Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Financial securities / Module 18

18The corporate debt menu

Every way a company can borrow, and how to choose between them

Every way a company can borrow, and how to choose between them.

Reading time
30 min
Sections
11
Exercises
3
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
15
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Sort any debt instrument by lender, maturity, security and ranking.

  • Compute the all-in cost of a loan or credit line once fees are included.

  • Explain how term loans, revolvers, commercial paper, private placements and private credit differ, and which suits a company of a given size.

  • Describe how factoring, leasing, securitisation and project finance lend against an asset instead of the borrower's name.

  • Measure covenant headroom and test liquidity in a bad year.

  • Build a financing package for a stated need and defend it against the obvious alternatives.

1The menu is organised by four questions

Before naming any product, learn the four axes that separate them. Once you can place an instrument on these axes, a new product name is never a surprise.

Four questions sort every debt product

Who lends decides price, size and speed

Banks lend from deposits and are regulated for it. Investors in bonds and commercial paper lend through markets, in large lots, to borrowers they can judge from public information. Specialist funds lend money raised for that purpose: they charge more and move faster.

How long decides what the money can safely finance

Short debt is cheap when the yield curve slopes upward and dangerous when it must be renewed in a crisis. Long debt costs a premium for the lender's wait and removes the renewal risk. The rule for a CFO is the matching principle: finance what lasts with debt that lasts, and what is temporary with debt that can be repaid when the need ends.

What backs the loan decides how much the borrower's name matters

An unsecured loan rests on the borrower's general ability to pay. A secured loan gives the lender a claim on a named asset such as receivables, machines or a building. At the extreme, in securitisation and project finance, the lender looks almost only at the asset and its cash flow.

Ranking decides who is paid first

A senior lender is repaid before a junior or subordinated one, and every lender is repaid before shareholders. Lower in the queue means a higher rate. One company can therefore borrow at several rates at once.

Instrument Typical lender Backing Can Harmony use it today?
Term loan Bank or bank group Unsecured or secured Yes
Revolving credit facility (RCF) Bank or bank group Usually unsecured Yes
Commercial paper Investors, via a bank Unsecured No, too small and unrated
Leasing Lessor The asset itself Yes, for equipment
Securitisation Investors, via a vehicle A pool of receivables Not at this size
Project finance Banks, development banks One project's cash flow Only for a stand-alone project
Private credit Debt funds Often the whole company Possible, but dearer

The menu on the four axes. Bonds, the largest public instrument, are in CF17.

Your uncle Karim runs a plumbing firm and says: a loan is a loan, I take whoever quotes the lowest rate. Explain to him, in under a minute and with one example, why the same rate can hide very different deals.

      Karim, take two loans at 5%. One lasts a year and must be renewed, the other lasts five years. In a tight year the first lender can ask 8% or refuse, and Karim must find the money elsewhere. The second is locked in. Same rate, very different risk.

      1

      1. Which four questions sort every debt product?

      2. What is the matching principle?

      3. Why is a lower-ranked loan more expensive than a senior one from the same company?

      2Bank loans are the workhorse, and the price is more than the rate

      Most companies of Harmony's size borrow mainly from banks. The two core products do different jobs, and their real cost includes fees that the headline rate leaves out.

      A term loan buys assets, and a revolver buys time

      A term loan is a fixed amount, drawn once and repaid on a schedule

      The company borrows, say, 12.0 million and repays over five years, equally each year (amortising) or mostly at the end (a bullet). The rate is a reference rate plus a margin. In euros the reference is Euribor, the rate banks charge each other for a stated period. In dollars it is SOFR, in sterling SONIA, and the euro overnight rate is the €STR. LIBOR and EONIA no longer exist.

      The margin pays for credit risk. It may follow a pricing grid that falls as the borrower's leverage falls, which rewards a company that pays down debt.

      A revolving credit facility is a limit the company can draw, repay and draw again

      An RCF (revolver) is a committed line: the bank promises to lend up to a limit during its life. The company pays interest on the drawn part and a commitment fee on the undrawn part, because the bank must keep capital and liquidity ready. The fee is often about a third of the margin. A revolver suits the temporary part of working capital, and lenders read an undrawn one as liquidity in a crisis.

      A loan agreement is a set of promises, and covenants are the ones that bite

      The agreement fixes amounts, pricing, repayment and what counts as default

      Four clauses recur. Pari passu ranks the lender equally with other unsecured creditors. Cross-default makes a default on other major debt a default here. A material adverse change clause lets the lender stop lending if prospects deteriorate sharply. A negative pledge stops the borrower giving security to others without sharing it.

      A financial covenant is a tripwire that hands control to the lender

      A financial covenant is a ratio the borrower must keep within a limit, tested regularly, most often net debt / EBITDA. If it is breached the lender may demand repayment or renegotiate, usually at a price. The aim is to let the lender step in early, while value remains. The gap between the current ratio and the limit is the headroom. In boom years many leveraged loans drop maintenance covenants altogether ("covenant-lite"), and the warning then comes later.

      2.1 A bigger revolver

      Harmony negotiates a revolver of 25.0 million instead of 20.0, with the same margin and fee terms. It still draws 6.0 million on average. Compute the yearly cost and the effective rate on the drawn amount, and say what the extra cost buys.

      Interest on drawn: 6.0 × 4.75% = 0.285. Fee on undrawn: 19.0 × 0.6125% = 0.116. Total 0.401 million, an effective rate of 0.401 / 6.0 = 6.7%.

      The extra 5.0 million of limit costs about 0.030 million a year more (0.401 against 0.371) and buys more liquidity at short notice, insurance against a bad season.

      a slider for the average amount drawn on a 20.0 million revolver, from 0 to 20.0 million, with bars for interest, commitment fee and effective rate. The learner sees the effective rate fall as use rises and discovers that an unused revolver is an insurance premium.

      1. 2.2 A bank offers a loan at 4.8% with a 1.5% upfront fee, and another at 5.1% with no fee. Which is cheaper over one year, and which over five?

      2. 2.3 Why does a pricing grid tied to net debt / EBITDA help a company that is deleveraging?

      3. 2.4 A covenant is set at 3.0× and the company is at 2.9×. Name two things it should do now.

      2

      1. Harmony draws 6.0 million on average on a 20.0 million revolver at 4.75%, with a 0.6125% fee on the undrawn part. What does it cost on the drawn amount?

      2. A 12.0 million five-year loan at 5.0% carries a 1% arrangement fee deducted at drawdown. Its all-in cost is about…

      3. After drawing 12.0 for the battery line, Harmony's net debt is 42.0 against EBITDA of 18.0, with a 3.0× covenant. How far can EBITDA fall?

      3Markets and funds lend too, but only to borrowers that fit their model

      Commercial paper, private placements and private credit bypass the bank. Each pays for the bypass with conditions on size, credit quality or price.

      Commercial paper lends for months, cheaply, to well-known names

      Commercial paper (CP) is a promise to pay a fixed amount within a year, often in one to three months, sold to investors such as money-market funds. Because it is unsecured and short, only borrowers investors know and trust can sell it cheaply. It usually costs less than a bank line. The catch is that if investors stop buying, as in March 2020, the issuer must repay every maturing note. Rating agencies and investors therefore expect an undrawn back-up line covering most or all of the paper outstanding.

      Private placements and private credit lend longer, on negotiated terms

      In a private placement the company sells a loan or bond to a handful of institutions, such as insurers and pension funds, which usually hold it to maturity. The paperwork is lighter than for a public bond and the size can be smaller. Investors accept less liquidity for a higher yield and tailored covenants.

      A direct lending fund, or private credit fund, raises money from investors and lends it straight to companies. Its selling points are speed, certainty and flexibility. Its signature product is the unitranche: senior and junior debt merged into one loan at one blended rate.

      3

      1. Why must commercial paper issuers keep an undrawn back-up line?

      2. Pedalia can borrow 3.0× EBITDA senior at 5.5% and 1.5× junior at 10%, or 4.5× as a unitranche at 7.5%. What does the extra half point buy?

      3. What is a Euro PP?

      4Asset-backed and project debt replace the borrower's name with an asset's

      When a company is too small, too new or too indebted to borrow on its name, it can borrow on what it owns or is about to build. The lender then watches the asset's cash flow.

      Leasing and factoring turn equipment and invoices into funding

      In a lease, the lessor buys the asset and the company pays rent for its use, often with an option to buy at the end. The lessor can repossess the asset, so a lease is often available where an unsecured loan is not. Under IFRS 16 a lessee shows nearly all leases as an asset and a debt, so a lease counts as debt in the ratios. Whether to lease or buy is a decision of its own, treated in CF44.

      Factoring is the sale of customer invoices to a factor, who advances most of the amount at once, collects from the customer and pays the balance less charges. The charges pay for financing, collection and often insurance against non-payment. If the factor bears the loss it is without recourse; if it can come back to the seller, with recourse. The lender looks at the customers' quality, not the seller's. Reverse factoring lets a strong buyer arrange early payment for its suppliers, who borrow on the buyer's credit; because it can hide debt, disclosure rules now ask companies to report it.

      Securitisation and project finance lend against cash flows that stand alone

      In a securitisation, a company sells a pool of receivables to a special purpose vehicle (SPV), a shell set up only to hold the pool. The SPV pays by issuing notes in layers called tranches. The junior tranche takes the first losses. The senior tranche is hit only when everything beneath it is gone.

      In project finance, sponsors create a stand-alone company for one venture, such as a solar plant or toll road. Lenders are repaid from the project's cash flow alone, with no claim on the sponsors beyond what was agreed (non-recourse). Debt is typically 70 to 80% of cost. The test lenders watch is the debt service cover ratio.

      DSCR = cash flow available for debt service / (interest + principal due in the period)

      Each project risk goes to the party best able to bear it: construction guarantees from the builder, long-term purchase contracts from customers, currency matching, insurance for political risk.

      4.1 A project that must pay itself

      A project costs 30.0 million and is financed 75% with debt, repaid in equal instalments over 10 years at 6.0% (annuity factor 7.360). Cash flow available is 3.5 million a year. Compute the yearly debt service and the DSCR, then the fall in cash flow that takes the DSCR to 1.0.

      Debt: 75% of 30.0 = 22.5. Yearly debt service: 22.5 / 7.360 = 3.057 million. DSCR = 3.5 / 3.057 = 1.14×.

      DSCR reaches 1.0 when cash flow falls to 3.057, a drop of 12.7%.

      a waterfall of a 100 pool with three tranches and a slider for pool losses from 0 to 40. Tranches empty from the junior up, and the learner finds the loss level at which each starts to lose, and why senior debt can be rated above the originator.

      1. 4.2 In factoring, what changes for the seller when the factor bears the loss on non-paying customers?

      2. 4.3 Why might a customer's lenders want to know about its suppliers' reverse-factoring programme?

      3. 4.4 Why does a project lender ask for a DSCR well above 1.0?

      4

      1. A pool of 100 is funded by senior 80, mezzanine 12 and equity 8. At what level of losses does the senior tranche start to lose?

      2. A project borrows 21.0, with yearly debt service of 2.505 and cash available of 3.2. What does a DSCR of 1.28× mean?

      3. What changes for Harmony when it factors invoices without recourse?

      5Choosing means matching the instrument to the need

      Two tests do most of the work: does the maturity match what the money buys, and does liquidity survive a bad year?

      Match maturity, then test liquidity and covenants

      The battery line lasts about five years and, on the CF24 forecast, pays back in 3.6 years. A five-year amortising loan, repaid 2.4 million a year in step with depreciation, fits it. The spring working capital peak is temporary and recurs, so a revolver fits it. The mismatch to avoid is financing the line on the revolver, which matures in three years, before the line has paid back.

      A short checklist turns the choice into a routine

      • Purpose and life. What does the money buy, for how long? Match maturity.

      • Size and name. Big and known enough for markets, or does it need banks or funds?

      • Flexibility. Can it be repaid early, and drawn when needed?

      • Covenants and security. How much headroom remains, and which assets are pledged?

      • All-in cost. Rate, fees and commitment charges, at the same maturity.

      • Diversification. Not one lender type, and not all debt maturing in one year.

      Rate type, currency and liquidity policy are in CF33; hedging in CF43.

      5.1 A bad year

      Harmony's spring peak turns out to be 12.0 million, not 8.0, and EBITDA falls to 15.0 million in a weak year. Net debt at year end, after the battery line, is 42.0. Compute the revolver drawn and undrawn at the peak, and net debt / EBITDA against the 3.0× covenant. Does it hold, and what would you advise?

      The revolver is drawn by 12.0 of 20.0, with 8.0 undrawn. Net debt / EBITDA = 42.0 / 15.0 = 2.8×, below 3.0×, so the covenant holds. Headroom is thin: EBITDA of 14.0 would breach.

      Advice: open talks with the bank before year end, consider postponing growth capex, and keep cash above the minimum.

      Your friend Nadia runs a bakery chain and wants to finance a 40,000 oven on her overdraft because it costs 4% against 5.5% for a five-year loan. Explain to her, with a number, what can go wrong, and what the alternative looks like.

          Nadia, an overdraft is a limit the bank can cut at short notice. On 40,000 the overdraft saves 600 a year (1.5 points). If the bank withdraws the line in a tight year, she must find 40,000 at once while her shops are short of cash. A five-year equipment loan repays the oven as it earns.

          a decision game in which the learner picks instruments for four needs (a five-year machine, a spring stock build, a stand-alone solar plant, an invoice backlog) and sees cost, covenant headroom and liquidity at the worst point of the year. Wrong matches show the failure: maturity too short, liquidity gone, or security tied up.

          1. 5.3 Why can two plans with identical net debt / EBITDA have very different risk?

          2. 5.4 A lender offers a lower rate if Harmony pledges all its receivables. Name one cost of agreeing.

          3. 5.5 Why should the term loan on the battery line not mature before the line has paid back?

          5

          1. Plans A and B have the same 2.33× net debt / EBITDA. Why is Plan A safer?

          2. In a bad year, the spring peak is 12.0 and EBITDA falls to 15.0, with net debt of 42.0. Does the 3.0× covenant hold?

          3. A baker wants to finance a 40,000 oven on an overdraft at 4% rather than a five-year loan at 5.5%. What is the main risk?

          Summary and cheat sheet

          The module’s formulas

          Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

          Cost of a revolver

          = × (r + m) + ×

          0.371 / 6.0 = 6.2% on the drawn amount, against a 4.75% headline.

          Covenant headroom

          = /

          From 18.0 to 14.0: EBITDA can fall 22%.

          Debt service cover ratio

          = /

          Lyon solar plant: 1.28×; 1.09× if output falls 15%.

          Annualised cost of factoring

          = ( / ) × 360 /

          Idea What to remember
          Four questions Who lends, for how long, against what, who is paid first.
          Matching principle Long debt for lasting assets; a revolver or other repayable line for temporary needs.
          Term loan Fixed amount repaid on a schedule. Reference rate plus margin, plus any arrangement fee.
          Revolver (RCF) Committed limit to draw and repay. Interest on drawn, commitment fee on undrawn.
          All-in cost The IRR of the borrower's cash flows, fees included. Above the headline rate when fees exist.
          Covenant A ratio to keep within a limit. Headroom is the distance to the limit.
          Commercial paper Short unsecured IOU for known issuers; needs a back-up line.
          Private placement, private credit Negotiated debt from institutions or funds: speed and certainty, often at a higher price.
          Leasing and factoring Borrowing against equipment or invoices; the asset or customer counts.
          Securitisation Receivables funded in tranches; the senior layer is safer than the originator.
          Project finance Repaid only from one venture's cash flow; lenders watch the DSCR.

          The one-sentence version

          Debt is a menu sorted by lender, term, security and ranking, so choose the instrument whose maturity and flexibility fit what the money is for, and judge its cost all-in, with fees and covenant headroom included.

          Key terms

          Term Plain-language meaning
          Revolving credit facility A committed credit line the company can draw, repay and draw again.
          Covenant A promise in a loan agreement, often a ratio, that lets the lender step in if broken.
          Commercial paper A short-term unsecured IOU sold to investors.
          Unitranche One loan merging senior and junior debt at a single blended rate.
          Factoring Selling customer invoices to a specialist for cash now.
          DSCR Cash available for debt service divided by the interest and principal due.

          Going further

          • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter on other debt products.

          • Brealey, Myers, Allen — Principles of Corporate Finance, chapters on how corporations issue securities and on leasing.

          Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.