Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Life cycle and deals / Module 36

36Group structure, holdings and spin-offs

How the shape of a corporate group changes who owns the cash, who is paid first and who pays the tax

How the shape of a corporate group changes who owns the cash, who is paid first and who pays the tax.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
10
Exercises
3
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
2

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why a diversified group can trade below the sum of its parts, and compute that discount.

  • Show what happens to value, net debt and earnings when a minority of a subsidiary is sold.

  • Calculate effective ownership through a chain of holdings, and say why control and ownership differ.

  • Explain structural subordination and decide where a group should borrow.

  • Describe the French parent-subsidiary regime, tax consolidation and the 15% global minimum tax.

1Why groups form, and why markets discount them

A group is a bet that running different activities under one roof is worth more than running them apart. Investors usually ask for proof.

Diversifying inside a company adds nothing that investors cannot do alone

Risk that can be diversified by shareholders earns no reward

Suppose Harmony adds a rental business because bikes sell in summer and rentals also sell in autumn. Cash flows become steadier. That sounds like value. But a shareholder who wanted steadier cash flows could have bought a share in Harmony and a share in a rental company, at almost no cost. CF15 showed that markets pay for risk that cannot be diversified away, not for risk that can.

The market often prices a conglomerate below the sum of its parts

A conglomerate discount is the gap between what the parts would be worth as separate companies and what the group is worth. Three causes are usually given. Cash from strong divisions may fund weak ones (cross-subsidy) instead of going to the best use. Investors who want a particular business prefer a pure play, a company that does one thing. And head office costs money, which the market capitalises.

Groups exist for real reasons, and the discount is not a law

Where capital markets are thin, a group works as its own capital market

In economies where banks matter more than stock markets, or where outside investors are hard to trust, a group can move cash from mature units to young ones faster and more cheaply than the market. Groups also make sense when activities share a brand, a technology, a customer base or a factory. And a family that controls a group may prefer to diversify inside it, because the family cannot easily sell its shares.

A discounted group has four ways out

  • Persuade. Publish divisional accounts, set targets for each unit and show the market what each part earns.

  • Sell a piece. Sell the division to a buyer who values it more (see CF38).

  • Spin it off. Give the division's shares to the existing shareholders (Part 4).

  • List part of it. Sell a minority stake in the division to outside investors and let the market put a price on it (Part 2).

Your uncle Karim runs a hardware shop and says: if my shop also sold garden furniture and ran a delivery van, I would be safer and so worth more to a buyer. Explain to him why a buyer might still pay less, using the idea that the buyer can diversify alone.

      A buyer who wants furniture can buy a furniture business. Karim's extra activities do not give the buyer anything they cannot get alone, and they bring costs and complexity. The buyer may even prefer a pure hardware shop and pay less for a mixed one.

      1.2 Fleet at a lower multiple

      Rental companies turn out to trade at 10 times EBITDA, not 12. Recompute Harmony's sum of the parts, the gap against the group value of 144.0, and the discount in percent.

      Fleet is worth 3.0 × 10 = 30.0 and the bike business 120.0, so the parts total 150.0. Against 144.0 the gap is 6.0, a discount of 6.0 / 150.0 = 4.0%. A lower multiple for Fleet means a smaller discount.

      two sliders, one for the multiple applied to the bike business (6 to 10) and one for the multiple applied to Fleet (6 to 16). A bar shows the sum of the parts against the 144.0 group value. The learner discovers that the discount appears only when the two multiples differ, and that it vanishes when the market applies a single multiple to everything.

      1

      1. Harmony's bike business is worth 120.0 and Fleet 36.0. The market values the group at 144.0. What is the conglomerate discount?

      2. Why do shareholders not reward a group for diversifying?

      3. When can a group make sense despite the discount argument?

      2Minority partners: selling part of a subsidiary

      A parent can sell some of a subsidiary and keep control. That brings cash and a market price. It also brings new owners whose interests are not the parent's.

      Selling a minority stake moves value around without creating it

      Control stays with the parent, so the subsidiary is still fully consolidated

      While the parent keeps control, usually through more than half of the votes, accounting treats the subsidiary as fully part of the group: all its sales, EBITDA and debt are added in. The outside owners appear as minority interests (also called non-controlling interests), a claim on part of the group's equity and profit.

      Analysts must subtract the minorities when they move from enterprise value to equity value

      Because the group's EBITDA includes 100% of Fleet, enterprise value covers 100% of Fleet. To reach what belongs to Harmony shareholders, the analyst deducts the market value of the minority stake, as in the bridge above. Forgetting this line overstates the equity value (CF27 gives the full bridge).

      A listing can reveal a higher price, but that is a re-rating, not a creation

      Companies often say a carve-out will 'surface value'. What happens is that the market sets its own price on the subsidiary. If that price is higher than the parent's internal view, the parent's remaining stake is worth more. If it is lower, the parent has a public record of a weaker valuation.

      2.1 The market pays 14 times

      Investors price Fleet at 14 times EBITDA when they buy the 30%. Compute Fleet's enterprise value and equity value (net debt stays at 6.0), the price Harmony receives for its 30%, and the value of the 70% it keeps. By how much have Harmony shareholders gained compared with the 30.0 equity value used before?

      Fleet's enterprise value is 3.0 × 14 = 42.0. Less net debt of 6.0, the equity is 36.0. The 30% sells for 0.30 × 36.0 = 10.8 and the 70% kept is worth 0.70 × 36.0 = 25.2. Harmony shareholders hold 10.8 + 25.2 = 36.0, against 30.0 before, a gain of 6.0. It is a re-rating, which holds only if the market is right.

      Control and ownership drift apart as layers are added

      Holding 51% at each layer controls everything and owns little

      A parent with 51% of a subsidiary controls it. If that subsidiary holds 51% of another, the parent controls both. But its economic interest in the second is only 0.51 × 0.51 = 26.0%. Add a third layer and it falls to 0.51 × 0.51 × 0.51 = 13.3%. The parent steers a company in which it owns only 13% of the profits.

      Intra-group prices are where minority shareholders get hurt

      A parent can charge its subsidiary management fees, royalties for a brand or a technology, or inflated prices for supplies. Each charge is a transfer between pockets.

      A holding company usually trades below the value of what it owns

      A holding company is a company whose main assets are shares in other companies. Its shares usually trade at a holding discount to the market value of its stakes. Reasons: investors cannot choose what the holding does with the stakes, its own shares are often less liquid, its running costs eat value year after year, and tax can be paid twice as money moves up. A typical discount is 10% to 30%, though some holdings with a strong record trade at a premium.

      If a holding's only asset is the 70% of Fleet worth 21.0 (0.70 × 30.0) and it trades at 17.0, the discount is (21.0 − 17.0) / 21.0 = 19.0%. Below control, a stake of roughly 20% to 50% is usually booked by the equity method: one line for the share of the other company's profit, with none of its sales, EBITDA or debt. A 25% stake in a venture earning 4.0 shows 1.0 of income, which is not cash unless paid as a dividend.

      1. 2.2 Why does selling 30% of a subsidiary at a fair price not change the value of the group's equity?

      2. 2.3 A parent owns 60% of a company that owns 60% of another. What is its economic interest in the second, and does it control it?

      3. 2.4 A 25% joint venture appears as one line of income in the accounts. What must the analyst do to get from the group's EBITDA to an enterprise value?

      2

      1. Harmony sells 30% of Fleet (equity 30.0) for 9.0. What happens to group equity value?

      2. A parent owns 60% of a company that owns 60% of another. What is its economic interest in the second, and does it control it?

      3. A holding's only asset is 70% of Fleet, worth 21.0. The holding trades at 17.0. What is its discount?

      3Debt, cash and tax inside the group

      Every box has its own creditors, and the money must travel through them. Where the debt sits and how the cash moves decide who is protected and how much tax is paid.

      Creditors of a subsidiary are paid before the parent's creditors see a euro

      The parent owns the subsidiary's equity, and equity comes last

      A subsidiary is a separate company. Its creditors have a claim on its assets. The parent has a claim too, but as a shareholder, which ranks after everyone owed money. If the parent has borrowed, its lenders can reach the subsidiary only through the parent's shares. This is structural subordination: lenders to the parent rank behind the subsidiary's creditors, even though both are 'debt'.

      Most groups borrow at the top and lend downwards

      A typical large group raises bonds or bank loans at the parent, then lends the money to subsidiaries through intra-group loans. The reasons are practical. The parent has one credit rating and one set of lenders, so the debt is cheaper and simpler. Cash is managed centrally and subsidiaries have less room to take excessive risks. Minority shareholders in a subsidiary also prefer it not to carry the parent's debt.

      Your friend Amina lent 5,000 to her cousin's company. A few months later she hears that the cousin's company is owned by a holding company that has itself borrowed from a bank. Explain why it matters, for her, whether the bank lent to the holding or to the operating company.

          Amina is a creditor of the operating company. A bank that lent to the holding company is repaid only from what the operating company's shareholders receive, after Amina and the other creditors. So she ranks ahead of the bank. If the bank lent to the operating company itself, it would rank alongside her, or ahead of her if it took security. Where the debt sits decides who is paid first.

          Tax rules push the shape of the group, and France offers two regimes

          Profits are taxed where they arise, and again when they move up

          A subsidiary pays tax on its profit. When it pays a dividend to its parent, tax could be charged again, and again when the parent pays shareholders. Most countries relieve this for corporate parents. They also limit how much interest can be deducted and require intra-group prices to match what independent parties would charge, the arm's-length principle.

          A global minimum tax limits how far structure can lower the bill

          For decades, groups placed profit in low-tax countries through royalties, loans and holdings. Governments responded with transfer-pricing rules, reporting by country and limits on interest. The most important response is the OECD's Pillar Two, applied in the EU and many other countries, though not adopted by the United States. Large groups, with consolidated revenue of 750 million euros or more, must pay an effective tax of at least 15% in every country where they operate, measured country by country. Where the rate is lower, a top-up tax brings it to 15%. If the group's companies in one country pay only 10% on a profit of 100, the top-up is about 5, before a deduction the rules allow for local payroll and tangible assets. Harmony, with sales of 120 million, is far below the threshold. Velora, about ten times larger, is not.

          3.2 A bigger loss in Labs

          Labs loses 4.0 instead of 2.0, and Harmony still earns 10.0 before tax. Compute the tax paid with and without tax consolidation, and the saving. Then say in one sentence why the saving matters more to a start-up subsidiary than the ability to carry the loss forward.

          Without consolidation Harmony pays 2.5 and Labs pays nothing, and its loss is carried forward. With consolidation the group pays (10.0 − 4.0) × 25% = 1.5, a saving of 1.0 now. For a start-up that may not be profitable for years, an immediate saving is cash it would otherwise wait for, and perhaps never use.

          a small simulator of a failing Fleet. The learner drags Harmony's debt between the parent and the subsidiary, sets a minority stake from 0% to 49% and the asset value in failure. The tool shows how much each group of creditors recovers. The learner discovers that lenders to the parent are the ones who lose first, and that guarantees close the gap.

          3

          1. Fleet's assets would sell for 30.0. It owes its bank 6.0 and suppliers 4.0; minorities own 30%. How much reaches Harmony?

          2. Under the régime mère-fille, what is the effective tax rate on a dividend received from a qualifying subsidiary?

          3. Why do most large groups borrow at the parent and lend down to subsidiaries?

          4Taking the group apart: spin-offs, split-offs and carve-outs

          When the structure costs more than it earns, it can be reversed. The three main tools differ in who ends up holding what.

          Three ways to separate, and who receives what

          A spin-off hands the subsidiary to existing shareholders for nothing

          In a spin-off, the parent gives all the shares of a subsidiary to its own shareholders in proportion to their holdings. No cash changes hands. The parent no longer owns the subsidiary, which becomes an independent listed company. A split-off is similar, but shareholders choose: they hand back parent shares and receive subsidiary shares in exchange. A carve-out, as in Part 2, sells a minority stake for cash and keeps the rest.

          Value is created only if the separation removes a real cost

          A spin-off cannot create value by itself, since the shareholders get what they already owned. Value can come from three places: the conglomerate discount closes, each company's management focuses on its own business, and capital is allocated by each business's own prospects, not by a central committee. Research generally finds modest gains on announcement, but results vary a lot with the quality of the separation.

          Separation also costs money. There are one-off fees, a new head office and board for each company, lost purchasing power, lost tax consolidation and sometimes a worse credit rating for the smaller entity. The test is whether the gain exceeds the cost.

          1. 4.1 Why does a spin-off not change the total value of shareholders' holdings on the day it happens?

          2. 4.2 How does a split-off differ from a spin-off, and what happens to the number of parent shares?

          3. 4.3 A parent carves out 25% of a subsidiary and keeps trading with it. Which conflict of interest has it created?

          4

          1. Harmony (150.0, 12.5 million shares) spins off Fleet (30.0), one Fleet share for five Harmony shares. What is the Harmony share worth afterwards?

          2. In a split-off of Fleet, what happens to Harmony's share count?

          3. Closing the discount adds 12.0; the spin-off costs 3.0 once and 0.5 a year after tax (5.56 at 9%). What if the discount only half closes?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Conglomerate discount

          = ( − ) / SdP

          Economic interest down a chain

          =

          Control needs only a majority at each layer.

          From the group to Harmony’s shareholders

          = − −

          Before and after the sale, 126.0: nothing is created.

          Effective rate under the parent-subsidiary regime

          = ×

          Idea What to remember
          Diversification Shareholders can diversify alone, so they do not pay extra for a diversified firm.
          Conglomerate discount Sum of the parts minus group value, divided by the sum of the parts.
          Minority sale Cash comes in and a claim of equal value goes out. Value is moved, not created.
          EV to equity bridge Subtract net debt and the market value of minority interests.
          Chain of holdings Multiply the stakes to get the economic interest. Control needs only a majority at each layer.
          Holding discount A holding trades below its stakes because of running costs, liquidity and tax friction.
          Structural subordination Creditors of a subsidiary are paid before the parent's creditors can touch its equity.
          Where to borrow Usually at the top for simplicity, lower down for tax or ring-fencing.
          France Mère-fille makes dividends nearly tax-free. Intégration fiscale nets losses against profits at 95% ownership.
          Spin-off, split-off, carve-out Shares given, shares exchanged, minority sold for cash.

          The one-sentence version

          A group structure moves control, creditor rankings and tax between boxes without creating cash, so it earns its place only when the parts share something real, and it should be redrawn when the discount and the cost of separation tip the other way.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Conglomerate discount The gap between the sum of a group's parts valued separately and the group's market value.
          Pure play A company active in one business only.
          Minority interests The part of a consolidated subsidiary's equity and profit that belongs to outside shareholders.
          Holding company A company whose main assets are shares in other companies.
          Equity method Accounting for a 20% to 50% stake as one line of income, without adding sales, EBITDA or debt.
          Structural subordination The lower ranking of lenders to a parent compared with creditors of its subsidiaries.
          Arm's-length principle The rule that intra-group prices must match what independent parties would agree.
          Spin-off Distribution of a subsidiary's shares to the parent's shareholders.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the organisation of a group.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on governance and corporate restructuring.

          • OECD — Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy: Global Anti-Base Erosion Model Rules (Pillar Two), 2021.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.