Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial policy / Module 32

32Raising equity

What selling new shares does to the people who already own the company

What selling new shares does to the people who already own the company.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
12
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Compute the share price after a capital increase and say who gains or loses value at any issue price.

  • Separate dilution of value from dilution of control, and compute both.

  • Run a rights issue: subscription ratio, theoretical ex-rights price and value of a right.

  • Show that the size of the discount in a rights issue does not change a shareholder's wealth.

  • Explain why an issue can raise earnings per share and still destroy value, and why the share price often falls on the announcement.

  • Compare the main routes for selling new shares and the French rules that govern them.

1What selling new shares does to old and new owners

Before any technique, the arithmetic of a sale of shares. Two things move: value and control. Keep them apart and the rest of the module follows.

New shares shrink your slice, not necessarily your wealth

A company that sells shares at their fair value is swapping cash for a slice of itself

Suppose Harmony sells 2.5 million new shares at 12.00, the current price. It raises 30.0 million. After the sale it holds that cash on top of what it owned before, so its equity is worth 150.0 + 30.0 = 180.0 million. Spread over 15.0 million shares, each is still worth 12.00.

A holder of 100 shares owned 1,200 before and owns 1,200 after. What changed is the size of the slice. Before the sale the holder owned 1 / 12.5 million of the company. After it, 1 / 15 million. The existing holders together now own 12.5 / 15 = 83.3% of the shares. This shrinking of ownership is dilution.

Price after = (old shares × old price + new shares × issue price) / (old shares + new shares)

The numerator is the value of the company before the issue plus the cash raised; the denominator is the new number of shares. Value before the issue is called pre-money (150.0 million here); value after, including the new cash, is post-money (180.0 million).

Selling below the market price hands value to the buyers

Now suppose Harmony sells the same 2.5 million shares at 10.00, to one new investor. It raises 25.0 million, so post-money value is 150.0 + 25.0 = 175.0 million and the price after the sale is 175.0 / 15.0 = 11.67. Every old share has lost 0.33.

The old holders lose 12.5 million × 0.33 = 4.17 million. The new investor paid 25.0 million for shares worth 2.5 million × 11.67 = 29.17 million, a gain of 4.17 million. Value has moved from one group to the other.

Control dilutes at any price

Your share of the votes falls even when your wealth does not

Votes follow shares. Assume Harmony's IPO sold only new shares. If the 2.5 million new shares go to outsiders, every existing stake shrinks in the same proportion, whatever the price.

Holder Shares (million) Stake now Stake after the issue
Founders 4.0 32.0% 26.7%
Northlight Ventures 3.5 28.0% 23.3%
Angels and family 2.0 16.0% 13.3%
Employees 0.5 4.0% 3.3%
Public shareholders from the IPO 2.5 20.0% 16.7%
New investor 2.5 0.0% 16.7%

Ownership of Harmony before and after a sale of 2.5 million new shares to outsiders

So there are two kinds of dilution. Value dilution happens when the issue price is too low. Control dilution happens when new shares go to someone else. Part 2 shows a technique that removes the first for everyone and lets each owner avoid the second by paying.

1.1 A small placement below the market

Harmony sells 1.0 million new shares at 11.00 to a single investor. Compute the price per share after the sale, the loss to the old holders in total, the gain to the new investor, and the old holders' combined stake.

The company is worth 150.0 + 11.0 = 161.0 million over 13.5 million shares, so the price falls to 11.93. The old holders lose 12.5 million × (12.00 − 11.93) = 0.93 million. The new investor paid 11.0 million for shares worth 1.0 million × 11.93 = 11.93 million, a gain of 0.93 million.

The old holders keep 12.5 / 13.5 = 92.6% of the votes.

Your uncle Karim owns 10% of a family firm that plans to bring in an outside investor with new shares. He says: "My percentage can only go down, so I can only lose." Explain to him, without the word dilution, what can go down, what does not have to, and which single number he should check in the offer.

      Karim: what goes down is his percentage of votes and of profits. His wealth does not have to fall: it falls only if the new shares are sold below their fair value. The number to check is the issue price against the value per share after the new money.

      Sofia: the fall may reflect investors' worry about why the company needs money, or simply the mechanical drop when rights detach. The new shareholders did not cause it. She needs to know which of the two it is, and what the cash is for.

      a slider for the issue price of Harmony's 2.5 million new shares, from 6.00 to 12.00. Two bars update live: the value transferred from old to new holders, and each holder's stake. The learner discovers that the transfer reaches zero at 12.00 while the ownership percentages never move, because control and value depend on different things.

      1

      1. Harmony (12.5 million shares at 12.00) sells 2.5 million new shares at 10.00 to one investor. The price after the issue is…

      2. In that issue at 10.00, the old holders lose…

      3. Harmony sells 2.5 million shares at exactly 12.00 to a strategic partner. Which dilution occurs?

      2The rights issue: owners buy first

      The classic way to raise equity from existing owners protects their wealth by giving them tradable coupons. The mechanism is short, and the numbers are always the same.

      A rights issue offers the new shares to existing owners first

      A right is a coupon that is worth something because the new shares are cheap

      In a rights issue the company offers the new shares to its current shareholders, in proportion to what they hold, at a subscription price below the market price. Each existing share carries one right. A stated ratio tells how many rights are needed to buy one new share. Rights can usually be sold on the market during the offer, so a holder who does not want to subscribe can still collect their value.

      Harmony offers 1 new share for every 5 held, at 10.00. That is 12.5 / 5 = 2.5 million new shares and 25.0 million of cash. The subscription price is a 16.7% discount to the market price of 12.00.

      After the issue the price drops to a weighted average, the theoretical ex-rights price

      Once the new shares exist, the company is worth 150.0 + 25.0 = 175.0 million, spread over 15.0 million shares. The result, 11.67, is the theoretical ex-rights price (TERP): the price one would expect after the rights have been detached. The fall from 12.00 is the value of a right.

      TERP = (N × P + n × S) / (N + n) Value of a right = P − TERP = (P − S) / (ratio + 1)

      N and n are the old and new shares, P the price before and S the subscription price. The ratio is 5 old shares per new one. For Harmony the value of a right is (12.00 − 10.00) / 6 = 0.33.

      Whatever a shareholder does, wealth is the same, except by doing nothing

      The size of the discount is a distraction

      A deeper discount means more rights, each worth more, and the same wealth

      Change one thing: Harmony sets the subscription price at 8.00 instead of 10.00, still 1 new share for 5. It now raises 2.5 million × 8.00 = 20.0 million. The company is worth 170.0 million over 15.0 million shares, so the TERP is 11.33 and each right is worth 0.67.

      A holder of 100 shares who subscribes buys 20 shares for 160.00. Their 120 shares are worth 120 × 11.33 = 1,360.00, so wealth is 1,360.00 − 160.00 = 1,200.00. A holder who sells collects 66.67 and keeps 100 shares worth 1,133.33: again 1,200.00. The discount changed the numbers and not the outcome.

      Control stays with those who put in cash

      Taking up rights keeps the stake; selling them keeps the money

      A shareholder who wants to keep their percentage must buy their share of the new shares. A shareholder who wants cash sells rights and accepts a smaller percentage. The table shows the choice for the two largest holders in the 1 for 5 issue at 10.00.

      A deeper discount means more new shares: raising 25.0 million at 8.00 takes 3.125 million shares (1 for 4), giving a TERP of 11.20, and Northlight would end at 3.5 / 15.625 = 22.4% instead of 23.3% if it sold its rights. Wealth is the same; votes are not.

      Holder Stake now Cost to keep the stake Stake if rights are sold Cash from selling rights
      Founders (4.0 million shares) 32.0% 8.0 million 26.7% 1.33 million
      Northlight (3.5 million shares) 28.0% 7.0 million 23.3% 1.17 million

      Large holders' choices are watched: subscribing shows confidence, and selling rights is noticed (Part 3).

      2.1 The angels decide

      The angels and family hold 2.0 million Harmony shares. In the 1 for 5 rights issue at 10.00, compute the cash they receive by selling all their rights, their stake after selling, the cash needed to subscribe in full, and their stake if they do.

      The right is worth 0.33. Selling 2.0 million rights brings in 2.0 million × 0.33 = 0.67 million, and the stake falls to 2.0 / 15.0 = 13.3%.

      To subscribe in full they need 0.4 million new shares (2.0 / 5) at 10.00, so 4.0 million. The stake then becomes 2.4 / 15.0 = 16.0%, unchanged.

      a rights-issue simulator with sliders for the subscription price (6.00 to 12.00) and the ratio (1 for 10 to 1 for 2). It shows the TERP, the value of a right and the wealth of a holder of 100 shares who subscribes, sells, partly sells or does nothing. The learner discovers that only doing nothing loses wealth, and that price and ratio change only the share count.

      2

      1. A 1 for 5 rights issue at 10.00 with the share at 12.00 gives a TERP of…

      2. A holder of 100 shares lets the rights lapse in that issue. Their wealth…

      3. Lowering the subscription price from 10.00 to 8.00, same ratio, changes…

      3What the market and the EPS line say about an issue

      A fairly priced issue should leave value untouched. Two readings of it still matter: earnings per share and the signal sent by the announcement.

      Earnings per share fall mechanically; the question is whether they recover

      More shares divide the same profit unless the cash earns something

      Assume Harmony earns net income of 9.0 million in the year of the issue. With 12.5 million shares, earnings per share (EPS) are 0.72 and the price of 12.00 is 16.7 times earnings. After the 1 for 5 issue there are 15.0 million shares. If the 25.0 million sat idle, EPS would fall to 9.0 / 15.0 = 0.60, which is 16.7% lower.

      If the cash goes into the plant and earns a return r after tax:

      EPS after = (E + r × proceeds) / (N + n)

      The issue raises EPS exactly when the new profit per new share, r × S, is above the old EPS. With S = 10.00 and old EPS of 0.72, the break-even return is 0.72 / 10.00 = 7.2%. That is the earnings yield at the issue price.

      Return on the 25.0 million, after tax Profit added (million) EPS after Change in EPS
      Idle cash (0%) 0.00 0.60 −16.7%
      6.0% 1.50 0.70 −2.8%
      7.2% 1.80 0.72 0.0%
      8.0% 2.00 0.73 +1.9%
      9.0% 2.25 0.75 +4.2%

      EPS accretion is not value creation

      The EPS test compares the project's return with the earnings yield of the share, here 7.2%. The right yardstick is the return investors require, 9% for Harmony's ordinary projects (CF25). The earnings yield understates it because the price already includes expected growth. Between 7.2% and 9.0% an issue lifts EPS and lowers value (see CF23).

      The market reads the announcement, and the average message is bad

      If the money is well used, the price rises before the shares are sold

      Markets price expectations. If investors believe the German plant will have a net present value of +3.0 million, they raise Harmony's value by that amount on the day they learn of it, before a single new share is sold.

      The act of issuing is itself a message

      Managers know more than outsiders. If they think the shares are expensive, selling new ones suits existing owners. Investors know this, so an issue is read as a hint that shares may be overvalued or that cash and debt capacity are short. On average, studies of listed companies find a negative share price reaction of a few percent. This is the pecking-order argument of CF29.

      Suppose Harmony's price falls 4% at the announcement, from 12.00 to 11.52. The market value of the old shares drops by 150.0 × 4% = 6.0 million. This signalling cost falls on the old holders even though the issue price is fair.

      3.1 Accretive, but is it worth it?

      Harmony's German plant could earn 7.5% after tax on the 25.0 million, in perpetuity. Compute EPS after the 1 for 5 issue, say whether the issue is accretive, and compute the NPV at 9%. What do the two answers tell the board?

      EPS after: (9.0 + 0.075 × 25.0) / 15.0 = 10.875 / 15.0 = 0.725, above 0.72, so the issue is accretive.

      A perpetual 1.875 million a year is worth 1.875 / 0.09 = 20.83 million for a cost of 25.0, so the NPV is −4.17 million. EPS improves and value is destroyed because 7.5% sits between the 7.2% bar and the 9% cost of capital.

      1. 3.2 Why do EPS fall if the new cash is not invested?

      2. 3.3 Harmony's price falls 4% on a fairly priced issue. Who bears the loss, and how much?

      3. 3.4 The price rises to 12.24 when investors learn of the plant. Who keeps that gain if the 1 for 5 issue at 10.00 follows?

      Your friend Sofia reads a headline: "Shares fall 4% on rights issue, shareholders lose billions." She asks whether the new shareholders caused it. Explain what the fall can and cannot mean, and which two facts she needs before saying shareholders lost anything real.

          a slider for the after-tax return on the 25.0 million, from 0% to 15%, driving two gauges. One shows EPS after the issue against the 0.72 baseline; the other shows the NPV at 9%. The learner discovers a zone, 7.2% to 9.0%, where EPS rises and value falls, and sees why the two measures part company.

          3

          1. With S = 10.00 and old EPS of 0.72, the issue is accretive when the plant earns more than…

          2. The plant earns 8.0% after tax. EPS rises to 0.73. The NPV at 9% is…

          3. Investors learn of a plant with NPV +3.0 and the price rises to 12.24 before a 1 for 5 rights issue at 10.00. Who keeps the 3.0?

          4Routes, costs and rules

          The same 25 million can be raised in several ways. Each one fixes who may buy, what discount is needed and who has to approve it.

          Five routes trade speed against fairness to existing owners

          The route decides who may buy and how much discount is needed

          Mechanics belong to CF22 and, from the banker's side, to the ECM module of this site. Here the question is what each route does to owners.

          Route Who can buy Discount to market Speed Effect on existing owners
          Rights issue Existing holders first Deep, as a safety margin Weeks Value protected; control kept if they pay
          Public offer without rights Anyone Moderate Days to weeks Value and control both diluted
          Accelerated bookbuilding Institutions, chosen overnight Small Hours to one day Value diluted by the discount; control diluted
          Reserved issue One named investor Negotiated Negotiated Large shift of control; price must be fair
          At-the-market programme Anyone, through the stock market Near zero Continuous Small steps; very little discount

          Routes for selling new shares by a listed company

          The true cost of a placement is the discount plus the fees

          Banks charge a fee, assumed here at 3% of the money raised. Return to the placement of 2.5 million shares at 10.00. The fee is 25.0 × 3% = 0.75 million, so the company keeps 24.25 million. Equity value after is 150.0 + 24.25 = 174.25 million, a price of 11.62, and the old holders lose 12.5 million × (12.00 − 11.62) = 4.79 million.

          4.1 The overnight placement

          Harmony chooses an accelerated bookbuilding instead: 2.5 million shares at 11.40, a 5% discount, with fees of 2% of the money raised. Compute the cash raised, the fee, the price per share after the issue and the total loss to the old holders. Then say what Northlight gives up compared with a rights issue.

          Cash raised: 2.5 × 11.40 = 28.5 million. Fee: 2% × 28.5 = 0.57 million. Net cash 27.93 million, so equity is worth 177.93 million over 15.0 million shares: 11.86. The old holders lose 12.5 × (12.00 − 11.862) = 1.72 million, discount and fees together.

          Northlight gets no rights, so it cannot subscribe, and its stake goes from 28.0% to 23.3% with no cash in return. A rights issue would have let it keep 28.0% for 7.0 million or take 1.17 million for its rights. The placement is cheaper and quicker, but removes the owners' choice.

          The law decides who must be asked

          Pre-emption is a default that shareholders can set aside

          In the European Union the rule is that existing shareholders have a pre-emptive right when new shares are issued for cash, unless the shareholders themselves waive it by vote, after a report from the board explaining why. This waiver is what makes routes such as accelerated bookbuilding possible.

          Public offers generally need an approved prospectus, with exemptions for smaller issues and, since recent EU reforms, for many follow-on issues by companies already listed.

          1. 4.2 Harmony sells 2.5 million shares at exactly 12.00 to a strategic partner. Which dilution does it cause, and which does it not?

          2. 4.3 Why can an overnight placement use a smaller discount than a rights issue?

          3. 4.4 Why does French law cap the discount on a public offer without DPS?

          4

          1. Harmony places 2.5 million shares at 11.40 overnight with a 2% fee. The old holders lose…

          2. What does Northlight give up in a placement compared with a rights issue?

          3. Why can an overnight placement use a smaller discount than a rights issue?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Price after a capital increase

          = ( + ) / (N + n)

          The same formula gives the TERP of a rights issue.

          Value of a right

          = ( − ) / ( + 1)

          EPS test of an issue

          accretive if >

          Value-creating only if r beats the 9% cost of capital.

          Cost of an issue to the old holders

          = × ( − )

          4.04 goes to the new investor, 0.75 to the banks.

          Idea What to remember
          Capital increase The company sells new shares for cash. Wealth moves only if the price is wrong; control dilutes in any case.
          Price after an issue (old shares × old price + new shares × issue price) / total shares. Cash raised is added to value.
          Control dilution Fall in each holder's share of votes. Avoided only by subscribing.
          Rights issue New shares offered first to existing holders in proportion to their holdings, with tradable rights.
          TERP (N × P + n × S) / (N + n). The expected price once the rights are detached.
          Value of a right P − TERP, or (P − S) / (ratio + 1). Compensation for the cheap subscription price.
          Discount in a rights issue A safety margin that sets the number of shares, not the holders' wealth.
          EPS test EPS rises if the return on the new money exceeds EPS / issue price. A lower bar than the cost of capital.
          Signalling cost Average negative share price reaction of a few percent when an issue is announced.
          Routes Rights issue, public offer, accelerated bookbuilding, reserved issue, at-the-market programme: speed against fairness.

          The one-sentence version

          Selling new shares at a fair price swaps cash for a slice of the company without changing what the old owners are worth, so judge an issue by the price, the use of the money and the signal it sends, never by the fall in the percentage held or the rise in EPS.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Dilution The fall in an owner's percentage of the company when new shares are created.
          Pre-money / post-money The value of the company before and after the new cash is added.
          Right A tradable coupon given to each existing share, allowing its holder to buy new shares at the subscription price.
          Subscription price The price at which new shares are offered to those who hold rights.
          TERP The theoretical price of an existing share after the rights have been detached.
          Accretive Raising EPS. It says nothing on whether value is created.
          Signalling cost The fall in share price caused by what investors infer from the decision to issue.
          Accelerated bookbuilding A fast placement of new shares with chosen investors, often overnight.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on cash capital increases.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on how corporations issue securities and on financing and valuation.

          • Myers and Majluf (1984) — Corporate financing and investment decisions when firms have information that investors do not have, Journal of Financial Economics.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.