Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Reading the accounts / Module 8

8Tricky items: leases, pensions, provisions, deferred tax

A field guide to the accounting items that hide debt or judgement

A field guide to the accounting items that hide debt or judgement.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
15
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
2

What you will be able to do

  • Say, for each tricky item, what it is, how it is booked and how to restate it.

  • Work through an IFRS 16 lease and explain why EBITDA and net debt both rise while cash does not move.

  • Value a pension or clean-up obligation and see why its size depends on the discount rate.

  • Read deferred tax, capitalised development and share-based pay as judgements that move profit without moving cash.

  • Rebuild net debt and EBITDA consistently, and choose which adjustments matter.

1One method sorts every item: what it is, how it is booked, how to restate it

A dozen items would be a dozen rules to memorise. They collapse into two families once you ask what each one really is.

Three questions turn an accounting rule into an analytical decision

The rule tells you how an item is booked, not always what it is

Ask three questions, in this order. Economics: is it a loan, a running cost, an owner's stake or an estimate? Booking: where does it land, in the balance sheet, the income statement, the cash flow statement or only the notes? Restatement: what does the analyst move, into net debt, out of EBITDA, into equity, or nowhere?

Restating is not second-guessing the auditor

The accounts follow the rules. The analyst reshuffles the same facts for another purpose: comparing two firms, valuing one, judging whether it survives a bad year. What matters is consistency. Whatever goes into net debt must also be reflected in EBITDA, and the same treatment must apply to every peer.

Two families cover almost everything: debt in disguise and earnings in disguise

Some items are financing under another name

Leases, pensions, clean-up obligations, sold receivables, stretched supplier credit and hybrid bonds share a pattern. The company received something and owes cash later to a specific party. Where there is a creditor, an amount and a date, the item behaves like debt. Part 2 covers this family.

Other items are estimates that move profit without moving cash

Deferred tax, capitalised development, share-based pay and expected credit losses depend on a judgement. Change the judgement and profit changes while the bank balance stays put. Part 3 covers this family.

1

  1. Which three questions does the module ask of every tricky item, in order?

  2. What is the golden rule when restating leverage?

  3. Which item belongs to the “earnings in disguise” family?

2Obligations that behave like debt

Five items share one test: someone is owed cash later for something the company has already received. The analyst's work is to find them and add them to net debt.

A lease is a loan taken to use an asset

IFRS 16 books the right to use as an asset and the rent as a debt

Before 2019 an operating lease was booked as rent and nothing else, so a company could occupy a warehouse for ten years and show no liability. Under IFRS 16 a lessee records a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. The liability is the present value of the remaining payments, discounted at the rate in the lease or the company's own borrowing rate. Each year the asset is depreciated and the liability bears interest. Short leases and low-value items may stay as plain rent.

The total cost is unchanged, but the ratio gets worse

The IFRS 16 charges over six years total 9.0, the same as the cash: 7.61 of depreciation and 1.39 of interest. Interest is highest when the liability is largest, so year 1 costs 0.15 more than the rent and the final year about 0.16 less.

The rent leaves EBITDA and reappears as depreciation and interest. EBITDA rises by 1.5, or 8.3%. Net debt rises by 7.61, or 25.4%. A ratio with debt on top gets worse although Harmony pays the same cash to the same landlord. To compare with a firm still reporting rent, or to read a covenant written on the old basis, reverse the entry. The golden rule: the lease is in both net debt and EBITDA, or in neither.

2.1 Forklifts on the balance sheet

Harmony leases a fleet of forklift trucks, separate from the warehouse. It pays 0.9 at the end of each year for five years, discounted at 4%. Compute (a) the liability on day one, (b) the year 1 charge against the rent, (c) the effect on EBITDA and net debt, and (d) the liability at 6%. Say why (d) is smaller.

(a) 0.9 × 4.4518 = 4.01. (b) Interest 0.16 plus depreciation 0.80 gives 0.96, against a rent of 0.90. (c) EBITDA rises by 0.9 and net debt by 4.01. (d) At 6% the factor is 4.2124 and the liability is 3.79. A higher rate makes each future payment worth less today.

A pension promise is a debt to employees, valued with a discount rate

A defined contribution plan is a cost, a defined benefit plan is a debt

In a defined contribution plan the employer pays a fixed sum and the employee carries the investment risk. Nothing is owed afterwards. In a defined benefit plan the employer promises a pension or lump sum fixed by a formula, so the employer carries the risk and a liability appears.

The obligation is a present value, so it moves with the discount rate

The company estimates the payments it will owe and discounts them at the yield on high-quality corporate bonds. Assets set aside in a fund offset the obligation. The difference is the deficit.

The service cost of another year of work is an operating expense. The interest on the deficit is a financial charge. Gains and losses from changed assumptions go straight into equity. The analyst treats the deficit, after tax, as debt, since contributions to fill it are deductible. The service cost stays in operating profit.

2.2 Is a pension deficit debt?

Velora's finance director says the deficit is not debt because no creditor can demand it tomorrow. Give two reasons the analyst includes it anyway. Then compute the after-tax deficit if yields instead rose by one point and the obligation of 500 shrank by 14%, with assets still 420.

First, the promise is a legal obligation to people who have already worked for it, and cash will be needed. Second, ignoring it makes a company with a big deficit look like one with none.

With the obligation down 14% to 430 and assets at 420, the deficit is 10, or 7.5 after tax.

Your sister-in-law Sophie teaches history. She reads that a school operator has 'zero net debt' although it signed 20-year building leases and promises pensions to its staff. Explain to her, without the words IFRS, liability or discount, why the operator is more indebted than it looks.

      Sophie. A lease is a promise to pay rent for years, like borrowing to use the building. A pension promise is money owed to people who have already done the work. The missing figure is the sum of those promises in today's money.

      Julien. If he counted the wood he bought as part of the table instead of as a cost this month, his profit would look better, but his bank account still went down. He should check how much cash the firm actually produced.

      A provision is an estimate of a future payment, not money set aside

      A provision exists only when there is a present obligation

      Under IAS 37 a provision is booked when a past event has created an obligation, an outflow is probable and the amount can be estimated reliably. A fear or a possible lawsuit does not qualify and is only disclosed. Restructuring needs a detailed formal plan, usually announced, which is why closures appear as one large charge.

      Warranty and clean-up provisions look alike but the analyst treats them differently

      Suppose Harmony must decontaminate the soil under its battery test track in ten years, at a cost of 3.0. The provision is the discounted amount: at 4%, 3.0 / 1.04¹⁰ = 2.03. Each year the discount unwinds, a financial charge of 2.03 × 4% = 0.08 in year 1. The analyst adds it to net debt, after tax as for pensions, because a known sum is owed at a known date. A warranty provision, by contrast, is a running cost of selling bikes and stays in operating working capital.

      Provisions are the easiest place to smooth profit

      Suppose Harmony added 1.0 of needless provision in year N, so EBIT showed 11.0 instead of 12.0, and released it in N+1. Profit looks steadier than the business. Watch for provisions growing faster than activity.

      Sold receivables and stretched payables are loans in disguise

      Factoring raises cash today, and who bears the loss decides the treatment

      A company can sell receivables to a factor for most of the cash at once. If the factor can come back to the seller when customers do not pay (recourse), the receivables stay on the balance sheet against a loan. Without recourse they can be removed.

      Supplier finance is a bank loan that looks like a trade payable

      In reverse factoring a bank pays a supplier early and the buyer repays the bank later, often after a much longer term. If the term is stretched far beyond normal practice, the payable is a bank loan. Harmony has 6.0 of its 26.0 of payables in such a programme, stretched from 60 to 120 days. Reclassified, net debt is 36.0 and the ratio 2.00. Since 2024 such programmes must be disclosed in the notes.

      Hybrids are part debt and part equity, and the split depends on who is asking

      A perpetual bond with a skippable coupon can count as equity

      A perpetual hybrid has no maturity and its coupon can be deferred. Because the issuer can avoid paying, IFRS can classify it as equity. Rating agencies typically give a share of the amount, often half, as equity credit. A lender may treat all of it as debt. All three are defensible. The analyst picks one and applies it to every company.

      1. 2.3 Harmony adopts IFRS 16 for a lease. Name two figures that rise and one that does not change.

      2. 2.4 A company sells receivables with recourse. Should an analyst add the cash received back to net debt? Why?

      3. 2.5 A falling discount rate raises a pension deficit although the company has paid nothing. Why?

      a lease simulator. The learner moves sliders for the annual payment, the term and the discount rate, and sees the liability, the yearly charge against the rent, and the effect on EBITDA, net debt and net debt / EBITDA, with a toggle between the IFRS 16 view and the rent view. The learner should discover that the total cost never changes, that early years cost more than the rent, and that a higher rate shrinks the liability.

      2

      1. Harmony's warehouse lease (1.5 a year, 6 years, 5%) under IFRS 16 gives a year 1 charge of…

      2. Bond yields fall by one point. What happens to a defined benefit pension deficit?

      3. Harmony sells 8.0 of invoices without recourse just before year end. The analyst should…

      3Items that move profit without moving cash

      The second family leaves cash alone and changes profit. Four items need a rule of thumb: deferred tax, capitalised development, share-based pay and expected credit losses.

      Deferred tax is the tax effect of a timing difference

      Tax law and accounting write assets off at different speeds

      Accounts depreciate a machine evenly. Tax law may allow more in the early years, as French rules do for some equipment. Early on the company pays less tax than its accounts suggest. The gap is tax postponed, so the accounts record a deferred tax liability: the timing difference multiplied by the tax rate.

      If Harmony keeps buying machines, new differences replace those that reverse, and the liability behaves like permanent equity. If investment stops, it reverses and behaves like debt. State which you assumed.

      A deferred tax asset on losses is a bet on future profit

      A company with tax losses can use them against future profit, and the asset is recognised only when that profit is probable. In France losses carry forward without time limit, but the amount usable in a year is capped at 1.0 million plus 50% of the profit above 1.0 million. Pedalia, the indebted rival, has 20.0 of losses, so a deferred tax asset of 20.0 × 25% = 5.0 may sit on its balance sheet. For a distressed firm the analyst usually writes it down to zero, since an asset that pays only if the company becomes profitable cannot repay a lender.

      3.1 Pedalia's tax losses

      Pedalia earns a profit before tax of 5.0. It has 20.0 of tax losses and the French cap applies. Compute (a) the losses usable this year, (b) the tax payable, against the tax with no losses, and (c) the losses left. Then give one reason the 5.0 asset might be written down.

      (a) Usable = 1.0 + 50% × (5.0 − 1.0) = 3.0. (b) Taxable profit is 2.0, so tax is 0.50, against 1.25 with no losses. (c) Losses left: 17.0.

      The asset might be written down because it pays out only if Pedalia makes large taxable profits for years, and the cap slows use even then. A lender cannot be repaid with it.

      Capitalising development spend lifts EBITDA but not cash

      Research is expensed, development may be capitalised

      Under IAS 38 research is always expensed. Development may be capitalised once conditions are met: technical feasibility, intention and ability to complete, probable future benefits and measurable cost. Internally built brands cannot be capitalised, while acquired ones can. The same economic asset gets different treatment depending on whether it was bought or built.

      The analyst compares firms on one basis: EBITDA less capitalised development, or capex that includes it. A rising capitalised share with falling cash conversion is a warning sign.

      Share-based pay is a cost even when no cash leaves

      Staff paid in shares are still paid

      Under IFRS 2 the company measures the fair value of shares or options at the grant date and spreads it over the vesting period as an expense, with the other side in equity.

      The analyst has two honest choices: treat the charge as a cost and lower EBITDA, or ignore the charge and count the dilution in the share count. Doing both counts it twice. Doing neither ignores a real transfer of value to staff.

      Expected credit losses book the bad debt before the customer defaults

      IFRS 9 asks for expected losses from day one

      IFRS 9 sorts financial assets into three groups: amortised cost, fair value through other comprehensive income, and fair value through profit. For receivables and loans it replaced booking a loss after a loss event with booking the expected loss from the start. Hedge accounting also sits in IFRS 9 (CF43).

      Harmony has 20.0 of receivables. An expected loss of 1.5% gives an allowance of 0.30. If dealers weaken and the rate becomes 3%, the allowance is 0.60 and profit takes an extra 0.30, although no customer has yet failed to pay. The analyst compares the allowance with past write-offs.

      Your friend Julien is a carpenter. He reads that a company's profit rose 20% 'because it started capitalising development costs'. Explain to him, using his own workshop as an example, why profit can rise while the bank balance does not, and what he should check next.

          1. 3.2 In Harmony's machine example, in which years is the deferred tax liability highest, and what happens to it in year 5?

          2. 3.3 A competitor shows a higher EBITDA margin than Harmony because it capitalises more development. How do you make the two comparable?

          3. 3.4 Why does share-based pay belong in an analysis of profit although no cash leaves?

          3

          1. A machine's tax depreciation is faster than its book depreciation. The accounts show…

          2. Pedalia has 20.0 of tax losses and a 5.0 deferred tax asset. A credit analyst usually…

          3. Harmony grants free shares worth 0.76 a year of expense. Which treatment counts the cost twice?

          4Put together, the items move Harmony's leverage from 1.67 to 2.36 times

          Each adjustment alone looks small. Added up, they change the picture.

          Rebuild net debt line by line and say which rule each line follows

          Four adjustments take net debt from 30.0 to 46.03

          On a pre-lease basis, as a covenant on frozen accounting rules might read it, the lease is left out and EBITDA stays at 18.0. Net debt is 38.42 and the ratio 2.13. Three readings of one company: 1.67, 2.13 and 2.36. Each is honest if its basis is stated.

          Two items explain most of the gap, so start there

          Of the 16.03 added, the lease and supplier finance account for 13.61. Rank adjustments by size and do the large ones first. An adjustment of 0.9 on a debt of 46 changes no conclusion.

          The notes hold the evidence

          Every item here sits in a note to the accounts, with rates and sensitivities. Read the notes. Deducting leases as debt in a valuation (CF27) also requires cash flows before lease payments, or the lease is counted twice.

          4.1 Comparing like with like

          Company X reports under IFRS 16. Its net debt is 45.0, including 15.0 of leases, and its EBITDA is 30.0, including 4.0 of rent added back. Harmony's ratio is 1.67 pre-lease and 1.93 lease-inclusive. Restate X on both bases and compare it fairly with Harmony. Say why X's reported figure against Harmony's 1.67 misleads.

          Pre-lease: net debt 45.0 − 15.0 = 30.0 and EBITDA 30.0 − 4.0 = 26.0, so 1.15, against Harmony's 1.67. Lease-inclusive: 45.0 / 30.0 = 1.50, against Harmony's 1.93. X is less leveraged on either basis.

          Comparing X's 1.50 with Harmony's 1.67 mixes bases. The gap looks like 0.17 when it is 0.52 or 0.43.

          a net debt bridge for Harmony with a switch for each item (lease, pension, clean-up, supplier finance, hybrid, factoring) and a choice of EBITDA basis, with a gauge of net debt / EBITDA. The learner should discover that two items drive most of the move, that a mismatch between numerator and denominator gives a wrong answer, and that every defensible basis tells the same story if stated.

          4

          1. After rebuilding net debt to 46.03 and EBITDA to 19.5, Harmony's ratio is…

          2. Company X reports net debt 45.0 (15.0 of leases) and EBITDA 30.0 (4.0 of rent added back). On a pre-lease basis its ratio is…

          3. Two adjustments explain most of the move in Harmony's leverage. Which?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Lease liability (IFRS 16)

          = ×

          EBITDA +1.5, net debt +7.61: the ratio goes from 1.67 to 1.93.

          Debt-like item after tax

          = × (1 − )

          Deferred tax

          = ×

          Restated leverage

          = /

          The lease in numerator and denominator, or in neither.

          Idea What to remember
          Three questions What is it economically, how is it booked, how do I restate it. Be consistent.
          IFRS 16 lease Liability at the present value of rent. EBITDA and net debt rise, cash is unchanged. Lease in both, or neither.
          Defined benefit pension Deficit is obligation minus assets and moves with the discount rate. After-tax deficit into net debt.
          Provision An estimate of a payment owed, not cash set aside.
          Clean-up provision Discounted future cost. Unwinding is a financial charge. Debt-like.
          Sold receivables If risk stays with the seller, it is a loan. Add the advance back.
          Supplier finance Stretched terms make a payable a bank loan. Reclassify the amounts in the programme.
          Deferred tax Tax postponed. Debt-like if it will reverse. A loss asset is a bet on profit.
          Capitalised development Lifts EBITDA, not cash.
          Share-based pay A real cost: expense it or count the dilution, never neither, never both.

          The one-sentence version

          Ask of every odd accounting item what it is economically, how it is booked and how to restate it, then move the debt-like ones into net debt and test the judgement-driven ones against cash, applying the same rule to every company.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Right-of-use asset The asset a lessee records for the right to use a leased item.
          Defined benefit plan A pension promise fixed by a formula, with the employer carrying the risk.
          Provision A liability of uncertain timing or amount, booked when an obligation exists.
          Deferred tax liability Tax postponed because tax and accounts treat an item at different speeds.
          Capitalising Recording a spend as an asset instead of an expense.
          Recourse The buyer's right to come back to the seller if a debt is unpaid.
          Hybrid A security with features of both debt and equity.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on complex points in analysing accounts.

          • IFRS Foundation — IFRS 16 Leases, IAS 19 Employee Benefits, IAS 37 Provisions, IAS 12 Income Taxes, IAS 38 Intangible Assets, IFRS 9 Financial Instruments.

          • Koller, Goedhart, Wessels — Valuation (Wiley), chapters on reorganising the financial statements.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.