million. If the dollar rose to parity it would be €10.0 million, a loss of €0.91 million with no matching gain in the business (CF43, CF47).

      Your neighbour Maryse runs a plumbing firm. She says: we own the van and workshop outright and owe the bank only 20,000, so we are safe. In March she nearly missed payroll. Explain solvent versus liquid using her example.

          a maturity-ladder game. Repayments appear as bars by year with a cash line. Buttons let the learner extend the RCF, refinance the notes early or fix part of the floating debt, each with a cost. They discover that moving the wall is cheap two years ahead and expensive in the year it falls due.

          3

          1. Harmony's current ratio is 2.0×. What can it not tell you?

          2. Banque du Rhône extends the 10.0 drawn on the RCF for three years. Year-end cash in N+4 becomes…

          3. Harmony borrows USD 10 million at 1.10 dollars per euro. The dollar rises to parity. What happens?

          4Covenants and stress tests: how far can Harmony fall?

          Forecasts are wrong. The useful question is not what the base case says, but how bad the year can get before a lender can act, or the cash runs out.

          A covenant is a promise that lets the lender step in early

          Covenants set ratio limits, and headroom measures the distance to them

          A covenant is a clause in which the borrower promises to keep a ratio within a limit. If it does not, the lender may charge a fee, reset the terms or demand repayment. Covenants let the lender step in while the borrower can still talk. A maintenance covenant is tested at every reporting date. An incurrence covenant is tested only when the borrower acts, for instance by taking more debt.

          The distance between the ratio and the limit is the headroom. The bank debt carries two covenants: net debt / EBITDA of at most 3.0× and EBITDA / net interest of at least 4.0×.

          A stress test shows which number gives way first

          Change one or two assumptions sharply, then recompute every measure

          A stress test asks what happens if things go badly in a specific way. It is not a forecast. Harmony faces two obvious shocks: reference rates up two points, and EBITDA down 25% as a slowdown hits dealers and stock piles up.

          Covenants lag, because they react to reported ratios. The cash shortfall shows first. At 3.3 a year, Harmony's 10.0 of cash lasts about three years. The undrawn 10.0 stretches that to six, if the line is still there. It expires in N+3, just when the cash would run out. Counting only the cash above the policy minimum of 4.0, the runway is under two years.

          The verdict: solvent, liquid for now, exposed in N+3 and N+4

          A diagnosis ends with a conclusion and an action list

          Put the pieces together. Harmony is solvent: leverage of 1.67× and cover of 9.0× are comfortable. It is liquid for two years. It is exposed in N+3 and N+4, where 28.0 falls due with a thin DSCR and mostly floating funding. The weakness is the shape of the debt, not its size.

          • Move the wall: extend the RCF and refinance the notes early (CF33).

          • Fix part of the floating debt to protect cover (CF43).

          • Diversify funding beyond one bank and one private placement (CF18).

          1. 4.1 In the stress table, why does the DSCR fall below 1 while the covenants pass?

          2. 4.2 Why is a maturity wall in N+3 a bigger worry if the RCF also expires in N+3?

          3. 4.3 A CFO proposes borrowing in dollars because the rate is 2 points lower, though all sales are in euros. Name the risk and one remedy.

          a stress dashboard with sliders for the rate rise and the EBITDA fall, and gauges for each covenant, the DSCR and the cash runway. The learner searches for the combination that breaks the first covenant and sees that DSCR and runway warn long before.

          4

          1. Harmony's covenant is net debt / EBITDA ≤ 3.0× with net debt of 30.0. Below what EBITDA is it breached?

          2. With rates up two points and EBITDA down 25%, Harmony breaches no covenant but its DSCR is 0.50×. What does this mean?

          3. What is the verdict on Harmony's debt?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Leverage

          = /

          Bank covenant: at most 3.0×.

          Debt service cover ratio

          = ( − − − ) / ( + )

          6.5 / 6.0: almost nothing is left over; lenders often want 1.2× to 1.3×.

          Interest cover

          ·

          With +2 points on 30.0 of floating debt: 6.9× and 4.6×.

          Idea What to remember
          Solvency vs liquidity Solvency: will future cash flows repay the debts. Liquidity: will cash be there on each due date.
          Free cash flow story Operations, reinvestment, free cash flow, then lenders and shareholders. Any gap is filled by debt, shares or lower payout.
          Growth uses cash first More sales need working capital and capex before they bring cash.
          Net debt / EBITDA Years of earnings the debt represents. Not years to repay, since EBITDA is not cash for lenders.
          Interest cover EBITDA or EBIT over net interest. The cushion if earnings fall or rates rise.
          FFO and FCF to debt Cash-based ratios: how much of the debt a year of cash flow could repay.
          DSCR Cash for debt service over interest plus repayment. Around 1 means no slack.
          Definitions Leases, pensions, hybrids and adjusted EBITDA change ratios. Compare on one basis.
          Maturity table Debt due by year against cash generated. Reveals walls that liquidity ratios miss.
          Floating and foreign debt Floating rates tie interest to the cycle. Foreign-currency debt adds exchange risk.

          The one-sentence version

          Read how the company has financed itself, compare its debt with the cash flows that will repay it, check the dates on which payments fall due, and test how far earnings and rates can move before a covenant breaks or the cash runs out.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Solvency Whether a company's future cash flows can repay everything it owes over time.
          Liquidity Whether a company has cash available on the dates payments fall due.
          DSCR Debt service cover ratio: cash available for debt service divided by interest plus scheduled repayment.
          Refinancing wall A year in which an unusually large amount of debt falls due at once.
          Transformation risk The risk of financing long-lived assets with short-term debt that must be renewed.
          Covenant A promise in a loan contract to keep a ratio within a limit, so the lender can act early.
          Headroom The distance between today's ratio and the covenant limit.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on financing analysis.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on financial analysis and planning and on short-term financial planning.

          • Damodaran — Investment Valuation (Wiley), sections on financial leverage and distress.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.