Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial securities / Module 19

19Shares and multiples

How to read a share, price it against what it earns, and adjust the numbers when the share count changes

How to read a share, price it against what it earns, and adjust the numbers when the share count changes.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
13
Exercises
3
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
2

What you will be able to do

  • Describe what a share gives its owner and compute earnings, dividend and book value per share.

  • Compute P/E, EV/EBITDA, EV/EBIT, P/B and the free cash flow yield, and match each to the question it answers.

  • Explain what drives each multiple and why 1 divided by the P/E is not the cost of equity.

  • Adjust per-share figures for splits, bonus issues and dilutive options using the treasury method.

  • Compute a total shareholder return and compare it with the return the investor required.

1A share is a claim on what is left

Before ratios, the thing itself. A share is a bundle of rights, and the per-share figures are a way of shrinking a whole company down to one slice you can hold.

A share gives a vote, a claim on profit and a price

Shareholders are paid last, so they own the upside and the risk

A company owes money to its lenders, its suppliers, its staff and the tax authority. Whatever remains after all of them belongs to the shareholders. This is why equity is called the residual claim. The remainder grows without limit when the company does well, and shrinks to zero at worst: the shareholder cannot lose more than the amount paid.

A share carries three rights. The right to vote at the shareholders' meeting, usually one vote per share. The right to a share of any dividend that is declared. The right to a share of what is left if the company is wound up. The company's equity is cut into equal shares, so each share carries the same slice of each right.

A price needs a market: free float and spread measure how easily you can trade

The market capitalisation is the share price times the number of shares. For Harmony at the IPO price it is 12.5 million × 12.00 = 150.0 million. It is the market's price for the whole equity.

Only shares held by outside investors can be traded freely. This is the free float. Before the IPO, Harmony's founders, Northlight and the other early holders owned all 10.0 million existing shares and none were for sale. The 2.5 million new shares are 20% of the 12.5 million total, so the free float is about 20% if nobody else sells. A small float makes the price jumpy, because a few orders move it.

Five per-share figures turn a company into one slice

Earnings, dividend, payout, yield and book value per share

EPS = net income ÷ number of shares DPS = dividends ÷ number of shares

Payout ratio = DPS ÷ EPS Dividend yield = DPS ÷ share price Book value per share = book equity ÷ number of shares

Earnings per share (EPS) is the profit attributable to one share. Dividend per share (DPS) is the part actually paid out in cash. The payout ratio is the fraction of profit paid out, and the dividend yield is the cash return on today's price before any price change. Book value per share is the accounting equity divided by the shares, a historical record of what was put in and kept.

Your neighbour Fatima has bought five shares of a bank after reading that its share price fell from 40 to 20 overnight. She is convinced it halved in value. Explain to her, with no jargon, what else she must check about the number of shares and the dividend before she knows whether she has lost anything.

      Fatima: the number of shares may have changed through a split, so the halved price may be a unit change. She should check her share count and any dividend. Without a split, the loss is real.

      Nadia: the options let her buy at 5 shares worth 8, so each is worth about 3 today. The company assumes she pays 5 and that the cash buys back shares at 8, so only 3 ÷ 8 of each option, or 3,750 shares in all, is new.

      1. 1.2 Why can the owner of a share never lose more than the price paid for it?

      2. 1.3 A company earns 40 million, has 20 million shares and pays 0.80 per share. Give EPS, payout ratio and, at a price of 25, the dividend yield.

      3. 1.4 Why would an investor pay less for a share with a 0.5% free float than for an identical business with a 40% float?

      1

      1. Before its IPO Harmony earned 7.5 million on 10.0 million shares. After it, pro forma net income is 8.06 million on 12.5 million shares. What is the new EPS?

      2. Why can a shareholder never lose more than the price paid?

      3. Why would investors pay less for a share with a 0.5% free float than for an identical business with a 40% float?

      2Multiples: price divided by what you get

      A multiple answers one question: how many euros do I pay for each euro of earnings, cash or book value? The skill is matching the right price to the right denominator, then asking what the answer is really saying.

      Match the price to the denominator, or the ratio means nothing

      Equity ratios divide equity value by what belongs to shareholders

      Net income, dividends and book equity belong to shareholders after the lenders have been paid. So they are divided into the price of the equity: the share price, or equivalently the market capitalisation. The main equity multiples are the price to earnings ratio (P/E) and the price to book ratio (P/B).

      Firm ratios divide enterprise value by what belongs to every investor

      Sales, EBITDA and EBIT are earned before the lenders are paid. They belong to all investors together. So they are divided into the price of the whole firm, the enterprise value (EV):

      EV = market capitalisation + net debt + minority interests + pensions and leases treated as debt − financial assets not used in operations

      For Harmony, EV is the market capitalisation plus net debt. Mixing the two families is the commonest error: market capitalisation divided by EBITDA falls as a company borrows more, which is absurd.

      The P/E ratio is a statement about growth, risk and rates

      The P/E tells you how many years of today's earnings you are paying for

      If a share costs 12.00 and earns 0.645, you pay 18.6 years of current earnings. The interesting question is why one company is tagged at 12 and another at 25.

      Three forces move it. Higher expected growth raises it, because tomorrow's earnings are larger. Higher risk lowers it, because investors demand a higher return and discount the earnings harder. Higher interest rates lower it, because the alternatives to shares pay more. A precise version links all three.

      Forward P/E = (1 − g ÷ ROE) ÷ (k − g)

      Here g is the long-run growth of earnings, ROE is the return on the equity the company reinvests, and k is the required return. The term (1 − g ÷ ROE) is the fraction of earnings the company can pay out while still growing at g: growth has to be funded, so it consumes some of the profit. It assumes ROE and g stay constant, so it is a thinking tool, not a forecast.

      a P/E dial. Three sliders for growth g, ROE and required return k redraw the forward P/E and a gauge from cheap to expensive, with Harmony's, Velora's and Brevo's actual multiples marked. The learner discovers that as g approaches k the multiple explodes, and that a rise of one point in k cuts the multiple more for high-growth firms than for slow ones.

      Enterprise multiples ignore financing, so choose them by the business

      EV/EBITDA and EV/EBIT compare firms with different debt and different depreciation

      P/E is affected by how much debt a company carries, because interest sits between operating profit and net income. A firm with the same operations and more debt has a different P/E. An enterprise multiple sits above the interest line, so it compares the business and leaves the financing out.

      EV/EBITDA is the favourite for capital-intensive or acquisitive sectors, because it ignores differences in depreciation policy. Its weakness is that it ignores the cost of replacing equipment. EV/EBIT charges depreciation, so it is better when assets wear out at similar rates across the sample.

      After IFRS 16 every enterprise multiple needs the lease debt inside EV

      Under IFRS 16, a company that rents its premises records the lease as debt and its cost as depreciation and interest. EBITDA rises because rent is no longer an operating cost. An EV that omits the lease debt then sits against an EBITDA that has been flattered.

      EV/Sales and FCF yield serve when profits are missing or distorted

      EV/Sales is used for firms with little profit yet, such as young software companies. It ignores margins, so it only works between businesses that will end with similar margins. The free cash flow yield divides free cash flow to equity by market capitalisation. It is harder to manipulate than earnings, but average several years, because it swings with the capital spending cycle.

      2.1 Brevo looks dear, or does it?

      Brevo, a heavily indebted e-scooter maker, has EBITDA of 10.0, net debt of 45.0, market capitalisation of 25.0 and net income of 1.0. Compute its EV, EV/EBITDA and P/E. Compare with Harmony's 8.5× and 18.6× and explain why the two multiples tell different stories.

      EV = 25.0 + 45.0 = 70.0. EV/EBITDA = 7.0×. P/E = 25.0 ÷ 1.0 = 25.0×.

      On EV/EBITDA Brevo is cheaper than Harmony (8.5×). On P/E it looks dearer (18.6×). Debt is 45 of the 70 of EV, about 64%. Interest absorbs most of the operating profit, so net income is tiny and any price divided by it gives a large number. Enterprise multiples compare firms with different debt.

      P/B asks whether the company earns more than investors require

      A company that earns its cost of equity should trade at its book value

      Book equity is what shareholders put in and left in. If the company earns exactly the return investors require on that money, it is worth exactly what was put in, and the share trades at book value, a P/B of 1. If it earns more, the market pays a premium for the surplus. If it earns less, the shares trade below book.

      P/B = (ROE − g) ÷ (k − g)

      With ROE equal to k the ratio is 1 whatever the growth. With ROE above k, faster growth lifts the ratio, because the company reinvests at an attractive rate. With ROE below k, faster growth lowers the ratio, because it reinvests at a rate that destroys value.

      Harmony before the IPO had equity of 54.0 and a value of 114.0, so P/B was 2.11. With ROE of 13.9% and k of 10.4%, the formula implies growth of about 7.2%, consistent with the P/E reading above.

      2.2 Two banks, two books

      Bank A has ROE of 8%, Bank B has 15%. Both have k = 10% and long-run growth g = 4%. Compute the P/B of each. A fund manager says: Bank A trades at 0.7 times book, so it is a bargain. Respond.

      Bank A: (0.08 − 0.04) ÷ (0.10 − 0.04) = 0.67×. Bank B: (0.15 − 0.04) ÷ (0.10 − 0.04) = 1.83×.

      Bank A at 0.7 times book is near its fair price on these assumptions. Its ROE of 8% is below the 10% required. A low P/B is cheap only if ROE is expected to rise to the required level.

      1. 2.3 Why does dividing market capitalisation by EBITDA make a company look cheaper as it takes on more debt?

      2. 2.4 A company has a P/E of 40. Name two different beliefs about its future that could justify it.

      3. 2.5 Why is P/B a poor tool for a consulting firm and a fair one for a bank?

      2

      1. Brevo has EBITDA 10.0, net debt 45.0, market capitalisation 25.0 and net income 1.0. Which statement is right?

      2. With ROE of 13.9% and k of 10.4%, what happens to the forward P/E when long-run growth rises from 5% to 8%?

      3. Why is 1 divided by the P/E not Harmony's cost of equity?

      3Per-share figures must be adjusted when the share count changes

      A price series that jumps by half after a split is not a crash. Adjustments keep per-share data comparable over time. They change the unit, not the value.

      A split or a bonus issue changes the number of slices, not the value of the pie

      The coefficient scales every past price and per-share figure

      In a stock split, each share is cut into several. In a bonus issue (free share issue), the company hands existing shareholders new shares for nothing, in a ratio such as one new for every five held. Nothing enters the company, so its value is unchanged: the price per share falls in proportion.

      Adjustment coefficient = N ÷ (N + N′) where N old shares receive N′ free shares

      Multiply every historical price, EPS and DPS by the coefficient to put it on the same footing as today's. Without it, a chart shows a fall that never happened.

      Employee options and convertibles dilute the earnings of existing shares

      Diluted EPS counts the shares that could exist, not only the ones that do

      A company may have promised to issue shares later: to staff holding options, to holders of warrants or to bondholders who can convert. If these claims were exercised, the profit would be shared among more shares. Diluted EPS shows that. It is the more cautious number.

      The treasury method assumes the option holders pay the exercise price and the company uses that cash to buy back its own shares at the market price. Only the difference is new shares. If the option is out of the money, nobody would exercise and it adds nothing.

      Net new shares = options × (1 − exercise price ÷ market price) if market price > exercise price, else 0

      Your friend Nadia works at a start-up and has been granted options to buy 10,000 shares at 5 each. The shares are now worth 8. Explain what her options are worth today, in plain language, and why the company counts fewer than 10,000 new shares when it computes diluted earnings per share.

          3

          1. Harmony grants one free share for every five held. What happens to the P/E?

          2. Staff hold 0.5 million options at a 12.00 strike. The share trades at 15.00. How many net new shares does the treasury method count?

          3. Options with a strike of 12.00 when the share is at 10.00 add how many shares to diluted EPS?

          4The investor's return and the market dashboard

          Multiples price the share. Returns reward the owner. This last part follows one investor and compares the result with the return required.

          Total shareholder return adds dividends to the price change

          The return has two sources, and the second can be larger than it looks

          An owner earns a cash dividend and a change in the price. Total shareholder return (TSR) counts both, with dividends treated as received when paid. For one year, TSR = (price end − price start + dividends) ÷ price start. For several years, it is the internal rate of return of the cash flows: the price paid, each dividend, and the final sale price.

          4.1 A fall cushioned by dividends

          An investor buys at 12.00, receives a dividend of 0.30 in each of the three years, and sells at 10.50 at the end of year 3. Compute the annualised price return and the TSR as an IRR. Say whether the investor beat a required return of 10.4%.

          Price return = (10.50 ÷ 12.00)^(1/3) − 1 = 0.875^(1/3) − 1 ≈ −4.4% a year. TSR is the IRR of −12.00, +0.30, +0.30, +10.80, which is about −1.7% a year.

          Dividends lifted the return by roughly two and a half points, yet the investor lost money and fell well short of 10.4%.

          Buybacks return cash too, so look at the total payout

          Many companies now return more cash through buybacks than dividends. A buyback shrinks the share count, which lifts EPS and the price per share. The total payout yield adds the dividend yield and the buyback yield. CF31 analyses buybacks and their EPS illusion.

          Compare what you earn with what you required

          The required return gives the price an investor expects to see next year

          From CF16, Harmony's required return on equity is the risk-free rate plus beta times the risk premium: 3.0% + 1.34 × 5.5% = 10.4%. A fairly priced share is expected to return exactly that. An investor at 12.00 who expects the 0.30 dividend therefore expects a price a year ahead of 12.00 × 1.104 − 0.30 = 12.95.

          a TSR race. The learner picks a purchase price, a dividend policy (none, 30% payout, 60% payout) and a sale price three years on, and sees price return and TSR side by side, with the 10.4% hurdle drawn as a line. The learner discovers when dividends rescue a falling share and when a share with no dividend still beats the hurdle.

          1. 4.2 Why can a share with a 1% dividend yield still deliver a 15% total return?

          2. 4.3 Harmony's required return is 10.4%. A year ago an investor bought at 10.00 and got 0.15 in dividends, and today the price is 11.00. Was the return above the hurdle?

          3. 4.4 Why is the realised return of one year a poor guide to whether a share was fairly priced?

          4

          1. An investor buys at 12.00, receives 0.30 a year for three years and sells at 10.50. What was the total return?

          2. Harmony's required return is 10.4% and the expected dividend 0.30. What price should an investor at 12.00 expect a year later?

          3. Why is one year's realised return a poor guide to whether a share was fairly priced?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Forward P/E

          = (1 − / ) / ( − g)

          About 15.6× on this year’s earnings, close to the 15.2× observed before the IPO.

          Enterprise value

          = +

          EV / EBITDA = 152.5 / 18.0 = 8.5×.

          Price to book

          = ( − g) / ( − g)

          Equal to 1 when ROE = k, whatever the growth; 2.11 implies g ≈ 7.2%.

          Treasury method (options)

          = × (1 − / )

          Diluted EPS = 8.06 / 12.6 = 0.640, against a basic 0.645.

          Idea What to remember
          EPS, DPS, payout EPS = net income ÷ shares. DPS = dividends ÷ shares. Payout = DPS ÷ EPS.
          Market cap and EV Market cap = price × shares. EV adds net debt, minorities and lease and pension debt.
          Matching rule Equity value over equity figures (P/E, P/B). EV over firm figures (EBITDA, EBIT, sales).
          P/E Forward P/E = (1 − g ÷ ROE) ÷ (k − g). Up with growth, down with risk and rates.
          EV/EBITDA and EV/EBIT Compare businesses regardless of debt. After IFRS 16, include lease debt in EV.
          P/B (ROE − g) ÷ (k − g). Above 1 only if ROE beats the required return.
          Treasury method Net new shares = options × (1 − strike ÷ price). Zero when out of the money.
          TSR IRR of price paid, dividends and sale price. Compare with the required return.
          Bonus issue Coefficient N ÷ (N + N′). Restate past data. Value is unchanged.

          The one-sentence version

          A share is the last claim on a company's cash, so its price is a forecast of growth discounted at a risky rate, and every multiple, per-share figure and return is a way of reading that forecast on a like-for-like basis.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Free float Shares held by outside investors that can be traded freely.
          Enterprise value Market capitalisation plus net debt and other debt-like items: the price of the whole business.
          Diluted EPS Earnings per share counting shares that options and convertibles could create.
          Treasury method Assumes option cash buys back shares at the market price, so only the net shares count.
          Total shareholder return Return from dividends plus price change, as an annual rate.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on the share and market multiples.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on how corporations issue securities and on valuing common stocks.

          • Damodaran — Investment Valuation (Wiley), chapters on relative valuation and on multiples.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.