Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Running the finance function / Module 44

44Real estate and lease-versus-buy

Whether a company should own, rent or finance the buildings it works in

Whether a company should own, rent or finance the buildings it works in.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
12
Exercises
3
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
2

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why owning, borrowing against and renting a property are three ways of financing the same asset.

  • Convert between a rent and a property value using a capitalisation rate, and say what moves it.

  • Run a lease-versus-buy comparison as a net present value, choosing the right discount rate for each cash flow.

  • Show how IFRS 16 and a sale and leaseback change EBITDA, net debt and multiples, and why peers are hard to compare.

  • Describe the main French and international property lease and ownership regimes in general terms.

1Property is a financing decision in disguise

A company that needs a building has to raise the money for it or pay someone else to have raised it. Everything else follows.

Owning, borrowing and renting split the same asset in different ways

Operating property serves the business, it is not the business

Property that a company uses to run its activity is operating property. Property held to earn rent or gains is investment property, which belongs to other businesses. Harmony's plant is operating property. Its job is to make bikes.

Harmony's plant has a market value of about 30.0 million and a book value of 14.0 million, the cost less years of depreciation. Land and buildings are written down in the books while market value often holds. As in CF24, judge it at what it could fetch.

Five routes put a roof over the business

Route Who owns Who provides the capital Main feature
Own, paid by equity Company Shareholders Full control, most capital tied up
Own, paid by a mortgage loan Company Bank and shareholders Loan limited to a share of value, with the building as security
Finance lease (property lease-purchase) Lessor, until a purchase option Lessor Long term, the company usually ends up owning
Plain lease Landlord Landlord Flexible, no capital tied up, rent paid for as long as needed
Sale and leaseback Buyer, after the sale Buyer Releases cash now, creates a long rent obligation

Five ways to finance the same building

A mortgage lender usually lends a share of the value, the loan-to-value ratio, because it can sell the building if the borrower fails. Other lenders then fear the best asset is pledged, so they ask for a negative pledge (a promise not to pledge assets to others) or a minimum-asset covenant. CF33 develops these tools.

Rent and value are two views of one number

The capitalisation rate turns a rent into a price

A buyer of a rented building receives rent each year. The yearly rent divided by the price is the capitalisation rate, or cap rate. It is the yield of the property. Turned round, value equals rent divided by the cap rate.

Value = annual rent ÷ cap rate

Cap rates follow interest rates, with a gap: property is riskier than government bonds, so its yield sits above them. When rates were near zero, cap rates were low and values high. After 2022 rates rose and many values fell, especially offices.

1.1 When the yield moves

Harmony's plant produces a rent of 2.25 million. Compute its value at cap rates of 6% and 9%. Then explain in two sentences why a bank that lent 60% of the value at the first rate may be worried at the second.

At 6% the value is 2.25 ÷ 0.06 = 37.5 million. At 9% it is 2.25 ÷ 0.09 = 25.0 million.

A 60% loan is 22.5 million at the first rate and 15.0 million at the second. A loan of 22.5 against a building now worth 25.0 is 90% of the value, so the lender's cushion has nearly vanished.

Who should own depends on who is best placed to carry the capital

Six factors tilt the choice

  • Maturity. A young, fast-growing company needs capital for products and people, so it tends to rent. A mature, cash-rich one can afford to own.

  • Shareholders. Family owners often hold property in a separate company (in France, a société civile immobilière, SCI) and rent it to the business, keeping a safe asset outside operating risk.

  • Type of asset. A building tailored to one process, such as Harmony's plant with its battery room, is hard to re-let, so landlords charge more for it than for a generic warehouse.

  • Tax. Selling crystallises tax on the gain. Some listed property vehicles pay little tax on rent in return for distributing it, which lowers their cost of capital.

  • Financial constraints. A company near its debt limits may rent because it cannot borrow more.

  • Financial logic. Landlords can carry a building at a lower rate than an operating company, perhaps 6% against Harmony's 9%, because rent is contractual. That is why a lease can be cheaper than owning: not a free lunch, but the risk sitting in cheaper hands.

Your aunt Nadia runs a hairdressing salon and says renting her premises is money thrown away, so she plans to take a loan and buy them. Explain to her, in everyday language, two costs of owning that she has not counted and one situation where buying could still be the better choice.

      A good answer says: the money used to buy would earn something elsewhere, so owning has a cost even without rent. It adds upkeep, taxes and repairs, and the risk that the property loses value or is hard to sell. Buying can still win if she is sure to stay for decades or the loan costs less than the rent saved.

      1

      1. Harmony's plant could be let for 2.25 a year. Investors move from a 6% to a 9% cap rate. What happens to its value?

      2. Why is paying rent not money thrown away?

      3. Which factor tilts a company towards owning its building?

      2Lease versus buy is a comparison of two streams of cash

      The choice becomes arithmetic: what does each route cost, in today's money, after tax? The hard part is the discount rate for each stream.

      Compare the cost of owning with the cost of renting, both in today's money

      Two questions replace one: what does each route cost, and how risky is each cost

      Owning costs cash now, brings tax savings from depreciation, and returns a resale value at the end. Renting costs a rent each year, which reduces tax. Only cash that differs counts: upkeep paid by the tenant under either route is left out.

      Rent is a fixed promise, so it behaves like debt and is discounted at Harmony's after-tax cost of borrowing, 5.0% × (1 − 25%) = 3.75%. Resale value is uncertain and deserves a higher rate. Discounting it at 3.75% would pretend that property prices are as safe as a loan repayment.

      The break-even rent shows how much flexibility is worth

      A lease is worth taking when the rent is below the break-even

      Instead of asking which route is cheaper, ask what rent would make Harmony indifferent. Buying costs 4.96. Each euro of annual rent costs 0.75 × 8.21 = 6.16 in present value after tax. The break-even rent is 4.96 ÷ 6.16 = 0.805 million a year. A landlord asking 0.80 is just below it. A landlord asking 0.90 would not be worth accepting, unless the lease gives something owning does not.

      A lease can give flexibility: if Harmony may not need the building after year five, an owner of a specialised building bears that risk, and an early-exit clause has an option value (CF26). It can also keep capital free for projects like the battery line of CF24. Both can be priced. Neither is a general reason to call leasing cheap.

      a lease-versus-buy calculator for the logistics building with three sliders: annual rent (0.60 to 1.00), resale value (8.0 to 14.0) and the discount rate on resale (3.75% to 12%). A bar shows the present cost of each route. The learner discovers that the rent and the resale rate move the answer much more than the tax rate does, and finds the break-even rent.

      2.1 A landlord who asks for less

      A second landlord offers Harmony the same building for a rent of 0.70 million a year. Using the 9% resale rate of the example, compute the present cost of renting and say which route is now cheaper and by how much. Then name one reason why the second landlord's rent may be lower.

      After tax the rent is 0.70 × 0.75 = 0.525 a year. Times 8.21 this is 4.31 million. Buying costs 4.96, so leasing is cheaper by about 0.65 million. The landlord may have a lower cost of capital, use the depreciation fully, or have a vacant building to fill.

      Your friend Karim is choosing between buying a car for 18,000 and a four-year lease at 300 a month. He says the lease is clearly cheaper because it asks for no deposit. Explain to him, without technical vocabulary, what he should compare instead and why the lease may not be cheaper.

          A good answer says: no deposit is only timing. Add up all the payments and compare them with the cost of owning the car net of its resale value, including insurance and mileage limits. The lease may be cheaper if the dealer subsidises it, dearer if the car keeps its value well.

          1. 2.3 Why is Harmony's rent discounted at 3.75% while the resale value is discounted at 9%?

          2. 2.4 A new lease moves upkeep costs from Harmony to the landlord. Why must the comparison now include them?

          3. 2.5 A manager says the lease should be taken because it does not use any of Harmony's borrowing capacity. What is wrong with this statement?

          2

          1. In the lease-versus-buy comparison, why is the rent discounted at 3.75%?

          2. The present cost of buying the building is 4.96 and of renting at 0.80 is 4.93. What is the break-even rent?

          3. A manager says the lease is better because it needs no cash on day one. What is wrong?

          3Leases change the accounts, the ratios and the valuation

          A decision with the same present cost can look very different in the accounts. This part shows what moves, and how to compare an owner with a tenant.

          Under IFRS 16 almost every lease becomes debt

          The tenant books an asset and a debt, and the rent disappears from EBITDA

          Under IFRS 16 a tenant records a right-of-use asset, the right to use the building, and a lease liability, the present value of the rents still to pay. The rent no longer appears as an operating expense. It is replaced by depreciation of the asset and interest on the liability. Short leases and small items are exempted. US accounting (ASC 842) also shows the lease on the balance sheet, but many leases keep one straight-line expense.

          Because EBITDA is struck before depreciation and interest, it rises by the old rent, and net debt rises by the lease liability. An unchanged company looks more profitable and more indebted at once. Net debt ÷ EBITDA moves less than either number.

          a toggle table of Harmony's ratios with three views: owns the plant, IFRS 16 after a sale and leaseback, and rent as an expense. A slider changes the lease length from 5 to 20 years. The learner discovers that the net debt counted under IFRS 16 hardly falls, and that the rent-as-expense view flatters leverage.

          Owner and tenant can only be compared on the same footing

          EBITDAR and lease-adjusted multiples remove the ownership choice

          Suppose Velora owns its plants and Harmony rents them. Velora's EBITDA is high because no rent is deducted, so a multiple of EBITDA compares different things. The cure is one basis for both: before rent (EBITDAR, R for rent) or after rent.

          Enterprise value must follow the same logic. If EBITDA is struck before rent, the lease liability belongs in net debt and in enterprise value. If EBITDA is struck after rent, it does not. Mixing the two is the standard error.

          Valuing the operating company and the property separately can reveal hidden value

          A company that owns valuable property can be seen as two businesses: an operating company (Opco), valued as if it paid market rent, and a property company (Propco), valued with a cap rate. If the market values the whole at less than the parts, a split or a sale may unlock value. The gap must be real: a plant tailored to bike assembly is worth less to a landlord than a generic building. CF28 covers sum-of-the-parts valuation.

          3.1 A shorter lease

          Harmony negotiates a shorter lease: 8 years instead of 15, at the same rent of 2.25 and the same rate of 5%. Compute the lease liability and the net debt counted under IFRS 16 after the sale (financial net debt 4.0). Compute net debt ÷ EBITDA with EBITDA at 18.0. Is the answer higher or lower than 1.52×, and why?

          The factor for 8 years at 5% is 6.46. The lease liability is 2.25 × 6.46 = 14.54 million, and net debt counted is 4.0 + 14.54 = 18.54 million. Net debt ÷ EBITDA is 18.54 ÷ 18.0 = 1.03×, lower than 1.52× because fewer rents remain to pay. The landlord has less security, so it may ask for a higher rent.

          1. 3.2 Under IFRS 16, a company signs a new ten-year lease. Name two lines of the accounts that rise and one that falls.

          2. 3.3 Why can a lower multiple after a sale and leaseback be a mere accounting effect?

          3. 3.4 What check tells you that an enterprise value and an EBITDA are on the same basis?

          3

          1. Under IFRS 16, what happens when Harmony signs a new lease?

          2. After the sale and leaseback, why does net debt counted fall only from 30.0 to 27.35?

          3. After the sale, EBITDA after rent is 15.75 and EV excluding leases 120.65. The multiple is 7.66 instead of 8.0. Why?

          4Local rules and the 2026 market shape the answer

          The method is universal. The lease contract, the tax and the market are local.

          French law makes the tenant's right to stay a feature of the lease

          The commercial lease gives the tenant a long-lived right to renew

          Since 2022, rates, remote work and buildings' energy performance have changed the arithmetic

          Higher rates changed values, and what tenants want changed demand

          Three developments matter in 2026. Interest rates are positive again: property yields rose, many values fell, and floating-rate property loans became costly, so refinancing is a real risk (CF12). Hybrid work cut demand for some offices, and a long office lease can leave a company carrying space it no longer needs, visible as an IFRS 16 liability.

          Energy performance now affects value and rent, as regulation, investors and lenders penalise inefficient buildings. Some leases carry a green lease clause under which landlord and tenant share data and plan works. Sustainability-linked property finance exists (CF45). Harmony's plant, with its heat-hungry paint shop, may need renovation before any sale.

          4

          1. In a French 3-6-9 commercial lease, what does the tenant usually have?

          2. What does the SIIC regime give a listed property company?

          3. Harmony's 2.25 rent is indexed at 2.5% a year. Why does the IFRS 16 liability understate what it will pay?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Capitalisation rate

          = /

          At 6% the same plant is worth 37.5; at 9%, 25.0.

          Present cost of buying

          = − −

          To compare with the present cost of renting: 0.60 × 8.21 = 4.93.

          Break-even rent

          = / ((1 − ) × )

          Lease liability (IFRS 16)

          = ×

          The sale raises 26.0 but net debt counted falls by only 2.65.

          Idea What to remember
          Three routes Own with equity or a mortgage, finance lease, plain lease. Sale and leaseback converts ownership into a lease.
          Cap rate Annual rent ÷ value. A higher rate means a lower value for the same rent.
          Rent is a cost of capital Renting does not avoid the cost of capital. It pays someone else for providing it.
          Lease versus buy Compare the after-tax present cost of each route. Include only cash that differs.
          Discount rates Rent: after-tax cost of debt. Resale value: a higher rate that fits its risk.
          IFRS 16 Lessee books a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. EBITDA and net debt both rise.
          Sale and leaseback Cash in, lease debt out. Value is created only through tax, buyer valuation or redeployment.
          Same basis Compare EBITDAR with EV including leases, or EBITDA after rent with EV excluding leases.
          France 3-6-9 commercial lease, ILC and ILAT indexation, crédit-bail immobilier and SIIC.

          The one-sentence version

          Treat a building as capital: compare owning and renting by their after-tax present costs, discounting rent like debt and resale value at a higher rate, then read the accounts and multiples on one consistent basis.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Operating property Land and buildings the company uses to run its business.
          Cap rate Annual rent divided by property value: the property's yield.
          Loan-to-value Loan as a share of the property's value.
          Effort rate Rent as a share of the tenant's sales.
          Right-of-use asset The asset a tenant books under IFRS 16 for the right to use a leased item.
          Lease liability Present value of the rents still to pay under a lease.
          EBITDAR EBITDA before rent: operating cash profit ignoring who owns the premises.
          Sale and leaseback Selling an owned asset and renting it back from the buyer.
          Opco / Propco The operating company and the property company, valued separately.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on managing operating real estate.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapter on leasing.

          • IFRS 16 Leases, IFRS Foundation, for the lessee accounting model.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.