Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial securities / Module 22

22How securities are sold

How a company gets shares and bonds into investors' hands at a fair price

How a company gets shares and bonds into investors’ hands at a fair price.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
17
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why securities are sold through banks, and what the four bank jobs are.

  • Read an order book and say why an issuer picks one price rather than another.

  • Work out the all-in cost of an equity offering, including underpricing.

  • Compute the value of a right and the ex-rights price in a rights issue, and compare it with a placement and a block trade.

  • Compare a public bond, a private placement and a loan on all-in cost.

1Banks are paid to close the information gap and to carry risk

Every technique solves one problem: the seller knows more than the buyer, and someone has to stand between them.

Investors cannot check what the issuer knows

The seller always knows more than the buyer

Harmony's managers know how many frames failed inspection last quarter and which dealers pay late. A fund manager in Frankfurt sees a brochure and accounts. If she suspects the seller is hiding something, she offers less, to honest issuers too, because she cannot tell them apart.

Three devices narrow the gap: a legal document that makes the issuer liable, independent checks by auditors and analysts, and a bank that puts its reputation behind the deal.

The prospectus is the issuer's legal statement of what investors were told

A prospectus describes the business, the risks, the accounts, the use of the money and the terms of the securities. In the EU a public offer or a listing normally needs one, approved beforehand by the national authority. The approval is not a verdict that the investment is good. It says the document is complete and understandable.

Issuer and directors answer for misstatements, which is why the risk section reads so gloomily.

The bank does four jobs, and they pull in different directions

Structuring, informing, distributing and underwriting are separate jobs

  • Structuring. Choosing the instrument, size, timing and technique.

  • Informing. Due diligence, drafting, the equity story, briefing analysts.

  • Distributing. Calling likely buyers and collecting their orders.

  • Underwriting. Promising the issuer a price and taking the risk of unsold securities.

Large deals use a syndicate. Global coordinators lead, bookrunners collect orders and set the price with the issuer, and smaller co-managers add distribution and share the fee.

The bank serves two customers whose interests collide

The issuer wants the highest price. The investors, who are also the bank's clients, want a price that lets them make money. The issuer's protection is practical: appoint more than one bank, and read the pricing logic instead of accepting it.

The commitment level decides who carries the risk

Underwriting moves the risk of a failed sale from the issuer to the bank

Technique Who carries the risk of unsold securities Typical use
Firm commitment The bank, from the moment the price is set IPOs and large bond issues, signed once the book is built (in a bought deal, before any marketing)
Best efforts The issuer. The bank only tries Small or difficult issues
Back-stop The bank buys what shareholders do not take Rights issues

Direct costs are visible, but they are the smaller part of the bill

Lawyers, auditors and listing fees add to the spread

1.1 A dearer syndicate

Suppose the banks had asked for a 5.0% gross spread and other costs had been 1.5 million. Compute the net proceeds of the 30.0 million IPO and the direct cost as a percentage of the gross amount.

Spread: 5.0% × 30.0 = 1.50, plus other costs of 1.50, gives 3.00. Net proceeds are 30.0 − 3.00 = 27.0 million. Direct cost is 3.00 / 30.0 = 10.0%, against 8.3% in the base case.

Amira runs a restaurant group and is thinking of selling a stake to investors. She asks: why pay a bank 4% of the money raised, when I could post an offer and sell the shares myself? Answer her without using the words underwriting or syndicate.

      The bank does three things she cannot. It knows who is likely to buy and can reach them in days. Its name tells strangers the numbers were checked. And it promises a price and takes the loss if the sale goes badly. Selling alone, she would face suspicious buyers and the risk that nobody turns up.

      1

      1. Why do investors offer less for securities when they cannot check what the issuer knows?

      2. In a firm commitment, when does the bank carry the risk of unsold shares?

      3. Harmony's IPO pays a 4.0% spread on 12.00. What do the banks pay Harmony per share?

      2An IPO finds its price by asking investors, not by calculating it

      The valuation methods of CF27 and CF28 give a range. Bookbuilding turns that range into one price, using the orders of the people who will pay it.

      The process takes months, and the price is set in a few days

      The weeks of preparation are about information, not selling

      • Months before: choose banks, run due diligence, write the prospectus, obtain approval.

      • Investors receive a price range. Harmony's is 11.50 to 12.50.

      • A roadshow of one or two weeks, then bookbuilding, pricing and allocation.

      • About thirty days of price support by the banks, and later the lock-up expiry.

      Harmony's IPO is entirely primary: 2.5 million new shares, with the money going to the company, taking the count from 10.0 to 12.5 million. A secondary tranche would be existing shares sold by current holders, who would keep the money.

      Bookbuilding turns orders into a demand curve

      Each order says how many shares at which price

      An investor places an order with a limit price, the most she will pay. Adding orders from the highest limit downward gives the number of shares wanted at each price or lower: a demand curve built from real commitments.

      With 6.0 million shares demanded and 2.5 million on offer, investors are scaled back. The allocation is not pro rata: issuer and banks favour holders who stay for years over those who buy to sell on the first morning.

      Sizing tools let the deal flex, and a lock-up protects the aftermarket

      The greenshoe lets the banks sell more than the base deal and cover either way

      An extension option lets the issuer sell more shares if demand is strong. A greenshoe, or over-allotment option, works differently. The banks sell up to 15% more shares than the base deal, borrowing them from a shareholder, and hold an option to buy the same number back at the offer price for about thirty days.

      The lock-up keeps insiders from selling into the first weeks

      Northlight, the founders and the employees agree not to sell for a period, commonly several months and sometimes a year. When it ends, the market knows a large holder can sell. That risk is the overhang, and it often weighs on the price beforehand.

      Underpricing is the largest cost of an IPO, and it is deliberate

      Shares sold at 12.00 that trade at 13.20 mean Harmony left money behind

      On average, IPO shares close their first day above the offer price. Suppose Harmony closes at 13.20, up 10%. The 2.5 million shares sold at 12.00 were worth 13.20, so Harmony gave up 2.5 × 1.20 = 3.0 million to the buyers.

      Issuers accept this because investors who reveal what they would pay need a reward, and a deal that trades up makes the next one easier.

      2.1 Should Harmony price at the top?

      The banks suggest pricing at 12.50, the top of the range. Compute the proceeds and coverage, and give one reason Harmony's CFO might still prefer 12.00.

      At 12.50 proceeds are 2.5 × 12.50 = 31.25 million, 1.25 million more, and coverage is 3.0 / 2.5 = 1.2×. A reason to prefer 12.00: coverage of 2.4× leaves a reserve of buyers if the market turns, while a thin book often trades below the offer price in week one, which upsets the long-term investors Harmony wants. A reserve of buyers is worth more than the extra 1.25 million.

      Paul is a retired teacher who reads the financial pages. He says: an IPO that rose 10% on day one was a triumph, so why do you say the company lost out? Explain what happened to the money, and why companies accept it.

          Imagine selling a house to a buyer who resells it next morning for 10% more. You got your price, but he made the gain on your house. Harmony's shares sold at 12.00 were worth 13.20 a day later, so 3.0 million went to the buyers.

          Companies accept a small rise as the reward for an honest price. A large one means the company was too generous.

          a bookbuilding simulator. The learner sees Harmony's order book and drags a price line between 11.50 and 12.50. The page shows proceeds, coverage and an estimate of the first-day move. The learner discovers that a higher price raises proceeds but thins the reserve of demand.

          1. 2.3 Why do banks allocate shares to investors who want to hold, rather than strictly in proportion to orders?

          2. 2.4 If the greenshoe is exercised in full, who receives the extra money in the Harmony example?

          3. 2.5 A fund manager will not buy in the IPO because the lock-up ends in 90 days. What worries her?

          2

          1. Harmony's book shows 3.0 million shares wanted at 12.50, 6.0 million at 12.00, for 2.5 million offered. Why price at 12.00?

          2. Harmony's shares, sold at 12.00, close day one at 13.20. What did Harmony give up?

          3. What does a greenshoe let the banks do?

          3A listed company can raise equity in days, with its shareholders or around them

          After the IPO, three routes are open: a rights issue, a placement and a block trade. They differ in who receives the money, who pays the discount and how fast it is done.

          A rights issue lets existing shareholders buy first, so a discount costs them nothing

          Each share carries a right to subscribe at a fixed price

          In a rights issue every shareholder receives tradable rights in proportion to the shares held. A set number of rights allows the holder to buy one new share at a subscription price below the market. The holder can use the rights, sell them or let them lapse.

          The deep discount does not matter by itself. The cheaper the new shares, the lower the share price falls and the more each right is worth. CF32 explains the effect on ownership and value in full.

          If Harmony's share fell below 10.40 during the subscription period, nobody would use the rights and the issue would fail. Banks therefore back-stop it for a fee, for instance 2.0% of 26.0 million, or 0.52 million. In effect they have sold Harmony a put at 10.40, and they price the fee like one.

          A placement is faster, but the discount goes to the new investors

          Selling to a few institutions skips the subscription period

          In a placement Harmony sells new shares to institutions chosen by the banks, often overnight, at a discount of a few per cent. Orders are collected for a few hours after the market closes, in an accelerated bookbuilding. Existing shareholders do not take part.

          A block trade sells existing shares, and the company receives nothing

          Large holders sell overnight at a discount, with a bank taking the risk

          After the lock-up, Northlight wants to cut its stake. Selling slowly would take months and move the price. It sells a block in one night. The bank either buys the block at a fixed price, a bought deal, or collects orders in a few hours and sets the price by accelerated bookbuilding.

          Route New money for Harmony? Speed Who bears the discount Typical constraint
          Rights issue Yes, large Weeks Nobody who takes part Subscription period, back-stop
          Placement Yes, moderate Overnight Holders who stay out Shareholder approval, size limits
          Block trade No Overnight The seller Lock-up, market signal

          3.1 A different rights issue

          Harmony's share trades at 13.00. It plans a rights issue of one new share for every four held, at 9.00. Compute the number of new shares, the amount raised, the theoretical ex-rights price and the value of one right. What happens to a shareholder with 400 shares who does nothing?

          New shares: 12.5 / 4 = 3.125 million. Raised: 3.125 × 9.00 = 28.125 million. Ex-rights price: (4 × 13.00 + 9.00) / 5 = 12.20. One right: 13.00 − 12.20 = 0.80.

          A holder of 400 shares who does nothing owns shares worth 400 × 12.20 = 4,880 instead of 5,200. He loses 320, the value of his 400 rights. Selling them would have recovered it.

          a slider for the subscription price in Harmony's one-for-five rights issue, from 8.00 to 12.50. The page redraws the amount raised, the ex-rights price and the value of a right, and shows a shareholder's wealth if he subscribes, sells the rights or does nothing. The learner discovers that the discount changes the cash raised and the share price, but not the wealth of anyone who acts.

          1. 3.3 Why does a bigger discount in a rights issue not hurt a shareholder who takes part?

          2. 3.4 Why must the bank in a block trade be paid for risk when the sale is over in one night?

          3. 3.5 Harmony wants cash within 24 hours. Which route does it take, and who pays the discount?

          3

          1. In Harmony's one-for-five rights issue at 10.40 with the share at 13.00, what is one right worth?

          2. Harmony places 10% of its capital overnight at a 5% discount. Who bears the discount?

          3. After the lock-up, Northlight sells 1.0 million Harmony shares in a block at 12.35. What does Harmony receive?

          4Debt is sold on spread, to fewer and more specialised buyers

          A bond buyer does not ask what a share is worth. She asks how much more than the safe rate she will be paid, and whether the issuer can pay it back.

          A bond is priced as a spread over a reference rate, tightened as demand builds

          The first price is a guess and the book moves it

          A bond's cost is quoted as a spread over a benchmark, typically the swap rate of the same maturity. The banks give the market initial price thoughts, a spread with room to tighten. If the book builds, they narrow the range and then announce a final spread. Demand lowers the issuer's cost, as it raises the price in an IPO.

          A public benchmark bond is generally large and rated, so a 30 million deal does not fit it. Harmony needs another route.

          A private placement trades size and liquidity for speed and discretion

          A handful of investors can lend without a public book

          In a private placement, the issuer sells notes to a few institutions, such as insurers and credit funds, which keep them to maturity. Terms are negotiated, there is no public prospectus, and a rating may not be needed.

          4.1 Placement or bank loan?

          The arranger had asked for fees of 0.40 million instead of 0.25. A bank offers a loan at 5.30% with no fee. Compute the all-in cost of the placement and say which financing is cheaper.

          Net proceeds are 30.0 − 0.40 = 29.60. The rate that equates 29.60 with four coupons of 1.5 and a final 31.5 is 5.31%. The loan costs 5.30% with no fee, so the two are about equal and the loan is marginally cheaper. The placement could still win on maturity, covenants or diversity of lenders.

          Bank loans are the main alternative and can be arranged in weeks, with covenants. The Corporate Banking Financing modules give the banker's view, CF18 compares the whole debt menu and CF33 shows how to design it.

          The right route depends on size, speed and how much disclosure the board accepts

          Compare routes on all-in cost, not on the quoted rate

          Route Buyers Typical size Speed Disclosure
          Public bond Many institutions Large Days once documents exist High, with prospectus
          Private placement A few institutions Small to medium Weeks Low
          Bank loan One bank or a syndicate Any Weeks Low

          a decision game. The learner receives six financing needs for Harmony and Velora, each with amount, deadline and willingness to disclose, and chooses the route. The page scores the choice and shows the all-in cost of the right answer and of the choice made. The learner discovers that the cheapest quoted rate is not always the cheapest route.

          4

          1. How is the cost of a new corporate bond usually quoted?

          2. Why does a public benchmark bond not suit Harmony's 30 million debt raise?

          3. A placement costs 5.00% plus 0.40 of fees on 30.0; a bank loan costs 5.30% with no fee. Which is cheaper?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Theoretical ex-rights price

          = ( × + ) / (n + 1)

          One right is worth 13.00 − 12.57 = 0.43.

          Money left on the table

          = × ( − )

          All-in cost of an IPO

          = ( + U) / (N × P₁)

          (2.50 + 3.0) / 33.0 = 16.7%, twice the 8.3% direct bill.

          All-in cost of debt

          = Σ / (1 + )ᵗ + A / (1 + y)ⁿ

          Idea What to remember
          Four bank jobs Structuring, informing, distributing and underwriting. The bank also serves investors, so read its pricing.
          Firm commitment The bank buys at an agreed price and carries unsold risk. The fee pays for it.
          Bookbuilding Investors give orders with limit prices, giving a demand curve and a price with a reserve of buyers.
          Greenshoe Banks over-allot up to 15% and cover with the option or in the market, which supports the price.
          Underpricing IPO shares usually close above the offer price. The gap is money left behind, often the largest cost.
          Rights issue Shareholders buy first at a discount. Those who act lose nothing to it.
          Placement and block A placement is a fast sale of new shares and existing holders pay the discount. A block sells old shares and gives the company nothing.
          Bond pricing A spread over a benchmark that narrows as the book builds. Small issuers use private placements or loans.
          All-in cost Include fees and discounts, not only the coupon or the headline price.

          The one-sentence version

          Banks close the information gap and carry risk, investors' orders find the price, and the true cost is the fee plus the discount, so compare routes on all-in cost.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Prospectus The approved legal document describing the issuer, the risks and the terms of securities offered to the public.
          Underwriting A bank's promise to buy securities at an agreed price, carrying the risk of unsold ones.
          Bookbuilding Collecting investor orders at limit prices to find the price of an offering.
          Greenshoe An option letting banks sell about 15% more than the base deal and cover it, to stabilise the price.
          Lock-up An agreement by insiders not to sell for a set period after an IPO.
          Rights issue A capital increase in which existing shareholders receive rights to buy new shares first.
          Block trade A quick sale of a large package of existing shares to a bank or to institutions.
          Basis point One hundredth of a percentage point, used to quote bond spreads.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the placement of securities.

          • Ritter and Welch (2002) — A review of IPO activity, pricing, and allocations, Journal of Finance.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on how corporations issue securities.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.