What you will be able to do
Explain why a company lists, and name the conditions under which staying private is the better choice.
Size an offer: split it between new and existing shares, and read the effect on free float and ownership.
Build a valuation range from peers and show why the offer price is set below it.
Follow an IPO from bookbuilding to lock-up expiry and compute proceeds, costs and the cost of underpricing.
Describe the obligations of a listed company and the French route out of the market, the squeeze-out.
1Why list, and why not
Listing is a trade. The company gives up privacy and some control, and receives a market. The trade only pays when the company needs what a market sells.
A listing sells three things: capital, a price and a currency
Money is the obvious reason, but not the only one
A listed company can raise equity again and again, quickly and in large amounts. Harmony's own shareholders are a family-and-angels group, a venture fund and its founders. None of them can fund a second and third plant forever. A public market has thousands of investors with small amounts each, and they add up.
The second thing sold is a price. Once shares trade, the market produces a value every day. That helps in three ways: employees can be paid in shares worth something visible, acquisitions can be paid for with listed paper, and early investors have a way to sell. Northlight Ventures funded Harmony in 2019 and cannot hold the stake for ever, because a fund has a finite life.
Each benefit has a price that is paid every year
Disclosure. Accounts, forecasts that move the share price, major contracts and ownership changes must be published, for competitors to read.
Cost. Listing fees, auditors, investor relations, board and committee time, and the regulator's rules. A mid-sized company should plan for roughly one million euros a year.
Pressure. Quarterly or half-yearly results become events, and a share price is a daily verdict on management.
Control. New shareholders vote. Founders keep control only if they keep enough shares or use tools covered in CF35.
Listing suits growth that needs outside capital, not a company that is merely proud
The right moment is a mix of company readiness and market readiness
A company is ready when it has three or more years of audited accounts under IFRS or an equivalent standard, a predictable story, a finance team that can close the books quickly, and a board with independent members. It is not ready if one customer provides most of sales. The market must be ready too: IPO windows open and shut, as 2021 and 2022 showed, and a sale into a weak window cannot be undone.
Staying private is a serious option
Private equity and private credit now give large private companies plenty of capital. A company with no need for outside money, a founder who values control and a business that is hard to explain in a press release can be better off private. Some firms also run a dual track: they prepare for a listing and a sale to a buyer at the same time, and pick the better offer.
Your neighbour Chantal runs a pharmacy chain with 12 shops and her brother as a partner. A banker told her to float it for "the visibility". Explain to her, in plain words, what she would gain and what she would give up, and which question she should answer before agreeing.
Chantal: she gains capital, a price and credibility, but gives up privacy, time and some control, and must first ask whether she needs outside money. Naïma: the jump cost the company the gap between close and offer on every share sold; the price was set that way to attract buyers and signal confidence; a 40% jump would mean the company sold far too cheaply.
1.1 The size of the deal
Harmony lists 2.5 million new shares at 12.00. Compute the market value of the equity at the offer price before and after the sale, the money raised, and the net debt after the offer if all net proceeds go to the bank before any other spending. Costs are 4% of the money raised plus 1.3 million of other expenses. Then state Harmony's net debt to EBITDA after the plant spending of 12.5 million is also made.
Before: 10.0 × 12.00 = 120.0 million. After: 12.5 × 12.00 = 150.0 million. Money raised: 2.5 × 12.00 = 30.0 million. Direct costs: 4% × 30.0 = 1.2 million plus 1.3 million, or 2.5 million, so net proceeds are 27.5 million.
Net debt after the offer, before other spending: 30.0 − 27.5 = 2.5 million. After the plant spending of 12.5 million: 2.5 + 12.5 = 15.0 million. Net debt to EBITDA: 15.0 / 18.0 = 0.83 times, against 1.67 before.
a decision game with six sliders for a fictional company: funding need, founder wish to keep control, years of audited accounts, size of the biggest customer, market window, appetite for disclosure. A needle moves between stay private , dual track and list . The learner discovers that funding need and market window dominate, and that readiness alone never tips the answer.
1.2 Who receives the money when an existing shareholder sells shares in an IPO?
The selling shareholder receives the money. The company receives nothing, although it still pays its share of costs.
1.3 Name two costs of being listed that continue every year.
Any two of: audit and reporting upgrades, listing fees, investor relations, a larger board with committees, the time of management spent on results and roadshows.
1.4 Why can a company that is ready still be right to postpone?
A weak window means a lower price and a high discount, and a sale of shares cannot be reversed. If the company does not need the money at once, waiting costs little and a poor IPO costs a lot.
1
Harmony's listing raises 30.0 million from new shares. Who receives money paid for existing shares sold in an IPO?
Only primary shares bring cash to the company.
Right. The company receives cash only for the new shares.
It charges listing fees only.
They earn a commission, not the proceeds.
Claire estimates the yearly cost of being listed at 0.9 and the interest saved on 15.0 of repaid debt at 0.75. What follows?
Right. The running cost exceeds the saving by 0.15 a year.
The saving is smaller than the cost.
That does not answer why to list.
They recur every year.
Why might a company that is ready to list still be right to postpone?
It must become an SA.
Lock-ups apply after the IPO.
Right. If the money is not urgent, waiting costs little.
They do not.
2Preparing the offer and setting the price
Six months of work lie behind a few days of selling. The CFO has to sort out the story, the legal form, the valuation and the size.
The equity story has to survive an analyst's spreadsheet
Preparation is mostly about removing surprises
A typical timetable runs six to nine months. Work covers accounts audited on three years of history under IFRS, a corporate form suited to listing, governance with independent directors and committees, a clean group structure, a dividend policy and employee share plans.
The equity story is the argument for why the shares should be worth the price. For Harmony it is short: a European e-bike market growing faster than the economy, a premium brand with a loyal dealer network, margin gains from in-house battery packs (the CF24 project), and a credible plan for the second plant. Each claim must be backed by figures an analyst can check.
The offer price starts from peers and ends below them
A valuation range is built from comparable listed companies
Bankers value the company by two routes: a DCF (CF27) and the multiples of listed peers (CF28). Velora, the large listed competitor, trades at 10 times EBITDA. Harmony is a tenth of its size, less liquid and with fewer years as a public company, so the banks apply a discount of one turn and use 9.0 times.
Sizing means choosing between new shares and existing shares
Primary shares are new: the company receives the cash. Secondary shares are sold by existing holders, who receive the cash. A mixed offer does both. A growth company leans primary. A fund that must return money to its investors leans secondary. Investors look closely at who sells: a founder who sells heavily at the IPO sends the signal that the person who knows the business best thinks the price is high.
The offer also has to be big enough. The free float is the part of the shares held by the public and traded. A small float means few trades and wide price gaps, so large funds stay away. Harmony's primary offer gives a float of 2.5 / 12.5 = 20%, and a market value of 150.0 million.
| Holder | Before (million shares) | After IPO (million shares) | After IPO (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Founders | 4.0 | 4.0 | 32% |
| Northlight Ventures | 3.5 | 3.5 | 28% |
| Angels and family | 2.0 | 2.0 | 16% |
| Employees | 0.5 | 0.5 | 4% |
| New public investors | 0.0 | 2.5 | 20% |
| Total | 10.0 | 12.5 | 100% |
Harmony's ownership: the founders and Northlight keep 60% together, so control stays where it was.
2.1 A mixed offer
Northlight asks for a mixed offer: 1.5 million new shares and 1.0 million of its existing shares, all at 12.00. Compute the money raised by the company, the money received by Northlight, the shares in issue afterwards, the free float, Northlight's stake after the sale and the market value of the equity. Why might the market like this version less than the pure primary offer?
The company raises 1.5 × 12.00 = 18.0 million gross. Northlight receives 1.0 × 12.00 = 12.0 million. Shares in issue: 10.0 + 1.5 = 11.5 million. Float: 2.5 / 11.5 = 21.7%. Northlight holds 3.5 − 1.0 = 2.5 million shares, or 2.5 / 11.5 = 21.7%. Market value: 11.5 × 12.00 = 138.0 million.
Investors may like it less because the biggest outside investor sells part of its stake at the moment of listing, and the company raises 12.0 million less than in the pure primary offer, so the second plant has less money.
2.2 Harmony's EBITDA is 18.0 and the offer is priced at 8.3 times EBITDA. Is the offer price above or below the peer-based fair value, and by how much per share?
Fair value from peers is 13.20 per share, so 12.00 is below it by 1.20 per share, or 9.1%. The multiple at the offer price is 150.0 / 18.0 = 8.3 times, one turn under the 9.0 times used for fair value.
2.3 Why does an SAS convert before listing in France?
An SAS cannot offer shares to the public on a regulated market. It must become an SA, and its articles must allow free transfer of shares.
2.4 A shareholder sells 100% of his stake in the IPO. Why might investors worry?
Investors would suspect that the person who knows the business best thinks the price is high, and nothing keeps the seller engaged in the company's future. Lock-ups and partial sales ease the worry.
2
Velora trades at 10 times EBITDA; the banks use 9.0 times for Harmony (EBITDA 18.0, net debt 30.0, 10.0 million shares). What is fair value per share?
Right. (162.0 − 30.0) / 10.0.
That uses Velora's 10 times without the one-turn cut for size and liquidity.
That is the offer price, set below fair value.
That forgets to subtract net debt.
Northlight sells 1.0 million existing shares alongside 1.5 million new ones, all at 12.00. How much does Harmony raise?
That is what Northlight receives.
That is the net proceeds of the pure primary offer.
That counts Northlight's shares as well.
Right. Only the new shares bring cash to the company.
Why must Harmony, an SAS, convert before listing in France?
Right. Approval clauses and transfer limits must go.
Those are automatic in listed companies unless opted out.
The conversion is about the legal form for public offers.
The AMF approves the prospectus either way.
3Selling the shares and what it costs
The offer itself lasts one to two weeks. In that time the price is discovered, shares are handed out, and a few rules restrain everyone involved.
Bookbuilding discovers a price by asking investors to name theirs
The book turns interest into a price
After the regulator approves the prospectus, the banks publish a price range and hold a roadshow, meetings in which management present the story to investors. Investors then place orders: how many shares, at what price. These orders form the book. If the book is several times the number of shares on offer, the price can be set at the top of the range or above it. If demand is thin, the price falls or the deal is postponed.
Allocation is a judgement call. The company and banks prefer long-term holders over traders. Some deals bring cornerstone investors, funds that commit before the launch and give comfort to others. In France retail investors get a share through the offre à prix ouvert (OPO), an open-price offer for individuals, while institutions buy in the placement global garanti (guaranteed global placement).
A greenshoe protects the price in the first weeks
The banks sell up to 15% more shares than the base deal, creating a short position. This extra option, the greenshoe or over-allotment option, lets the banks buy those shares from the company at the offer price within about thirty days. If the price rises, they exercise the option and the company sells more. If it falls, they buy shares in the market, which supports the price, and the option is not used.
For Harmony, 15% of 2.5 million is 0.375 million shares. If the option is used in full the company sells 0.375 × 12.00 = 4.5 million euros more, the total reaches 34.5 million, and the shares in issue become 12.875 million. The free float is then 2.875 / 12.875 = 22.3%.
a greenshoe simulator. The learner moves a line for the share price over the first 30 days, and the page shows how the banks cover their short position: by exercising the option when the price is above 12.00, by buying in the market when it is below. The learner discovers that the greenshoe gives the issuer extra money in strong deals and gives the price a floor in weak ones.
3
Harmony's book shows orders for 10.0 million shares against 2.5 million on offer. What does that mean?
Right. Allocation scales back orders and favours long-term holders.
The offer size is fixed at 2.5 million (plus the greenshoe).
Orders are scaled back.
Banks also want holders who will not sell at the first rise.
The share closes at 13.00 on day one. What is the true cost of the IPO, as a share of the 30.0 raised?
Right. The visible fee is the smallest part.
That is only the underwriting commission.
That is the discount to fair value.
That is the underpricing or the direct costs alone.
The greenshoe is exercised in full. What is the free float afterwards?
That is before the option.
That is the size of the option relative to the base deal.
Right. 2.875 million public shares out of 12.875 million.
2.875 / 12.5 forgets the new shares in the denominator.
4Life after listing, and the way out
The IPO is the start of a permanent relationship with the market. The company has to earn the right to a good price every year, and the market can also take control away.
A listed company is valued all the time, and managers feel it
Disclosure and guidance create a discipline
A listed company must publish accounts, major events and ownership crossings. It also needs to decide how much to say about its future. Promise too much and targets are missed. Say too little and the shares trade at a discount. Claire's rule: give a range, then beat it.
The price also acts as an alarm. If Harmony's shares fall sharply, a predator can buy blocks. Founders and Northlight hold 60% and are safe for now, but if Northlight sells its 28% after the lock-up, control questions arise (CF35, CF38).
Leaving the market is possible, and the law protects those who are left
Companies delist because the market no longer earns its keep
A company may stop being listed if it does not need new funding, if its shares trade too little, if listed-company costs are heavy, or if a buyer wants it. A private equity fund, a strategic buyer or the main shareholder launches a takeover offer (CF38). If the offer succeeds, the buyer holds nearly all the shares and wants the rest. A squeeze-out is the right of a majority holder, once it crosses a high threshold, to force the remaining holders to sell at a fair price.
4
A bidder wants to delist Harmony with a 90% squeeze-out threshold. The founders and Northlight sell it their 7.5 million shares. How many more must it win?
7.5 million is 60%, far below 90%.
90% of 12.5 is 11.25, not 8.75.
Right. 11.25 − 7.5: most of the minority must tender.
Only 90% is needed.
What protects minority holders who are squeezed out in France?
Above the threshold, they cannot.
Right. The AMF oversees the procedure.
A squeeze-out forces them to sell.
The price is set at the time, with an expert opinion.
Founders and Northlight hold 60% after the IPO. When do control questions arise?
Right. The founders' 32% alone can be challenged by a buyer of blocks.
Double votes need two years of registered holding.
A falling price makes blocks cheaper to buy.
60% together keeps control for now.
Summary and cheat sheet
The module’s formulas
Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.
Fair value from peers
= ( × − ) /
Offer price 12.00: a discount of 1.20 / 13.20 = 9.1%.
True cost of an IPO
= + +
Free float after the greenshoe
= ( + ) / ( + n + g)
| Idea | What to remember |
|---|---|
| Why list | Capital, a visible price and credibility. The company pays with disclosure, cost, pressure and control. |
| When to list | Real funding need, audited track record, ready team, open market window. Waiting costs little. A bad window is costly. |
| Primary vs secondary | Primary shares bring cash to the company. Secondary shares bring cash to sellers. Heavy selling by insiders is a warning. |
| Valuation range | Peer multiples with an adjustment for size and liquidity, checked against a DCF. |
| IPO discount | A deliberate price below fair value, about 5 to 15%, that pays investors for the unknown. Harmony: 9.1%. |
| Bookbuilding | Investors state orders at prices. Coverage of the book guides the price and the allocation. |
| Greenshoe | An option on up to 15% more shares. It gives extra funds in strong deals and supports the price in weak ones. |
| Lock-up | Insiders agree not to sell for about 180 days. Expiry can create an overhang. |
| True cost | Fees, other costs and underpricing. Harmony: 5.0 on 30.0, or 16.7%. |
| Exit | Takeover then squeeze-out above a high threshold, with an expert opinion on price. |
The one-sentence version
An IPO buys permanent access to public capital and a visible price, and the company pays for it in fees, a deliberate discount, disclosure and exposure to a change of control, so list only when the access is worth more than the bill.
Key terms
| Term | Plain-language meaning |
|---|---|
| IPO | The first sale of a company's shares to the public, followed by trading on an exchange. |
| Free float | The proportion of shares held by the public and available for trading. |
| Primary offer | New shares sold by the company, which receives the cash. |
| Secondary offer | Existing shares sold by current holders, who receive the cash. |
| Bookbuilding | Collecting investors' orders at different prices to set the offer price and allocate shares. |
| Greenshoe | The banks' option to buy up to about 15% more shares at the offer price to cover over-allotment. |
| Lock-up | A promise by insiders not to sell their shares for a set period. |
| Squeeze-out | The right of a holder above a high threshold to force remaining holders to sell at a fair price. |
Going further
Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the initial public offering.
Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapter on how corporations issue securities.
Ritter, J. — Initial Public Offerings, work on underpricing and long-run performance, available on the author's academic pages.
Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.