Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Life cycle and deals / Module 38

38Buying and selling companies

How deals create value, how they are run, and who keeps the gain

How deals create value, how they are run, and who keeps the gain.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
11
Exercises
3
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Size a synergy case and the bargaining zone it creates.

  • Explain how a private sale runs, from teaser to closing.

  • Compare locked-box and completion-account pricing and compute a price adjustment.

  • Describe how a public takeover bid works, and compare cash and share payment.

  • Name the French thresholds for a mandatory offer and a squeeze-out.

  • Say what merger control and foreign investment screening add to a deal.

1Why deals happen and who keeps the gain

Every acquisition rests on a claim about extra value. Learn to size that claim and to see the price as a way of sharing it.

A deal is worth doing only if the whole is worth more than the parts

Synergy is extra cash that neither company can produce alone

Synergy means that the combined cash flows exceed the sum of the separate ones. It comes from a short list of sources: cost savings from scale or from removing duplicated work, extra sales from selling more through the same channels, control of a scarce input, and a lower cost of capital for a larger or less risky group. Growing bigger or diversifying adds no cash, since shareholders can diversify on their own.

The price splits the synergy between the two sides

The seller will not accept less than Volta's stand-alone value, 27.5. The buyer should not pay more than that value plus the net synergies, 27.5 + 13.67 = 41.17. Between those two numbers lies the bargaining zone: any price inside it beats walking away for both sides. Where the price lands depends on negotiating strength, information and competition.

A bargaining-zone slider. The learner drags the equity price from 27.5 to 41.17 and watches two bars show the gain of Harmony and of Volta's sellers, with the total fixed at 13.67. A second control scales the synergies that actually materialise (100%, 50%, 0%). The learner should discover that the zone shrinks quickly when synergies disappoint, and that a price near the top of the zone gives the buyer nothing.

Most of the value goes to the seller, and the buyer has to earn its share

Studies of past deals find that sellers capture most of the gain

Research on large samples of takeovers finds that target shareholders gain a clear premium, while buyers on average earn returns close to zero and many do worse. Three causes recur: synergies are overestimated by the people who propose the deal, competition between bidders hands the gain to the seller, and integration is harder than planned.

The buyer should value the target alone first, name who delivers each synergy and when, and fix a walk-away price before negotiating.

1.1 When the synergy is half as large

1.1 — Claire's team revises the savings to 1.0 million a year before tax, with the same 3.0 integration cost and the same 9% rate. Compute the net synergy value, the maximum price Harmony should pay for Volta's equity, and what is left for Harmony if it still pays 32.0.

The after-tax saving is 1.0 × 0.75 = 0.75 a year, worth 0.75 / 0.09 = 8.33, or 5.33 after the 3.0 integration cost. The maximum equity price is 27.5 + 5.33 = 32.83.

At 32.0, Harmony keeps 32.83 − 32.0 = 0.83. The sellers took 4.5 of the 5.33.

Your neighbour Karim runs a plumbing firm and is about to sell it to a larger competitor. He says: they will make a fortune from my customers, so I should ask for everything they will gain. Explain to him why the buyer will not pay that, and what a realistic ask looks like.

      Karim. The buyer will pay up to the stand-alone value plus the gain, never all of it, since it needs a reason to buy. The gain comes from the combination, not from Karim's customers alone. A realistic ask is a price above his stand-alone value, backed by evidence.

      Nadia. The price is what the bidder will pay to persuade holders to sell, and it includes a share of the bidder's expected gain. She should read the board's reasoned opinion and the expert's report, and ask whether a better bidder might appear.

      1. 1.2 Name two sources of synergy that create cash and one that does not.

      2. 1.3 Harmony values Volta alone at 27.5 and sees 13.67 of net synergy. A rival bids 41.17. What happens to Harmony's gain if it matches?

      3. 1.4 Why does the buyer's own forecast of synergies deserve more scepticism than the seller's forecast of Volta's profits?

      1

      1. Volta is worth 27.5 alone and the deal creates 13.67 of net synergy. What is the most Harmony should pay for Volta's equity?

      2. Why does diversification not count as a synergy?

      3. Studies of past takeovers find that, on average...

      2Selling a private company: a process built to manage risk

      A private sale is a sequence of steps, each of which gives the buyer more information and the seller more commitment. The contract then decides who bears the risks that remain.

      A sale runs in stages, from a teaser to a signed contract

      An auction creates competition, a bilateral deal creates speed

      The seller's adviser can approach one buyer, or run an auction. An auction starts with a teaser, a short anonymous summary. Interested parties sign a non-disclosure agreement, receive an information memorandum and submit non-binding offers. Shortlisted bidders get a data room, a secure online archive of contracts, accounts and permits. They meet management, read a draft contract and submit binding offers. The whole process usually takes several months.

      An auction maximises price when several buyers value the business highly. It costs time and exposes secrets to competitors. A bilateral negotiation is quicker and quieter but gives the seller one price and no pressure. Some sellers run a sale and a listing in parallel (see CF37).

      Documents mark the steps of commitment

      • A letter of intent records price range, timetable and exclusivity. It is mostly non-binding, apart from confidentiality and exclusivity.

      • Due diligence is the buyer's investigation of finance, tax, law, commercial position, technology and, increasingly, sustainability.

      • The sale and purchase agreement (SPA) is the binding contract. Between signing and closing, the conditions precedent must be met, typically merger control clearance and any required approvals.

      The price is a formula, not a single figure

      Enterprise value is agreed, then the equity price is adjusted

      Buyers and sellers agree an enterprise value, and the cash paid for the shares is that value minus net debt, plus or minus a correction for working capital. Two mechanisms settle the correction. With completion accounts, a set of accounts is drawn up at closing and the price is adjusted for the actual net debt and working capital. With a locked box, the price is fixed on the basis of a balance sheet at an earlier date, the seller promises that no value leaves the company after that date, and any leakage, such as a dividend, is repaid euro for euro.

      A toggle table with two columns, locked box and completion accounts, and four events that can happen before closing: a 0.4 dividend paid to the sellers, a working-capital squeeze, a strong trading month, and a large customer payment arriving late. For each event the learner decides who bears the effect, then sees the correct answer and the euro impact on Harmony. The learner should discover that completion accounts leave trading risk with the seller, and a locked box passes it to the buyer.

      An earn-out pays later if the forecast proves right

      When the sides disagree about the future, part of the price can depend on results. In an earn-out, the buyer pays an extra amount if, for example, the target reaches a profit level in the next two years. It also causes disputes: after the sale, the buyer controls the profit that decides the payment.

      Warranties, escrow and insurance cover what no one has found

      After closing, the buyer cannot unpick the deal because of a surprise. The SPA therefore contains warranties, statements by the seller about the state of the business, and a claim for damages if they prove untrue. Claims are limited by a cap and a time limit. To make a claim worth something, part of the price is held in escrow, a third-party account. Warranty and indemnity insurance is now common: the insurer pays the buyer and the sellers leave with their cash.

      In the Volta deal, 10% of the closing payment, 2.9 million, sits in escrow for eighteen months.

      2.1 Two ways to settle the price

      2.1 — At closing, Volta's net debt is 4.9 and its working capital is 5.2. The agreed figures are 4.0 and 6.0 and the headline price is 32.0. What is the equity price under completion accounts? Then suppose the sellers paid themselves a 0.4 dividend after the locked-box date. What does a locked-box price become?

      Completion accounts: 32.0 − (4.9 − 4.0) − (6.0 − 5.2) = 32.0 − 0.9 − 0.8 = 30.3.

      Locked box: the price stays at 32.0 and the 0.4 dividend is leakage, repaid euro for euro, so the price is 31.6. The trading movements in working capital and debt are not adjusted, so the buyer bears them.

      1. 2.2 Why does a seller prefer a locked box?

      2. 2.3 What is the purpose of escrow, and what does it not protect against?

      3. 2.4 In a French sale, who is consulted before signing, and can that body stop the deal?

      2

      1. In an auction, when does a bidder get access to the data room?

      2. Which price mechanism leaves trading risk up to closing with the seller?

      3. Volta's earn-out pays 3.0 in two years if EBITDA reaches 5.5, with a 50% chance. What is it worth today at 9%?

      3Buying a listed company: the offer goes to its shareholders

      A listed target has many owners and a market price. The rules exist to protect minority holders, and they shape how the buyer approaches the board.

      A takeover bid is an offer made to every shareholder

      The buyer can build a stake, then bid

      A buyer often starts by acquiring shares in the market. Disclosure rules require a holder to declare when its stake crosses set thresholds, and parties acting together count as one holder. A buyer who crosses the control threshold must offer to buy the rest.

      The bid can be paid in cash, in shares or in both

      Cash gives the sellers a known amount. Shares give them a stake in the combined company, so they share the synergies and the risk that they do not appear. Mixed offers combine the two.

      Financing a bid with debt also raises the buyer's leverage. Go back to the private deal at stage 1 figures: if Harmony paid 32.0 for Volta's equity in cash from new borrowing and took on its 4.0 of net debt, group net debt would rise from 30.0 to 66.0 against combined EBITDA of 22.5. Net debt over EBITDA would go from 1.67 times to 2.93 times. Whether the deal raises earnings per share says little about value; CF39 explains why.

      A cash-versus-shares simulator. The learner picks the offer price per Volta share and the percentage of synergies that arrive, then toggles the payment between cash and shares. Two bars show the gain of Harmony's old holders and of Volta's holders. The learner should discover that shares transfer risk to the sellers: when synergies fall short, the cash offer is better for them and the share offer is better for Harmony.

      Boards defend, and shareholders decide

      A board that thinks a bid is too low can look for a better bidder, a white knight, or issue shares or warrants to dilute the bidder. In some countries the board must stay neutral. The shareholders decide by tendering or not. When the bidder owns almost all the shares, a squeeze-out lets it buy the remainder.

      France: the AMF sets the rules of a public offer

      3.1 A higher bid

      3.1 — Harmony raises its offer to 13.20 per Volta share, a total of 36.3. Compute Harmony's gain if it pays in cash. If it pays in new Harmony shares at 12.00, what share of the group do Volta's holders own, and what is each side's gain?

      In cash, Harmony's gain is 41.17 − 36.3 = 4.87.

      In shares, Harmony issues 36.3 / 12.00 = 3.025 million shares. Volta's holders own 3.025 / 15.525 = 19.5% of the group. Combined equity is 191.17, so they hold 37.25, a gain of 9.75. Harmony's old holders hold 153.92, a gain of 3.92. The gains add up to 13.67.

      The higher price moves gain towards Volta's holders in both forms.

      Your aunt Nadia owns shares in a small listed company. She has received a letter saying that a rival has offered 20% more than the market price, and she asks whether this means the company is worth that. Explain to her what the offer price tells her, and what she should read before she decides.

          1. 3.2 In France, at what stake must a holder bid for the rest of a listed company, and at what stake can it force out the minority?

          2. 3.3 Why does a share offer shift some risk from the buyer to the target's holders?

          3. 3.4 Name two defences a target board can use against a bid it does not want.

          3

          1. Harmony bids 12.00 per Volta share in cash, 33.0 in total. What does Harmony keep of the net synergy?

          2. In France, when must a holder file a mandatory offer for a company on Euronext Paris's regulated market?

          3. Why does a share offer shift risk to the target's holders?

          4Regulators and the first two years decide whether the deal pays

          Competition and security authorities can delay or prevent a deal. After closing, execution decides whether the synergies appear.

          Regulators can block, delay or reshape a deal

          Merger control asks whether competition will suffer

          Above certain turnover thresholds, a deal must be notified to the competition authority before it closes. The authority asks whether the combined company could raise prices or reduce choice. It can clear the deal, require remedies such as the sale of a business, or block it. A vertical deal like Harmony and Volta raises a different question from a merger of rivals: whether the buyer could cut off supply to competing bike makers.

          In the European Union a large cross-border deal is filed once with the European Commission, and smaller deals go to national authorities. The United States has its own filing and waiting period. The SPA makes closing conditional on clearance.

          Foreign investment screening asks who will own the asset

          Many countries now review purchases of companies in sensitive sectors by foreign investors, and the EU has added a regime on foreign subsidies that distort competition. Batteries, energy storage and components for the energy transition are the kind of activity governments watch. Screening can add months and conditions, so check early.

          Integration is where the 13.67 is earned or lost

          The price is paid on day one and the synergies arrive over years

          Closing transfers ownership. It does not by itself change a single supplier contract or working habit. The savings depend on a plan: who leads integration, what merges first, which customers need reassurance and which people must stay.

          4

          1. What does a competition authority ask about a vertical deal like Harmony and Volta?

          2. Why might foreign investment screening matter for Volta?

          3. Which synergies are usually delivered after a deal?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Net synergy value

          = × (1 − ) / −

          1.5 / 0.09 = 16.67, less 3.0.

          Bargaining zone

          ≤ price ≤ V stand-alone +

          Zone from 27.5 to 41.17; at 32.0 Harmony keeps 9.17.

          Price under completion accounts

          = − + ()

          Sellers’ stake when paid in shares

          = / ( + n)

          Idea What to remember
          Synergy Extra cash that the two companies produce together. Only cash-creating sources count.
          Bargaining zone From the target's stand-alone value to that value plus net synergies. Any price inside it works for both sides.
          Who gains On average the target's holders take most of the gain. Competition and optimism push the price up.
          Price mechanism Completion accounts adjust for actual net debt and working capital. A locked box fixes the price and bans leakage.
          Earn-out A deferred payment tied to results. It bridges disagreement and creates disputes.
          Warranties and escrow Seller statements, backed by money held aside for a period. Insurance now often replaces the sellers' liability.
          Cash vs shares Cash gives certainty to the seller. Shares share synergy and risk and spare the buyer's balance sheet.
          French thresholds Mandatory offer at 30%. Squeeze-out at 90% of capital and voting rights. AMF supervises.
          Regulators Merger control and foreign investment screening can delay or reshape a deal. Clearance is a condition of closing.

          The one-sentence version

          Pay for a company only up to its stand-alone value plus the synergies you can really deliver, and use the price mechanism, the contract and the offer structure to keep part of that gain.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Synergy Extra cash created by combining two companies.
          Bargaining zone The range of prices that leave both buyer and seller better off than walking away.
          Locked box A price fixed on an earlier balance sheet, with a promise that no value leaves afterwards.
          Completion accounts Accounts drawn up at closing to adjust the price for actual debt and working capital.
          Earn-out A later payment that depends on the target's results.
          Escrow Money held by a third party to cover possible claims.
          Squeeze-out A forced purchase of the remaining shares once the bidder holds almost all of them.
          Tender offer A public offer to buy shares directly from shareholders.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on negotiating control: private sales and takeover bids.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on mergers and corporate control.

          • Rosenbaum and Pearl — Investment Banking: Valuation, LBOs, M&A and IPOs (Wiley).

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.