Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Value and investment / Module 28

28Valuation II: multiples, sum-of-the-parts, premiums and discounts

How the market, the assets and the buyer's identity shape the price of a company

How the market, the assets and the buyer’s identity shape the price of a company.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
12
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Compute enterprise-value and equity multiples and apply them to a target without mixing numerators and denominators.

  • Choose peers and a multiple that suit a business, and explain why a low multiple is not always cheap.

  • Value a group by the sum of its parts and measure a holding discount.

  • Value a company from its assets and say why asset value is a poor floor.

  • Explain control premiums, minority and illiquidity discounts, and who pays for what.

  • Reconcile several methods into a range, the way a fairness opinion does.

1Multiples borrow the market's opinion of similar companies

A multiple is the fastest valuation tool and the easiest to misuse. The arithmetic is one division. Everything depends on what you divide and by what.

A multiple is a price divided by a measure of size

Suppose a bakery sells for 300,000 and earns 50,000 a year before costs of ownership. The buyer paid six times annual earnings. If a similar bakery earns 60,000, a reasonable guess is that it is worth about 360,000. That is the whole method: find the price-to-size ratio of similar businesses, then apply it to yours.

Companies have two kinds of price. Enterprise value (EV) is the price of the whole business, paid to lenders and shareholders together. Equity value is the shareholders' part only: EV minus net debt (CF27).

EV multiple = EV / (EBITDA, EBIT or sales) Equity multiple = Equity value / (net income or book equity)

The rule that prevents most errors is consistency. A number that belongs to the whole business (EBITDA, EBIT, sales) pairs with EV. A number that belongs to shareholders after interest (net income, book equity) pairs with equity value. EV divided by net income is meaningless.

Peers matter more than arithmetic, and a low multiple is not a bargain

A trading multiple comes from the share prices of listed peers. A transaction multiple comes from prices paid for whole companies, so it includes a premium for control (part 3). Do not mix them.

Good peers share the drivers of value: growth, margins, risk and capital intensity. Same sector is a start, not a test. Four fictional listed rivals follow, in € million.

Peer EV EV/EBITDA EV/EBIT P/E Net debt / EBITDA
Velora 1,680 10.0× 14.0× 17.0× 1.5×
Alpenrad (Germany) 640 8.0× 12.3× 15.0× 2.0×
Ruota (Italy) 425 8.5× 12.5× 16.3× 2.0×
Rollan 180 6.0× 15.0× 30.0× 4.0×

Velora: EBITDA 168, EBIT 120, net income 84, net debt 252. Alpenrad: 80, 52, 32, 160. Ruota: 50, 34, 20, 100. Rollan: 30, 12, 2, 120.

Rollan is the trap. Its 6.0× EV/EBITDA looks cheap and its 30× P/E looks dear, yet both reflect distress: interest on heavy debt shrinks its net income, and investors doubt that its EBITDA will last. A careful analyst leaves it out of the core set.

Choose the multiple that fits how the business makes money

  • EV/EBITDA suits capital-heavy firms with different depreciation policies. It flatters a firm that must keep spending on equipment, since that spending never appears in EBITDA.

  • EV/EBIT charges depreciation, a rough proxy for keeping assets alive. Better when capital intensity differs.

  • EV/sales is a last resort for firms with no profits yet, and works only among peers with similar margins.

  • P/E is simple and popular but distorted by debt (below).

  • Price to book suits banks and insurers, whose balance sheets are mostly financial assets and liabilities carried close to their value, and means little for brand or software value.

Leases need care. Under IFRS 16 (CF8) EBITDA excludes rent and lease debt joins net debt. Peers reporting under US GAAP may show rent inside EBITDA. Put every peer on the same basis before dividing.

The most dangerous distortion is leverage. Debt makes the equity of two identical businesses worth different amounts, so their P/Es differ. Applying one firm's P/E to another firm with a different debt load gives a wrong answer even when the businesses are twins.

1.1 Twins with different debt

Two firms have the same operating profit of 20, tax at 25% and the same EV of 200. Firm A has no debt. Firm B has net debt of 100 costing 5%. Compute each firm's net income, equity value and P/E. Then apply A's P/E to B's net income and say how far the result is from B's true equity value.

Firm A: net income 20 × 0.75 = 15. Equity value 200. P/E = 200 / 15 = 13.3×.

Firm B: interest 5, profit before tax 15, net income 15 × 0.75 = 11.25. Equity value 200 − 100 = 100. P/E = 100 / 11.25 = 8.9×.

Applying A's 13.3× to B's 11.25 gives 150, which overstates B's true equity value of 100 by 50. Debt lowers equity value faster than it lowers earnings, so P/E falls with leverage. Use EV multiples and subtract net debt instead.

Harmony and the four peers in a table, with a tick box beside each peer and a choice of multiple (EBITDA, EBIT, P/E). The learner includes or removes Rollan, switches multiples and watches the implied value of Harmony move. What to discover: the answer depends more on the choice of peers and multiple than on the arithmetic.

  1. 1.2 Why does EV/net income make no sense?

  2. 1.3 Name one reason a peer in the same sector may be a bad comparison.

  3. 1.4 A target has far more debt than its peers. Which is safer to apply, EV/EBITDA or P/E, and why?

1

  1. Harmony's EV is 144.0 and its equity value 114.0. Which pairing gives a meaningful multiple?

  2. Rollan trades at 6.0× EBITDA and 30× earnings. A careful analyst…

  3. Two identical businesses with EV of 200 differ only in debt. Applying the unlevered firm's P/E to the levered one…

2A group's value is the sum of its parts, minus what the structure costs

When a company runs different businesses, one multiple blurs them. Valuing each part separately is more accurate, and the gap between that sum and the market price is informative.

Value each activity with the multiple of its own peers

A single multiple assumes one business. Harmony has two: bikes assembled in volume at modest margins, and spare parts and accessories at higher margins. Their peers differ, so the group average hides it.

The same method values a holding company. Add the value of each stake, subtract the holding's net debt and costs, and compare with its market capitalisation. The shortfall is the holding discount. It reflects layers of cost, trapped cash, doubts about capital allocation and the difficulty of selling stakes.

2.1 The holding discount

A holding owns 60% of a listed subsidiary whose equity is worth 500, and 100% of an unlisted business worth 150 (enterprise value, no debt in it). The holding has net debt of 90. Its own market capitalisation is 288. Compute the sum-of-the-parts equity value and the holding discount.

Stake in the listed subsidiary: 0.6 × 500 = 300. Add 150. Subtract net debt of 90. Sum of the parts equity value: 360.

Market capitalisation is 288. Holding discount = 1 − 288 / 360 = 20%.

Harmony's sum of the parts with two sliders, one for the bike multiple and one for the parts multiple, and a third slider for a structure discount from 0% to 25%. The learner sees the group value against the 144.0 DCF and the discount at which the two meet. What to discover: small multiple changes on the larger part matter more than large changes on the smaller part.

Asset value describes what a company owns, not what it earns

The asset-based method values what the company owns, one item at a time, at what each would fetch. Start with book equity and adjust: land and plant at market, inventories after writing down obsolete stock, brands and customer lists if they can be priced, then the tax on the revaluations. The result is adjusted net assets.

Assets can be valued as a going concern, where the plant keeps producing, or on liquidation, where it is sold piece by piece for much less. A company is worth more than its assets only if it earns above its cost of capital. The link is economic profit.

2.2 — Marc is a plumber. He owns a van, tools and a customer list, and wants to know what his business is worth. A friend tells him the tools and van are worth 25,000 and so that is the price. Explain to Marc, in everyday words, why the customer list and his own hours matter and why 25,000 may be too low or too high.

      Marc, the tools and the van are what you could sell on their own. The customers are why people ring you. If they stay when you stop, the business is worth more than the tools. If they call only because you do the work, a buyer will pay little more than 25,000.

      So 25,000 is too low if the customer list is real and lasts, and too high if you are the only reason they call.

      2

      1. Harmony's bikes make 14.0 of EBITDA at 8.0× and parts 4.0 at 10.0×. The sum of the parts is…

      2. Harmony's adjusted net assets imply an EV of 90.0 while its DCF says 144.0. The gap is best described as…

      3. When is asset value a true floor under the price?

      3The price depends on who is buying, how much and how easily they can sell

      The same company has a different price for a bidder taking control, an investor buying a few shares, and a family trying to sell a private stake. Three adjustments capture this: control premium, minority discount and illiquidity discount.

      A control premium pays the seller for what the buyer expects to gain

      A listed share price reflects the company run as it is. A buyer who takes control can change strategy, cut costs or combine businesses. If that is worth more than the market price, the buyer can pay a control premium and still gain.

      The most a rational bidder pays is the market value plus the value it can add (the synergies, CF38). Every euro of premium above the real gain passes value from the buyer's shareholders to the seller's. Premiums in public takeovers are often in the range of 20% to 40% of the pre-bid price.

      Minority and illiquidity discounts are different things

      A minority discount reduces the price of a stake that cannot control decisions. It is real only when the controllers can in fact extract value. Where the law protects minorities and the company is well run, the case is weak. A DCF values the whole business as run, so no further minority discount belongs on a stake derived from it.

      An illiquidity discount applies when shares cannot be sold quickly or cheaply, as in private companies. The buyer needs a higher return to accept being stuck. A useful proxy is the discount at which companies list.

      3.1 Who captures the gain?

      Listed target: market value 150.0. A bidder expects synergies worth 40.0 and offers a 25% premium. Compute the premium paid and the value the bidder's shareholders keep. Then say what happens to the answer if a rival forces the premium to 30%.

      Premium: 150.0 × 25% = 37.5. Bidder's gain: 40.0 − 37.5 = 2.5.

      At 30%, the premium is 45.0 and the bidder loses 5.0. The seller's shareholders take almost all the value, and a competitive bid can push the buyer under water.

      a bidding game. The learner sees the target's market value of 150.0 and a hidden range of possible synergies. Two or three rival bidders raise the premium in rounds, and the learner decides to stay or leave. At the end the site reveals the true synergies and who gained. What to discover: the winning bidder in an auction often overpays, because the winner is the one who most overestimated the gain.

      3.2 — Sofia has a 5% stake in her family's company and a buyer offers her 30% less than the pro-rata value. Explain to her, without finance jargon, which parts of that cut might be fair and which might not.

          Sofia, a cut might be fair if the other owners decide everything without you, if the firm pays no dividends, or if you cannot sell to anyone else. Those are real reasons a buyer pays less.

          It is not fair if the firm pays regular dividends and the rules protect small owners. Ask which reason applies. A cut with no stated reason is a negotiating tactic.

          1. 3.3 Why is a control premium not a free gift to the seller's shareholders?

          2. 3.4 Name one case where a minority discount is justified and one where it is not.

          3. 3.5 What is the difference between an illiquidity discount and a minority discount?

          3

          1. A bidder pays a 30% premium on listed Harmony (150.0). Its synergies turn out to be worth 30.0. The bidder's shareholders…

          2. A DCF of the whole business, run as it is, is used to value a 5% stake. Should a minority discount be applied?

          3. Peers imply 123.0 of equity. A 10% illiquidity discount for unlisted Harmony gives…

          4Reconcile the methods into a range, then say what would change it

          A valuation is a story supported by several numbers. The last step lays the methods side by side, explains the gaps and states what a seller and a buyer should each believe.

          The football field shows where the methods overlap

          A football field is a chart with one bar per method, each bar running from the low to the high value. Where the bars overlap lies the range worth defending. The table converts Harmony's methods to enterprise value in € million.

          Method Low High What it assumes
          Trading EV/EBITDA, 8.0× to 10.0× 144.0 180.0 Peers' current prices, no control
          Trading EV/EBIT, 12.3× to 14.0× 147.7 168.0 Charges depreciation
          Transaction EV/EBITDA, 9.0× to 10.5× 162.0 189.0 Includes a control premium
          DCF, 144.0 ± 10% 129.6 158.4 Harmony's own plan (CF27)
          Sum of the parts 141.0 163.0 Bikes 7.5× to 8.5×, parts 9× to 11×
          Assets plus excess profit 90.0 100.0 Today's earnings only, no growth

          The transaction multiples (9.0× to 10.5×) are illustrative precedent deals.

          The stand-alone methods (trading multiples, DCF, sum of the parts) overlap between 147.7 and 158.4. The transaction row is higher because it includes control. The asset row is lower because it excludes growth. They answer other questions.

          4.1 Read the football field

          A DCF gives 120 to 150, trading multiples 135 to 160 and a sum of the parts 140 to 170. Find the overlap and its midpoint. Then say whether a seller or a buyer should lead with the higher figure.

          The highest low is 140 (sum of the parts) and the lowest high is 150 (DCF). Overlap: 140 to 150, midpoint 145.

          The seller leads with the higher bars. The buyer leads with the DCF and treats the rest as the seller's argument.

          Higher rates lower multiples, so compare multiples across time with care

          Multiples are not constants. A company whose cash grows at g and is discounted at k is worth 1 / (k − g) times next year's cash. When k falls, the multiple rises sharply. Takeover multiples also follow the stock market.

          Sellers point to transaction multiples and the sum of the parts, which are high. Buyers point to stand-alone DCF and asset value, which are low, and keep the synergies for themselves.

          A young firm is worth its future earnings and little else. A mature, asset-heavy firm is valued closer to its assets. In every case, show a range and name the assumption that would move it most.

          4

          1. Harmony's stand-alone methods overlap between 147.7 and 158.4. Why is the transaction row (162 to 189) left out of that overlap?

          2. With growth of 2%, the rate falls from 9% to 7%. The multiple of next year's cash…

          3. In a negotiation, the buyer tends to lead with…

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Enterprise-value multiple applied

          = × −

          A whole-business numerator goes with a whole-business denominator; P/E does not mix with EV.

          Sum of the parts and holding discount

          ; discount = 1 − / SdP

          For Harmony: 1 − 144.0 / 152.0 = 5.3%.

          Value from economic profit

          = + ( − ) / k

          1.44 / 0.09 = 16.0; the other 44.0 up to the DCF is growth in economic profit.

          Control premium and the bidder’s gain

          = −

          If the synergies are worth only 30.0, the bidder loses 15.0.

          Idea What to remember
          Multiple A price divided by a measure of size. Apply it to a target's size to get its value.
          Consistency Whole-business prices (EV) go with whole-business measures (EBITDA, EBIT, sales). Equity prices go with net income or book equity.
          Trading vs transaction Trading multiples show the market price of a minority share. Transaction multiples include a control premium.
          Choosing peers Match growth, margin, risk and capital intensity. Remove distressed names or show them apart.
          Which multiple EBITDA for capital-heavy firms, EBIT when capital intensity differs, P/B for banks, sales only as a last resort.
          Leverage distortion P/E changes with debt. EV multiples are safer across different capital structures.
          Sum of the parts Value each unit with its own peers, then deduct structure costs. The shortfall against market price is the holding discount.
          Asset value Adjusted net assets show what the company owns. Goodwill is the extra value of earning above the cost of capital.
          Control premium What a buyer pays for the right to change the business. It should not exceed the value of the synergies.
          Minority and illiquidity A minority discount needs a specific cause. An illiquidity discount applies when shares cannot be sold easily.
          Football field Present several methods as bars and read the overlap. A range beats a single number.
          Rates and multiples Higher rates lower multiples. Do not compare with deals done at near-zero rates.

          The one-sentence version

          Use several methods, put them on the same basis, explain why they differ through control, growth, risk and liquidity, and present a range with the assumption that would move it most.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Enterprise value The price of the whole business: equity value plus net debt.
          Trading multiple A multiple built from the share prices of listed peers.
          Transaction multiple A multiple built from prices paid to buy whole companies, including control.
          Sum of the parts A value built by pricing each business unit separately and adding.
          Holding discount The shortfall of a holding company's market value below the sum of its parts.
          Adjusted net assets Book equity restated to current values, net of tax.
          Economic profit Operating profit after tax minus the cost of the capital employed.
          Control premium The extra paid over the market price for the right to control the company.
          Illiquidity discount A lower price because the shares cannot be sold quickly or cheaply.
          Football field A chart of valuation ranges by method, used to read the overlap.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the practice of company valuation.

          • Damodaran, A. — Investment Valuation (Wiley), chapters on relative valuation and on acquisition premiums.

          • Koller, Goedhart, Wessels — Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies (McKinsey/Wiley), chapters on multiples and on reconciling approaches.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.