Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial securities / Module 20

20Options

The right to choose, and why it has a price

The right to choose, and why it has a price.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
12
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Draw the payoff and profit of a call, a put, and their writers, and find the break-even.

  • Split an option's price into intrinsic and time value, and say how each of six inputs moves it.

  • Use put-call parity to price a put from a call.

  • Price an option by replication in one step and read the Black–Scholes formula and the Greeks.

  • Recognise options inside equity, convertibles, staff plans and investment choices.

1The shape of an option

Before any formula, you need to see what an option pays. Everything later in the module rests on the picture of a payoff that has a kink at the strike.

A call and a put are two one-way bets

A call is the right to buy at a fixed price

Imagine a coupon that lets you buy one Harmony share at 12.00 at any time until a date one year away. You paid 1.59 for the coupon. If the share is at 16 on that date, you use it: you pay 12, receive a share worth 16, and keep 4. If the share is at 9, you throw the coupon away. You never pay 12 for something worth 9.

That coupon is a call option. The price fixed in advance is the strike, here 12.00. The share it refers to is the underlying. The date is the expiry. The 1.59 paid up front is the premium. A put option is the mirror image: the right to sell at the strike. It gains when the share falls.

At expiry the payoff has only two branches

At expiry the holder of a call receives the share price minus the strike if that is positive, and nothing otherwise. The holder of a put receives the strike minus the share price if that is positive, and nothing otherwise.

Call payoff = max(S − K, 0) Put payoff = max(K − S, 0)

S is the share price at expiry and K is the strike. Subtract the premium paid and you have the profit. The table uses the Harmony call (strike 12, premium 1.59) and a Harmony put (strike 12, premium 1.24), ignoring the interest lost on the premium.

Share price at expiry Call payoff Call profit Put payoff Put profit
8 0 −1.59 4 +2.76
10 0 −1.59 2 +0.76
12 0 −1.59 0 −1.24
14 2 +0.41 0 −1.24
16 4 +2.41 0 −1.24
18 6 +4.41 0 −1.24

Profit per share, euros. Premiums from the pricing method of part 3.

The call needs the share above 13.59 to profit: the strike plus the premium. The put needs it below 10.76. Between those two prices the buyer of either option has lost money, even though the share moved the way they hoped.

The seller takes the opposite side of every line

The seller of the call (the writer) collected 1.59 and owes the buyer whatever the buyer gains. If Harmony reaches 18, the writer pays 6 and is down 4.41. If the share ends below 12, the writer keeps the 1.59. The buyer's loss is capped at the premium and the gain is open-ended. For the writer it is the reverse.

Leverage and insurance are the same property seen from two sides

A small move in the share becomes a large move in the option

If Harmony rises from 12 to 13, a gain of 8.3%, the call rises from 1.59 to 2.24, a gain of 41%. That magnification is leverage. The same shape works as insurance. Take a shareholder who owns 100,000 Harmony shares and fears a fall. She buys 100,000 puts with a strike of 12 for 1.24 each, a total of 124,000. Whatever happens, she can sell at 12.

Your neighbour Marc, a plumber, says an option is just a bet and he does not gamble. Explain to him, using the idea of a car insurance policy, why a put can be the opposite of a bet. Say what his premium buys and what he gives up.

      A good answer says: a put on shares you own works like car insurance. You pay a fee, the premium. If nothing goes wrong you lose the fee and are glad. If the shares collapse, the put pays and your loss is capped. Marc gives up the fee and in return cannot lose more than a fixed amount. Only a put bought on shares you do not own is a bet.

      1.1 Reading a payoff table

      Harmony shares trade at 12.00. A call with strike 14 costs 0.90 and expires in one year. Find the break-even share price and the profit if the share ends at 20 and at 10. Then do the same for the buyer of a put with strike 9.50 costing 0.60 if the share ends at 10.

      The call breaks even at 14 + 0.90 = 14.90. At 20 the profit is 6 − 0.90 = 5.10. At 10 the call is worthless and the loss is the premium, −0.90. The put pays nothing at 10, since 10 is above its strike of 9.50, so the loss is its premium, −0.60.

      1

      1. A Harmony call with strike 12 cost 1.59. What is the profit if the share ends at 16?

      2. Above what share price does the buyer of Harmony's call (strike 12, premium 1.59) make a profit?

      3. A shareholder with 100,000 Harmony shares buys 100,000 puts with strike 12 at 1.24. What has she bought?

      2What an option is worth before expiry

      At expiry the value is a payoff. Before expiry it is a price, and that price depends on six inputs. Knowing the direction of each is more valuable than memorising any formula.

      An option's price is what you could get now plus what uncertainty might add

      Intrinsic value is what exercising would give today

      A call with strike 12 on a share at 15 is in the money: exercising it would give 3. That 3 is its intrinsic value. At a share price of 12 it is at the money, and below 12 out of the money. In both cases the intrinsic value is zero, never negative.

      Time value is the price of the chance that things improve

      With a year left, a call with strike 12 on a share at 15 is worth about 3.79, not 3.00. The extra 0.79 is time value: the chance that the share goes higher before expiry, with no matching risk on the downside. At a share price of 12 the call is worth 1.59, all of it time value. At 9 it is worth 0.33, still not nothing, because the share could recover.

      Option value = intrinsic value + time value

      Share price Intrinsic value Time value Call value (1 year) Status
      9 0 0.33 0.33 out of the money
      12 0 1.59 1.59 at the money
      15 3 0.79 3.79 in the money

      Harmony call, strike 12, one year, 30% volatility, 3% rate.

      Six things move the price, and each one has a reason

      Four are easy to guess, two need explaining

      Share price and strike set how far the option is from paying. Time to expiry and volatility (how widely the price swings, as a yearly percentage) set the chance of it getting there. The interest rate and dividends adjust the price through the cost of waiting. A higher rate raises calls and lowers puts because the strike is paid later.

      Input (one change) Harmony call Harmony put Why
      Base case: S=12, K=12, 1 year, 30%, 3% 1.59 1.24 Reference point
      Share price up to 13 2.24 0.89 Call closer to paying, put further
      Strike up to 13 1.18 1.80 Call must beat a higher bar
      Volatility up to 40% 2.06 1.70 More chance of a large move, both ways
      Maturity up to 2 years 2.33 1.63 More time for a large move
      Interest rate up to 5% 1.71 1.12 Strike paid later is worth less today
      Dividends falls rises Cash leaves the share before expiry

      Prices from the model of part 3. One input moved at a time. The dividend row is the direction of the effect.

      Volatility raises both the call and the put

      A share that swings widely is more likely to end far above the strike, and far below it. The call buyer gains from the first and ignores the second, so the call is worth more. The put is worth more for the mirror reason.

      Put-call parity ties calls and puts to the share and to a loan

      A call and a put on the same terms cannot be priced independently

      Take a call and a put with the same strike and expiry, both European (usable only on the expiry date, unlike American options, usable on any day until then). Buy the call and sell the put. At expiry, if the share is above the strike you exercise your call and gain S − K. If it is below, the put you wrote is exercised against you and you lose K − S, which is again S − K with its sign. In both cases the result is S − K.

      That is exactly what you would get from owning the share and having borrowed the present value of the strike. Two packages with identical payoffs must cost the same today. This gives the relation known as put-call parity:

      C − P = S − K × e^(−rT)

      C and P are the call and put prices, S the share price, K the strike, r the interest rate and T the time in years. The factor e^(−rT) discounts the strike with continuous compounding. For Harmony, the right side is 12 − 12 × e^(−0.03) = 0.35, and the left side is 1.59 − 1.24 = 0.35. The prices of part 1 satisfy it.

      Parity shows that a put is a call in disguise, so option theory can be learned on calls alone.

      2.1 Using parity

      Harmony shares are at 12. A one-year call with strike 12 is quoted at 2.00 and the discrete rate is 3%. Compute the put price by parity. Then say what a bank would do if the put were quoted 0.30 higher than your answer.

      Put = 2.00 − 12 + 12/1.03 = 1.65. If the put were quoted 0.30 higher, a bank would sell it, buy the call, sell the share short and lend the discounted strike. At expiry the pieces cancel in every case, and the bank has pocketed 0.30 with no risk. Such quotes do not last.

      1. 2.3 A call on a share at 15 with strike 12 is worth 3.79. How much is intrinsic value and how much time value?

      2. 2.4 Why does a higher interest rate raise call prices and lower put prices?

      3. 2.5 A call costs 1.59 and the put on the same terms costs 1.24. What does the difference of 0.35 tell you, and what does it not tell you?

      a price board for the Harmony call and put with sliders for share price, strike, volatility, maturity and rate. The learner discovers that volatility and maturity raise both prices, while share price and strike push them in opposite directions.

      2

      1. A call with strike 12 is worth 3.79 when the share is at 15. How is that split?

      2. Which change raises both the call and the put on Harmony's share?

      3. Put-call parity says C − P = S − K e^(−rT). For Harmony, the right side is 0.35. What does that difference say?

      3Pricing: the copy, the formula and the Greeks

      Two methods give the same answer. One is simple enough to do by hand. The other is the one banks use. Both rest on the same argument: if you can build the option from simpler pieces, it must cost what those pieces cost.

      Pricing by copying: build the option out of shares and a loan

      If two packages pay the same, they cost the same

      Find a mix of shares and borrowing that pays exactly what the option pays in every possible future. The mix has a known price, and the option must cost the same. Otherwise someone could buy the cheaper and sell the dearer for a riskless gain.

      Take the smallest possible world. In one year Harmony's share, now 12, is either 15 or 9.60. A call with strike 12 pays 3 in the first case and 0 in the second. The rate is 3%. We want shares and a loan that pay 3 and 0.

      The price does not depend on how likely the rise is

      The calculation used the two future prices, the strike and the rate. It did not use the chance that the share rises. The copy pays the same as the option in both states, so the odds cannot matter. They are already inside today's share price.

      The same world prices the put, which pays 0 if the share rises and 2.40 if it falls. Its value is 1.14, and 1.49 − 1.14 = 0.35 equals 12 − 12/1.03, so parity holds. Cut the year into many steps and repeat the calculation backwards from expiry, and the answer converges on the Black–Scholes formula.

      3.1 A one-step replication

      In one year Harmony's share is 14.40 or 9.60 (starting from 12). The strike is 12 and the rate is 3%. Find the delta, the shares bought, the amount borrowed and the call price. Then check that the copy pays the right amount in both states.

      Delta = 2.40 / (14.40 − 9.60) = 0.5. Buy 0.5 share for 6.00 and borrow 0.5 × 9.60 / 1.03 = 4.66. The call costs 6.00 − 4.66 = 1.34. In the good state the shares are worth 7.20 and the loan is 4.80, leaving 2.40. In the bad state the shares are worth 4.80 and the loan is 4.80, leaving 0. The copy matches the call.

      Black–Scholes is the many-step limit, with volatility as the only unknown

      The formula needs five inputs that you can look up and one that you must estimate

      In 1973 Fischer Black and Myron Scholes, and independently Robert Merton, published a formula for a European option when the share follows a smooth random path. Scholes and Merton received the Nobel prize in economics in 1997. You need to recognise the formula, not derive it.

      C = S × N(d₁) − K × e^(−rT) × N(d₂)

      d₁ = [ln(S/K) + (r + σ²/2) × T] / (σ × √T) d₂ = d₁ − σ × √T

      N is the standard normal cumulative distribution, which turns a number into a probability. σ is volatility. The formula has a familiar shape: the call is a share position minus a loan position, like the replication above. N(d₁) is the delta, the number of shares in the copy. N(d₂) is, loosely, the probability the option finishes in the money in the risk-neutral world used for pricing, where every asset is assumed to earn the risk-free rate.

      For Harmony, with S = 12, K = 12, T = 1, r = 3% and σ = 30%, d₁ = 0.25 and d₂ = −0.05. The call is worth 1.59 and the put 1.24. Every price in this module comes from this formula.

      Volatility is the one input nobody can observe

      Volatility describes the future, so it cannot be looked up. Historical volatility measures past movement. Implied volatility is the figure that makes the formula reproduce a traded option price, so it is the market's own estimate. Traders quote options in implied volatility so that different strikes and maturities can be compared.

      The Greeks measure how the price moves when one input moves

      Traders name each sensitivity with a Greek letter. Delta is the change in option value for a one euro move in the share: 0.60 for the Harmony call, so a 0.12 rise in the share adds about 0.07. The formula gives 1.67 instead of 1.59, a rise of 0.073, so the approximation is close.

      Gamma is how fast delta itself changes: the call's delta is 0.48 at a share price of 11, 0.60 at 12 and 0.70 at 13. Vega is the change per point of volatility, about 0.046 for this call. Theta is the loss of value as time passes: left alone, the call falls from 1.59 to about 1.10 after six months.

      1. 3.2 The bank in the running case sold 20,000 Harmony calls with a delta of 0.60. Roughly how many shares does it buy to hedge?

      2. 3.3 Why does the probability that the share rises not enter the price of the call?

      3. 3.4 What is implied volatility, and why do traders prefer it to quoting prices?

      a replication game. The learner drags sliders for shares and loan until a portfolio matches the call in both states, then raises the number of steps from one to ten and watches the price converge on the Black–Scholes number.

      3

      1. In one year Harmony's share is 15 or 9.60; the call with strike 12 pays 3 or 0; the rate is 3%. What is the call worth?

      2. Why does the probability of a rise not enter the option's price?

      3. What is implied volatility?

      4Why options matter in corporate finance

      Options are not only a trader's tool. They are built into the capital structure, into staff pay and into the choice of when to invest.

      Equity is a call option on the firm's assets

      Shareholders of a levered firm own a right, not a claim

      A company has borrowed 70, repayable at a date. At that date, if the assets are worth more than 70, lenders get 70 and shareholders keep the rest. If the assets are worth less, shareholders hand the keys to the lenders and walk away, because limited liability stops lenders from asking for more. The shareholders' position is the payoff of a call on the assets with a strike equal to the debt.

      Assets at repayment Lenders receive Shareholders receive
      50 50 0
      70 70 0
      90 70 20
      110 70 40

      A fictional indebted firm (think of Pedalia) with debt of 70 due. Equity = max(assets − 70, 0).

      Suppose the assets are worth 70 for certain: equity is worth 0. Suppose instead they are worth 50 or 90 with equal chances, which also averages 70. Equity receives 0 half the time and 20 the other half, so it is worth 10 on average. The riskier plan is worth more to shareholders, and the extra value comes from lenders.

      Options hide inside the securities a company issues

      Warrants, convertibles and employee plans are all options on the company's own shares

      A warrant is a call on the company's own shares, issued by the company. A convertible bond is a bond plus a call. The holder pays for the call by accepting a lower coupon, so the financing looks cheap, but the saving is paid for with the option given away. CF21 prices the pieces. Real options, the flexibility to wait, expand or abandon a project, are valued with the same binomial logic in CF26. Options also hedge: CF43 compares them with forwards and swaps.

      Employee option plans are calls handed to staff, usually at a strike close to the current price. Under IFRS the options are measured at their fair value on the grant date and that cost is expensed over the period staff must wait to acquire them, so a pricing model is needed.

      Explain to Elodie, who runs a small shop and has never owned shares, why the owners of a company that owes the bank more than it owns could rationally prefer a risky plan to a safe one. Use the picture of a ticket that is worth nothing unless things go well.

          A good answer says: the owners of a firm that owes more than it owns hold a ticket worth nothing unless things go well. A safe plan leaves it worthless. A risky plan gives it some chance of paying, and if it fails the owners lose nothing more, because the bank cannot ask for more. The owners gain from the gamble and the bank carries the downside. That is why lenders add conditions on risk-taking.

          4.1 Costing an option plan

          Harmony considers granting 250,000 employee options with strike 12.00 and a life of one year (30% volatility). Compute the fair value of the plan, the share count dilution as a percentage of 12.5 million shares, and say which of the two numbers better measures the cost to existing shareholders.

          Fair value = 250,000 × 1.59 = 0.40 million. Dilution = 250,000 / 12,500,000 = 2.0%. The fair value is the better measure of cost, because each option gives only part of the upside, not a whole share.

          an equity-as-a-call simulator. The learner sets the debt and drags the spread of asset outcomes while a chart splits value between lenders and shareholders. Raising the spread shifts value to equity when debt is high, and barely matters when debt is low.

          4

          1. A firm owes 70. Its assets will be worth 50 or 90 with equal chances. What is its equity worth on average?

          2. Why do lenders to a highly indebted firm write covenants on risk-taking?

          3. Harmony grants 500,000 options worth 1.59 each. What best measures the cost to existing shareholders?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Payoffs at expiry

          Call = max( − ; 0) Put = max(K − S ; 0)

          Less the premium for the profit: Harmony’s call needs a share price above 13.59.

          Put-call parity

          − = − K ×

          0.35 on both sides for Harmony.

          Black-Scholes

          C = S × N() − K e^(−rT) × N() with

          Call 1.59, put 1.24 for Harmony’s one-year option.

          One-step replication

          = () / ()

          Call = Δ × S − Δ × S_d / (1 + r) = 6.67 − 5.18 = 1.49.

          Idea What to remember
          Call Right to buy at the strike. Pays max(S − K, 0) at expiry. Buyer's loss capped at the premium.
          Put Right to sell at the strike. Pays max(K − S, 0). A put on shares you own is insurance.
          Break-even Strike plus premium for a call, strike minus premium for a put. Direction alone is not enough.
          Intrinsic and time value Intrinsic is what exercising gives today. Time value is the extra price of the chance of improvement.
          Six drivers Share, strike, volatility, maturity, rate, dividends. Volatility and time raise both calls and puts.
          Put-call parity C − P = S − K e^(−rT). Same strike and expiry, no dividends, European options.
          Replication A mix of shares and a loan can copy the option. The option costs what the copy costs.
          Odds do not enter The price does not depend on the chance of a rise. It depends on the possible prices and the rate.
          Black–Scholes The many-step limit. Only volatility is unobservable. Implied volatility is the market's estimate.
          Delta, gamma, vega, theta Sensitivity to share, to delta, to volatility, and to time. Delta is the hedge ratio.

          The one-sentence version

          An option is the right to choose after the facts are known, so its value comes from uncertainty and can be found by copying it with shares and a loan.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Option The right, but not the duty, to buy or sell something at a fixed price.
          Strike The fixed price at which the option can be used.
          Premium The price paid for the option.
          Intrinsic value What exercising the option would give today, never below zero.
          Time value The part of the price above intrinsic value, paying for the chance of improvement.
          Volatility How widely a price swings, as a yearly percentage.
          Delta How many shares behave like one option. The hedge ratio.
          Put-call parity The link that fixes the price of a put once the call, the share and the rate are known.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on options.

          • Hull — Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapters on option properties, binomial trees and the Black–Scholes–Merton model.

          • Black and Scholes (1973) — The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities, Journal of Political Economy.

          • Cox, Ross and Rubinstein (1979) — Option Pricing: A Simplified Approach, Journal of Financial Economics.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.