What you will be able to do
Turn a vague worry about prices into an exposure measured in euros.
Explain why a forward rate comes from interest rates and not from a forecast.
Compare a forward, a swap, an option, a cap and a collar by what each costs and what each gives up.
Size a hedge so that it cannot turn into speculation.
Explain what hedge accounting changes and what it leaves untouched.
1Map the exposure before you buy anything
A hedge is a solution. First the company needs to know what the problem is and how large it is.
Hedging pays only when bad outcomes are costly for the firm
A shareholder can diversify away risk, so the firm needs its own reason to hedge
An investor who holds Harmony and fifty other shares already owns a mix of dollar winners and losers. She does not need Harmony to remove its dollar risk for her. If hedging only lowered risk, it would add no value (CF15).
Value appears when swings are costly inside the company. Three channels matter.
Distress costs. A bad year can push net debt above what lenders accept. Harmony stands at 1.67 times EBITDA. Lenders, suppliers and key staff react to trouble long before bankruptcy.
Underfunded investment. If cash flow collapses in the year Harmony wants to spend 9.0 million on capex, it must delay good projects or raise money on bad terms.
Covenants. Loan agreements set limits on ratios such as net debt to EBITDA. A price shock can breach them even when the business is sound.
Five families of risk, and this module covers the financial ones
Each family has its own tool, and financial derivatives fit only some of them
| Family | Harmony example | Usual response |
|---|---|---|
| Market | Dollar cost of cells, aluminium price, floating rate | Forwards, futures, swaps, options (this module) |
| Counterparty | A dealer pays late; a bank fails on a swap | Limits, collateral, credit insurance |
| Liquidity | A credit line is not renewed | Back-up lines, cash buffer (CF33, CF42) |
| Operational | A supplier fire, a cyber attack, a flooded plant | Controls, insurance, dual sourcing |
| Country and legal | A new tariff, a change in battery rules | Contracts, diversification, political risk insurance |
A derivative is the right tool for market risk and a poor one for most of the others.
An exposure is a cash flow whose size depends on a price
Measure the position in euros: what moves, by how much, and when
A company is long a price if it gains when the price rises, and short if it loses. Harmony must buy dollars, so it is short the dollar: the dearer the dollar, the dearer the cells. For each exposure the treasurer writes down the amount, the date, and the euro effect of a plausible price move.
Currency exposure has three kinds: transaction (a known payment in another currency), translation (converting foreign subsidiaries into euros) and economic (the slow effect on competitiveness). This module works on transaction exposure. CF47 treats the others.
A treasurer also quotes a value at risk: the loss not expected to be exceeded in, say, 95% of cases over a period. It depends on price history, so it is paired with stress tests of scenarios that have never occurred.
Hugo runs a bakery and buys flour in euros. He says: my accountant wants me to hedge the flour price, but if I hedge I will not be any richer, so what is the point? Explain to Hugo, without jargon, when a hedge is still worth it, and when his accountant is wrong to ask.
Hugo is right that a hedge does not raise his average profit. It is worth buying only if a very bad flour year would hurt the bakery more than a good year helps, for instance by making him miss a loan payment. With a cash cushion and the power to pass prices on, the accountant is wrong to insist. Without them, a hedge is cheap insurance.
1
When does hedging add value for Harmony's shareholders?
Diversified shareholders already remove that risk themselves.
That is a view, and acting on it is speculation.
A hedge that loses money can still have done its job.
Right. Lowering risk alone adds nothing that shareholders cannot do by diversifying.
Harmony must pay $9.0m in a year. Which position is it in?
No: it loses when the euro falls, so against the dollar it is long the euro.
Right. It loses when the dollar rises.
Fixed in dollars, but its euro cost moves.
It would be long if it received dollars.
Together, the three bad moves (dollar, aluminium, rates) cost Harmony 1.87 million. What does EBITDA over interest become?
Right. EBITDA 16.58 over interest 2.45.
That keeps EBITDA at 18.0 (18.0 / 2.45): it ignores the fall in EBITDA.
It stays well above the floor.
Both EBITDA and interest move.
2Foreign exchange: fix the rate today, or buy the right to
Currency risk is the clearest case. Harmony's dollar bill is the thread.
A forward fixes today the rate for a payment later
A forward is a binding promise to exchange currencies at an agreed rate on an agreed date
Harmony asks Banque du Rhône to sell it $9.0 million in twelve months at a rate agreed today. Nothing is paid now. In a year Harmony pays euros, receives dollars, and hands them to the supplier. Whatever the spot rate has done, the euro cost of the cells is fixed.
The forward rate is set by interest rates, not by a forecast
The bank could get the same result without a forward: borrow euros, convert them to dollars now, and lend the dollars for a year. If the forward differed from the cost of that route, someone would earn a risk-free profit. So the forward must reflect the gap between the two interest rates.
Forward = Spot × (1 + dollar rate) / (1 + euro rate) (dollars per euro)
Take spot 1.10, a one-year dollar rate of 4.0% and a euro rate of 3.0%. The forward is 1.10 × 1.04 / 1.03 = 1.1107. The dollar pays more interest, so it is worth less in the forward market: a euro buys more of it. This is why Harmony's cells cost 8.10 million under the forward, against 8.18 million at today's spot, a gap of 0.08 million.
The cheapest hedge is a cash flow that moves the other way
Natural hedges and netting come before bank products
A natural hedge matches a payment with a receipt in the same currency. If Harmony sold bikes in dollars, those sales would pay for the cells and only the difference would need hedging. Other routes: ask the supplier to invoice in euros (it will price in its own risk), or net payments between group companies before touching a bank. These routes are cheap but rarely cover everything.
2.1 Harmony's sterling receipts
Harmony sells to UK dealers and will receive £4.0 million in twelve months. Spot is 0.86 pounds per euro, the one-year pound rate is 4.0% and the euro rate 3.0%. Compute the one-year forward rate, the euros Harmony locks in by selling the pounds forward, and the euros it would get at today's spot. Then say how much the hedge gains or loses if the spot rate in a year is 0.95.
The forward is 0.86 × 1.04 / 1.03 = 0.8683 pounds per euro. Selling £4.0 million forward locks in 4.0 / 0.8683 = 4.61 million euros. At today's spot, the pounds would be worth 4.0 / 0.86 = 4.65 million. The forward gives up 0.04 million because the pound pays higher interest.
If the spot rate in a year is 0.95, the unhedged pounds are worth 4.0 / 0.95 = 4.21 million. The hedge gains 4.61 − 4.21 = 0.40 million.
2.2 Harmony buys the forward at 1.1107. A year later the spot rate is 1.25 and the cells cost 7.20 million at spot. Did the hedge fail?
No. The hedge cost 8.10 − 7.20 = 0.90 million more than the spot purchase, but it removed the risk of paying up to 9.00 if the euro had fallen. The test is whether the outcome stayed in the planned range, not whether the hedge paid.
2.3 The bank has no view on the dollar. Why is its forward rate still different from today's spot?
The forward is fixed by arbitrage between two interest rates. The bank can borrow euros, buy dollars at spot and lend the dollars, so a forward priced elsewhere would hand someone a risk-free profit. No view on the dollar is needed.
2.4 Name one scenario in which Harmony is glad it bought the option rather than the forward, and one in which it prefers the forward.
The option wins if the euro ends above 1.146, for instance at 1.20: cost 7.75 against 8.10. The forward wins at 1.10 or below: 8.10 against 8.43, since the premium bought nothing. In the worst case the option still caps the bill at 8.43.
2
Spot is 1.10 dollars per euro, the dollar rate 4% and the euro rate 3%. Why is the one-year forward 1.1107?
It is the interest gap, not risk.
No view is needed; it is arithmetic.
Right. Borrowing euros, buying dollars and lending them must cost the same.
The gap comes from the rates, not a fee.
Harmony buys a dollar option at 1.10 for a premium of 0.25. When does it beat the forward at 1.1107?
Right. Then 9.0 / spot + 0.25 falls below 8.10.
The premium must be recovered too.
There the option costs 8.43, more than the forward.
At 1.20 the option costs 7.75 against 8.10.
Harmony will receive £4.0m in a year. Spot 0.86 pounds per euro, pound rate 4%, euro rate 3%. How many euros does a forward lock in?
Right. Forward 0.8683; 4.0 / 0.8683.
The forward goes the other way: the pound pays more interest.
That is the unhedged value if spot ends at 0.95.
That is the value at today's spot.
3Interest rates and commodities: swap, cap and future
The same logic applies to other prices, with a new cost: the cash a hedge can call for when the market moves.
A swap turns a floating rate into a fixed one
A floating loan passes the rate risk to the borrower, and each point costs 0.30 million
Harmony pays €STR plus 2.0% on 30.0 million. With €STR at 3.0% the rate is 5.0%. A rise of one point adds 0.30 million a year. (€STR replaced EONIA in the euro market. SOFR and SONIA play the same role for dollars and pounds.)
A swap exchanges the interest payments, not the loan
Harmony keeps its loans and agrees a separate contract with the bank on 20.0 million of the 30.0, called the notional: Harmony pays a fixed 3.2% and receives €STR. The €STR it receives pays the floating part of the interest. What is left on that 20.0 is the fixed 3.2% plus the 2.0% margin, 5.2%, or 1.04 million a year, whatever the market does. The other 10.0 still floats.
Net interest cost = loan rate − €STR received + fixed rate paid = (€STR + margin) − €STR + fixed
A swap is symmetric. If €STR falls to 2.0%, the same 20.0 unhedged would cost 4.0%, or 0.80 million. The swap holds it at 1.04 million, a cost of 0.24 million over what floating would have been. The swap did what it was bought to do.
Caps and collars protect against the bad move and differ in what they give up
A cap is an option on the rate, a collar is a cap paid for by selling a floor
A cap pays Harmony the difference whenever €STR exceeds an agreed strike. A collar pairs a bought cap with a sold floor: Harmony gives up the gain if rates fall below the floor strike, and the premium received pays for the cap. Take a one-year cap at 4.0% costing 0.6% of the notional, or 0.12 million, and a collar with cap 4.0% and floor 2.5% at zero net premium.
| €STR in a year | Unhedged | Swap at 3.2% | Cap at 4.0% | Collar 2.5% to 4.0% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0% | 0.80 | 1.04 | 0.92 | 0.90 |
| 3.0% | 1.00 | 1.04 | 1.12 | 1.00 |
| 4.5% | 1.30 | 1.04 | 1.32 | 1.20 |
Annual interest on the 20.0 million of floating debt covered by the hedge, € million, premium included.
The swap removes all uncertainty and all upside. The cap keeps the upside at a visible cost. The collar costs nothing upfront but gives up the gain below the floor. No column wins everywhere: the choice is about which regret Harmony can live with.
3.1 A bigger rate shock
Rebuild the table for €STR at 5.5%. Compute the interest cost for the unhedged loan, the swap, the cap and the collar, premium included. Which instrument looks best in this scenario, and which looked best when €STR fell to 2.0%?
At 5.5% the debt costs 7.5% on 20.0 million: unhedged 1.50. The swap stays at 1.04. The cap pays 20 × 1.5% = 0.30, so the cost is 1.50 − 0.30 + 0.12 = 1.32. The collar's cap is also struck at 4.0%, so the cost is 1.50 − 0.30 = 1.20.
The swap looks best here. When €STR fell to 2.0%, no hedge at all (0.80) was cheapest, followed by the collar (0.90) and the cap (0.92), and the swap was dearest (1.04). No instrument wins in every scenario.
a slider for €STR from 0% to 7% that redraws the annual interest cost of the unhedged loan, the swap, the cap and the collar as four lines. The learner discovers where the lines cross, that the swap is a flat line, and that in the middle of the range the collar costs the same as no hedge.
Futures fix a commodity price and call for cash every day
A future is a standardised forward that settles its gains and losses daily
A forward is a private contract with one bank. A future is the same promise traded on an exchange. A clearing house stands between buyer and seller, and both sides pay or receive their gains and losses every day. These payments are called margin. A futures price rarely matches Harmony's exact grade and date, so a small basis gap remains between hedge and purchase.
Camille is a nurse who has just fixed the rate on her mortgage. A year later rates fall and she says: I lost money by fixing. Using Harmony's swap, explain to Camille why the swap is not a mistake when it pays more than floating, and what she got in exchange.
Camille bought certainty. At 2.0%, Harmony's swap cost 1.04 million against 0.80 floating, a gap of 0.24. At 4.5% the same swap would have saved 0.26. Nobody knew which way rates would go, and what she paid for was a budget that does not move.
3
Harmony pays a fixed 3.2% in a swap on 20.0 of its loan at €STR + 2.0%. What is the cost on that 20.0?
The €STR received cancels the €STR paid.
The 2.0% loan margin is still paid.
Right. The €STR received pays the floating part.
That is the point of the swap: it no longer does.
With €STR at 3.0%, what does the 2.5%–4.0% zero-premium collar cost on 20.0 million?
The floor only binds below 2.5%.
The cap carries a 0.12 premium; the collar does not.
Right. Inside the band the collar does nothing.
The collar does not fix the rate.
Harmony buys aluminium futures for 1,000 tonnes at 2,400. The price falls to 2,100. What happens?
That describes a forward, not a future.
It bought at 2,400; a fall means it pays.
The position stays open unless Harmony closes it.
Right. Daily settlement can strain liquidity even when the hedge is sound.
4Deciding: how much to hedge, and what to leave alone
The instruments are the easy part. The hard part is a policy that stops hedging turning into a bet.
A written policy turns hedging from a bet into a routine
The hedge ratio must stay below the amount the company is sure to need
A policy states what is hedged, up to what proportion, with which instruments and banks, and who reports to the board. The proportion falls with the horizon: for example 80% of next quarter's forecast, 50% of the quarter after, less beyond. Forecasts worsen with distance, and a hedge on a payment that never happens is not a hedge.
4.1 A deeper fall in volume
Harmony hedges 70% of $9.0 million at 1.1107. A collapse in sales cuts the real need to $4.5 million, and the euro rises to 1.30. How large is the excess hedge in dollars, and what does it cost in euros?
The hedge is 0.7 × 9.0 = $6.3 million against a need of $4.5 million, so $1.8 million is excess. Bought at 1.1107 it costs 1.62 million, while the dollars are worth 1.8 / 1.30 = 1.38 million. The loss is 0.24 million.
Some exposures should be left alone
Do not hedge what is uncertain, shared with rivals, or cheaper to bear
Uncertain flows. A bid that may not be won is better covered by an option, whose cost is capped, than by a forward that leaves a loss if the contract is lost.
Risks shared with competitors. If every e-bike maker buys dollar cells, a dear dollar lifts everyone's prices and Harmony can pass part of it on.
Views. A forward bought because the treasury expects the dollar to move is speculation. Forward markets are priced to remove easy gains.
Hedge accounting aligns the books with the economics, but changes no cash
Without it, the loss on the hedge appears before the gain on the thing hedged
A forward is valued at market at each reporting date. If the euro rises to 1.20 before delivery, the forward shows a loss of roughly 0.60 million now (ignoring discounting), while the cheaper purchase is recorded later. Profit swings even though the hedge worked.
Under IFRS 9, a company that documents the link between the hedge and the exposure may treat it as a cash flow hedge. The gain or loss on the effective part waits in equity and moves into profit when the hedged purchase reaches the income statement. The result is smoother reported profit. The cash received and paid is exactly the same.
Every hedge adds a counterparty
The risk is the value the bank owes you, not the notional amount
If rates rise, Harmony's swap becomes valuable: the bank owes it the difference. Say the swap pays 1.5 points more than Harmony pays, on 20.0 million, with four years left and a 4% discount rate. That is 0.30 million a year, worth 1.09 million today. This is what Harmony loses if the bank fails, not the 20.0 million notional. Treasurers cap exposure per bank, spread trades and ask for collateral under a credit support annex to the ISDA agreement.
4.2 Rates fall and the swap shows a loss. The board wants to cancel the hedging policy. What do you reply?
The loss means rates fell, so floating debt would have been cheaper this year. Harmony still pays a fixed 5.2% on the swapped 20.0 and its budget is intact. Cancelling after a favourable move only exposes the company before the next unfavourable one. The test is the stability of interest cover, not the sign of the swap.
4.3 Harmony has a signed £4.0 million order and a pending $20 million supply tender it may not win. Which should be hedged with a forward and which with an option, and why?
The signed £4.0 million order is certain, so a forward suits it. The $20 million tender may be lost: a forward would leave Harmony with a loss and no purchase to offset it. An option caps the cost at the premium if the tender fails.
4.4 A swap on 20.0 million has value 1.09 million to Harmony. What is Harmony's counterparty exposure and what can it do about it?
The exposure is 1.09 million, the value the bank owes, not the 20.0 million notional. Harmony can limit it by capping the amount placed with any one bank, splitting trades across banks and requiring collateral under a credit support annex.
a decision game with ten exposure cards (a signed order, a possible bid, a floating loan, a shared industry cost, a trivial amount) to sort into: hedge with forward, hedge with option, natural hedge, insure, or leave alone. The learner is scored against the policy logic above and discovers that the correct answer is often not to buy a derivative.
4
Harmony hedges 70% of $9.0m at 1.1107; the real need falls to $4.5m and the euro rises to 1.30. What does the excess cost?
Beyond the real need it is a naked position.
That is what the excess dollars cost, not the loss.
Right. $1.8m bought for 1.62, worth 1.38.
That is the earlier case: $2.7m excess at 1.20.
What does IFRS 9 cash flow hedge accounting change?
The derivative is reported either way.
Right. The effective part waits in equity until the hedged item reaches profit.
The rate is fixed by the contract.
Cash is exactly the same.
Harmony's swap on 20.0 million is worth 1.09 million to it. What is the counterparty exposure?
The exposure is all four years, discounted.
Right. Limit it per bank and with collateral.
Harmony's swap is with its bank, not a clearing house.
The notional is never exchanged.
Summary and cheat sheet
The module’s formulas
Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.
Forward rate (interest-rate parity)
= × (1 + ) / (1 + )
The $9.0m bill costs €8.10m forward, against 8.18 at spot: arithmetic, not a forecast.
Net cost of a swapped loan
= ( + ) − €STR +
The €STR received cancels the €STR paid: only the fixed rate and the margin remain.
Cost with an option to buy dollars
= / max( ; ) +
The option beats the forward when the euro ends above 1.146.
Counterparty exposure on a swap
= ×
The risk is the value owed by the bank, never the 20.0 notional.
| Idea | What to remember |
|---|---|
| Why hedge | Only where bad outcomes are costly for the firm: distress, lost investment, covenants. Lowering risk alone adds no value. |
| Exposure | A cash flow whose size depends on a price. Measure amount, date and euro effect. |
| Forward rate | Spot × (1 + foreign rate) / (1 + euro rate). It reflects interest rates, not a forecast. |
| Forward vs option | The forward fixes the outcome at no upfront cost. The option caps the bad outcome and keeps the good one for a premium. |
| Swap | Exchanges floating for fixed interest on a notional. It removes both risk and upside. |
| Cap and collar | A cap insures against rising rates. A collar sells a floor to pay for it. |
| Hedge ratio | Keep it below the amount the firm is sure to need, falling with the horizon. |
| What not to hedge | Uncertain flows, risks shared with all rivals, trivial amounts, and any position taken on a view. |
| Hedge accounting | IFRS 9 cash flow hedge defers gains and losses in equity until the hedged item hits profit. Cash is unchanged. |
| Counterparty | Exposure is the positive market value owed by the bank, not the notional. |
The one-sentence version
Map the exposures in euros, hedge only what is certain and costly to lose, size the hedge below the sure amount, and never confuse insurance with speculation.
Key terms
| Term | Plain-language meaning |
|---|---|
| Exposure | A cash flow or value that changes when a market price changes. |
| Hedge | A position taken so that its gains and losses offset an exposure. |
| Forward | A binding contract to exchange an asset or currency at an agreed price on a future date. |
| Swap | A contract to exchange two streams of payments, such as floating for fixed interest. |
| Cap, floor, collar | An option setting a ceiling on a rate, an option setting a minimum, and the two combined. |
| Notional | The amount on which swap interest is calculated. It is not itself exchanged. |
| Margin | Cash paid or received daily to settle gains and losses on a future. |
Going further
Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on risk management in the firm.
Hull — Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapters on forwards, futures, swaps and hedging strategies.
Froot, Scharfstein, Stein (1993) — Risk management: coordinating corporate investment and financing policies, Journal of Finance.
Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.