Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Reading the accounts / Module 7

7Accounting standards and group accounts

Who writes the rules, and how a group's accounts are built from many companies

Who writes the rules, and how a group’s accounts are built from many companies.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
14
Exercises
4
Recall questions
6
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
2

What you will be able to do

  • Say who writes accounting rules and which rulebook applies to which accounts.

  • Explain the main principles (accruals, cost versus fair value, prudence, substance over form) and what each does to reported numbers.

  • Choose between full consolidation, the equity method and neither, from the facts about control and influence.

  • Build a simple consolidated balance sheet with goodwill and minorities, and explain an impairment.

  • Describe the French two-layer system of statutory and consolidated accounts.

  • Adjust a group's debt and earnings for what the consolidation method hides.

1Who writes the rules and who reads the accounts

Accounts are produced under rules with three different masters. Knowing which master wrote a rule tells you what the number is for.

Three forces shape the rules, and they want different things

Tax wants cautious numbers, standard-setters want comparable ones

Tax law prefers accounts that are cautious, stable and easy to audit. In France the tax return starts from the accounts, so accounting rules are partly tax rules. A standard-setter writes detailed rules so that two companies in the same situation report the same way. A securities regulator, such as the AMF or the SEC, makes listed companies publish on time. A company can therefore hold several legitimate profit figures, each answering a different question.

The IASB writes the international rulebook and the US keeps its own

The IASB is a private body under the IFRS Foundation. It issues IFRS standards after public consultation. Since 2005 the European Union requires listed groups to use IFRS, as adopted by the EU, in their consolidated accounts.

The United States uses US GAAP, written by the FASB and enforced by the SEC. Convergence stalled and differences remain.

The rulebook depends on who you are and which accounts you publish

Individual accounts describe one legal entity and are called statutory because the law demands them. Consolidated accounts describe a parent and everything it controls as one economic unit. A company with no subsidiaries produces only the first kind.

Entity Individual accounts Consolidated accounts
French listed group French rules (PCG) IFRS as adopted by the EU
French unlisted group French rules (PCG) IFRS or French consolidation rules, by choice
French company, no subsidiary French rules (PCG) None
US listed group US GAAP US GAAP

Which rulebook for which accounts

The auditor gives an opinion, not a guarantee

An independent auditor certifies that the accounts give a true and fair view, free of material misstatement. The duty is one of means, not result. A clean opinion says the rules were applied. It does not say the company is sound.

In France, a group keeps two sets of accounts, and the tax authority reads only the first

Your uncle owns a Lyon bakery chain made of a parent company and three shop companies. His accountant says the group has two sets of accounts and that tax is calculated on the first. Explain why there are two, what each is for, and why the second is not an attempt to hide something.

      A good answer says each company is a separate legal person with its own accounts, and tax is computed on each. The chain is one business in practice, so the owner and the bank want to see it whole. The consolidated accounts add the parent and the shops and remove sales between them.

      The second set hides nothing: it is the same activity for a different reader.

      1

      1. In France, which accounts is a group's corporate tax computed on?

      2. What does a clean audit opinion tell an investor?

      3. Since 2005, EU listed groups must prepare their consolidated accounts under…

      2The principles that decide what a number means

      Behind the standards sit a few principles. They explain why accounts show cost where an investor wants value, and why two firms can follow the rules and still look different.

      A handful of principles turn transactions into numbers

      Going concern and accruals set the frame

      Going concern values assets as tools in a working business, not at forced-sale prices. Accruals record a sale when earned and a cost when incurred, not when cash moves (CF6).

      Cost is checkable, fair value is relevant, and the standards use both

      Under historical cost, an asset stays at the price paid less depreciation. Under fair value, defined in IFRS 13, it is shown at the price it would fetch in an orderly sale between market participants. Cost is checkable. Fair value is relevant but can be a guess when no market exists. IFRS mixes the two.

      Prudence, substance and consistency discipline the choices

      • Prudence. Do not overstate assets or income. French rules name it as a principle. IFRS rests on neutrality, with caution as a support.

      • Substance over form. Book what a transaction really is. A lease that finances a machine is debt, whatever the contract is called (CF8).

      • Consistency. A change of method is applied retrospectively: the comparative year is restated and the effect goes through opening equity, not the current profit.

      • Materiality. Only items that could change a reader's decision must be corrected.

      French rules and IFRS differ on a few principles that move real numbers

      Topic French rules (PCG) IFRS
      Prudence Explicit principle Neutrality, with caution as a support
      Development costs Choice to expense or capitalise Capitalise when strict criteria are met
      Goodwill Amortised over its life unless that life is unlimited Not amortised, tested each year
      Joint ventures Proportionate method allowed Equity method

      Differences that change profit, equity or debt

      2.1 Same business, two rulebooks

      A company capitalises 3.0 million of development spending a year and amortises it evenly over five years, starting in the year of spending. A peer with an identical business expenses it all. In the first year, by how much does the first company's operating profit exceed the peer's?

      The first company spends 3.0 and records 3.0 / 5 = 0.6 of amortisation. The peer expenses all 3.0. The first company's operating profit is higher by 3.0 − 0.6 = 2.4 million.

      2

      1. Harmony revalues land bought for 8.0 to 14.0 under the revaluation model. What happens?

      2. Harmony's book equity is 54.0 and its equity value 114.0. Why the gap?

      3. A company capitalises 3.0 of development a year over five years; a peer expenses it. First-year operating profit is higher by…

      3From several companies to one group

      A group's accounts add the companies up. The method depends on how much power the parent has, and the price paid must be allocated before the totals make sense.

      Control, not ownership, decides whether a company is added in full

      The law treats each company as separate. An investor treats the group as one business, because the parent decides what its subsidiaries do.

      Parent's position Name Treatment
      Power over main decisions and exposure to returns Subsidiary Full consolidation: add 100% of every line
      Shared control under a contract Joint venture Equity method (IFRS)
      Significant influence, presumed from about 20% of votes Associate Equity method
      Less than that Financial investment Fair value, as a financial asset

      The consolidation ladder

      Control under IFRS 10 means power over the activities that drive the returns, exposure to variable returns, and the ability to use the power to affect them. More than half the votes usually gives control. Less can do so if the rest is scattered, or through board seats or contracts.

      3.1 Control or influence

      Classify each case as control, joint control, significant influence or none. (a) Harmony holds 45% of a battery maker and 200 small shareholders hold the rest. (b) Harmony and a partner each hold 50% of a charging network and every major decision needs both. (c) Harmony holds 22% of a motor supplier with one seat on a nine-member board. (d) Harmony holds 8% of a start-up with no board seat.

      (a) Control, probably: 45% with a scattered remainder gives de facto control, and the French 40% presumption points the same way. (b) Joint control, a joint venture under the equity method. (c) Significant influence, an associate under the equity method. (d) None: a financial investment at fair value.

      a slider for Harmony's ownership of Ravel from 0% to 100%, with a switch for how the rest is held (one block holder or scattered). The treatment and the consolidated lines change as the slider passes 20%, 40% and 50%. The learner discovers that thresholds are presumptions that facts about other shareholders can override.

      The price is allocated to what was bought, and the remainder is goodwill

      Harmony does not inherit the target's book values. It re-measures the target's assets and liabilities at fair value on the purchase date, including unbooked intangibles such as customer contracts. This is the purchase price allocation. The excess of the price over the fair value of the net assets is goodwill. It pays for people, expected savings, and sometimes for overpayment.

      Harmony's 24.0 investment has been replaced by Ravel's assets and the goodwill. Net debt jumped from 30.0 to 58.0 because Ravel's debt arrived too, and net debt over EBITDA moves from 1.67 to 58.0 / 22.0 = 2.64 times, with Ravel's EBITDA of 4.0 added in full.

      3.2 A second allocation

      Harmony buys 60% of a hinge maker, Brake & Co, for 15.0 million. Book net assets are 16.0 million. Brand and contracts of 6.0 million are found, with deferred tax at 25%. Compute goodwill with the minority at its share of net assets, and again with the minority valued at 9.0 million.

      Fair value of net assets = 16.0 + 6.0 − 1.5 = 20.5 million. With the minority at its share of net assets, goodwill = 15.0 − 0.6 × 20.5 = 2.7 million.

      With the minority at 9.0, goodwill = 15.0 + 9.0 − 20.5 = 3.5 million. It is higher because it includes goodwill for the 40% Harmony did not buy.

      The equity method puts a share of profit on one line and hides the debt

      For an associate the parent adds no lines. It shows one investment, rising with its share of profit and falling with dividends received.

      An analyst valuing the group (CF27) treats the investment as a separate asset and decides whether to add the associate's share of debt.

      Control and interest diverge in a chain of holdings

      Suppose Ravel owns 70% of Ravel Italia. Harmony controls both, so Italia is fully consolidated. Harmony's interest in Italia's profit is 0.8 × 0.7 = 56%. Control decides the method, interest decides how profit is split.

      Your friend has put 20,000 into a restaurant owned 30% by her cousin's company and 70% by a chef. The cousin's accounts show a single line for the restaurant. Explain why they do not include the restaurant's loan, and what your friend should look at to see whether the cousin is exposed to it.

          Under the equity method the cousin shows one investment line and one profit line. The restaurant's loan stays in the restaurant's own accounts.

          To see the exposure, read the notes, which summarise the associate's balance sheet, and compute 30% of its debt.

          1. 3.4 Why does the group show 100% of Ravel's EBITDA although Harmony owns 80%?

          2. 3.5 What would goodwill be if Harmony had paid 20.0 instead of 24.0, all else equal?

          3. 3.6 Where does the 4.75 appear, and who does it belong to?

          3

          1. Harmony owns 80% of Ravel. In the group accounts, Ravel's debt appears at…

          2. Harmony buys 60% of a company for 15.0; fair value of net assets is 20.5. Goodwill with the minority at its share of net assets is…

          3. Harmony holds 30% of Aria, which has 20.0 of net debt. In Harmony's net debt, that debt appears as…

          4After the deal: goodwill, eliminations and currency

          The consolidated balance sheet is not the end. Goodwill must be tested, internal trades cancelled and foreign subsidiaries translated into euros.

          Goodwill is never amortised under IFRS, so it must be tested instead

          Each year the group compares the carrying amount of the unit earning the goodwill with its recoverable amount, the higher of its value in use (discounted future cash flow) and its fair value less selling costs. If the carrying amount is higher, the difference is an impairment loss, charged first to goodwill, then to the unit's other assets. It is never reversed for goodwill.

          Some argue for amortisation, as French rules mostly require, because impairment tests rest on forecasts that managers control. The IASB examined it and kept impairment-only, with better disclosure. Track goodwill against capital employed: Harmony's 5.0 is 4.3% of 116.75.

          4.1 How far does the loss reach

          A unit has net assets of 12.0 million plus goodwill of 5.0 million, 17.0 in all. Compute the impairment and the goodwill left if the recoverable amount is (a) 15.5 million and (b) 10.0 million. In case (b), where does the part of the loss beyond goodwill go?

          (a) Impairment 1.5 million, all against goodwill, leaving 3.5 million.

          (b) Impairment 7.0 million. Goodwill absorbs 5.0 and goes to nil. The other 2.0 is spread over the unit's other assets in proportion to their carrying amounts, here reducing net assets from 12.0 to 10.0.

          sliders for the unit's cash flow, growth and discount rate. A bar shows the recoverable amount against the carrying amount of 30.0. As the learner lowers growth or raises the rate, the bar crosses the line and the impairment and income hit appear. The learner discovers how small a change in the rate wipes out goodwill.

          Internal trades are cancelled so that only dealings with outsiders remain

          If Ravel sells frames to Harmony, the group has sold nothing outside itself. Consolidation removes the internal sale, purchase, receivable and payable, and any profit in stock not yet sold to a customer.

          Foreign subsidiaries are translated, and the difference goes to equity

          Under the usual closing-rate method, a subsidiary's assets and liabilities are converted at the rate on the balance sheet date, income and expenses at the average rate for the period, and equity at historical rates. The difference falls into a translation reserve in equity, not profit. It reaches profit only when the subsidiary is sold.

          A euro invoice paid in sterling is a transaction effect and goes to profit (CF47).

          Your cousin runs the Swiss branch of a family import business. She says the group accounts are wrong, because her branch made a profit in francs but the group shows her contribution to equity fell. Explain how both can be true and where the loss is recorded.

              The profit in francs is real and, translated at the average rate, adds to group profit. But the branch's whole net assets are converted at the closing rate. If the franc fell against the euro, they are worth fewer euros than before, even after adding the profit.

              The loss sits in the translation reserve in equity, not in the income statement.

              1. 4.3 Why is an internal sale removed from consolidated sales although a real invoice was issued?

              2. 4.4 What is the impairment on a unit carried at 40.0 with a recoverable amount of 43.0?

              3. 4.5 Does a translation loss on a foreign subsidiary reduce group net income?

              4

              1. A unit is carried at 40.0 and its recoverable amount is 43.0. The impairment is…

              2. Ravel sells frames to Harmony with a margin of 1.5 on 6.0; 2.0 remain in Harmony's stock. The group removes…

              3. A sterling subsidiary does well, but the pound falls. Where is the translation loss recorded?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              The module’s formulas

              Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

              Partial goodwill

              = − ×

              Full goodwill

              = Price + − ANJV

              Equity-accounted investment

              = + −

              Impairment

              = max(0 ; − )

              Idea What to remember
              Who writes the rules Tax authorities, standard-setters and securities regulators. The IASB writes IFRS, the FASB writes US GAAP.
              Which accounts Individual accounts per legal entity, consolidated accounts per group. Listed EU groups use IFRS for the second.
              Audit An opinion that rules were applied and the picture is true and fair. A duty of means, not a guarantee.
              Cost and fair value Cost is checkable, fair value is relevant. Book equity is not market value.
              Full consolidation Control: add 100% of every line, show the minority's share as funding and as profit attributable to minorities.
              Equity method Significant influence or joint venture: one investment line, one profit line, and the debt stays hidden.
              Control and interest Control decides the method. Interest, the product of holdings in a chain, decides who gets the profit.
              Price allocation Price minus fair value of net assets is goodwill. Harmony and Ravel: 24.0 − 19.0 = 5.0.
              Impairment Carrying amount above recoverable amount: goodwill is written off first. Non-cash, and the delayed cost of a poor price.
              Eliminations and translation Internal sales and stock profits are cancelled. Foreign subsidiaries use closing and average rates, with the difference in a reserve.
              France Individual accounts under the PCG carry the tax link. French goodwill is usually amortised, IFRS goodwill never is.

              The one-sentence version

              Accounts follow rules written by tax authorities, standard-setters and regulators, and a group's accounts add up everything the parent controls, at fair value on purchase, with goodwill tested every year and internal dealings removed, so read the method and the notes before trusting any ratio.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              IFRS International standards written by the IASB, required for the consolidated accounts of listed EU groups.
              Consolidated accounts The accounts of a parent and the companies it controls, presented as one business.
              Control Power over a company's main decisions plus exposure to its returns. It leads to full consolidation.
              Non-controlling interest The share of a subsidiary's equity and profit that belongs to outside shareholders.
              Equity method Showing a stake as one line that rises with its profit and falls with dividends.
              Goodwill The price paid above the fair value of identifiable net assets.
              Impairment A write-down when an asset's carrying amount exceeds what it can recover.
              Fair value The price in an orderly sale between market participants at the measurement date.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapters on accounting information and on consolidated accounts.

              • IFRS Foundation — IFRS 10 Consolidated Financial Statements, IFRS 3 Business Combinations and IAS 36 Impairment of Assets, the standards behind Parts 3 and 4.

              • IASB — Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting (2018), on the qualities and principles of useful accounts.

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.