Skip to content
Corporate & Investment Banking My progress Français

Home / Corporate Finance / Beyond the textbook / Module 45

45Sustainable finance and ESG reporting

Why climate and social questions end up in the cost of capital, the accounts and the loan agreement

Why climate and social questions end up in the cost of capital, the accounts and the loan agreement.

Reading time
20 min
Sections
11
Exercises
4
Recall questions
9
Quiz questions
12
Simulators
3

What you will be able to do

  • Explain through which three channels ESG issues reach a company's value, and test each with a number.

  • Read the vocabulary of reporting: double materiality, scopes 1, 2 and 3, ESRS, ISSB and the EU taxonomy.

  • Compare green bonds, sustainability-linked bonds and loans, and compute what a margin ratchet or a greenium is worth.

  • Add an internal carbon price to an NPV and find the price at which a decision flips.

  • Spot greenwashing and say what evidence would settle it.

1Why finance cares

ESG is not a separate subject added to finance. It enters through risk, through the discount rate and through access to capital, and each channel is testable.

ESG reaches the numbers through cash flows, risk and access to capital

A flood, a strike and a weak board all show up in cash flows

A plant on a flood plain may be shut for weeks. A supplier with poor labour practices may face a ban. A board dominated by one person may approve a bad acquisition. In each case expected cash flows fall, or their spread widens.

The three letters sort these risks. E covers emissions, energy, water and biodiversity. S covers employees, supply-chain labour, product safety and communities. G covers board independence, pay and controls (see CF35).

A company is exposed in two directions: what happens to it and what it causes

Climate change can damage the company: physical risk (floods, heat) and transition risk (carbon prices, new rules, customers moving away). The company also affects the world through its emissions and its workers. Finance once ignored this second direction because nobody charged for it. Regulators, customers and lenders increasingly do.

Investors have changed behaviour, and that changes the price of money

Large asset managers and pension funds employ ESG analysts and screen portfolios. Some exclude whole sectors (divestment). Others keep the shares and press management to change (engagement). Banks track climate risk in their loan books.

The evidence on returns is mixed, and honest analysts say so

Studies of ESG and performance disagree. Some find slightly better returns, some none, some lower. High scorers are often large and profitable already.

Since 2022 there has also been a political backlash, especially in the United States. The finance conclusion is unchanged: use ESG where it traces to cash, risk or access to capital.

a slider for Harmony's cost of capital from 8.0% to 10.0% that redraws the enterprise value around 144.0 million, plus a second slider for long-term growth. The learner discovers that two tenths of a point is worth about 3%, and that the same change is worth far more when growth is high.

1.1 Pricing a lost reputation

A sustainability downgrade makes investors require 0.3 points more: Harmony's cost of capital rises from 9.0% to 9.3%. With the same stylised cash flow of 10.08 million and 2% growth, compute the new enterprise value and the loss in millions and in percent.

New value = 10.08 / (9.3% − 2.0%) = 10.08 / 0.073 = 138.08 million. The loss is 144.0 − 138.08 = 5.92 million, or 4.1%.

The loss (4.1%) is larger than the earlier gain (2.9%) because the move is larger: 0.3 points against 0.2. For moves of equal size the effect is slightly larger for a fall in the rate than for a rise, because value grows ever faster as the rate approaches the growth rate.

Explain to Chloé, who runs a small catering business and has never studied finance, why a company that pollutes less might borrow more cheaply. Use the idea of risk and one number. Do not use the words ESG or discount rate.

      A good answer: a lender worries about being repaid. A company that pollutes less is less likely to face a fine, a ban or lost customers, so its income is steadier. A lender who sees less chance of trouble accepts a lower rate, for example 0.1 point less on 20 million, a saving of 20,000 a year.

      1

      1. Through which channels does sustainability reach a company's value?

      2. A stylised cash flow of 10.08 grows 2% a year. The cost of capital falls from 9.0% to 8.8%. Value goes from 144.0 to…

      3. A downgrade raises Harmony's cost of capital from 9.0% to 9.3%. What is the loss?

      2What a company must measure and publish

      Reporting rules decide which numbers exist, how they are built and who checks them. Three ideas carry most of it: double materiality, the three scopes and the taxonomy.

      Double materiality asks two questions where financial reporting asks one

      Financial materiality asks what the world does to the company

      An item is material if leaving it out could change a reader's decision. In financial accounts the reader is an investor, so the test is whether the item affects company value. A flood risk to the plant is financially material.

      Impact materiality asks what the company does to the world

      Under the European approach, double materiality, a topic is also reportable when the company's impact on people or the environment is significant, even with no cost to the company today. Emissions in Harmony's supply chain may not dent profit this year, but they are reportable because the impact is real.

      The standards of the ISSB (IFRS S1 general, IFRS S2 climate) take the first view only. They are built for investors and are being adopted in a growing number of countries.

      The three scopes show that most emissions sit outside the company's own walls

      Scope 1 is what you burn, scope 2 is the power you buy, scope 3 is everything else

      The Greenhouse Gas Protocol counts emissions in tonnes of CO₂ equivalent (tCO₂e), which converts other gases into the CO₂ amount with the same warming effect. Scope 1 is direct emissions: gas burned in the plant, company vehicles. Scope 2 is the emissions behind the electricity and heat the company buys. Scope 3 is the rest of the value chain: purchased components, transport, use of products, disposal.

      2.1 A cut in the plant is not a cut in the footprint

      Harmony cuts scope 1 and 2 emissions by 30% and its suppliers cut scope 3 by 5%. Compute the new total in tCO₂e, the percentage fall in the total, and the new intensity if sales stay at 120 million.

      Scopes 1 and 2: 2,000 × 0.70 = 1,400. Scope 3: 28,000 × 0.95 = 26,600. New total: 28,000 tCO₂e.

      The fall is 2,000 / 30,000 = 6.7%. Intensity is 28,000 / 120 = 233 tCO₂e per million euros.

      a drag-and-drop game. Twelve cards (gas boiler, bought electricity, battery cells, courier delivery, commuting and so on) go into scope 1, 2 or 3 buckets, and Harmony's footprint bar updates. The learner discovers that most cards land in scope 3 and that the plant is a small share.

      European and international rules turn measurement into a duty to report

      CSRD and ESRS set the European content; the taxonomy sets the vocabulary of green

      The CSRD (Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive) replaced the older non-financial statement. It requires a sustainability statement inside the management report, prepared under the ESRS (European Sustainability Reporting Standards) and checked by an external assurance provider, usually the auditor. The EU's simplification package launched in 2025 (the "Omnibus") postponed the later waves, narrowed the obligation to the largest companies and is cutting the number of ESRS data points. Harmony is far below the new size thresholds, so it would most likely report voluntarily, for instance under the lighter voluntary standard drafted for smaller companies (VSME), because banks and large customers ask for the data.

      The EU taxonomy is a classification of activities that make a substantial contribution to an environmental objective, such as climate mitigation, without significant harm to the others and with minimum social safeguards. Companies in scope report the share of turnover, capital expenditure and operating expenditure that is aligned, meaning it meets them.

      1. 2.2 Why can an emission with no effect on Harmony's profit still have to be reported under double materiality?

      2. 2.3 Harmony halves its gas use. Which scope falls, and by how much of the total?

      3. 2.4 Capex alignment fell from 40% to 25% in a year with a large warehouse. Did Harmony become less sustainable?

      2

      1. What does double materiality add to financial materiality?

      2. Harmony's emissions are 1,200 (scope 1), 800 (scope 2) and 28,000 (scope 3). A plan aimed only at the plant addresses…

      3. Capex alignment with the EU taxonomy fell from 40% to 25% in a year with a large non-aligned warehouse. What follows?

      3Financing with a sustainability label

      Some bonds and loans carry a green or social label. The label adds a promise, a report and sometimes a price effect. This part shows what each instrument promises and what it is worth.

      Green bonds tie the money to projects, sustainability-linked ones tie the price to targets

      A use-of-proceeds bond is an ordinary bond with a destination for the cash

      A green bond pays a coupon and repays at maturity like any bond (CF17). The issuer also promises to spend the proceeds on eligible green projects, to track the spending and to report on it. A social bond does the same for social projects. The market reference is the voluntary Green Bond Principles of ICMA, and the EU has an optional Green Bond Standard.

      A sustainability-linked instrument pays for performance, not for a use of funds

      A sustainability-linked loan or bond does not restrict the use of the money. The issuer picks key performance indicators, such as emissions, with targets and dates. The interest margin depends on whether the targets are met: that is a margin ratchet. Meeting the target lowers the margin, missing it raises it.

      The ratchet is a nudge and a signal. It does not pay for decarbonisation, and a target that is too easy sends a weak signal.

      The greenium is the price edge of a green bond over its twin, and it is small

      The greenium is the amount by which a green bond yields less than an otherwise identical conventional bond of the same issuer. Where it exists it is a few basis points (a basis point is one hundredth of a percent).

      3.1 A bigger ratchet on a bigger loan

      Harmony negotiates a five-year, 25 million sustainability-linked loan with a ratchet of ±0.15%. Compute the yearly interest effect if the target is met, the gap between meeting and missing it, and the present value at 9% of five years of savings. Does this fund a project that costs 2.0 million?

      Yearly effect: 25 million × 0.15% = 0.0375 million. Gap between meeting and missing: 0.075 million a year. Present value of five years at 9%: 0.0375 × 3.890 = 0.146 million.

      Only about 7% of the 2.0 million project: the ratchet helps but does not fund it.

      Ratings and labels help only if the claims can be checked

      ESG ratings disagree with each other far more than credit ratings do

      ESG rating providers use different indicators, weights and data, so two can score the same company very differently. Credit rating agencies rarely differ by more than a notch or two. An ESG score is a question, not an answer.

      Greenwashing is a claim that outruns the evidence

      Greenwashing means presenting a company, product or fund as more sustainable than it is. Typical forms: a vague claim ("eco-friendly") with no data; a green project hiding a dirty core business; a distant target with no plan; intensity falling while total emissions rise. European securities supervisors treat misleading claims as a priority.

      The defence is the same as in accounting: a stated method, a baseline year, an auditor and a consistent measure.

      1. 3.2 A green bond funds a solar roof on Harmony's plant. Can bondholders claim the roof if Harmony fails?

      2. 3.3 What is the weakness of a sustainability-linked loan whose target Harmony already reaches?

      3. 3.4 Why is intensity per euro of sales risky as a headline figure on its own?

      Explain to Thomas, who buys bonds for his savings, why a green bond may pay him a coupon almost the same as a normal bond, and what he should check before trusting the label. Use one number.

          A good answer: the bond is a promise from the whole company, so the risk is the same as for its other debt, and the coupon is only about 0.05 point lower, say 4.95% against 5.00%. Before trusting the label, check who reviewed the project list and whether the company reports on how the money was spent.

          3

          1. What does a sustainability-linked loan tie to targets?

          2. Harmony's green placement saves 0.05% on 30 million. Reporting costs 12,000 a year. What is the net gain?

          3. Why can ESG ratings of the same company differ widely?

          4Putting carbon and purpose into decisions

          Reports and labels matter little if investment decisions ignore them. This part shows how a carbon price changes an NPV and how French law lets a company bind itself to a purpose.

          An internal carbon price turns a hidden cost into a line in the cash flows

          It is a price the company charges itself for every tonne it emits

          Carbon is already priced for large installations in the EU emissions trading system, and the border carbon adjustment (CBAM) is phasing in a charge on certain imports. Much of Harmony's footprint faces no direct charge today, but rules, customers and lenders are moving one way.

          An internal carbon price is a figure in euros per tonne that a company adds to the cost of emissions when it evaluates projects. It is a planning tool, not a tax, and it should be applied to every project alike.

          Internal carbon price (€/tCO₂e) Yearly carbon cost avoided (€m) NPV at 9% (€m)
          0 0.00 −0.34
          50 0.03 −0.17
          100 0.06 −0.01
          150 0.09 +0.16
          200 0.12 +0.32

          Heat pump NPV as the carbon price rises

          The price should be a stress test, not a ticket to approve anything

          The risk is choosing the price to get the answer you want. Show the NPV at several prices, state the price the board adopted, and report the break-even.

          4.1 Two projects, one carbon price

          Harmony also considers solar canopies over its car park: outlay 1.5 million, savings of 0.16 million a year after tax for ten years, 250 tCO₂e avoided a year. Compute the NPV at 9% with no carbon price and the break-even price in euros per tonne. At 150 euros per tonne, which of the two projects should Harmony fund first?

          Solar NPV with no carbon price: −1.5 + 0.16 × 6.418 = −0.47 million. Break-even price: 0.473 / 6.418 = 0.0737 million a year, divided by 250 tonnes, gives about 295 euros per tonne.

          At 150 euros the solar project is still negative: 250 × 150 = 0.0375 million a year gives an NPV of −0.47 + 0.0375 × 6.418 = −0.23 million. The heat pump is positive (+0.16 million). Fund the heat pump first.

          a slider for the internal carbon price from 0 to 300 euros per tonne, applied to five Harmony projects. The learner watches each NPV turn positive at a different price and discovers that the break-even price is the figure that ranks projects.

          French law lets a company bind itself to a purpose, and a fund to a label

          A purpose written in the statutes can be enforced, a slogan cannot

          A statement of purpose in a brochure constrains nobody. One written into the articles of association does, because directors must then act within it.

          1. 4.2 Why should an internal carbon price be applied to all projects and not only to green ones?

          2. 4.3 The heat pump NPV is −0.01 at 100 euros per tonne. Is the project worth doing at that price?

          3. 4.4 What does a société à mission add that a published statement of purpose does not?

          Explain to Yasmine, a student who has just started finance, why a project that loses money today can be accepted when the company adds an internal price on carbon. Say what the price represents and why it is not cheating.

              A good answer: the company pretends carbon will cost 150 euros a tonne to see whether the project still stands if it does. No money changes hands. It is not cheating if the price is stated, applied to all projects and shown beside the plain NPV. A project that only works when carbon is free carries a hidden risk.

              4

              1. Harmony's heat pump: outlay 2.0, savings 0.30 a year for 8 years, NPV −0.34 at 9%, 600 t avoided. Break-even carbon price?

              2. Solar canopies have an NPV of −0.47 and a break-even of about 295 euros. At a board price of 150 euros…

              3. What does a société à mission add to a published statement of purpose?

              Summary and cheat sheet

              The module’s formulas

              Tap a term to see what it means and its value at Harmony.

              Value of a cash flow growing for ever

              = / ( − )

              At 8.8%, value goes to 148.24: +2.9% for two tenths of a point.

              Carbon intensity

              = /

              It falls when sales rise, even with unchanged emissions: never a headline on its own.

              Value of a margin ratchet

              = × ×

              About 4% of the 2.0 project: a signal, not a source of funding.

              Break-even carbon price

              = − / ( × )

              Idea What to remember
              Three channels ESG matters to finance through cash flows, risk and access to capital. Anything else is a claim to test.
              Double materiality What the world does to the company plus what the company does to the world. Required in Europe, not in ISSB.
              Scopes 1, 2, 3 Direct emissions, bought energy, rest of the value chain. Scope 3 is usually the biggest and weakest data.
              EU taxonomy Defines which activities count as sustainable. Reported as shares of turnover, capex and opex.
              Green bond Ordinary bond, promise on use of proceeds. Same credit risk as the issuer's other bonds.
              Sustainability-linked Margin or coupon moves with targets. The ratchet nudges and signals, it does not fund the project.
              Greenium A few basis points: Harmony's 0.05% on 30 million is 15,000 a year.
              Internal carbon price Planning price per tonne added to project cash flows. Report the break-even, here about 102 euros.
              French tools Société à mission binds the company through its statutes. Label ISR applies to funds.

              The one-sentence version

              Sustainability matters to finance when it changes cash flows, risk or access to capital, so measure it with consistent methods, price it in decisions with a stated carbon price, and accept a label only for what it can prove.

              Key terms

              Term Plain-language meaning
              ESG Environmental, social and governance issues that affect a company or are affected by it.
              Double materiality Reporting both what sustainability issues do to the company and what the company does to people and the environment.
              Scope 1, 2, 3 The three layers of emissions: direct, from bought energy, and from the rest of the value chain.
              EU taxonomy The EU classification of economic activities that are environmentally sustainable.
              Greenium The lower yield of a green bond compared with an identical conventional bond.
              Internal carbon price A euro-per-tonne figure a company adds to project cash flows to test their resilience.
              Greenwashing Presenting something as more sustainable than the evidence supports.

              Going further

              • Vernimmen, Quiry, Le Fur — Finance d'entreprise (Dalloz), chapter 1, on the evolution of corporate finance towards sustainable and responsible finance.

              • ICMA — Green Bond Principles and Sustainability-Linked Bond Principles (voluntary guidelines, regularly updated).

              • Greenhouse Gas Protocol — Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard and Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard.

              Independent educational material. Not investment, legal or tax advice. All companies and figures in the running case are fictional.